I've only had the banana bread ice cream sandwich so it should be noted that I haven't actually ever had meal food here lol. But this banana bread ice cream sandwich was HUGE and the taste will forever be engrained into my memory! It's a small establishment, but is a good place to stop by for a sweet treat if you walk around. In addition to this, the employers were super great and kind. read more

eats & sweets - Banana Bread Ice Cream Sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

Grabbed a sandwich for lunch one weekday. No wait, quick service and tasty sandwich. It was huge though. Enjoyed the other half the next day. The new owners streamlined the menu, which I find easier. A gem downtown Lafayette! read more

See all

Wonderful place to go during hot summer days! Unique water fountain outside and a take a book near by! Love this place and would highly recommend, especially the flavors and options of GF. read more

I have been a long time customer, really since they opened. Periodic lunches and the traditional holiday pie. The new ownership has modernized the interior and continues to deliver a quality lunch experience. The baking however has become a weakness. The holiday pie this year was pecan. Unfortunately, it was not edible. It was so caramelized and over baked the my sharpest knife could not begin to cut it. We broke it apart and threw it out. I really hope this was a one off. read more

Got the pastrami and lemon creme pie, everything was delicious. Parking in front of building is limited but specific to the area so allows for a quick run in. read more

UPDATE: Came here again after the store manager reached out to me. ONCE AGAIN HORRIBLE SERVICE! First my partner tried to ask something about the menu and the girl didn't even listen to her straight away was like no then walked away. Then I was looking in the sweets cabinet and the cashier kept pressuring me anything else, anything else. I felt so rushed and there was no one behind me. The service here is terrible not welcoming at all. Which sucks because the food here is good. I'm up for second chances but this place is gonna take a lot of work. read more

eats & sweets - Cashier - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

(2 stars because it was my first time here and I haven't had the chance to try their ice cream/other desserts) but I just had the most horrible grilled cheese :( I spent $16!!!! on the apple & bacon grilled cheese for the employee to say they didn't have any apples after I had already paid for it (I added arugula) but when I opened up the sandwich the sourdough bread was stale and wasn't even toasted. The cheese was overkill and not really melted. And the bacon was so greasy. I'm really bummed about this sandwich next time I'll save my money and make it myself! read more

eats & sweets - A&B grilled cheese - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

Love Eats and Sweets! This has been one of the few places I frequent during Covid, and they are doing amazing! I love the atmosphere inside and that they have so much different options to eat. Try the Tofu Sandwich! You can add all sorts of fun vegetarian add ons. They have great ice cream as well. It can get a bit crowded in there but there's a lot of seating. read more

eats & sweets - Tofu sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

We were served by an employee who clearly did not want to be there. We felt very rushed to order and to get out of the shop, which was weird because it was not near closing time and there was no line behind us to merit that kind of service. I thought, "Oh, this just must be what this place gets away with because the ice cream is so good." However, after tasting my scoop, I realized I was wrong. The ice cream is not worth enduring customer service like that. So, why 2 stars and not 1? I give 2 stars for the products available. They have desserts for GF and Vegan diets, which is always nice to know and see. read more

Delicious ice cream! We went when it was raining so didn't get to enjoy the outdoor seating but it was very cute! The staff was wonderful and on the ball! read more

Great location with potential, but lots of missed details and letdowns. Sandwich bread was stale, ice cream cones were stale, multiple things out of stock, one of the ice cream freezers is broken (so limited flavors), no paper towel in the bathroom, etc. The place needs a coat of paint and a face lift as well. Ownership should spend some time tightening up some of the details and this place would be great. Right now, it's clear this place isn't being well maintained. The staff are all very kind, so that is a bright spot. read more

I have tried this place twice. The first time I came in for sandwiches. I did not like the taste and it was really thin & overpriced unfortunately. The second time, today, we came in for ice cream. It was good. I got a brownie too and it was the hardest and driest brownie I've had in a long time. Would go back for ice cream, but wouldn't get anything else. read more

Excellent soups, sandwiches, desserts and ice cream served by some of the nicest people in the sweetest old town in Colorado!

