Rating: 5 stars I hadn't ordered from DiMatteo's in about 8-10 years, but I'm so glad I gave it another shot, it was absolutely worth it. I got a small cheese pizza with tomato and fresh basil, and it was delicious. Simple, fresh, and full of flavor. No complaints, no need for adjustments--just great pizza done right. I placed the order through DoorDash and picked it up in person. The staff was friendly, the place looked clean, and my order was ready right on time--fresh and hot. Can't ask for more than that. I'm already thinking about my next pizza from here. Definitely a solid spot in Hamden if you're craving classic, well-made pizza. read more

I can't believe this is my first time trying the pizza. I'm a New Haven native and I've visited this plaza more than I can count. I don't know if I ever visited as a child, but I don't think so. I had a taste for pizza, but by the slice & since I was already in Hamden and learned that they have slices, I decided to give them a try. So happy I did. I love options. They have some great selections with meat, but I no longer eat meat so I opted for two cheese slices. It totaled to six dollars and change, and you need to spend $10 to use your debit card so I selected a veggie slice with spinach, roasted red peppers and eggplant. I was greeted immediately by a nice lady working behind the counter. She warmed up the selected slices, and I just observed the atmosphere. It's a cute spot, decent amount of seating. It looks like they offer espresso and wine. They also had packaged dessert items for your sweet tooth. They also have the pizza topping staples: red pepper flakes, Parmesan cheese, etc. The sauce is a little sweet, but I did enjoyed it. The veggie slice did not have red sauce, so if you enjoy spinach bread, you would probably enjoy that slice. It was a good experience. I found parking easily. It was nice and clean inside. When I want pizza by the slice, I will definitely keep them in mind. The slices are huge by the way. I could barely finish two. So happy to have the 3rd for leftovers. read more

Di Matteo's Pizza Restaurant - Cheese slices; Mixed veggie slice. - Italian Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

I always judge a restaurant on their plain cheese pizza. This pizza is super flavorful without being greasy. Great balance of cheese and sauce. I dont know what these other people are complaing about. It's been a long time since I've had pizza this good and the service was smooth. read more

Great local pizza & restaurant! Never disappoints. The pizza is fantastic and so are the salads and pastas. Friendly staff too!

I placed an order through doordash for dimatteos pizza because I had a craving for some good pizza. But that's where I fell short. The pizza was lacking in flavor the crust was very thick and seriously was not as delicious as I remembered growing up.. with all these great place places to have pizza in New Haven I don't know why I would ever order dematteo's again it was not good. read more

Poor customer service that's one woman behind the counter is very very very rude I've been eating there for over twenty some years and as the years went by it has went down hilll soooooo much it's goes from the service not wearing no gloves to serve the food it's just that one woman would ring the register and they have the nerve to touch the pizza but now days who really believes of wearing gloves I won't go there any more once was a fabulous restaurant to now done like it at alll.... read more

Used to go here a lot for their chicken and pasta dishes but today we wanted to try their pizza. We also got a couple of their potato croquettes. The croquettes were filled with mashed potatoes and diced ham. They were tasty, not too salty and made for a very nice appetizer. The pizza was very good. The crust, sauce and vegetables were all fresh and delicious. The cheese was also good, but somehow weighed heavily on my stomach and made me feel uncomfortable. I'm not going to condemn them for this, but if I want pizza from them again I'll ask for them to go light on the cheese. As far as their other dishes, my family and I have previously enjoyed their chicken Florentine and their pasta with garlic and oil. This place makes good quality food consistently and you can eat here with confidence. read more

Di Matteo's Pizza Restaurant - Potato Croquettes - Italian Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

We have gone to Di Matteo's for years. We had an unfortunate experience this evening. The pizza was not as good, it was chewy and there was far too much cheese. You would think that a lot of cheese would be great, but it was like rubber. Too much of a good thing isn't appropriate. This was definitely the case. We didn't say anything about the pizza because we were hungry and we got off to a bad start with the server who seemed to think she knew more than we did about glassware. She gave us beer glasses for our wine and when we asked her for wine glasses , she corrected us. "These are new wine glasses," she said. We pointed to the other glasses available in our view and she told us what they were for. For whatever reason, these new beer glasses were supposed to be what was served with white wine. We didn't pursue it further with her. Our stomaches were growling and expecting the pizza we always used to enjoy which turned out to be less than adequate. It was all very disappointing. We won't be back. read more

I've been going to this place for many years, they're consistently good. The service is always great. The pizzas good... lets be honest, there's better pizza in New Haven, but it's still really good and Di Matteo's is worth going to for the service alone. The entrees are good sized portions and very tasty. They've got a cozy dining room that's Great for parties. read more

You guys get a 8/10 Food meaning the pizza was great. Prefer a bit more crispy.counter people were great. The place just got a renovation but felt somewhat of a weird vibe. Service was great. read more

