Ugh, I almost don't want to do this. Let me start with the good (and my hesitation for giving only 2 stars). My waitress was awesome. She was young and just SO friendly. At first I was a little taken aback, but she treated me as if I was a family member, which actually was kinda funny and made you feel at home. The place seems family run, she kept calling someone in the kitchen "uncle". The decor is nothing fancy, which is perfect for a pizzeria. This is where it turned for the worse. I got the hot turkey sub with a side of fries. My sub was probably on par with what you get at subway, except more expensive, and with less options for toppings. The fries, if you can call them fries. I don't know what went wrong. I don't know if they were left in too long, or ... went bad? (This is why I am not a cook) They were horrible. There was no potato inside this crunchy fried ... stuff. Many of them were like ... I don't even know how to describe it. It looked like freeze dried fries. Maybe it was a bad batch. Maybe some of the other food is excellent. I don't know. But for the price, it was just not good. I will not be returning. (Note: I really did like the waitress and family aspect so much that I couldn't bring myself to say how horrible the fries were) read more

Dimitri's is really good. A good friend lives in the oakville area and we will usually order from here for food when we're visiting. The meatballs are to die for and out of this world. The service on the other hand? Not the greatest. We ordered a chicken parm grinder, a buffalo chicken pizza, penne alla vodka, and a children's pasta and meatball. Upon arrival, we had it delivered, the children's pasta was missing. The delivery guy was still parked in the driveway so one of us went outside to inform him and another called the restaurant to let them know of the mistake. The woman on the phone insinuated that we must not have seen it and that surely it was there. And she told us to call back in 5 minutes... So we did. When we called her back the children's meal was never even made! Yet we were just too stupid and couldn't see it. They brought it back over to us with no apology or offer of compensation. read more

very good new haven style pizza. thin and crispy, good charred crust, sweet and tasty sauce. best spot in town for sure!

Stopped in here on a Saturday at 11am in need of pizza! We attended a wedding the night before that was all drinks and minimal food, so needless to say we were hurting. Dimitri's was so friendly and offered to let us bring our take-out pizza order into the dining room. We hadn't realized the dining room was an option. They brought us glasses with ice to split our bottled soda (remember we originally were going to head out or eat in the take out area). Glad we had cash to tip since we had prepaid on a card. They checked on us regularly without being annoying and everyone was friendly. The pizza hit the spot! Thank you for being open at 11am! read more

Good family run pizzeria on the main drag. Waitress was very friendly and accomodating, the salad was basic but fresh tasting. The pizza crust is crispy and thin, the sauce is sweet and they don't go overboard with the cheese. We got eggplant on half our pie which was floured then fried, that was a good choice. This was a nice change from other pizzeria's in the area. The price was definitely fair for what you get. The dining room could use detailed cleaning and probably an update. The decor is a little tacky and dated. read more

Honestly i did not enjoy the food at all. Kind of highly priced for my taste.you be the judge. It's just my opinion.

The new look is great, but it is ALWAYS freezing in there. I really like the wraps, their fries are amazing. My husband likes the gyro and salads. The only real issue I have with it, other than the heat, is the service can be slow. Especially on a Friday or Saturday evening. read more

Fresh and tasty food. Good portions, good value. Kitchen could be a little cleaner. Open late, which is a plus. I recommend their pizza, their subs, and gyro's are always good. read more

I love this place. It's a real gem in Watertown. The menu has something for everyone. The pizza is solid. Great for a quick dinner with the family or a quick drop by for take-out. My favorite is the Chicken Caesar wrap. read more

Like other yelpers, my family has come to love and order out from here at least once a week. The prices are affordable and the food is delicious Italian. I couldn't ask for a better pizza/Italian go to in Watertown. It is absolutes the best in town for the price and quality! Parking though is a bit questionable as busy, however we pick up most of the time. read more

They are very consistent in delivering good food!! Pizza great sauce nice airy crust. Great bread used for grinders. Never had a bad meal here. Would highly recommend when you don't feel like cooking. Wings are crispy..tasty, but still juicy!! The calzones are great !! Especially the eggplant calzone! Try it read more