Bomb dot Com! We were in the area a while back, and the kids wanted to get Ice Cream and a bite to eat, low and behold we found a two for one. They have great sandwiches and ice cream. Though at the time they were a bit understaffed, and some of the items took a serious amount of time to get... Like 20+minutes. We waited though, and were patient and they apologized for the delay. In the end all of it was worth the wait, and everyone enjoyed what we had ordered. If in the area we would certainly stop by again. I highly recommend the Banana Bread Ice Cream Sandwich!!! 10/10. read more

See all

LOCAL SUPPORT SUNDAY! Eats and Sweets can fill a sweet tooth craving with the one option I have tried! That is...drumroll... BANANA BREAD ICE CREAM SANDWICH. Why did I have to hear it from them to know this was a thing? This bakery brought a whole new meaning to dessert to me. I'm not a huge "Cookie Ice Cream" sandwich type of gal, so Eats and Sweets hit the nail on this one. I actually tried Eats & Sweets as their "Food Truck" at Rayback Collective. It was such a cute food truck and it caught my eye instantly. They did have two options for ice cream and it was either vanilla or chocolate, pretty basic. My fiancé and I decided to share one and it was $8, which I originally thought was pretty high. It turned out $8 would fill both of us up and leave a little extra for later, so I call that a good bang for your buck. Let's be honest to pull this dessert apart to really tell if it's good is that each component is delicious on its own and better together. The vanilla ice cream was creamy, slightly melting which was needed to bite through the sandwich and a cold delicious treat on its own. The banana bread by itself was, okay. I won't say it was amazing and fantastic, but it was decent. The only thing I wished for was a thicker banana bread. Once I tried it altogether, it was almost missing that banana bread flavor. I still gave 4 stars because it was a decent price and delicious dessert as a whole. Since it was melty, it wasn't really picture worthy, but what I did do during this COVID time was create my own at home and I took a picture of the bread to ice cream ratio I would've wanted. Maybe it'll have the owners revamp a thicker banana bread, please!!! Other than that it's amazing. read more

According to my credit company I've spent fifty seven dollars here in the last week I don't regret a penny! read more

We bought a peach pie at this place at the peach festival. The crust looks good but when we cut it, the peaches are still hard and in big chunks, pretty much uncooked. read more

eats & sweets - We bought a peach pie but the peach is uncooked. They are hard chunks. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

I'd like to preface this message by saying I love coming to this store for their cheesecake and carrot cake. I am leaving a three star review instead of 4 because I quite honestly had the most bizarre and rude customer service experience of my life tonight at this location. At about 8:30pm (they typically close at 9:00pm) I was walking up to the front door to snag a few pieces of cheesecake before closing. As usual an employee was unloading the food truck from the day and the door was slightly open. As I walked up to the door a young woman, an employee, was also about to walk in the front door. We made eye contact and acknowledged each other, I smiled at her, and as I was about to follow her in, with my arm and hand extended to catch the door after her, she quickly spun inside and slammed the door right in my face. After a brief moment of utter confusion I read the printed sign on the door that they were closing a bit early to prep for a special event - totally fair. I cannot understand how this young woman thought it was a better choice to slam the door in my face and let me read the sign than to briefly explain they needed to close a few minutes early for a completely legitimate reason. I almost wanted to knock on the door and ask this person why she slammed the door in my face but it seems obvious I would not have gotten a mature response. I will be back for more cheesecake but I hope you guys can figure stuff like this out. read more

Eats and sweets is amazing! We have always loved stopping by for great sandwiches and delicious treats. So they were my first thought for a custom cake for our 5 year anniversary. We had a s'mores cake that we've been talking about for the past 5 years. Eats and Sweets was able to make one like the original even better! We shared with family and everyone after it was the best they've had. Highly recommend Eats and Sweets for anything delicious you ever need! read more

eats & sweets - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

We love how kid friendly eats and sweets is and it is in walking distance of the WOW museum and has outdoor seating as well. Our kiddos love the kids meal which comes with a small scoop of ice cream. Their sandwiches are good...I like the vietnamese cubano and the pastrami. Their desserts are made in the store and all look delicious! We have always had friendly customer service here. read more