You know this place has been here a long time when the last yelp review is from over a year ago, with most being over 3 years old. We came for pizza and enjoyed it. tasty sauce, fresh mushrooms, good salty pepperoni. Looking for ses to eating the leftover cold pizza for breakfast tomorrow! read more

Di Matteo's Pizza Restaurant - Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

26 years I've lived in Hamden, I never ate here, so last week I decided to try it, I walked in, got my pizza, and it was not what I ordered, the girl at the counter charged me for a pizza that I did not order ( it was more money) she was rude when I asked her to make what I ordered, and her rude response was " well that's how I heard the order", but I ordered online. I just left, it wasn't worth the aggravation. read more

I've been gone from the area a decade, so I'm happy writing this bit of terrible news. Di Matteo's has the best cold pizza in the entire world. When I lived there, by the end of it, I would not infrequently order an entire pizza from the restaurant, bring it home, and put the entire thing in my fridge immediately. As a warm pizza? It's passable. Cold? It's nirvana. If you're a cold pizza fan, do this. Your life will change. read more

Great pizza, This pizzeria that has been in Hamden for years. Fair pricing too! The employees work hard and they stay open the hours they post. Bought a pizza recently where they were near to close and they accommodated me. That's service! read more

From the outside it looks like your typical pizza joint located in a corner of a shopping plaza. Who would think the dinners would be so good! Omg I was surprised and had it not been for my aunt and uncle I would have never come here let alone order dinner rather than pizza. I can't tell you how much bill was for the 5 of us because my uncle paid but we all had some outstanding food. Don't judge from the outside - go in and order dinner. Calamari appetizer- light and tender all rings no tentacles. Some of the best I've ever had Broccoli Rabe and sausage app - very very good Pork chops with hot peppers and sauce- 2 huge thick cut pork chops, looked good. My uncle could only eat one pork chop and was full Rosemary chicken- my aunts favorite Chicken rippini (spelling?) three of us ordered this off the specials menu - Omg I could eat this everyday. Two large chicken cutlets breaded and fried and stuffed with ricotta and spinach and topped with a vodka sauce and crumbled sausage. Could only finish one. Can't wait to have the other for lunch tomorrow. Cappuccino - very good Gelato - good If in the area go in and order dinner! read more

I have been going to this restaurant for over 30 years. They did a beautiful job on the remodel but unfortunately the customer service leaves a lot to be desired. I ordered the cheese ravioli and was shocked to find a teaspoon of salt in each ravioli. I told the waitress and she said really? I then told the manager and he said oh yes we know. We purchase the ravioli and we told them it was too salty. Don't you think some kind of accommodation like telling the customer before they have the food would have been appropriate? He couldn't care less after I said the next time he should tell the customer. I hate to stop going to this restaurant but I'm seriously considering it. The owner's daughter is lovely but unfortunately she wasn't there. read more

I just had to write a review. Disclaimer: I am gluten intolerant NOT Celiac so I am unable to speak to cross contamination as I've not had an issue. I just order a GF combo pizza. It is sooooo delicious!! The crust is crispy yet soft! The pizza was loaded with toppings and cheese! I was extremely impressed. I've ordered GF pizza from here before and it was really good, but this one was over the top! read more

Been here a couple times, dining in and ordering out, I've enjoyed my experience a lot! Pizza is delicious, pasta dishes are huge, and sandwiches are also really yummy. Wait staff is very nice, very clean restaurant, and prices are extremely reasonable! Will certainly be back! read more

Pizza is great. My favorite is a white pie with fresh garlic and tomato! Fried calamari was also good. Service is always friendly which is a huge plus. read more

Really friendly staff but really terrible pizza. To start off, we waited probably close to an hour for just one large pie. Then we finally got our food and it was a half cheese half pepperoni and olive pizza that we ended up getting sick from. The pizza wasn't even worth the wait. After eating a few bites, I already felt sick. Do not go here unless you want to sit on the toilet for hours on end. read more

Rarely dine in here. Actually only my second time and now I remember why. The food is good. Sausage garlic pizza is my favorite. The service here is just ok. Not overly friendly. Will stick to take out read more

Not very nice people they just stare at you while you eat very rude. Quality of food isn't good and the prices are extremely high I wouldn't recommend bad experience read more

Great place to have a consistently fine dinner in a casual atmosphere!! Great job and the customer service s very nice, the food amazing and it comes out in a reasonable time. read more

Delicious pizza restaurant! My favorite is their Healthy Choice pizza which has broccoli, onion, and spinach on it! I also love their cheesy garlic bread! Good prices and good food make this restaurant a good choice read more

Little pricey, But the food was never a disappointment. Good pizza, good food. The calizone was big and good also.

