Been going to Shirley's before they moved up the hill. I've never been disappointed. Service is…read morehelpful and knowledgeable. If Shirley's doesn't have it you don't need it. I wonder if Jessie is still cutting keys?

Shirley's is an independently owned all purpose hardware store with everything you need to keep…read moreyour life in order except a personal assistant. Batteries, beach towels, measuring cups, paint, trash cans, watering cans, you name it. They will make copies of your keys in just a few minutes. The ladies who work here are right out of Comedy Central. They never crack a smile but deliver some downright memorable one liners. The island gossip can all be heard here at Shirley's. The best place on the island for last minute mass-produced Halloween costumes. It's a lot cheaper buying light bulbs and dishtowels off island, but then you knew that already.

Bought a Lodge 9x13 cast iron casserole today, came to$67.99 with tax. Lodge BW13C…read more Checked Lodge website, on sale for $39.95. Checked Amazon, $39.95 free shipping. Checked Eastmans website, shows a price of $49.95 which is the actual Lodge list price. I won't buy time from these rip-offs. BEWARE PRICE GOUGERS!!

Eastman's is a private enterprise and also a community treasure. It is an old-fashioned hardware…read morestore where you can get all kinds of advice in regard to a myriad of issues. I went there the other day with a hose that had a problem with one of the ends. It took the man at the counter 30 seconds to look at the hose and another 30 seconds to fix it at no charge. It is always fun to go there and to just walk around and look at all the stuff. It has an ambience more akin to 75 years ago than today. Not only do the members of the staff want to help you, they actually know how to solve virtually any problem that you bring to them. This is one enterprise that Falmouth cannot afford to lose. It is something that we should all support.

Wonderful, clean hardware, well laid out hardware store in Edgartown. The staff, all of them, were…read morevery friendly, which was a nice change of the experiencing I have been having around the island lately. They carry Benjamin Moore paint, which was why I went in; they do samples and will paint match for you. I will definitely be a return customer while we renovate our home.

I came in for LED replacement lightbulbs. Extraordinarily stubborn short-tempered manager refused…read moreto accept that she didn't understand my question. She was extremely rude and then she walked away. Never going back to that place. Not at all the MVY I know and love. LED bulbs have two factors: Kelvin AND Lumen output (i.e. color temperature and wattage). She refused to listen even after I told her I deal with lighting in my profession. We kept going around and around.. then she stormed away.

Scott and his team do a great job! They are friendly and knowledgeable. They are always ready to…read morehelp solve your problem or answer a question. If they don't have an item, they will order it for you.

I've shopped there three times and have yet to leave satisfied. Staff act like they're doing you a…read morefavor by helping you, they can't seem to get orders right, and what one person says is countered by the next person you talk to. I just left with $50 worth of products I have no use for because their internal communication sucks. Never going again, and I'd advise you to go to the Ace down the road!

I needed to replace a few boards on my back deck so we measured them up and went to Cottle's in…read moreEdgartown. I thought the price of the fir boards was fair. There was no extra charge for cutting the boards although the cuts were not necessarily even I was able to use them after a little fixing. Staff was very helpful with our purchase from the warehouse to the cashier. They also had nails so we had a one stop shop.

Their website states that they are open on Saturdays , while the Edgartown site is closed…read moreSaturdays. This is misinformation as the West Tisbury location is definitely closed on Saturday . It was not pleasant driving all the way from Edgartown on Saturday only to find them closed, contrary to their website. Also the time and gas wasted was annoying. Hope they will update their website , not a difficult task .

The staff at island lumber is very knowledgeable and helpful. I am always able to find what I need…read moreat island lumber. They've been around forever for good reason!

From the owner: Ace is the place. The helpful hardware store.read more

Excellent service, all the workers there take there make sure you're getting the best deal, and are…read morereally nice.

Long time customer. Great hardware store. Incredibly well stocked with broad range of quality…read moreproducts. Staff is very friendly and very helpful. My "go to" store on the Cape.

Through the magic of Chat GPT and the internet I was referred to Jerry's paint&hardware in Rhode…read moreIsland, USA. I live in Northern Kentucky. I needed a discontinued faucet for my hallway bath, as my old one was now leaking. I talked to Rob (He's very professional.) and he sent me a matching faucet in the mail. It's now installed ,working great. Jerry's paint and hardware has it going on. They made it easy.

This store has everything you need and the staff is knowledgeable and helpful. Whether it's filling…read morea propane tank, replacing a window screen, finding a plumbing part or strategizing what type of tool I might need for a project they have it all AND they know how to use it. There are floor staff everywhere to answer questions. In response to the previous review about chatty cashiers -- this isn't a chain store. It's a local place with lifetime customers including other businesses, contractors, homeowners and vacationers, too. It's a community business where we can take a moment to acknowledge each other with a "hello how are you." If the reviewer was that put out they could have easily said something to the (always present) owner rather than complain about it here. The friendly cashiers are long female time employees who will not only ring up your purchase but are very knowledgable about the products sold and where to find them.