Duffy's is OK. I have only been there once so I am not expert in all of their offerings. I can only speak for the hamburger. I know people rave about the burgers so we thought we would give it a try. Like I said, it was just OK. Service was good, wait staff pleasant, and a comfortable place to have lunch. Overall though, I feel I prefer Griff's Place in New Dorp for burgers. It may just be me so do not be discouraged about trying Duffy's yourself. read more

First time actually coming here. I've heard nothing but good reviews. They were accurate! Delicious burgers and egg roll. I would highly recommend trying them if your ever in the area. read more

See all

Always one of the best meals on the island! They truly do have the best burgers Entrées and specials are always very good and fresh I don't know why we attempt going to other places that serve similar menu when we always leave disappointed Last night we went to a place up the way it was so bad. We left the food and went to Duffy's. read more

Ordered a cheeseburger deluxe w fries order came out w potato chips Waitress was nice she realized it should have come w fries she corrected and brought fries. Cheeseburger was good but English muffins was not crispy it fell apart from wet lettuce and tomatoes. I had to pick at cheeseburger because muffin fell apart.Really not to impressed. Fries was frozen then cooked that were not so good. One of the kids working there actually tossed bill on table. My friend and I laughed.i jokingly said I should toss it back to him. I would go back but only for a pint of Guinness or a drink. Typical pub. read more

Normally, I love this place. The service is always great. Tonight, I ordered a Cobb salad and potato skins to go. I get the food home and to my surprise...two sunny side up egg instead of hard boiled eggs. Salad covered in runny egg yolks No dressing either. I call and am told ...it's no longer on the menu. Then I'm told "it's egg". I asked the person who answered if he understands the difference in the cooking methods of the egg. He replied NO. He gets a manager who says "sir you are being hostile with the employe And instructs me to bring back the food so he can see the problem and they will re make a new one when I arrive or you can get a free Cobb salad next time you come in (the salad that is no longer on the menu). I said no ...I will throw it out. He said OK. Have a good night. He also said the girl who took the order and the boy who answered the phone were not familiar with the menu. The salad was recently removed from the menu. Apparently the kitchen staff was unfamiliar as well and forgot the difference in a fried egg and a hard boiled egg. A simple. read more

Good food. Had their burger and fried ravioli. But it was rather busy on a week day and the one server they had was running around so much he never checked back in on us after delivering the food, not even to get us the check. Had to guilt the guy in charge of cleaning tables into taking our payment so we could leave. They had every baseball game on and one hockey game, so it's a great place to watch the games. read more

I had the biggest craving for a burger over the past few days so my husband took me to Duffy's for the first time after growing up going with friends. Let me just say how upset I am that he hasn't taken me here sooner!! When I tell you I had the bestttt burger I've had in a while I'm not exaggerating. Thick, juicy, and cooked to perfection! I cannot wait to come back! read more

The service is great! super friendly staff. The burgers are delicious especially on the English muffin bread. Their chicken wraps are great also. The beers are great they always have a game on!! read more

Fabulous burgers, entire staff couldn't be nicer and more attentive. Place is kept spotless, and every plate looked great. Can't wait to go back and try their Ruben. 4 stars in stead of 5 , because seating is tight. You need a plan b in case you can't park, but worth traveling to from out of the area. read more

After Staten Island half, we waited for dinner to celebrate my friend's accomplishment! I was excited because I've heard of Duffy a bunch but didn't have a chance to go (or really I forgot!). Ordered a speciality burger- blackened blue cheese burger with a side l their fries. Definitely like the crinkle cut- they're crunchy! Good to note: they don't have a surcharge fee for credit cards! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Duffy's was one of our regular spots when we lived around the corner. We were on Staten Island this weekend and I had some free solo time and stopped in for lunch. My wife was at a baby shower, my son was hanging out with his friends. Duffy's is your typical neighborhood bar / tavern. It's been here forever. The beer is cold, the drinks strong and the food consistently good. They brag that they have the island's best burgers (debatable) but, they are really really good. I ordered off the Saturday special menu. A cup of New England Clam Chowder and the Cowboy Burger hit the spot on a rainy dreary day yesterday. The burger was delicious and cooked to order. The service was nice too. I washed it all down with a draft Miler High Life. Craft beer and fancy cocktails are not on the menu here. read more

See all

This was my 2nd time at Duffy's. I really enjoy the burgers and wings. The sangria was also really good. And the staff is really pleasant and welcoming. read more

See all

Asked the bartender how much a miller was and he said "if you gotta ask it's too much" crazy work for a guy working for tips.