The restaurant looks not very fancy but it is worth visiting here cause they afford bunch of great meals. I tried penne pasta with red clam sauce which gave me nice combination of garlic, tomato and chopped clam. Also, Manhattan style calamari is worthy trying! The portion is huge, which means I can share the dish with my friends and family members. The spiciness of the sauce was just perfect for me. I loved the texture of squid. The server was very nice and kind. We could feel that we are treated as valued customers. The music was not that bad but the light is a bit dark to take a great picture. This might be a reason that not many pictures have been uploaded for Di Matteo's Pizza. We will visit this place when we feel like having Italian food going forward. read more

Di Matteo's Pizza Restaurant - Penne pasta with red clam sauce. Yummy. - Italian Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

Terribly overpriced. For 17 dollars, no salad comes with a chicken dish. This is a pizza joint, not a fancy Italian eatery. The owner needs to climb down from his high horse and serve what people want. I would drop $17 on dinner with a salad, no problem. Gouge me for an extra $2, I don't think so. read more

Walked into the restaurant after a long day and decided to give them a try. My waitress was very sweet and sat me right away. They seem to do takeout as well. The dining room is separated from the front where people seem to come in and out frequently for takeout orders. The menu has all the typical Italian dishes. I went with gnocchi and asked them to put it in their vodka sauce. It was a generous portion and I thought it was delicious. I tried the gelato for dessert and was also delicious. I was really impressed by my waitress.. I wish I knew her name blonde hair in a short haircut. I'd definitely go back. read more

I must admit, when I recently moved to Hamden for grad school, I did not think I would be able to find a convenient, affordable, and good "go-to" pizza place. After some atrocious pizza misadventures, I found Di Matteo's.... The saving grace of pizza in Hamden. Di Matteo's is your standard, solid pizza place: thin crust, plenty of toppings, affordable. I frequent Di Matteo's and have yet to be disappointed. I have only taken out, but they updated their restaurant and take out portion of their space it's clean, spacious, and quiet! If you live in Hamden, and don't want to travel to surrounding towns for a decent pie, this is your place. The only downfall is that they don't deliver! If you're into standard NY style pizza, this will leave you with Di Matteo's magnetic business card stuck to your fridge. read more

Food is great, service sucks! My wife and I have gotten pizza from here a few times now and it's really the only reason we keep coming back. The customer service is terrible here! read more

A few years ago Dimatteos was a serious contender for best Italian food in the area. They had a fire maybe 6 years ago and it really seems like their food has two periods, before the fire (amazing), and after the fire (horrific). My pictures speak a thousand words. It was 8pm on Saturday night and there were two tables of people 60 or older. Not one single pick up order came in the entire time we were there. There were four waitresses on, however no one was working. Literally someone from the kitchen walked our food out about 45 mins after we ordered. By the looks of it it took them that long to find it in the freezer and pop it in the microwave. Avoid, for great Italian food go to Amicis - around the corner, friendlier staff and the quality is in a league all its own. read more

See all

I was raised in an Italian family in Jersey and I have to admit, this place is ace when it comes to good Italian food. I went to college in CT and suffice to say that the folks in New Haven take pizza seriously...not quite like New Yorkers but I digress. We got two pies, one regular plain and one with mushroom and sausage. In a word, WOW. The sauce was sweet but not thin. Sometimes the sweet sauces are watered down...not here. I'm not in the area all that often but I'll be looking forward to return trips :) read more

I came upon this place by chance. I live 45 minutes away, but by golly I would drive all that way to come back here again. The wait staff was very friendly, chill and great conversationalists - striking up a convo with my waitress was so easy and I enjoyed every minute of it. The pizza was delicious; I wanted to take my time and enjoy every bite of it. read more

Decent pizza but there's much better around. Went here early Sunday afternoon only because every other pizza place in the area was opening at 3PM. The pizza was decent but beware there is no medium just small, large (aka medium 16") & xl. Place was clean, staff was ok, a few folks were waiting for take out so I guess they ok. read more

See all

I would have given more stars but, after weighing the quality and quantity of what I got versus the cost of my chicken parmigiana dinner, I am disappointed!! Two dinners, one side, and a couple rolls for $36!!! I probably wouldn't have minded if they gave more for my money but... This side options are pasta, potatoes, or salad... Every other restaurant I've gone to in the past, pasta was included with my chicken Parmesan! PLUS a side! The food was edible, so there is always that :-/ read more

I wasn't impressed with this pizza. It's definitely pizza, but there are better places in the area. We ordered take-out, which was pretty fast. We got garlic bread which was okay but more crunch than bread. The pizza was fine, but the dough had all the wrong proportions and they used canned mushrooms. Not a bad place there are just better ones that are just as convenient. read more

Amazing pizza!! Love the chicken rosemary dish also, and the potato croquettes never disappoint!!! Love this place !

We like Di Matteo's. Great Pizza plus a full menu of other selections. Also, a decent selection of wine and beer. There's something for everyone. The location is very convenient as well--close to shops and the parkway. That works well for dine in and take out. read more

Mediocre in every respect. Don't know what more to say. Would I return ? No. Recommend? No

Great Pizza. Very consistent. Every time I go in to pick up my Pizza the staff is always friendly. Top pizza in Hamden if not the best in Hamden. If you don't want to drive to New Haven for a Pizza Get It Here. read more