I picked up cookies on a Saturday evening. I was immediately greeted by a friendly staffer and quickly placed and received my order. The cookies were still warm when I got home and they were a hit amongst my guests. I enjoyed all the flavors and they tasted great the next day. The store was clean and tidy and there was plenty of parking. read more

See all

First time here and they are pretty good. Not too sweet like most cookie places and not too stuffed full is icing or cream or whatever. The vibe when you walk in is comfy and the people there were super nice. We got the churro, cookies n cream, Brooke annnnnd birthday cake. The churro was suggested and for me it was the WINNER! I don't know if we will be back ONLY because it's a little out of the way for us but they are definitely a fav as far as cookies go! 5 stars from me keep doing what you're doing Dirty Dough! read more

Dirty Dough - Birthday cake, Brookie, churro and cookies n cream - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Their cookie options are creative with a couple rotating flavors every week. The cookies are baked fresh and dressed before boxing. The cookies were very sweet. It's good for sharing so everyone can have a bit of each to try the flavors. There is plenty of parking and it's within walking distance of the other restaurants in the center. The employees were friendly and have a sense of urgency when helping customers. read more

Dirty Dough - Brookie, chocolate chip, raspberry, cookies and creme - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Stopped in on a Saturday night to finally try this place out. The staff was very friendly, helpful and efficient. They had a steady line of customers. The disappointment was the cookie I had. It was nothing special. Maybe the other flavors are better but there was no real wow factor considering it's a $4 cookie. read more

Dirty Dough - Brookie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I think these cookies are a good match to Crumbl! I like that they have more cos intent flavors, but still rotate in a few new ones. I had the Muscle cookie. They take the cookie out of the warmer and top it fresh so that the toppings aren't melted off or messy by the time you get it. The cookie I had was great. Very rich, but had a great flavor. I would go back to try a few new ones. The staff were friendly, but make sure you plan to take your cookie to go... the suite is very small, so there is no place to sit. read more

Dirty Dough - The Muscle cookie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Omgggg 10/10 This is the perfect late night snack! I've been a little worn out on crumbl so I'm glad to have a new cookie option on the north side. The cookies are very fresh and I love the variety of options! That service was also great and friendly. Highly recommend this place! read more

The staff was very friendly when we came in but I hate to say that is the best thing about my experience. The store was clean but had an odd smell of like sulphur in the air which wasn't the best. We took our cookies to go since there is no place to enjoy on site. We got a couple of different varieties and were disappointed by them all. The chocolate chip was not warm or gooey and appeared to be unfilled. The lemon was the same. We got two of the reverse cookies and while they looked amazing, the taste was not. They tasted like pure sugar and not very chocolate-y or peanut butter-y. Just disappointing when you pay almost $5 per cookie. read more

Dirty Dough - Reverse cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Cute atmosphere and very kind staff. I was greeted when I came in and was given time to look at the menu since I was new. The cookies are soft and warm, and the flavors are so fun. I like that they have a rotating menu, as well as a standard menu. They are pricey, but they are fun cookies so you pay for the experience. You would have to pay a pretty penny, or come regularly to try everything. As a first timer, it would cost a lot to try every single cookie. I got 2 cookies from the standard menu, Cookies & Cream and Brookie. Both had stuffing that wasn't in your face and over powering. I also got two items from the weekly rotating menu, Carmadoodle and Cookie Butter. Again, the stuffing ratio was perfect, especially in the carmadoodle. I noticed there was less filling in that one, I am assuming because caramel is so thick and sticky. Definitely a great dessert option if you're looking for something fun! read more

See all

I was given a box of 4 cookies as a gift. It's a newly opened cookie shop(Fishers and Keystone avenue) I personally was not a big fan of cookies in general because sometimes they're too sweet, dry and etc. But I can confidently say that I love stuffed chocolate chip and a rookie from Dirty Dough. They're very soft, gooey and brookie especially has a cake texture which I prefer. They make fresh batches of cookies at the store and you can watch them baking because it's an open kitchen. Staffs are young students and they're helpful and kind. It's a great gift idea because their package is pretty. read more

