I took the ferry today from Bayshore Long Island to go to Ocean Beach fire Island. It was my first…read moretime there. So I was walking around and I was looking for something quick to eat didn't wanna spend a lot of money and I saw this little pizzeria and I figured I'd give it a try. I ordered one regular slice and one Sicilian slice and I also got a soda. It came out to 1765 yes, a little pricey. But I gotta say I'm pleasantly surprised both slices were really good. I would probably even say 8.5 out of 10. Both slices were a little crispy chewy and definitely tasted fresh right amount of cheese the right amount of sauce. I added a little red pepper for a kick. No lie the pizza was really shockingly good did not expect that from a beach area. My only regret was not ordering another slice but I'll definitely come back. Also the girls were very nice there and helpful .

We ordered the Calamari Arrabiatta and 3 slices of pizza…read more ALL WERE PERFECT! The flavors that dance around on your tastebuds from the calamari Arrabiatta are amazing. The tangy little kick from the sauce is absolutely memorable. We dipped our pizza into the sauce and BOY OH BOY that changed everything! The perfect NY pizza can not always be found outside of NYC or the boroughs, but you better your a55, you'll find it at Beacheria. The place is clean and quirky. The employees seem to take so much pride in their place of work and the foods made. I even think I heard the manager telling the cooks how much we enjoyed our food. The best thing is to know that they received our feedback immediately. OH! and they have PAC-MAN!

Pizza Time located off Neighborhood Road in Mastic Beach, Long Island offers an array of pizzas,…read morecalzones and pasta. I started my journey at Pizza Time with an order of their chicken roll and I asked for extra marinara sauce, you gotta have extra marinara so the Gewy cheese sauce and chicken cutlets matches well with it. However, my tastebuds were a little disappointed because the marinara sauce was not what I expected, however there's always opportunity to better ourselves with quality ingredients. The chicken roll was good, it was baked to my liking but the sauce was not pleasant. I then ordered their Rice Ball and I would have to say that I struggled to enjoy. Every pizzerias has their way of making their rice balls but the rice ball was cold and just wasn't suiting my craving. But I strongly believe that Pizza Time can be recommended by those that are locals and love pizza, if I had to give them a chance of redemption, I would have to try their pizzas and not their chicken rolls or rice balls. They have a very adorable menu and they offer a 2 slice and a drink special for only $6.50, you can't beat that price! Stop on by on your next trip and give Pizza Time a try.

First things first. The food is awesome. The service is awesome. Everybody's wonderful and polite…read morethere. It is very embrace of when you go there. You get welcomed and you get thank you and you get polite. Everything, those people know how to treat everybody the right way, just like their family. I see that that place should get 100% likes. No matter what the case is, it's in the right corner where everybody can go and get some very good pizza. And it's right next to a church also, and right next to a Fire

If you're looking for the kind of pizza spot that leaves a lasting impression, this spot was one of…read morethem. We made a quick pit stop here before heading out to Long Beach to catch the sunset and some live music on a Friday night. Let me just say, this place absolutely hits the mark, whether you're grabbing a pie to go or taking your time and soaking in the lively, authentic pizzeria vibe. The ambiance is effortlessly inviting. When you step in, you're greeted by the smell of fresh baked dough, gooey cheese, and a friendly crew behind the counter. Even though we were in a rush, you could tell Saint James is the kind of place where locals gather, families grab an easy dinner, and pizza lovers unite over a hot, cheesy slice. The walls are filled with classic memorabilia, and there's just something homey and vibrant about the space. Now to the star of the show: the pizza! We ordered a classic cheese pie right from their Yelp page (super easy process, by the way! All the menu options are laid out with prices and descriptions, and online ordering was a breeze). The crust was that perfect balance of thin, crisp on the bottom, with just enough chew to make each bite satisfying. The cheese was plentiful, gooey, and rich, with a tangy tomato sauce that tasted homemade. We enjoyed our pie oceanside at the beach, and even after the drive it held up perfectly. No sogginess or limp crust! I can only imagine how fantastic their pies are fresh from the oven in-house. Next time, I'm grabbing a seat and trying the pasta, too.

The pizza was good, and so fresh made to order! The only down fall was the grandma was really oily-…read morebut still tasty! The staff was incredibly friendly I will definitely return just because of the service!

Solid pizza and super friendly staff . The prices are very reasonable . This is my family's go to…read morewhen in KP .

Long Island has a pizza parlor on every corner. It doesn't mean they're all good. If you're looking…read morefor that perfect, no-frills, consistently delicious slice, Short Stop Pizza absolutely delivers. The pizza is exactly what you want it to be...crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right balance of cheese. Every bite tastes fresh and well-made, not rushed or overly greasy like you find in a lot of places. It's the kind of spot where you know you're getting a solid, satisfying meal every time. It even arrives hot with delivery. Beyond the food, iIt feels like a true neighborhood staple, the kind of place you keep coming back to because it never disappoints. Simple, reliable, and genuinely good pizza and subs. Highly recommend.

The Pizzeria was absolutely amazing! Excellent service, incredible pizza, and the broccoli pinwheel…read morewas SO good. Definitely one of the best pizzas we've had on Long Island, and we'll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend!

Lilly and Brian both did an amazing job behind the counter, making the experience even better. And…read morethe pizza? Absolutely delicious! It's definitely a spot to visit weekly for a good slice of pizza or a satisfying meal.

Over the years we've tried and frequented many pizza restaurants in the area (Huntington,…read moreCenterport, Northport, Greenlawn), and we've chosen Broadway Pizza to be our weekly go to. In our opinion, they have the best tasting sauce, and the proper sauce-cheese ratio.

Great ny pizza and very friendly team. I almost got an impulse slice of Sicilian because it looked…read moreso good!

4.5 Stars (I rounded up)…read more We ordered a large deep dish pepperoni pie with hot honey, garlic knots and a salad for delivery during the dinner rush. The guy who took the order was very pleasant, polite & well organized. After speaking with him, I was confident that the order would be executed correctly. Kudos as well to the delivery guy, who had the pizza to us in 20 minutes, piping hot. The pizza was delicious, like rock star status. The pie had a delicious (plentiful) sauce, and they use the little pepperoni which gets crispy and curls up with a little pool of oil (LOVE THIS). The hot honey that was drizzled on the light/buttery crust was a nice finish to each slice. How do they coax so much flavor into that dough? This will now be a weekly routine except we're going to rotate the deep dish offering and try the meatball burrata. Garlic knots were cold, hard and lacking Parm and EVOO?? Caesar salad was run of the mill with a micro-portion of dressing. We will be back.

Hands down, the best pizza around. Never had any less than 5 star. Everything about it is…read moreperfection. Our absolutely favorite is a well done Margarita pizza. Only con is that everyone else knows about it too, so can get busy. If ordering from delivery, take note of the day and time. There can sometimes be a wait, but it's TOTALLY worth it. You know that "can't wait until morning when I can have a cold slice for breakfast" feeling? Not gonna happen because there is never anything left!

Always fresh made. Stopped in for a quick bite around lunchtime. It was quite busy. They offered a…read morelunch menu which you can choose soup or salad & the other was pasta or sandwich. Which was perfect for us.

Pizza here was fine. Nothing too special. I ordered a regular slice and a Sicilian slice with…read moresausage. Both were good. They have a good amount of seating inside and the staff is pretty friendly. I wouldn't drive an hour to come here, but it certainly isn't a bad place to visit if you're in the area. 3.5 stars.