Excellent pizza. I prefer the regular but many prefer the sweet sauce…read more Gotta get pepperoni on at least half of a pie. A drop of sauce on ever slice of pepperoni . Incredible.. I miss Angelo being there making pizza on a Friday evening. A must stop if you are a pizza aficionado. Just a great pie.

Angelo's plays no games and is up there with NEPAs best pizza, in my book, they are number one…read more Their regular pizzas are good, but the sweet sauce is where the magic is at. My picture is a mini thick sweet, and that's exactly how you order it. Calling Angelo's is a journey, they are operating off of a single land line so you usually have to call 2, 3, or seriously on busy nights or a Friday during lent 20+ times. From there you tell them the size, crust type (regular or thick), sauce type (regular or sweet) and then any toppings. Be prepared to wait at least 30 mins, but in many cases over an hour. While this sounds like an awful experience, it's certainly worth it. This pizza incredible. Last time I stopped by it was cash only, but there's an ATM. When you go in, there's a counter up front and a cooler stocked with drinks. The space has a few tables, but most people are doing takeout. Angelo's, while it's not easy, I love you!

Very good round pizza overall, but the best is the white pizza. The white w/broccoli is good, but…read morefor something different (and even better) try the white pizza with sausage or pepperoni. There's only 2 booths if you wanted to eat in and depending on when you order it could take awhile. I've only tried the pizza, but they have the usual wings, hoagies, fried foods menu as well. For all of the pizza places in the area, they are a bit expensive.

We love it! I think their prices are reasonable when you compare them to other places nearby. The…read moreonly thing I don't like is the wing sauce doesn't really stick to the wings. We love their pizza subs and appetizers.

I was home visiting my parents and decided to try Whistle Stop in Mt Top since I've heard good…read morethings and it looked legit from pictures. Holy sh-t balls! I was blown away happy with it. Thin crust and crushable, but still sturdy with substance to it. The cheese/traditional sauce was flavorful and outstanding right out of the oven piping hot. I got half pepperoni, but in my opinion this pizza is so good it needs no help with toppings. Next time I will stick to a plain cheese pie and might try the sweet sauce. I highly recommend skipping the takeout if you can and eating this there in their cozy restaurant right out of the oven. Perfection. For context, I'm a pizza snob and tough grader. My local faves are Sabatini's and Pizza L'Oven in Exeter pending what style I'm in the mood for. Whistle Stop was outstanding and every bit as good as the best NEPA has to offer. I'm not a score guy, but if pushed it was easily 9 out of 10. On the Portnoy scale, I bet he would give it mid 8's. Maybe upper 8's or better.

Our favorite pizza in Mountain Top! Crust is perfect everytime and love the diced onions. Call…read moreahead and ask for wait times as they get pretty busy and sometimes you have to wait a little longer than they say. But worth it.

We really wanted to try a different type of pizza and after reading mixed reviews we decided to…read moregive it a try since there are several people who say it is great despite the way it looks... yeah no thanks we had the same experience as others, when you get it to go it is just a soupy soggy mess and the sauce??? Wow did it taste bad, there's too many other pizza options in the area to even consider this one.

If you like pizza that is soupy and looks like vomit that is served with a spoon then this place is…read morefor you. But I don't like that kind of pizza. The wings and burgers are great as well as the service. Cold beer. Its small but a nice place.

Today we brought a high school team to eat in this restaurant. Although we did experience some…read moreproblems, I will say the male manager on duty was absolutely phenomenal and GREAT TO WORK WITH. The food was a variety variety which is 25 different people and every single item looked and tasted outstanding. We were able to banquet room by ourselves, which was very quiet, but we all taken care of. No Doubt restaurant and homemade food apart. Again, I would like to thank the manager on duty today as he was great.

Good pizza, but the slowest service I have ever experienced. Placed our order at 450pm and received…read moreit at 620pm at the table

I went on a very busy weekend. They were slammed. The service was still great. We got square pizza…read morewith onions and it was delicious. The crust is really what makes their pizza good.

This place has really turned itself around. Have frequented several time in the past few…read moreyears...food and service is excellent! Must tries are the thin crust Sicilian pizza, turkey burger and boneless bites. Their mix hamburgers and turkey burgers are very well seasoned. Well done management!!

Was waiting for this to be open with great anticipation, however terribly disappointed to say the…read moreleast. Pizza is Terrible & overpriced

I'm not one to give bad reviews but this time I think it's necessary so that the rest don't waste…read moretheir time ordering from this store, I ordered my pizza and it never arrived and I didn't even receive a call or explanation about what happened with my order. A total disappointment!!!!

Our local go-to pizza place. Pizza is good, meatball sub is super yummy and any other menu item…read morewe've tried we've been happy with. The atmosphere is underwhelming, but no biggie. They do have tables where you can eat, but most people carry out. Plenty of parking in a parking lot in front of the business.

Pizza was undercooked, soggy, lacking flavor and greasy. The establishment itself is awkwardly…read moredecorated and dirty. The entire place was filled with smoke that it was stinging my eyes. The only reason I gave two stars is because the young guys working there are nice and gave good service. But clearly they have no idea what good pizza is, especially in this area. Hope they realize and make changes.

I placed a large order that included several dozen chicken wings that I requested to be cooked…read moreextra crispy. I understand that what I expect to be extra crispy may not necessary be the same opinion of the cook. However, we were not able to eat the wings because they were questionably not cooked all the way (not to mention not crispy). The wings had a texture of chewing gum and were room temperature at best internally. I also ordered two large pizzas, they were actually above average in taste. However, due to the fact I had to throw away the wings and being that a very similar instance happened several months prior with another order I had. It only gets one Star!

I don't know how this restaurant only has 2 1/2 stars! I'm pretty loyal to Wilkes-Barre pizza.. and…read morethis is the closest in Mountain Top you're going to get! The Sicilian is absolutely to die for! Delicious.