See all

We stopped in for their Grand Opening. It was fun! There was a DJ on his turntables outside dropping beats and prizes to win on their prize table; everyone got to spin and win! Each staff member was super nice even while they were slammed with business. Our order took a little longer than expected, but they were totally worth it when they came out!!! Highly recommend stopping in for a little special treat when you are craving a bougie cookie. read more

See all

catfish of cookies. These were supposed to be filled with gooey deliciousness and they were flat and DRY. The photos of the cookies and examples by the register are completely different. Cookies n Creme 7/10 - (Vanilla cookie loaded with Oreo cookie chunks and white chocolate chips. Stuffed with a creme filling and topped with white icing and Oreo crumbs.) Raspberry Fudge Brownie 7.6/10 - (Rich fudge brownie cookie mixed with white chocolate chips. Stuffed with raspberry filling and hot fudge. Topped with white icing drizzle.) Stuffed Chocolate Chip 6/10 - (Our specialty chocolate chip cookie is loaded with milk chocolate and semi-sweet chocolate chips.) Raspberry Toaster Tart 8.4/10 - (Our classic sugar cookie filled with raspberry jam and topped with icing and sprinkles.) - taste good but CATFISH Lime & Coconut 5/10 - (Tangy lime sugar cookie mixed with coconut and white chocolate chips. Stuffed with our signature sweet cream filling then rolled in sugar crystals and drizzled with lime glaze.) read more

See all

Came in here twice this week. The first time we were happy and received warm cookies. We came in tn and the cookies were cold and rock hard. When asking the cashier, he said that this is the new way that management is doing things. They are no longer serving the cookies warm. We found this out after we bought them.. read more

Dirty Dough - Burnt and cold cookie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Dirty Dough is a bit different than Crumbl-- these cookies are STUFFED in the middle. My absolute favorite is the inside our Reese's. They have a rotating menu similar to crumbl, but they seem to keep 3 or 4 on the menu at all times. Def recommend checking it out! read more

Dirty Dough - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I loved the ambiance here!! And the service was quick, and the food tasted amazing! 10/10 would recommend

As a Crumbl purist, I was hesitant to give Dirty Dough a try. However, I thought every cookie I tried was delicious, and I was shocked to find that it's a good match to Crumbl! First of all, the ambiance in the Dirty Dough storefront is much different than Crumbl's. There's dimmer lighting, more space to spread out, and the walls (lined with light-up signs of cheeky sayings) are painted Dirty Dough's signature teal instead of Crumbl's pastel-pink. Overall, it's a much more mellow environment than Crumbl. The two women working when I stopped in were both very polite and greeted us at the door. They were both wearing hairnets and gloves, so I infer that safety is taken seriously at Dirty Dough. Now, unlike Crumbl's rotating menu, Dirty Dough has a set of six permanent flavors (cookies-n-cream, classic chocolate chip, raspberry toaster tart, brookie, "the reverse", and "the muscle") along with 2 weekly specials (cinnamon roll and snickerdoodle). The cookies were similar to Crumbl's in size, but tasted very different. These cookies were thinner tasted very buttery. What makes Dirty Dough unique is that every cookie is stuffed with a filling! I had "the reverse", and my cookie was filled with hot fudge. My cookie was served to me right out of the oven, so I was able to experience that lava-cake moment of a chocolate explosion before the hot fudge cooled and hardened. Don't worry about your cookies going cold on the way home--the Dirty Dough box has instructions for how to reheat cookies in your own oven! If you're looking for a cold and creamy treat, try a dirty shake! It's a whole cookie of your choice blended into chocolate or vanilla ice cream. I highly recommend coming to Dirty Dough with friends so you can split and share several types of cookies! read more

Dirty Dough - Dirty Dozen! - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

As a sweets and cookie lover, I was excited to see another cookie spot coming to fishers. Our first time coming here was grand opening day. They gave free cookie to every person through. The cycle through a couple of new flavors but also has some standards, which are always available. I liked how they have more standards than crumbl because sometimes it is nice being able to get one you really like more frequently. I ordered the cookies n cream and it was one of best cookies I've ever had. Definitely partly because it was so warm and fresh, but I have had it multiple times since and it has been good every time. The workers are always nice and the line moves quick. It is usually much less busy than crumbl so it is nice to not have to wait. The app needs some work, but overall the experience is always a good one. We will definitely be coming here pretty often and am excited to see some of the new flavors they come up with! read more

