We tried three different cookies - brookie, reverse, and a chocolate marshmallow concoction that I didn't get the name of. The brookie and the reverse were very similar, both very soft and gooey and over the top sweet. The chocolate marshmallow cookie was my favorite of the three because the cookie had a small amount of crisp on the exterior that added a dimension to what was also a very soft sugar bomb interior. None of cookies were bad. If you want a sweet indulgence, any of them will satisfy. Literally any of them. I could hardly tell them apart. The best part for me was the sauces that they add to the cookie before serving. That at least mixed up the flavors a little. The restaurant has a few tables inside and out. There isn't a public bathroom available, though, so don't plan on staying long. They have great hours, but maybe haven't figured out how to service the entire shift yet. On weeknights they are open until 9:00 and on Saturday they are open until 11:00. I originally tried around 9:30 pm on a Saturday night and the store was out of all but two flavors of cookies. When I came back on a Wednesday night at 8:00 pm they had most flavors, but were out of two. I don't know how common it is for them to be out of cookies, but 2/2 isn't a good look. If all you sell are cookies, you better have cookies when people want them. I met the same employee on both visits. He was very nice, quick to greet us after arriving, and clear on the menu limitations. I'm not sure if he is staff or ownership, but either way I think he is an asset to business. They have a sign that says they sell ice cream to go with the cookies. I peeked into the counter to see what kind of ice cream and it was mostly empty, so I'm not sure what the options are on that front. Maybe just simple chocolate and vanilla? Not sure. I think the cookies would go pretty well with ice cream and if I went back I would probably try that. Price is kind of steep for cookies (~4.55 each), but not out of line with what other fancy bakeries charge for their cookies. This is never going to be a frequent stop for me, but it was fun to try. read more

Poor girl was all alone behind the counter and it was busy! She was friendly and worked quickly We ordered one of every cookie as it was our first time Cookies were good. The reverse resees and cookies and cream are really yummy! The chocolate chip was not the greatest. Really sugary you could taste the sugar grains. All and all if I was in the mood for a cookie and this place was close I would go again. This is an update: about 30 min after we ate these today me AND my husband were puking. Before someone comments it's because we ate all The cookies we literally only had a quarter of each cookie. Some that we didn't like as much just a bite so it wasn't from over doing it. Because of this I'm dropping my rating to 2 stars read more

See all

So I partook in group order. It was fast. Shared a reversed Reese's and brookie. Um yassss! So delicious and gooey!! Soft center makes it one percent better than crumbl I loved it read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - Tiffany box of cookies - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

If I could give a negative I would!! 2/3 times we've gone, they've given us an oatmeal raisin cookie. Once we asked for a seasonal and the other time it was a gluten free. The second time the worker told us they were in the oven and to come back in 15 min. We waited 15 minutes and paid $5 for a cookie I couldn't eat. ??? read more

The marketing for Dirty Dough is top notch. They popped up on social media feeds and had to find them to try right away. I was intrigued by their cookies filled with different fillings. We got a box of 6 and were sadly disappointed. Every cookie just kind of blended together and were bland. Not really worth the calories and over sweetness. read more

These cookies were amazing! We got a box of 4 and got the regular chocolate chip, Oreo, Reeses and Butter Cookie. They're all great. I would much rather come here rather than any other cookie stop. The service there was great and friendly. Can't wait for my next cheat day to come back. read more

See all

We've been excited to try this place since they opened. I read a few bad reviews about it being too doughy, but we wanted to try it out. The box says you either microwave or bake the cookies after purchasing so we did that and honestly, they were still too doughy and not good. My favorite was the one with the pretzel, but likely because it was the best texturally. I wouldn't return. read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

It was opening day, the restaurant filled quickly at 10 am and the receipts had no names or numbers on them making it a tad difficult to know who had what. Online ordering was on a thirty minute delay. Adding to the confusion was additional opening day events such as balloon animals and a wheel which was near impossible to spin against the flow of incoming and outgoing traffic. The raspberry chocolate cookie was being handed out freely to the line as well as buy one get one cookies and coffee which was both free and utterly terrible. The chocolate chip cookie was quite boring. A lob of dough. The raspberry filled cookie was more of a lava cake when reheated and was a wonderful gooey mess. The inside out Reese's cup was brilliant. This shows the brand's value to a crowded cookie marketplace. I can see them being friendly and relaxing when the issues are ironed out. read more

