Been going to Shirley's before they moved up the hill. I've never been disappointed. Service is…read morehelpful and knowledgeable. If Shirley's doesn't have it you don't need it. I wonder if Jessie is still cutting keys?

Shirley's is an independently owned all purpose hardware store with everything you need to keep…read moreyour life in order except a personal assistant. Batteries, beach towels, measuring cups, paint, trash cans, watering cans, you name it. They will make copies of your keys in just a few minutes. The ladies who work here are right out of Comedy Central. They never crack a smile but deliver some downright memorable one liners. The island gossip can all be heard here at Shirley's. The best place on the island for last minute mass-produced Halloween costumes. It's a lot cheaper buying light bulbs and dishtowels off island, but then you knew that already.

This place is a good old fashioned hardware store with a wide variety of items and a friendly…read morestaff. I have found everything I need.

PRO: The place has just about everything - window shades,…read morekeys cut, kitchen Items, paint, lawn and garden, bathroom items, etc. CON: The older male who works here? Needs an attitude adjustment. He's been downright rude and unprofessional as a business owner (or spouse or whatever he is) to myself and my husband. Asserting minimum credit card charges whenever he wants to, ripping receipts from me and throwing mine at me... Absolutely inappropriate behavior.

If they don't have it, you don't need it. The buyer/owner is a genious...don't know what we'd ever…read moredo without it. Selection, staff, service, value all 5 star!!!

Could be our favorite store anywhere. Anything we could think of that we wanted, we found here…read more Amazing array of hardware plus kids toys, garden supplies, tools, chairs and beach furniture. Went back several times during our visit. The staff are amazing - ask them anything and they take the time to listen to you, make suggestions immediately know where the perfect item is. A happy place to shop that really has everything.

Bought a Lodge 9x13 cast iron casserole today, came to$67.99 with tax. Lodge BW13C…read more Checked Lodge website, on sale for $39.95. Checked Amazon, $39.95 free shipping. Checked Eastmans website, shows a price of $49.95 which is the actual Lodge list price. I won't buy time from these rip-offs. BEWARE PRICE GOUGERS!!

Eastman's is a private enterprise and also a community treasure. It is an old-fashioned hardware…read morestore where you can get all kinds of advice in regard to a myriad of issues. I went there the other day with a hose that had a problem with one of the ends. It took the man at the counter 30 seconds to look at the hose and another 30 seconds to fix it at no charge. It is always fun to go there and to just walk around and look at all the stuff. It has an ambience more akin to 75 years ago than today. Not only do the members of the staff want to help you, they actually know how to solve virtually any problem that you bring to them. This is one enterprise that Falmouth cannot afford to lose. It is something that we should all support.

This review is for the Main Street Kitchen part of the store. As I see with another reviewer, I,…read moretoo, had issues with their Dura Supreme product. The quality was a problem, and it was a painful process working with Main Street. The shelves within these cabinets were terrible. I could have bought cheaper shelving from Home Depot and they would have been of a far superior quality than what I paid loads of money for with Botello's store. Thankfully my contractor cared about the quality of what he installed and made me new, quality shelving. Unfortunately the hutch had glass doors and painted shelves so that needed to come from Dura Supreme (attached a picture to show example of quality issue). 6 lots of shelving later, 2 of which were the wrong color, and I now have shelving that is ok but not great quality. Some of the cabinets arrived with a weird film on the inside and a bottom corner of the oven area was not right, and the contractor had his people fix these issues as best as they could. We had to have 3 lots of pantry doors sent as 2 lots were the wrong size. And through this all the folks at Main street were on top of nothing so it all continued to drag out. All of this started with their sitting on ordering a color sample for 2 months and when finally ordered, it was the wrong color. This meant that the color held up starting as it delayed the order. Main Street continued with sitting on things from this point to the end. We were always told solving these issues were a top priority, but they never were!! 16 months after delivery of cabinets, which does not include the lost time in finalizing the color sample, we had the last of the bits to complete the kitchen. I requested a discount given the quality issues and the burden of the kitchen completion delay, not to mention the constant follow up required to even get things moved along as they were never on top of anything. Then to be told we should be satisfied but at the same time tell us "This is not typical for the cabinet line, and I have been speaking with Dura Supreme since receiving your email." This was the response I received when I sent an email in July that listed out all the quality issues we experienced. So we should pay typical prices for what is not typical??? Back in July we were told they were working on organizing an on-site visit from the manufacturer, but unsurprisingly, many months later and still nothing. No communication, absolutely nothing. These were not cheap cabinets and we deserved better from Botello's. It is clear they don't care about customer service or the quality of the product they deliver. I am grateful my contractor cared about quality and did all that he could to fix the problems of what was delivered but it was no thanks to Botello's. I highly recommend you look elsewhere and save yourself the frustration and grief.

