You will find yourself at Granite at some point during your island stay. Why? Because they have…read moreeverything you could ever want except for milk, eggs, reading material and lobster. And booze. But all of that is nearby. Granite has everything else. If your house is missing potholders, beach towels, a blender or a garden hose, come on over. If your kids need their Scrabble fix, a new doll or some Silly Putty, come on over. If Granny needs some knitting yarn, some new sheets or a flashlight to get around at night, come on over. If you need a window fan, some paint, a lobster pot or a new beach chair, come on over. Anyone who needs anything craft related will eventually come to Granite, along with you and your gang. Glue, tape, needles and thread, glitter, stickers, and those fat Popsicle sticks you used to make miniature forts with as a kid- they are all here. Open year round, parking is a total headache in the summer, so get here early and get out fast. After all, beach days on the Vineyard are precious. Why waste them shopping unless you absolutely have to?

I purchased an item that when I took it home, I realized that the box was torn and it obviously had…read morebeen returned and was being resold. t turned out that it was not was I needed, so I brought it back with the reciept. I was told that I had used it and that they would not give me credit for my purchase. They kept the product as well. This is the last time I will go to Granite.

Been going to Shirley's before they moved up the hill. I've never been disappointed. Service is…read morehelpful and knowledgeable. If Shirley's doesn't have it you don't need it. I wonder if Jessie is still cutting keys?

Shirley's is an independently owned all purpose hardware store with everything you need to keep…read moreyour life in order except a personal assistant. Batteries, beach towels, measuring cups, paint, trash cans, watering cans, you name it. They will make copies of your keys in just a few minutes. The ladies who work here are right out of Comedy Central. They never crack a smile but deliver some downright memorable one liners. The island gossip can all be heard here at Shirley's. The best place on the island for last minute mass-produced Halloween costumes. It's a lot cheaper buying light bulbs and dishtowels off island, but then you knew that already.

WAY MORE THAN HARDWARE STORE!! This store is like a HomeGoods with a kitchen focus and a coastal…read morefeel and more affordable prices. I had so much fun looking around at all the helpful and cute items!! Will certainly be back

Bought a Lodge 9x13 cast iron casserole today, came to$67.99 with tax. Lodge BW13C…read more Checked Lodge website, on sale for $39.95. Checked Amazon, $39.95 free shipping. Checked Eastmans website, shows a price of $49.95 which is the actual Lodge list price. I won't buy time from these rip-offs. BEWARE PRICE GOUGERS!!

Wonderful, clean hardware, well laid out hardware store in Edgartown. The staff, all of them, were…read morevery friendly, which was a nice change of the experiencing I have been having around the island lately. They carry Benjamin Moore paint, which was why I went in; they do samples and will paint match for you. I will definitely be a return customer while we renovate our home.

I came in for LED replacement lightbulbs. Extraordinarily stubborn short-tempered manager refused…read moreto accept that she didn't understand my question. She was extremely rude and then she walked away. Never going back to that place. Not at all the MVY I know and love. LED bulbs have two factors: Kelvin AND Lumen output (i.e. color temperature and wattage). She refused to listen even after I told her I deal with lighting in my profession. We kept going around and around.. then she stormed away.

If you need paint you will not find a more knowledgeable, friendly and honest person than Jason in…read morethe paint department at Aubuchon Hardware in Falmouth. He is just AWESOME. Incredible service and so very, very friendly !! Update. I wish I could keep giving five star reviews to Jason at the Benjamin Moore paint store at Aubuchon hardware. Not only is he extremely helpful and kind, he is just a really nice human!!

I've shopped there three times and have yet to leave satisfied. Staff act like they're doing you a…read morefavor by helping you, they can't seem to get orders right, and what one person says is countered by the next person you talk to. I just left with $50 worth of products I have no use for because their internal communication sucks. Never going again, and I'd advise you to go to the Ace down the road!

I needed to replace a few boards on my back deck so we measured them up and went to Cottle's in…read moreEdgartown. I thought the price of the fir boards was fair. There was no extra charge for cutting the boards although the cuts were not necessarily even I was able to use them after a little fixing. Staff was very helpful with our purchase from the warehouse to the cashier. They also had nails so we had a one stop shop.

Their website states that they are open on Saturdays , while the Edgartown site is closed…read moreSaturdays. This is misinformation as the West Tisbury location is definitely closed on Saturday . It was not pleasant driving all the way from Edgartown on Saturday only to find them closed, contrary to their website. Also the time and gas wasted was annoying. Hope they will update their website , not a difficult task .

The staff at island lumber is very knowledgeable and helpful. I am always able to find what I need…read moreat island lumber. They've been around forever for good reason!

From the owner: Ace is the place. The helpful hardware store.read more

Always love going to this store. Everyone is so helpful and friendly. So much more convenient than…read morethe big box stores. Prices are just as competitive too! I have never had a bad experience.

Excellent service, all the workers there take there make sure you're getting the best deal, and are…read morereally nice.

The service here is good and the selection of items are great for getting beach chairs or things…read morefor an RV. You can order online and pick it up.

Through the magic of Chat GPT and the internet I was referred to Jerry's paint&hardware in Rhode…read moreIsland, USA. I live in Northern Kentucky. I needed a discontinued faucet for my hallway bath, as my old one was now leaking. I talked to Rob (He's very professional.) and he sent me a matching faucet in the mail. It's now installed ,working great. Jerry's paint and hardware has it going on. They made it easy.

This store is everything that I love small hardware stores. They always seem to have what I need,…read moreand the people are locals who are more interested in their clientele than I have found at many big box stores. After moving to the area recently, my wife and I have needed several things to get our new home up and running. Every time I've walked in, Newport Hardware had what I needed, could find it in their cornucopia of good stuff and were as courteous as you please. The military discount is another bonus. I'd almost make an excuse to go visit this place. I will certainly keep giving these folks my business.

I've been a loyal customer for many years and used the store for all my hardware needs. The blonde…read morecashier, Sonjia, began to refuse to ring up my orders. One day I asked why she wouldn't wait on me. She began to berate me and call me names. The same thing happened the next time i was in and she added I was never to speak to her again. I spoke with the manager and explained the treatment I'd been receiving. I wanted him to talk to her about the way I'm being treated. He said that I must have done something to upset her. I informed him that she has waited on me for years with no problems.. I've been merely making purchases and leaving. He said he felt she was in the right and we agreed I should take my business elsewhere. That said, I recommend One Stop Building Supply.