I visited this place with my girlfriend, it was our first time and the experience was beyond words.. service was friendly and the food was delicious.. read more

Great dive bar! I think we were the only people at the bar that didn't know everyone else who came in. We were treated nicely by a friendly bartender. They are famous locally for their burger and it's no wonder. I had a provolone and bacon burger served on an English muffin and cooked to medium perfection. Wifey had a delicious chicken sandwich and we shared perfectly cooked onion rings. They had a half dozen beers on tap. The place looks nice and retro but well kept. 5 large TVs played the last week of NFL games. If you are hungry for a burger and thirsty for a beer this is your place! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is my favorite bar and restaurant in Staten Island bar none.. Growing up in the area, i've been coming to this place since I was a kid. The burgers are some of the best i've ever had. It's served on an english muffin which goes perfectly with the thick patties they have. I usually get it with a side of sweet potato fries which are always cooked just right. They are also known for their wings and other dishes but the burger is what really makes this place special. Everyone I know agrees this is the best burger spot on the island. Drinks are also great. They have any domestic beer you can think of and a few imported ones as well. The vibe this place has really makes you want to drink domestic though. Service is very friendly and attentive. It's also very reasonably priced. Overall- Perfect place for a burger and fries and a few beers to go along with it. Multiple TVs make it great for watching a game. read more

Excellent food and highly attentive servers. Dive vibes are great when you just want good food and to keep it casual. Will go again and again and again. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Cheese burger on an English muffin, lettuce, tomato and onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I went here for a function earlier today. Food was not bad but it is in big portions. My only concern was the outdoor hut seemed a bit tight in space. Otherwise, it was a good experience. read more

Duffy's Tavern - Buffalo Chicken Sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Ambiance, Food, Service. All 5 Stars. I'll be back. PS- Ladies Room bathroom attendant Tara was the sweetest ever read more

Duffy's Tavern - Great drinks, great bartender. & he's cute ! - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I've been coming here since I was a child and the food has been fantastic each and every time! If you're looking for a table you better get there early, the restaurant fills up quickly and it's understandable! The burgers are the best on the island and best in the city!!! If you're looking for great local food at a great price this is definitely a must try!! Only drawback is the parking (understandable this is not the establishments fault) definitely A+ must try!! read more

0 stars. Had the worst encounter with a bartender EVER. Absolutely no customer service skills so rude it was disgusting. I went to order food next door with my friend and it was a 40 minute wait so we walked next door to Duffy's to grab a drink while we wait. The man behind the bar rudely screamed I don't make that what do you want when we asked for our drinks and then continued to yell I don't make that go across the street or something like we were children. It was rude and disgusting and embarrassing because the WHOLE restaurant turned around and looked at us. He rudely said I don't do those go across the street. I guess your bartender wants people to take their money and business elsewhere. We are grown adults and we're shunned away so disrespectfully because we asked for two shots he wasn't sure about. Would love to speak to management about this issue. read more

This quaint local bar is cozy with an extension the back for more customers. The servers are always pleasing. If you want to try one of the best burgers in NYC you have to go to Duffy's. read more

I love Duffy's. Excellent burger and assorted other bar foods. Be mindful this is a neighborhood old timers bar. No fancy drinks or food. Just the basics. And it's perfect. read more

I have been here many times tonight was not a good experience if your kitchen doesn't know how to cook a burger to the correct temperature that a customer orders use a meat thermometer, and American cheese is not the same as provolone cheese very disappointed won't be returning read more

Bartender service was outstanding. I customized my burger with their bacon jam. Was so delicious. Cant say enough about it.. please try it. You will not be disappointed. Monday night bartender is awesome. read more

Fantastic juicy hamburgers cooked to perfection with your choice of toppings ranging from tomatoes & lettuce to sautéed onions. The French fries are excellent here as well. Casual dining atmosphere. No reservations required. Parking in rear. Service is on time and polite. Have eaten here more than once and would definitely return! read more

Burger was nicely cooked but the roll was old. Should've jus stuck w the English muffin it comes on. Sweet potato fries speak for themselves. Like fried chicken, you'd have to Try Hard to mess them up. Coffee sucked. Their special penne shrimp vodka was deliciously piping hot, cheesy, spicy and fresh. Very very cool that a pub on the strip serves stellar pasta! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Duffy's is not just great burgers anymore. They have become so much more than that I had perhaps the best sandwich I've eaten in a while. Prime rib with cheese on focaccia with au jus. The meat was great, even though the fat was on the edges of the meat. The au jus was salty. The bread was so much better than using Italian hero bread. Their quesadillas are outstanding as well. I've heard great things about the fried chicken. Next time read more