See all

Normally never have an issue here, but we came today (3/23/25) and arrived at 10:20a (they open at 8am) the girl saw me, walked to the back and took over 10 minutes to help us, once we finally ASKED for some service, and she was rude with her answer. None of the lights were on in the store, and she acted like she did not want to be here at all. read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

I was skeptical about the concept of cookies with filling! I am a pretty plain cookie eater I guess (love a good sugar cookie). These are tasty and not overly sweet. My fave was the cookies n creme. The raspberry toaster tart had great flavors but the cookie itself was way too raw for me. This was like eating dough basically. Crisp on outside and soft on inside is my ideal. The Reese cookie had a liquid filling. If you like peanut butter desserts - this is a must try. My second fave was the the kitchen sink which was sweet and salty, and topped with a pretzel. Overall I think they are good and pretty creative esp at the price point. I'd compare it to a lions cub in both size and price. read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - a box of doughnuts - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Being fairly new they've got some staffing issue kinks to work out. There was only ONE worker as far as I can see and she not only had to run the register but she had to make the cookies as well. Also the door was locked from the outside automatically so if you want to get in then someone from the inside is going to have to open the door for you to get in. Nevertheless the one worker exhibited great calm under pressure and was polite and efficient. These cookies aren't pre decorated and ready to go like at CRUMBL's. The one worker had to get the base stuffed cookie, add the toppings, swirls, and decorations herself after she rung you up so this makes walking in kind of a hassle because there is a considerable wait, especially if the person in front of you orders dozens and dozens of cookies. I recommend ordering your cookies ahead after you see what you want on their website. Now to the cookies. They are ALL fabulous and scrumptious and there is like a stuffed gooey center filled with various peanut butters, creams, chocolates, fudges etc. I would say that they're BETTER than CRUMBL's because of the thick rich gooey lump in the center, the moist, homemade taste and flavor as opposed to CRUMBL's mass produced appeal, and the cookies at this place are made to look EXACTLY as advertised. The last time I went to CRUMBLS the worker had the nerve to ARGUE with me about how much toppings could be placed on the cookie and how it's against managements orders to apply more. The cookie I paid for not only didn't look like the ones advertised online but didn't even look like the sample cookies they had out on the counter! All I asked for was a FEW more pieces of cookie dough on the featured cookie for that week and the CRUMBL worker began shaking, gyrating, foaming at the mouth, and preaching about how she can't put a few more nuggets of raw cookie dough as decoration on the cookie and if she did how she would be sent to Chillicothe Womens Correctional Facility. I guess CRUMBL's was so comfortable being at various locations and especially Hilliard that the overall customer service at that place has gone SOUTH and they don't believe in giving you your moneys worth anymore. Sometimes competition can be a good thing and hopefully this place works out their staffing issues because overall I think they have a great business model, good location, good product, and great customer service and hopefully they mop the floor with the CRUMBL's Hilliard location and wipe them off the face of the EARTH! read more

See all

Went in after dinner and lights were out. No cookies were ready and employee was mad we walked in.

Dirty dough was delicious! The staff member there was really friendly and attentive even though he was the only person working that day

Service was HORRIBLE. I ordered 2 hours ahead knowing i'd need the cookies and that they wouldn't be sold out. Only come to find out just because you order they don't care. Got there opened my box and it was cookies I didn't order and they didn't even inform me. Then argued with me when I said I wanted what I ordered because the women didn't want to make more at 2:00 PM not even near closing. Wish I could give a 0 star read more

Ordered cookies online on a Saturday for an anniversary treat at 9pm (they close at 11pm on Saturdays). Drove 20 minutes to pick up my cookies that I had paid for and when I arrived (an hour and a half before they were supposed to close) the store was already closed and I never got my cookies. It's now Tuesday and I've called several times and went to the store again asking to get a refund and I have yet to get my cookies or a refund. read more

