I would like to give them five stars for the pizza which was better than I expected with really…read moregood crust. But they blew it on a few other important things. They told us 20-30 minutes on the phone, but it took an hour so we had to sit and wait 30 minutes longer than we had planned. The 18" pizza was under cooked, the veggies on this pizza were raw and we had to finish cooking the pizza when we got them home. Our second pizza with garlic, chicken and white sauce was good but light on chicken, some slices had no meat, and several slices had no spinach. Spinach is cheap, they could have put a lot more on and the cost would have been pennies. For a somewhat expensive pizza they need to raise the bar on toppings. The pizza dough was great, and the cheesy bread and marinara was also spot on. All in this was a far super pizza to Dominos or Pizza Hut and prices along the lines of a Godfathers or Mellow Mushroom.

Ordered over the phone and pizza was hot and ready when we got there. Young staff obviously have it…read moretogether. Large Supreme had wonderful crispy crust which didn't deflate in the box. Adequate toppings exactly as described. Just the right amount of everything and the cheese blend is unique. Will be our go to pizza place!

Food was excellent. Service was swift even though I added…read moresomething to my telephone order when I arrived I enjoyed watching the employees work. Clean and efficient and respectful toward each other Overall a good experience.

I was told this was the best pizza in Jacksonville, but I have to disagree. It was mediocre at…read morebest. There was nothing really special about the pizza. I took it to go, so I didn't eat in the restaurant. I cannot comment on service or ambience.

We stayed on Emerald Isle for a week and were told that this is the best pizza on the island by a…read morecouple of people... so we decided to give it a chance for dinner one night. It was a supreme type of pizza. And it was bad. It was not cooked all the way. So we tried 15 more min in the oven at our condo... We didnt even keep the leftovers. Based on my experience, drive across the bridge for pizza..

The positives: delivery was fast and the Stromboli was tasty…read more The negative: the pizza and the marinara sauce. The sauce tasted more like ketchup than marinara. The pizza was so flavorless and disappointing.

Pizza is dull and tasteless. Same Pizza Hut experience wherever you go. I prefer real Italian pizza…read moreand not a cheap knockoff.

Horrible! the worst order ever. First, when we went to pick up the order it took my wife having to…read moreopen the door several times and tapping on the counter with her keys to get service! Second, we arrived home and we had like 2 inches of bread on the sides and like three in the corners. Toppings were in shape of a circle when we ordered the square pizza (big box) it seems like they have a bunch of lazy employees that do not like their job. I did not return it because my little daughter was really hungry and also to avoid them doing something to our next order for returning it! This has been the worst order that we have ever received and worst customer service. If they dont like their job send them to get a new one! Sorry but not returning nor recommending!

Don't let the location fool you! They make amazing pizza! I grew up on Godfathers Pizza and had…read morethought that they went out of business. This was the first time I had heard the name in so long that I wasn't sure if it was the same pizza place. It was recommended that we try their pizza and not knowing if it was the same pizza as my childhood, I ordered a basic pepperoni pizza and found that it tasted the same as the pizza from my childhood! That's why I say don't let the location fool you! Yes, they are located right next to a gas station, but they have good foodies, friendly staff, and the wait time isn't bad. If you're wanting to try something different from the other pizza places, I say give Godfathers a try!

I wish they had their own restaurant sad that one of the best pizza places in Jacksonville is in a…read moregas station

Hoagies, Pizzas & Italian water ices are great. They know exactly how to serve & prepare toasted…read morehoagies as well. The place reminds of many good pizza & hoagies restaurants from upstate NY. Great Restaurant

We got the Buffaroni pizza which is pepperoni with ranch, buffalo, and hot honey. I enjoyed the…read moretoppings. Both my husband and I agreed the pizza was undercooked. I would suggest ordering well done for a fully cooked pizza. The service was order at the counter and they were very polite. We would give it 3.5/5 stars.

I frequently head to Sugar Hill Pizzeria on Sunday evenings when I have work in Kinston. I always…read moreorder the same thing, a supreme pizza, so I can't speak for all of the other things on their menu. But I've enjoyed delicious pizza each time I've visited. The staff is friendly and helpful.

Excellent food, excellent service and a great atmosphere. Pricing is reasonable and they have the…read morebest pizza in town.

All the employees were pleasant and helpful. My family and I didn't like the flavor of the pizza…read more The cheese pizza was the most palatable. It could just be that we are new to NC and where we're from we were used to something different. We ordered some assorted slices as well and 2 of 4 were burnt on the bottom. Edit: I know it's a far stretch here, but have you considered that fact that Yelp asks days later if you'd still like to leave a review so I thought why not..now I have the owner scratching his head and finding it suspicious that someone could possibly have not been thrilled by his pizza. It was a review from a day you were very much open, Friday. I still think that any and everyone should give it a try if they are so inclined. I'm also thrilled that so many people have enjoyed it. As a business owner, your immediate response to a review should not be to attack the reviewer. This interaction has left a much worse taste in my mouth than the burnt pizza.

As a native New Yorker from THE Island this place is spot on!!!…read moreGreat authentic pizza, REALLY!

On the road again & kept hearing about these homemade Mozzarella Cheese Stix from this local…read morepizzeria...so I had to try it out! Yes, if you are in The New Bern area and have a craving for Pizza - This is the SPOT! 1st they told me it would be about 40 min & they showed up w/in 25-30min!!! The Mozz Stix are amazing (see pics). You can order a 3 or 6 piece & comes w/ pizza sauce for dipping. Also ordered a slice of cheese just to check out their sauce & style - great thin crust w/ flavorful sauce & extremely large slices for $2.95. Finally had to check out the Stromboli. Ordered the Steak & Cheese and it did not disappoint. Overall this spot is a local hidden gem w/ homemade flavorful items at a great price range. Definitely worth a try if you are in the area!

I moved to New Bern from New Jersey four years ago, and I'm so grateful to have found this little…read morepiece of home away from home. The pizza is exceptionally good, the garlic knots are delicious, and the mozzarella sticks are honestly some of the best fried cheese I've ever had. Don't sleep on their subs or salads either! I've had the Italian sub and the steak and cheese salad with oil and vinegar as the dressing--both are absolutely spot-on every time. There are a few tables available for dine-in, and if you live in River Bend (the neighborhood it's located in), they offer delivery right to your door. Ordering for pickup is also super easy and convenient.