I've never left Dimitri's disappointed! There calzones are awesome! Staff is really friendly and I love that they deliver!!! Everything is also priced really good! read more

Never again am I ordering from this place! I ordered a garden salad w/chicken and a side of fries for delivery. To my surprise the total came out to $17.23. I called back and spoke to lady (who was extremely rude btw) to tell her I was overcharged and per menu facebook total should be approximely $14. She says its my fault?? I told her how is it my fault if you have not updated your FB page?? On top of that, they charge $1.00 for paying with a debit!! What prosperous business does not absorb that fee? Apparently them! I told her that out of courtesy and took keep my future business, they should give me a free side of fries. She says, we will see and HUNG UP on me! They have just lost a customer for sure! (PS this lady urgently needs a lesson on business etiquette) read more

Love the greek pizza, however the delivery person forgot to get my address for pizza delivery.

Really good pizza. I'm sad I'm out of their delivery range, or else I'd be eating from here more often. Friendly service in a small, casual dining area. read more

Very good pizza, will go here again. Friendly people behind the counter, many things to choose from on the menu

The pizza is awesome but the Caesar salad with grilled chicken is unbelievable. Yum!!

Their special is a hearty pizza, yum! Gyro is alright. Take-out is fast. read more

Dimitri's has really great pizza, and it is not greasy/oily like traditional Greek pizza. The crust is crisp and the cheese and sauce is really good. Unfortunately, I don't order it enough! read more

Excellent pizza, crisp crust, lavish topping. Garlic Parmesan wings are addictive even when reheated. The spinach side dish is a treat in itself, I order two, and salads are freshly made: I recommend the Shrimp Caesar. I am a long term repeat customer. This is a really good restaurant. read more

Amazing pizza, antipasto ( get their house dressing!!!), and country fries. Friendly staff just don't get delivery it always takes longer then they say it will. read more

This is a most common Mom & Pop establishment, a throw back from the queens and Brooklyn New York of years gone by. A family run business which serves excellent far, be it American, Italian or Greek. We have samples almost all dishes on the menu, including the specials. All are above average and served with personality and charm read more

I don't know why people say the pizza is good. I got a small meatball pizza and it was clear the sausage was from the freezer and not made with the pizza. Compared to New York pizza, it's not good pizza. It's thick, not hot, and the cheese is stuck to the crust. read more

LOVE Dimitri's. Food is always consistently great and Kelly is the BEST waitress. Nice to have a place like this in town and can always rely on good service AND good food (rare to get both!) Can't help but comment on the previous reviewer from Litchfield stating "décor is a little tacky and dated" I believe the owners have some child portraits hanging of their grandchildren. I would much rather take good food and great service over modern décor ANY DAY. (example--@theCorner in Litchfield. More of a modern feel but BAD service!) read more

Good greek pizza. The medium thick hot out of the oven.

I was in town visiting my mom and we saw (and smelled!) this place while we were upstairs getting massages earlier in the day. We finally decided around 6:30 that we couldn't be bothered to make ourselves dinner, so we went to Dimitris. Almost all the tables were filled up within 5 minutes of our arrival, and the poor waitress was serving all of them alone. We ordered a calamari appetizer to split. It was OK, but definitely not even close to the best calamari I've had. Our pizza however, was to die for. We ordered a medium low-cal speciality pizza to split, but we ordered it because of the toppings - not the fact that it was low-cal. The waitress informed us there was no mozzarella on the pizza, so we of course asked for it to be added. It took a long time, but it was worth it. We definitely could have gotten away with a small, but this way we had plenty for leftovers the following day. The service was slow but the waitress was doing her best and was very pleasant. A bit pricey, but OK for a special dinner with my mom. read more

This restaurant is one of the cleanest I have ever seen. The restaurant is family friendly and the food is amazing. The owners are great people and very hardworking. They make you feel like you are part of their family read more

Girl at the the pickup counter was unbelievably rude. Along with messing up my order without a single acknowledgement or apology. 2-3 stars for shitty customer service. read more

Best grinders in town. Also the deck out back is great. One of the few places in town that offers outdoor seating. Nice view of the historic factory buildings in the Depot Square. read more