I've tried this place a few times now, and I've been pretty happy with it so far! It reminds me of Crumbl, but the cookies here are *stuffed* with goodies! They have some flavors that are always available, and they also have a rotation so there are always new things to try. I'vell tried the cookies and cream, reese's, brownie, raspberry jam, biscoff, cinnamon roll, and a chocolate one with marshmallow stuffing. They were all pretty good. I've only ever had one that was straight up not cooked enough. This absolutely has not kept me from returning. FYI there is one cookie that stands out every time: the cookies and cream. Do not sleep on this one! It's so good!! read more

Terrible milkshakes tasted like soggy cookies and were $7 a piece. Half our our milkshakes was jus wiped cream they didn't take the time to even fill them up all the way. Cookies were alright don't understand all the hype about them. Didn't have much flavor and were very gooey in the middle. Regret even stopping in and making an order I will not be coming back! read more

I was super excited to try Dirty Dough, but I am unfortunately extremely dissatisfied with the cookies! I got a cookie that was so doughy I had to try and cook it in the oven. Which did not work. And I know cookie places like this like to do a doughy kind of cookie but it genuinely looked/tasted as if it didn't even get cooked, it was disgusting. I am so bummed. read more

Wow! This place is dangerous! We tried the Chubby Hubby, and it was delicious! Chocolate, peanut butter, and pretzel combined to create an unbelievable delight! read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - Chubby Hubby Dirty Dough Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I would give this 6/5 if I could coming from spoiled California here. The workers here are just the nicest, the cookies are absolute GOD TIER and for being such a busy place and the service is lightning fast (when I say fast, I mean like faster than fast food fast). Seriously thrown away by this place, haven't had a good cookie in a while: not too sweet, layered flavors, nearly perfect texture, and great palate variety! I will say, I've tried a few cookies places before: Crumbl, Insomnia, Dirty cookie, etc. (more than I can count in Cali) but this is still easily one of the best! When I moved to Ohio, I never really understood the hype behind Crumble besides maybe the size. Their cookies were a little bit too sweet for me, farrr too dense (almost uncooked) and in general just doesn't match the balance that Dirty Dough has. PLUS, Im not sure if it's just me but I absolutely hate wasting my time waiting for a pack of 4-6 cookies (I'm talking 1-2 hours, not including waiting in line). If you're looking for one of the best cookies in Ohio, I always recommend this place as a staple of the Columbus area! read more

See all

I made an order online because their website says they were open until 11 PM. It is 528 and I go to pick up my order from the store and the doors locked in the closed. read more

Amazing customer service and cookies and cream cookies with ice cream is delicious 10/10 read more

Dirty Dough - Hilliard - Desserts Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Stopped in the Hilliard Dirty Dough this week to see what the shouting' was all about. The young lady who waited on me was pleasant and knowledgeable. I went for the reverse Reese's. I'm a sucker for a warm peanut butter cookie. The Reese's peanut butter cup pieces were too dry for my liking, the rest of the topping were good and ample. HOWEVER, I was over half way into my cookie when I pulled out a long blonde hair. Needless to say VERY DISAPPOINTING! This was my first and last visit. MAYBE I BETTER UNDERSTAND THE "DIRTY" COMPONENT TO DIRTY DOUGH'S. read more

I picked up a stuffed chocolate chip cookie today and it was raw! I like my cookies soft, but not raw! Something went wrong, not a good experience. read more

Loved it! Cookies served WARM and seats to eat right away. Beverages also sold here, including cookie milkshakes!! Workers were very helpful & polite. WE WILL BE BACK! read more

Great service but terrible everything. Spent $7 on a milkshake only for it to be half whipped cream and half actual shake! They put a whole cookie in it so it so it tasted like chocolate milk with soggy cookies. Cookies don't even taste cooked. Will not be returning again! read more

Cookies were not great. Chocolate chip was very bland and way too undercooked on inside. I feel like they needed some salt. Reese's was better and so was chunky hubby but not overwhelmed by any of them really. Not worth the calories read more

These are better than Crumbl and Insomnia Cookies. I had the reverse reeces and cookies and cream, both of them were absolutely amazing. Customer service was great - they seemed genuinely happy that I enjoyed the product. I can't reccomend Dirty Dough enough - if you're thinking of coming here, please do. read more