Most of the time, I can't get enough of DIY projects. I built my own lofted bed and frame this past summer, built a new desk, wired up a custom sound system for my room and even built a miniature trebuchet from 2"x2"s during winter break. I know what I need for my hardware needs; the ironically named Economy Hardware doesn't provide it.
Economy proudly displays a sticker on its door that names it a top local business. I suspect that the only reason it's survived this long is that it's within easy range of MIT and a lot of affordable student housing, and is on Mass Ave and thus doesn't require half a brain to find. Otherwise, how would its prices and poor variety and quality have stayed around so long?
First off, Economy tries to be a lot of things at once that it just is not - and that other stores in the area do better. It tries to be a craft store, but Pearl Arts and Crafts is just down the street and has about 10 times the selection. It tries to be a furniture store, but I can count about three different dedicated furniture and lightings stores between MIT and Harvard. And finally, it tries to be a hardware store, but only has the back section devoted to it and can't even offer a decent selection.
Let me elaborate: as a DIY junkie I'm looking for quality and variety. My standards aren't that high; I don't, for example, expect a local establishment to carry much in the way of building quality wood, and correspondingly, the needed joist hangers and such. But if I need 1.5" #10 nails, I expect to find them in any establishment purporting to sell nails. Instead, the only thing I can find in the way of nails at Economy are 3" #16 nails, that not only are expensive, are also cheap, poorly made Chinese crap that bend as easily as wire when hammered. Unh-huh.
I'm looking for contact paper to cover a rough particleboard surface. I don't even care about the pattern, I just want something that won't give me splinters. Economy has nothing. If they dedicated themselves to having a decent selection of hardware, they might actually carry something as useful as contact paper, but instead I had to chance upon a tiny hardware store while on the way to buy cake in Haymarket that carried it instead. Yep.
I'm looking for some plexiglass and they don't carry it. Pill's down the street does. I'm looking for rubber spray-paint and they don't carry it. Pill's down the street does. And since this place seems to be a home furnishing store as well, I figure I might as well look for some decent desk lighting. They don't carry it. See a theme here?
Economy is quite simply a case of a store trying to be too many things at once, finding out they absolutely suck on ice because of it, and then deciding that they'll try and survive by other means.
By other means, I think they probably thought of atmosphere. The store itself is a chic modern affair, with good music in the background, high ceilings and excellent lighting. I don't care. Why do you think that utilitarian places like Home Depot or (more pertinently) Pill's hardware just down the street have survived? People who walk into a hardware store are not looking for a new home, they're looking for something to build. The overabundance of help at the front desk couldn't even tell me where to find a basic chalk line (which, by the way, ended up being one of the worst I've worked with, even though it was the only one Economy offered).
Finally, I have to talk about pricing, which brings me to the supreme irony of Economy Hardware's name. I'm sorry, but economy is the least of Economy's characteristics. Economy is hardly something you'd expect from a place that has splurged on its appearance and far too many helpers so obviously, and it shows. No other place I know will charge you $70 for 6 rolls of silver duct tape and a few small colored rolls. Hell, I could have ordered the stuff online and saved over $20 even with shipping. The prices for the crappy nails I mentioned before was ridiculous. Economy, you might appeal to the naive students and the yuppies pleased with such a clean store, but I really, really don't want to pay $1 extra on everything that would be over $7 at a normal place just because you play Led Zeppelin on the PA.
I suspect the only reason I will ever, and I mean EVER go here again is if I need something small or if someone else is footing the bill. My advice? Go up the street to Pill's, or if you really need something specific take the time to go to Andrew on the T or Somerville and go to the Home Depot. If you were looking for something else Economy sells, try any one of the other places I've mentioned above. This place is not, I repeat not worth your money. read more