Got the Chicken Cordon Blue, no Swiss cheese. The chicken salad was just canned chicken and mayonnaise. Not good. Mushy and no flavor. Food was mediocre at best. Not what I would expect for chicken salad from a deli. I can get canned chicken and add mayo. Yuck! Menu picture showed chunks of chicken. Like you would expect. Ordered and paid online. Showed up at the posted pick up time. Was not ready. They did not even have my order. They finally found it and made the order. This place used to be good. Last couple of times I have been here it's not been good. Don't bother ordering online. The staff said they don't get the orders. read more

We love this old town Lafayette restaurant. The food is delicious and fresh. Service is fairly quick. Love this place!

AWESOME. COOKIES. AND. CREAM. Their prices are a bit much and the check-in deal is hardly worth it, but man do they have a killer C&C ice cream. I'd go back strictly for that. Not a fancy place and is very homey. I'd suggest cleaning up shop a little by de-cluttering and adding a bit of a modern flare so that it looks fresh and appeal to more people. The staff is nice and overall they have a good thing going on. read more

eats & sweets - Business Card - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

This is a great place to stop and enjoy a soup or sandwich! Their ingredients are always fresh. They are great at making sure your are happy with your selection. My granddaughter's favorite is there ice cream. Candy can and salted caramel are her favorites. The best part is they let you sample so you can find your favorite. They also have a nice selection of vegan desserts. I am partial to their cupcakes. There is always a nice surprise in the middle. The staff is very nice! read more

Service was great! Such a cute and fun little shop to come try pastries and sandwiches! Food was delicious. I will definitely be coming back

I am so happy we have a place like this in our community! The people here are amazing - you can tell they love their job! GET THE CHEESECAKE. it is the best thing I have ever had! I love their ice creams and the mini cupcakes are the perfect size (red velvet and the carrot cake!) I bring all of our visitors here and they still talk about it! read more

I just had Eats and Sweets provide the food and the cake for my birthday party. It was awesome. The cake was stellar--lemon poppy seed with raspberry filling and cream cheese frosting--wow it was delicious. It was a well flavored & dense cake. The filling was just the right amount of sweetness. They also provided sandwiches, wraps, veggie tray and fruit bowl. Everyone loved it. The food was fresh and beautifully displayed. Many of the guests want to know who did the catering. They were really impressed with the food and cake as well. I'll definitely use Eats and Sweets again. It is great having such great service and food right in my home town. Thank you Bobby for making my party such a success. read more

Good ice cream and food , people are nice and good location , great place to hang out in nice weather

Their soup is awesome. Try the gazpacho in the summer, it's really good. We've never had a bad experience. Be sure to check out the Tibet store next door. read more

So yummy. I loved that they had vegan ice cream! What a cool little spot. Prices were a little high but to be expected for the area. I wish portions were a little more generous. Otherwise, worth checking out. read more

Ive been here twice now. Food here is good. Solid choices & nice bakery side of things. Nothing fancy. Their downfall is their negative attitudes & bad service. Customer service makes it hard to want to come back. read more

Slow. Lots it's edge. Quiche had 0 flavour. Wait is too long for warm ice cream... needs to get it together

I went in after never being in before, and I was immediately turned on by the positive atmosphere. All of the employees were very friendly, and the rest of the customers in the restaurant seemed happy with their meal. I got the Italian sandwich, and a nice girl with red hair I think her name was cat made my dish and might I say it made my day. This sandwich was the most Bussin sandwich I've ever had in my entire life shout out to her. She was friendly and made conversation while I was waiting she deserves a raise! I highly recommend eating at eats and sweets 100/10 % read more

Had a gluten free Greek wrap from the food truck and then the next day asked a young girl how they made it. She said they used a regular flour tortilla. I proceeded to explain I don't eat gluten and it feels painful when I do. I asked her if they used a gluten free tortilla and she then said "if you ordered a gluten free wrap we made it gluten free". Clearly not the case because of the intestinal pain and headache I have today! Atleast be honest about your mistake... read more

Really really good ice cream and desserts, not Overly enthusiastic service. Loved the special flavors, the cherry basil was so delish! read more

eats & sweets - Cherry basil and vanilla bean - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