I just ordered from Duffy's tavern and 2 great things occurred for my review . Quick delivery service as the food arrived like it just came from the kitchen . Second plus was the food was GREAT had a cheeseburger with waffle fries and it was perfect ! Also ordered the wings which had the right amount of sauce to them with some kick and lots of flavor . Once covid restrictions end I would love to experience the atmosphere of the tavern in person read more

Duffy's Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Too much cheese on the burger, literally a block of cheese. Cheap cheese. Patty was really dry, did not enjoy the English muffin as the breading. Burger fell apart with each bite. Onion rings were soggy. Steak was over cooked, no pink at all. read more

THE JUICE IS LOOSE! Straight up one of the best burger places in NYC. For the price of a fast food meal you can have a fat, meaty, and juicy burger that's cooked to perfection and leave you reaching for napkins to wipe the juice off your face and hands. The burger is plain, simple, and very flavorful, with no nonsense or unnecessary sauces. However, you can add toppings on it for extra cost. Definitely get their burger (medium rare), which will melt in your mouth like butter, yet it doesn't taste greasy! They serve the burger on an English muffin which tends to be more durable than a regular bun whic simply can't handle the juicyness of the burger. Plus it has less bread so you can enjoy more of their meaty goodness. The service is faster than some fast food joints. Nice staff with a manly bar atmosphere that will make you feeling like you can fight a bear or a fire after the meal. They are also known to make everything like wings, bacon, fries extremely crispy. Wouldn't be surprised they blowtorch all their food before serving. read more

See all

I like this place different take on there burger that are so good, there fires even there sweet potato fries are good. I don't get to go here much but when I do no Regrets read more

Duffy's what can I say. Best burger in Staten Island !! Always crowded and service always perfect

Oh my God, Duffy's Tavern was definitely magnificent. If you don't like a place with a great atmosphere, then don't go here. Each and every single item that we have ordered was very fresh and tasty. Not to mention, the service was terrific and the staff was really welcoming. Duffy's Tavern - Well worth the high reviews. read more

What's crazy is I go based offffff reviews ! Idk if it's cause it was Fuckin late or not but nahhhhhh ! Fries was not even half way cooked soggy asf ! As if they were microwaved for a minute and sent to me ! The fish isn't even fried the breading is still like white & light on one side !!! Boyyy the chilli does not move like the cheese wasn't even melted just a stack of American slices on top of some cold ass fuckin meat never in my life did I order 50$ worth of food and experience this ! The fuckin salad is BLACKKK ! Y'all did real bad duffys y'all need to be straight duffed ! read more

Amazing!!!! Nice fresh burger on a English muffin! Burger was huge and delicious, couldn't stop eating! read more

Duffy's Tavern - a plate of food - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Had lunch here with the Mrs. today before going to see the SI Yanks. We decided we were going to order off the specials menu. For an appetizer, we had the Cajun Steak Tips which had a nice little kick, it was served with salsa and sour cream. For burgers, (which may be the best on Staten Island), I had the Irish Cheddar burger with sweet potato fries and my wife had the Bleu Cheese burger with waffle fries. Everything was very good, we lucked out as the place was not very crowded. On a side note, they also have awesome French Onion Soup and Chili, which are great during those cold days. read more

See all

Greeting- by waitress Vibe/ barfly city Bathroom- fail Service- very good waitress Price- good Parking- street meters Food Burger $7.50 is a solid good burger in a english muffin Onion rings are huge and greasy yet tasty $2 extra WIGB? Yes if was walking by Time out mag best burger on SI Its a good burger. But do not drive to SI to get one. Its nit worthy if a burger sojourn. read more

See all

This is a hole in the wall Irish bar with probably the best cheeseburgers on Staten Island! Very good value/ price and the meat in the burgers is thick and very tasty. They are served on a toasted English muffin and with melted on cheddar cheese. Above average tasting fries too. The seating can get a bit cramped if they are busy - the tables are fairly close together and the hallway is kinda narrow. Nice authentic/ nostalgic bar atmosphere though. read more

Great friendly service. Ice cold beers and well mixed cocktails (we had a Bitburger and a Dirty Martini). The burger was perfectly cooked and juicy. Will definitely be coming back! read more

Duffy's Tavern - Smokehouse Burger and Seasoned Waffle Fries - Burgers Near Me - Staten Island, New York