Each Christian Brothers is independently owned and operated with the owner on site…read more I have been bringing my vehicles here for several years now and they provide extremely friendly and honest service and trustworthy repairs at a fair price. They handle everything from an oil change to engine replacement and doesn't matter if it's gas or diesel, foreign or domestic. They are a AAA approved auto repair center and have ASE certified technicians. They also offer the Nice Difference Warranty a 3 year / 36,000 mile warranty on all repairs. NOTE: This review is for the Fishers location.

Was incorrectly told I needed a new battery (tested and confirmed it's fine at another mechanic…read moreshop). Was quoted about $800 above what I paid elsewhere for a new thermostat (Oem parts). Diagnostic was $300, and had that done for $100 elsewhere.

I was shopping an AC replacement for a 12 year old car and kept getting quotes worth half the…read moreresidual value of the car, in mid May I wanted a working AC system, but didn't want to improve an old car 50% for intermittent summer use. Carmel AG came back with a price I could live with, got it done in one day, and Will is one of the nicest guys on the planet. Going forward, I won't use anyone else.

From the owner: At Carmel Auto Repair, we specialize in fast, honest, and reliable vehicle repairs with a focus on…read moretrust, transparency, and long-term customer relationships. Whether you need a quick oil change or full engine diagnostics, we treat every car with care and every customer with respect. Here’s what makes us different: ASE-Certified Technicians – Our experienced team has serviced over 10,000 vehicles with accuracy and dedication. Same-Day Service – We prioritize speed without sacrificing quality. Most repairs are completed the same day. Free Diagnostics – Get upfront, transparent estimates with no pressure and no hidden fees. Complete Auto Repair – We handle brakes, suspension, A/C, electrical systems, hybrid vehicles, transmissions, and more. Hybrid and Electric Expertise – Specialized in diagnostics and repair for hybrid and EV vehicles. Clear Communication – We explain everything in plain language, so you understand exactly what your car needs. Comfortable Waiting Area – Relax with Wi-Fi and refreshments while we work on your vehicle. Locally Owned and Operated – Proudly serving Carmel, IN with a commitment to community and quality. 2-Year Warranty on Parts and Labor – Because we stand behind the work we do. If you're looking for a repair shop that delivers real value, real service, and real results, Carmel Auto Repair is the team you can count on. Book online or call today to experience the difference.

I gave this guy every opportunity to make good on his promise to repair my car's power steering…read moreissue! I called him the first time and he came out and failed to complete the repair and wanted $130 bucks and promised to come back and repair the problem. Then it snowed. After the weather was better I never heard a word from Antwoine! I called him and he came out and again he failed to repair the car. Claimed he would ensure better communication and didn't! Haven't heard from him since. I DO NOT recommend his services. Extremely unprofessional and does not know the courtesy of a phone call and will not do what he promises. I can understand busy schedules but a phone call only takes a minute! The only reason I'm not giving him a big fat 0 is because I had to give at least one star! He won't be in business long so use him at your own risk!

This is in response to A2 Automobile Repair. We spoke Friday, and he agreed to return Saturday to…read morediagnose the issue, but he never showed. When I texted at 12:25 PM asking his arrival time, he said he couldn't come due to weather--even though it wasn't raining--and then pushed availability to next Thursday, which doesn't work for me due to a scheduled surgery. He has avoided completing the work he was paid to do. I paid a $100 diagnostic fee (with the understanding it would go toward repairs), and we agreed on a $450 total. He later increased the price to $750 without justification. I have invoices showing the originally agreed work and costs. He also failed to properly diagnose the issue, which could have included a simple code reset and pressure test. I even provided proof from AutoZone showing no parts were purchased for my vehicle. Overall, this was unprofessional and unreliable service. Proceed with caution. When he told me he was only 19 years old it all made sense. Please do not use his guy, but if you do know he is just a back yard mechanic.

I am thankful for these folks being available while my wife was traveling. The check engine light…read morecame on while traveling, and the concerns elevated. My wife called me with the news, and I was concerned that during the holidays, service and parts resources would be limited. I was able to get a fix on my wife's location and immediately reached out to local repair shops, only to find, as expected, that many were closed for the holidays. Dynamic answered the call and provided the most needed assistance. My wife arrived at the location an hour before opening. Once the mechanics arrived and opened the doors, they quickly evaluated my wife's car. The tension in the situation was relieved when the concern was identified and its severity reduced. We cleared the EVAP system error code, and my wife continued her journey home. There were some complications with administering compensation for the services, but we worked them out.

Quick, affordable, and quality work. Not to mention, great customer service! I highly recommend…read morethis place.

Very helpful. I felt better about buying the car after he looked it over. He met me where the car…read morewas for sale, drove it, ran computer diagnostics, did a visual inspection, etc...

Excellent and affordable services. Was completed in a swift amount of time and showed up on time…read more I live in a new residence and it is difficult to locate me, but, he continued searching until I was located. 5 - Stars!!!!!

My 2011 Jaguar had overheating issues that my local mechanic could not diagnose. Mike at Hash…read moredetermined what the problem was within hours. I thought their pricing was very fair. You may need to wait a week or so to get in because they are very good at what they do. Highly recommended!

We have always had excellent service from Hash Imports, as well as reasonable pricing. We highly…read morerecommend them

In late 2025 I bought a used 2014 Ford Edge-Limited V6 through Carvana. After getting it checked…read moreover I discovered it needed a lot of work. I first took it to my local Ford dealership and asked them to check the car out and fix what needed fixing, the end result was very unsatisfactory leading to losing trust in their mechanics. I next took my Edge to a Christian Brothers auto shop in my area with the hopes of finding a trustworthy replacement for the Ford dealership. Strike Two!!! they tried to replace a part that Ford had already done . Bottom line , they tried to rip me off!!! I caught it and confronted their management. They won't get any more business from me. Moving forward to February 2026-My car started to experience front end suspension noises, AGAIN! (Ford fixed it-so I thought). I needed to find another shop that won't rip off the customer. Reputation is key! My search commenced and I found a local shop near me called "The Noble Mechanic" - (Reputation is key) I made an appointment and was assigned to service adviser Andrew. I told him my story and asked to have my car totally diagnosed and checked over again. I needed peace of mind on all previous work that was supposedly done that I was charged for. I stressed that I'm looking for a new shop to bring my family's business to. I received my car health report and was informed that the Ford dealership used NON-OEM third party parts when they repaired my front suspension. These were bad parts that didn't fit correctly and were failing. Adviser Andrew then provided options for me to consider and suggested the correct OEM equivalents over original OEM to save me $$$$. Overall, Their total car check and diagnosis is very detailed with pictures and the communication walkthrough is done with patience and clarity not rudeness and short answers. Although, I would like to see their labor rate charge of ($137.43 hr.) fully disclosed on invoices/bills (Had to ask Andrew for it) may be higher than other shops, but please consider this, you WANT a shop who employs highly trained and experienced mechanics who love cars and will NOT cut corners when repairing it. Reputation is key!!! Reviews count!! Thank you Andrew and your great team of mechanics for their work. The Noble Mechanic has earned our business going forward.

They are very expensive, same / more than Lexus the dealer. Felt adversarial when we brought up…read moreconcerns regarding damage body damage found when we picked the car up. Had a failure of a system they serviced within days after appointment; based on conversation with manager following suspected damange decided it wasn't worth my breath to engage. I won't darken the door step of this establishment again.