Banana bread and ice cream together?!?!!! Never thought to put these together but it is amazing. Especially with cotton candy ice cream. I've also heard the sandwiches are amazing. Next time we will try those. We will definitely be coming back! read more

I came in and Meg put the SWEET in eats and sweets. I felt so welcome and could tell she was excited to serve me. On top of that the ice cream was so good definitely recommend!! read more

Five Star Rating System Rubric: Stars are based on the categories below. A place can earn up to a star for each category. Atmosphere Service Taste Dietary Accommodations Overall Experience Atmosphere: Thumbs up! The door opens and the fresh smell of soup, bread, and homemade desserts greet the casual patron. The aromatic aromas instantly start to lower your cortisol levels after a long day at work. Or perhaps your mood is uplifted knowing that a tasty dinner or dessert awaits you. Eats & Sweets decor can make you feel like you took a step back in time to a more relaxed era. The colored scheme creates for a unique environment and blends nicely with the art based theme of Lafayette. The atmosphere also serves well as a comforting place for families and their kids. Great for the single patron, families, friends getting a meal, or a casual date night, Service: Thumbs up! Eats & Sweets, along with Cannon Mine Coffee Shop, are truly a locals hang. The employees are always friendly, up for a quick conversation, and remember what you like. They do a great job of making you feel right at home. Shut out to all the good peeps there! Taste: Thumbs up! Picture yourself sitting down and opening up the wrapper of a visually stunning sandwich. Your mouth instantly floods with saliva as you tear it apart and notice the perfectly melted cheese dripping out the side of the sandwich. Right before you take a bit, you pause and dip the sandwich into the finely paired homemade vegetable soup sitting in front of you. You smile knowing the savory taste you are about to indulge in. The soup and sandwiches are some of the best tastings you will find for miles around. Having grown up in the land of delis in NJ, I have a sort of refined palette for such things. As if the sandwiches were not already the best around, Eats & Sweets also has some of the finest desserts. All homemade. Try the chocolate macaroons or the gluten-free cheesecake (even if you love gluten). Honestly, you can not go wrong with any dessert there. Dietary Accommodations: The gluten-free bread is super tasty and pairs well with the sandwiches. Eats & Sweets offers a variety of GF options for sandwiches and desserts. They also have some great salads as well. Vegans and vegetarians do not have to fret either. Overall Experience: Eats & Sweets is truly one of Lafayette's great local food hangs. The menu is simple and offers choices of suggested sandwiches or make your own. Same as the salad menu. The soups are always amazing and most times there is an option for the GF/dairy free patron and the anything goes, patron. The staff is always super nice and knowledgeable about the menu. Always making good suggestions. They make you feel like they want you there. Shout out to the owner Bobby for always being super cool and friendly. Lafayette offers a lot of dining options that always seems to be overpriced with servers that do not seem too friendly. Eats & Sweets is a great hang for just about anyone. Do know that summer hours are busy, so you may have to be patient. But, the overall experience is worth the wait. read more

Really good ice cream (Birthday cake in regular cake cone) and it was a welcomed addition to not have to pay extra for a cake or sugar cone. The birthday cake ice cream was definitely a special recipe but I did not find it to sweet or lacking flavor. I wish the ice cream could fit further down into the bottom of the cone but I fixed that by pushing the ice cream down as I ate it. My husband loves the banana bread Ice Cream sandwich and made sure to get it along with two ice cream flavors. When mixing the flavors for the ice cream sandwich they give you the option to have the flavors side by side or on top of one another. I thought that was a good option to have should one need it. I also purchased a regular chocolate chip cookie (they have gluten free cookie options as well) and a small red velvet cupcake. I'll update the review after I have the chocolate chip cookie, but I found the red velvet cupcake to be pretty good. I scraped 85% of the icing off the top because it was too sweet for me but overall I enjoyed my trip to Eats and Sweets read more

eats & sweets - Birthday Cake Ice Cream in a cake cone with the regular chocolate chip cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Lafayette, Colorado

Went to lunch there today. The food was fresh and the sandwiches were fantastic. The service was very friendly. You definitely need to go if you are in the area. read more