See all

Tried it out a few weeks ago, the cookies were alright.. the peanut butter cup one was delicious but the other ones didn't have much flavor and weren't worth $5 a cookie. I'd choose Crumbl over these but I would try again. read more

Dirty Dough - Box - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Well, google states that they open at 10am, along with their exterior signage. Employees arrived 5-10 minutes before and couldn't get into the establishment. We waited and waited and the business never opened. This is their first few weeks of being open, you would think they would be open at their stated times and go above and beyond to make an impressionable first time experience. We are now pulling out and have waited 15 minutes with no luck. Lights are still off in the building and employees are still waiting in the parking lot to begin their job. Crumbl Cookies - here we come! read more

Dirty Dough - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Pros: Open on Sundays Cons: Underbaked, greasy, sickeningly sweet cookies and a strangely empty interior read more

Happened to be on 37 today and have been wanting to try these huge cookies, so we stopped in. Now that 37 is finished with construction it seems hard to get to most of the bussiness in the area, luckily Dirty Dough is easy access from the double roundabout at 131 st. Cute, small and clean shop. They have 7 cookies all the time: stuffed chocolate chip, brookie, the reverse, cookies n creme, raspberry toaster tart, the muscle made with protein powder and gluten free oatmeal raisin. We ordered cookies n creme, dirty churro, brookie, party animal. Favorites were cookies n creme, party animal and dirty churro. All were huge cookies that looked amazing and tasted great but defiantly need to share they are super sweet but that is the point! I prefer Dirty Dough over crumble. These cookies tasted great right after purchase and even later for a sweet bit before bed, lol! They have reheating instruction in oven or microwave for 15 secs but honestly ours didn't last long enough to need that. Would say give it a try and find your favorite cookie indulgence! I will need to try more flavor combos lol!!!!!! read more

See all

This place is awesome! Delicious treats. A little expensive for what you get but overall, it's a delicious once-in-awhile treat that is well worth it! Will be glad to return someday soon. read more

My husband picked up cookies as a surprise tonight. One of the cookies was clearly overcooked. Two were chocolate chip, 1 was a brookie, and one was chocolate/peanut butter. To my dismay, they were all flavorless and horrible. If you can't make a chocolate chip cookie right, idk what else to say . We will not be returning. read more

Very yummy!! Great option to get a warm cookie to fix your cookie craving. Their staff was very informative of what each cookie was and how they were made. I love the color theme of the place. I'll definitely be back!! read more

First day open, Google states that they are open until 10pm. I drove the 30 minutes there...I was able to walk into the establishment with about 10 other people @8:15pm...Myself and the 10 other people will told to leave because they closed at 8pm for Grand Opening...no signs displayed anywhere. Who opens for limited hours for day 1? Why not just serve the people you have inside your lobby? To bad we were not able to experience your cookies...It might of been more accepted if the lady that shewed us away was more polite. read more

Didn't like it, Way too sweet...tastes just like crumble cookie. Customer service was also bleh. Rather take the drive to TeeJays Sweet Tooth in Indianapolis bc they're items are original and flavorful! read more

The cookies are really good,better than crumbl and not overly underdone. Always served warm. Some are a bit too sweet for me but if you like that sort of thing then you'll like these. My favorite is cookies and cream. The service is mostly good,the employees are nice but the owner or manager isn't very nice. read more

I tried four different cookies and each seemed undercooked, bland, and out of balance, just too much sugar. If I had to recommend one variety, I'd pick chocolate chip, but these cookies are honestly not worth the price. read more

Very comparable to Crumbl. What is unique is the fillings. Cookies N Creme and the Raspberry Toaster Tart are excellent. You won't regret giving it a shot. read more

Very well baked cookie, great flavor, great workers and customer service, and a lot of different flavors of cookie and ice cream to choose from. read more