Triple Header: Wonderful service. Good Food. Great Pricing…read more Recommended for taking your folks out for dinner.

Always my favorite on the Cape, the food and the service are amazing. (If weather is friendly the…read moreoutside tables are magical!!)

Great stop after a long day on Nantucket. A must stop any time we go to the Cape. Relaxing…read moreatmosphere, service was great and the food is the best! (The seafood tower was more than enough for our fam or 4!)

Food was amazing. I had the clam chowder and my wife had the Lobster bisque…read more Issue I had with them, this is not a bowl. Especially at $13.95. My Moscow mule was $15. Reason I gave them a 3 is their billing. They charge 3.95 percent when paying by credit card. So the " shack " is a pricey place and felt a little duped with the bowl and the billing process.

We've been by Baxter's Boathouse and Wharf restaurant a million times as we take the Hyline Boat to…read moreNantucket at least monthly. I'm glad we did stop in today!! Plenty of parking, free too. Right near the Steamship Authority landing. We opted to sit outdoors, 72 Degrees, sun under clouds, umbrella, and a very slight light wind. The smell of the high tide coming in. Just incredible. Serendipitous. Seafood Bisque... we are sold! Always thought the best was at the Sagamore Inn, but Baxter's beats it by a mile AND they make it on site daily. Hot, thick, briney, and delicious; full of lobster and scallops. True New England seafood perfection!! She had the Broiled Cod, and I the Broiled Scallops. Both were absolute perfection as well (I think we found a new go-to place at the landings)! A teeny bit off of the beaten path, but so worth it! Glad we finally did it! Wonderful staff, and the prices are not touristy robbery either. No negatives whatsoever.

Great ambiance but service and food is lacking. Food is not worthy of the price they are charging…read more $23 for a small bowl of fried fish bites served in a plastic bowl on a paper plate. No water offered, coke was not refilled. Been there done that .

PJs will always be an institution! Yes they make delicious fried clams and lobster rolls, but don't…read moresleep on their other dinners. We just wanted a light snack because it was a little late in the day. A friendly woman (who I believe was an owner) was training someone and recommended the tuna sashimi dinner. We got that and a cup of their amazing clam chowder and it was perfect. The fish was fresh as was the rice and salads. Later in the week we returned for fried clams, scallops, and a fish dinner which were equally perfect. See you next year!

In search of a new seafood shack after breaking up with Arnold's for ethnical reasons, I chose PJ's…read morefor my yearly fix of fried seafood. We ate on the patio on a high top table near a screen window, which was lovely. The biggest advantage over Arnold's is that the joint is BYOB. That's a rare thing in the Cape. The fried cod was flaky, lightly coated, and perfectly fried with an abundant amount of homemade French fries, a roll, and standard fare Cole Slaw. The roll is unnecessary, in my opinion. Missing having onion rings on the menu. Arnold's (and the old Liam's at Nauset Beach) made the best. Condiments are serve-yourself, but you'll have to ask the host for lemon slices. We'll return for fried food but will continue to search other locales. We went back the next night for ice cream and it was just average. $5 for a small scoop in a bowl, we were charged more for a small sundae than what was advertised on the board, and service was very slow. However, the sundae hit the spot and they didn't skimp on the hot fudge and walnuts.

A wonderful seafood restaurant in old Route 6A! No negatives whatsoever. A warm and nostalgic…read moreestablishment that reminds me of the Statuit in Scituate, Mass. back in the 1980s-early 1990s. This place, hmm, it is like going back to my childhood home; nice woodwork, good lighting, and strewn with nautical themed items throughout. A large dining room, a bar, and an area of hightop tables. Exceptionally clean with plenty of room. Plenty of parking behind the building. Don't go too fast of it will take you a five mile trek to do a "youie". Another lovely and warming touch, much like the Statuit or the Wayside Inn, you start with crackers and cheese - very nice. We ordered raw bar, a Baker's Dozen of the fatest, coldest, and delicious oysters along with a half dozen shrimp. All prepared very well too. My bride ordered the fish tacos and she loved them. I had the stuffed scallops with mushrooms and lobster - again fantastic! A sophisticated dish. Excellent staff, friendly, accommodating, and just a pleasure to be around. Zack and George, just the best! Wonderful service!! The prices are spot on too. It may look like a typical New England Pub/Tavern burger joint, but it is so much more than that. Go slow on Old Route 6A, on the left as you are heading west. Five stars. Worth the stop!!

We had a really enjoyable dinner here last night using a Cape Cod Daily Deal, and the experience…read moreended up being wonderful from the moment we were seated. Our server, Mitch, was outstanding -- soft‑spoken, professional, and genuinely attentive. He explained the specials clearly, checked in at just the right moments, and kept everything moving smoothly. In the off‑season on Cape Cod, that level of service is rare and very appreciated. We started with mai tais. They weren't traditional -- definitely on the sweeter side -- but still very tasty and fun to sip. For an appetizer, we shared the calamari, which was excellent: crisp, tender, and full of flavor. For dinner, my husband had the salmon special, coated in pistachios and cooked beautifully. I ordered the shrimp and scallop fra diavolo, which was delicious -- generous portions, perfectly cooked seafood, and a sauce with just the right amount of heat. Both meals were so plentiful that we brought home leftovers, and neither of us had room for dessert. Overall, this was a great meal with standout service. Mitch made the late afternoon feel smooth, warm, and well cared for. We left happy, full, and impressed -- a lovely meal out.

Had a great dinner tonight, the scallops were fantastic. My wife had the fish and chips, she…read morereally enjoyed them. The oysters were fresh and extremely tasteful. I believe our servers name was Avari, she was very helpful and gave us some great suggestions Thank you for a great evening.

Wow-what a difference a few years makes. Previously this…read morewas our absolute fav restaurant on the PLANET. Now, I don't think we will come back. We had oysters which were good, but followed by our entre, swordfish and a burger. Just sadly, ZERO TASTE. I'm a bit incredulous-what has changed?? Both of our meals were not good. I'm just so sad.

Similar food but a little more upscale than a typical fried seafood shack on Cape Cod…read more The food at Cooke's hasn't changed much in the past 30 years. They have the typical fried seafood players and lobster rolls that you would find elsewhere. They do have a large air conditionied dining room (you order at a cou ter and they bring your food to you). They also serve beer and wine

My girlfriend and I stopped here for lunch. We got 2 drinks, fish and chips, a cheeseburger (didn't…read morecome with fries, those are extra) and fried calamari. You order at the front counter, pay for the food right then, and then sit wherever you'd like and they do bring the food over to you but it's not like a traditional waitstaff role and after a grand total of $74.85 I was still presented with the do you want to tip 20% on the little kiosk thing that you tap your card on. I tip for service, not somone handing me my food on a tray. This place is for you if you wear Birkenstocks, drive a Tesla and you're willing to drop $80 on basic seafood for two people. It's fish and chips, not a NY strip choice usda certified angus beef grass fed gluten free filet mingon, it shouldn't be $26.

Food was good and on time!!! Swan river fish sandwich and…read morefries were delicious and the fish and chips were great. The lobster salad was short on lobster, but tasty.

Everything! Terrible vibe.. food very average and extremely overpriced…read more Not a welcoming vibe with zero atmosphere. Ordered a flatbread which was mediocre at best, and SO small I was done in 5 bites! Price $20! Glass of average wine $14 Went there because I have the last surname hoping it would be nice..will NOT be back. Very disappointing.