The store has large readable signs overhead to lead you to the product you want. If, you don't…read morelocate it the staff is very helpful and will lead you to the product you seek, then stay a while in case you have more questions, beautiful

I needed to replace a few boards on my back deck so we measured them up and went to Cottle's in…read moreEdgartown. I thought the price of the fir boards was fair. There was no extra charge for cutting the boards although the cuts were not necessarily even I was able to use them after a little fixing. Staff was very helpful with our purchase from the warehouse to the cashier. They also had nails so we had a one stop shop.

Their website states that they are open on Saturdays , while the Edgartown site is closed…read moreSaturdays. This is misinformation as the West Tisbury location is definitely closed on Saturday . It was not pleasant driving all the way from Edgartown on Saturday only to find them closed, contrary to their website. Also the time and gas wasted was annoying. Hope they will update their website , not a difficult task .

Scott and his team do a great job! They are friendly and knowledgeable. They are always ready to…read morehelp solve your problem or answer a question. If they don't have an item, they will order it for you.

This store beats the big box stores hands down! I've been there several times and the staff is…read moremore than helpful, courteous, and friendly. I highly recommend this hardware store.

The team at this location is super helpful. I went in looking for a specific kind of paint and the…read moreteam talked me through what I really needed. I admit, I needed a bit of hand holding and they could not be any more helpful. Thanks Mashpee Ace!

top notch customer service for even small items. They know their tools and how to choose what you…read moreneed.

I've been a loyal customer for many years and used the store for all my hardware needs. The blonde…read morecashier, Sonjia, began to refuse to ring up my orders. One day I asked why she wouldn't wait on me. She began to berate me and call me names. The same thing happened the next time i was in and she added I was never to speak to her again. I spoke with the manager and explained the treatment I'd been receiving. I wanted him to talk to her about the way I'm being treated. He said that I must have done something to upset her. I informed him that she has waited on me for years with no problems.. I've been merely making purchases and leaving. He said he felt she was in the right and we agreed I should take my business elsewhere. That said, I recommend One Stop Building Supply.

This store is everything that I love small hardware stores. They always seem to have what I need,…read moreand the people are locals who are more interested in their clientele than I have found at many big box stores. After moving to the area recently, my wife and I have needed several things to get our new home up and running. Every time I've walked in, Newport Hardware had what I needed, could find it in their cornucopia of good stuff and were as courteous as you please. The military discount is another bonus. I'd almost make an excuse to go visit this place. I will certainly keep giving these folks my business.

Worst check out person ever.... Saturday Nov 15th around 10 am at home section. We said hi she…read moredidn't even acknowledge us and didn't even bother to stand up to ring us up; we had to had her the stuff so her machine would scan them... horrible.... Never going back there again. Fired those people that don't want to work and hire friendly and helpful type of crew members... absolutely ridiculous.... Jezzzz! I've lived on the island for over 10 years and today was the day I gave them a shot. NEVER AGAIN... I think I'll return my stuff later.

I've been shopping at Marine Home Center for almost 20 years and for the most part the sales…read moreservice people are very polite and extremely accommodating but on two occasions over the last week I had the rudest person (both times it was Denise Allen). Ms. Allen seemed annoyed she had to ring up my order...that's all she had to do...she provided Zero service. It's service like Ms. Allen's that makes me wish there were more alternatives to Marine Home Center on this island.