Wow, I'm actually surprised by the low ratings this restaurant has been getting, since I've never had a bad experience there. Forgive me, now that I've grown to love this place, I feel like I need to defend it a bit.
So, it all started when one of my friends suggested this place because she had their #27 Sudado de Pescado and liked it. We were working all day that day so we had to just do take-out. I took her suggestion and ordered it, and it was delicious. I ate all of it. The flounder was cooked in a soupy, tomato-based sauce with onions, bell peppers, and serranos. Wonderful flavors and a great kick. All of my other co-workers enjoyed their dishes as well.
After that one experience, I was hooked, so after a second pleasant meal of take-out, I finally brought a friend to dine in. The place was very cute. They may have done some renovations recently, and it was very comfortable. We shared two dishes: #10 Lomo Saltado (sauteed tenderloin beef with onions, tomatoes, french fries, and green onions) and #13 Saltado de Verduras con Pollo (sauteed mix of vegetables with chicken in a special sauce). Both were delicious. The beef was tender and the vegetables were so crisp. Nothing was overcooked. The chicken was also tender. On that day, the #13 was the daily special, so it came with a soup. It had a medley of vegetables, but the broth was bursting with the flavors of cilantro and chicken. I couldn't get enough of it. I was so pleased with the food, I ordered some take-out to bring to my fiance.
Today, my friend and I went back, and she told me that the day after I took her to Don Pedro's, she brought her boyfriend to try the food. He liked the food as well. She introduced me to one of their appetizers they had together last time: #2 Papa Rellena. She ordered it again today, and I took a taste. It was so full of goodness: a potato stuffed with beef, onions, egg, and a little sweetness and tartness from some raisins. The pickled sliced onion salad that accompanied it was crisp and refreshing.
I've had other Peruvian food, and this place probably isn't 100% authentic, but you have to think about how this place needs to maintain its business: by targeting Americans, NOT Peruvians or Americans who have gone to Peru and know what Peruvian food is. The same thing goes for any ethnic food. I mean, if you only wanted authentic Chinese food, then forget about ever finding it in the US, maybe aside from the handful in NYC or Southern California. But, I'll bet that they have at least few dishes on their menu that are "Americanized."
As far as I am concerned, everything I've ordered off the menu has been good. Believe me, I'm not one to settle for mediocre food and neither are my friends.
At the end of the day, Don Pedro's has good food, good service, and good prices. What more can you ask for? I say give it a chance. read more