My favorite meatball parm is now crap. What is with the salt??? I could not finish my sandwich. It…read morewas so very salty. The person who took my order on the phone didn't speak enough English to understand what I wanted. They had to put someone else on the phone. In 3 months the place has gone straight to hell. I won't be back

All I really wanted was a good piece of pizza so I jumped on Yelp to find what was recommended…read morenearby. I was not disappointed with the grandma slice and regular pizza at all! The grandma was definitely my favorite, so I had to go back and get a second. What really put it over the top for me was the little bit of pesto diagonally drizzled on each slice. Yes. I had three slices and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Staff is great...and its laid-back pizza joint at the end of a mostly empty shopping center. I did notice plenty of takeout orders so the locals must know it's good, too.

Heard many praises about this place through FB. Just ordered large pepperoni pie from this place…read moreusing the Slice app. Actually wanted to try this pizza place for first time. This town has so many food places anyway. It was very good pizza; not so saucy, thin crusted, plenty toppings and cheese. Maybe only minus is price is little high but hey; you pay more to have great food! Typical symbolic textbook NY style pizza! The way should be. Would defintely order here again.

John's of Arthur Ave in Middletown is great! Their pear salad is amazing with blue cheese and all…read morethe best tasting salad toppings. I added shrimp and this put it over the top! Excellent! I also ate half of my mom's wrap (the next day) that was on the specialty board. It was next level! Their fried calamari is awesome! And that's coming from someone who is PICKY about good calamari. I think the dressing on the salad was delicious and house made, and their two sauces they serve with the calamari are also better than anything I've had! Pizza is good. Slices are huge! And other items are great as well. The food speaks for itself here. Kudos to John's. (I've been coming here for about 15 years) Always a solid food option!

excellent pizza and a friendly owner who supports the Orange county fair grounds…read more I was very pleased with my experience there

Again we returned, got a side salad ,wings artesian bread-small gluten free collie flour reg pizza…read more They should change name to 5 star pizza

The greatest deal in Middletown, the pizza is always delicious and I love talking with the owners…read morebecause they are so friendly and welcoming.

Love this place - husband and wife team work hard and produce such good food. Their entrees taste…read moresooo good.

Was in the area doing some shopping & wanted a quick bite to eat. First time at this pizza shop,…read more which serves more than just pizza. Greeted at the counter. There is plenty of seating inside. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza & a drink. I also was given an extra slice of what I believed to be a chicken cutlet slice to try out. It was pretty tasty. Now I know of a great pizza shop when I'm back in the area

We decided to order takeout on a really busy day. We ordered the Cranberry Walnut Salad. Salads are…read moremy go to since I can't eat dairy or eggs. I had my salad without cheese--they were happy to leave it out. Yelp says vegan options but I didn't see any on the menu--that's why I gave 4 stars. Some people seek vegan due to food allergies. Service was fast. The food was fresh. The salad was amazing and filling and great for the price. I can't comment on Ambiance since it was a quick online order and pickup. Serving size was great for a salad. Will come back!

Food was delicious. Filet mignon egg rolls were a great appetizer. Thoroughly enjoyed my vodka…read moreparmesan foccacina and my husband's prosciutto pizza was very good too. Service was great as well.

Food is good but the PIZZA was great. We ordered a few things (Apple dessert; to die for),…read morePepperoni pizza 10/10 would order again. Skip the sandwich it was average at best. Service was ok, nothing to brag about but we were there in the middle of the day so wasn't expecting anything great. Ambiance is good, typical pub atmosphere. Looks like a cool place to return on the weekend or HH! My advice order the pizza to go or stop in a for a pint!

I love their tacos. It's been awhile since I've been here and I wasn't disappointed. They moved…read morefrom the corner to right next door so I walked into their old spot when I first arrived and was told to go next door. The cashier was friendly and I ordered 3 steak tacos. They were fresh and delicious. It was my first time trying the hibiscus drink and it was lightly sweetened and refreshing. They also have horchata, watermelon, and pineapple flavored drinks as well. I will definitely be back to try more. Can't ask for anything better than pizza and tacos in one place.

Absolute GARBAGE service…read more I ordered two simple sandwiches for myself and my girlfriend. They decided to NOT send me those two sandwiches, but send me some garbage, thrown together wrap. They called us and when we answered, it was too loud and unintelligible to understand. We tried to call back and nothing. When our food was delivered. It looked horrible, unappetizing and wasn't hot, just lukewarm. I'm extremely disappointed in the food, but more so, I'm disappointed in the customer service because when I called after and complained, they said "go ahead and ask for a refund." As a Hispanic man, I always try to support local Spanish business, but this is ridiculous. I do not recommend this restaurant at all.

Hands down the best pizzeria I have ever gone to. Amazing services, food is beyond amazing and at a…read moregreat price as well.

We ordered a catered meal for Mothers Day and Caputo's did not disappoint!! The food was delivered…read moreas ordered,hot and on time! Our guests loved the food!! Many thanks for making my Mother's Day flavor filled and stress free! So lucky to have this hidden gem in Middletown. Keep up the good work! I want to give 5 stars but it will only post 1 DEFINITELY A FIVE STAR EXPERIENCE!!

Love this place! Haven't been here in a long time so it was way over due! Stopped in for date night…read morewith girlfriend and I had my absolute favorite "pasta del la Nona". Location is perfect because then after dinner you can hit the brewery just around the corner to continue a date. Perfect date night scenario. Service is awesome, ambience is perfect and I love this place. Give me pasta or give me death!

After a long stretch on the road between Acadia and Blackwater Falls, we landed in Middletown, NY…read morewith the energy level of two tired turtles. Going out was not in the cards -- pajamas and take-out were the vibe -- so we ordered from Cosimo's, hoping for comfort food without fuss. Success. The crème penne was creamy, soothing, and exactly what travel-weary souls need, and the light pear salad brought a fresh, bright balance that made us feel like we were still making respectable life choices. Portions were generous enough to stretch into a second meal (a road-trip blessing), and everything arrived well-packaged and warm. Simple, satisfying, and perfect for tired travelers who just want to eat well and crawl into bed.

Food was amazing, atmosphere was great, everyone was super friendly, and Uncle Paulie is the goatread more

Best pizza around and it's not even close. If I'm anywhere within 15…read moreMin of it I driver there