Food was horrible tasted like it came straight outta someone's booty i hate it!! Food was wet and soggy and it had this horrid stench. I came here with my husband Joe, and the staff was slower than snails, not to mention smelled like snails to. They didn't even ask me for my order and came out with soggy crickets. I cant even fathom how disgusting and disappointed I was. I would rather eat a bunch of horse crap rubbed inside a dirty trash can than have this food! NEVER GO HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

I had lunch the other day. I normally love this place. I got the country fried steak. The breading was so salty I couldn't eat it I don't know what changed in the kitchen but that day the quality was bad read more

We stumbled across this restaurant on our trip to Evansville to visit the LST, and the Cross Eyed Cricket was nearby. Trusting their website advice to overlook the appearance of their restaurant, which is located in an older house in a more industrial area, we decided to have dinner in a non traditional restaurant, and we were very glad that we did. The service was excellent, so friendly and efficient that we could have been in a 5 star restaurant. But you wouldn't find food that good in most fancy restaurants. We started with a plate of fried green tomatoes, and while no one is ever going to fix them as well as Daddy did in his iron skillet, they provided a dip to join them that was quite good... certainly, not one that Daddy ever thought of! Auntie had the pulled pork dinner with mashed potatoes and gravy & apple sauce. She ordered the appetizer brussell sprouts, and they were amazing! Hubby went with one of his favorite meals: fried catfish; yes, he almost inhaled it! As always, his German fried potatoes were great, and what can you really say about cottage cheese? It was there, and he ate it I went for the kubuki steak with fried cabbage & onions & mushrooms. The fried rice was delicious, but the ribeye took "delicious" to a whole new level! Oh! My goodness! It practically melted in my mouth! And the cabbage!! Wonderful! The "50's" down-home furnishings were likely family hand-me-downs & yard-sale finds, not particularly pretty but serviceable and authentic. Everything was very clean, even the too-small restroom, which reminded me of the first one my grandmother ever had in her house. Again, it was clean, but there was a leak on the restroom floor, something that can easily be repaired. If you are looking for upscale decor, don't come here. But if you want terrific food, friendly service, and a delightful experience, be sure to visit the Cross Eyed Cricket; it's wonderful! I understand there's a sister Cross Eyed Cricket in a three-story building right in the middle of the charming downtown. Their food might be almost as good as we had, but I think the lost atmosphere will detract from the visit. It's your call! read more

See all

I've lived nearby for the majority of my life and had never tried the Cross-Eyed Cricket. This establishment has been a part of this community for as long as I could ever recall. It is definitely a place where one would pass by and say, "I should stop there some day." Today was my day. The restaurant is a small, diner-style restaurant. I was immediately impressed with the live edge tables throughout. Even on their outdoor patio, I noticed live edge on their stool-height tables. There were 11 full size tables/booths and 4 small tables. It was quaint. I ordered their meatloaf which came with three sides. I selected mashed potatoes and a double portion of fried okra for $13 and a soft drink for $3.25. A dinner roll with regular and strawberry butter accompanied the plate. The meatloaf was smothered with brown gravy, so if a ketchup topping is your thing with meatloaf, you might want to select a different entree. The food was okay. Not fantastic but not terrible - this is what earned the 4 stars. My feeling was that most everything was purchased from a food supplier, heated and served. It was good diner food but probably not a place that I would choose to impress a date. I noticed a few families dining in and a few singles (like me). Overall, I am glad that I finally tried it but can't say that this would be a place that I would frequent. It would be nice to know how long they have been operating. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Meatloaf, mashed potatoes and fried okra - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Best burger and fries I've had in a long time. The food was out fast. So yummy and delicious but not to mention not to pricey read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Amazing burger omg best burger and fries I have had in long time. - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

By far the best breakfast in town in my opinion and absolutely love the waitress and friendly staff. And the bread pudding is a must! You have to try it because you will never taste any like it. It's by far superior! Good work guys read more

I'm not giving up on this place yet because the green beans and mashed potatoes were delicious. However, the batter on the chicken fried chicken was nothing but raw, slimy, thick flour. It was so slimy that it wasn't sticking to the chicken at all. As you can see in the picture below, that is the little bit of chicken that's in the middle and the rest is the batter. It was inedible. The batter is thicker than the chicken. I still can't believe that this is what they're serving people. Crazy. I know they have great food, that's why I'm so shocked about this chicken. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Chicken fried chicken - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

The service was good, but a little slow. Food was tasty and just the right amount. A nice, clean little diner.

Food was outstanding and service was great as well. Really good experience. Did not disappoint.

Had a late breakfast. Food is excellent. Service was very good. Dining room and bathrooms are small. Still a nice quaint little restaurant . Will repeat! read more

Excellent service by Kalee! Incredible food! Impossible to leave there hungry! Best breakfast in town! Great variety on the menu! Relaxed diner setting! read more

As far as ambiance goes this is a mom and pop kinda place . The food is ABSOLUTELY delicious and wonderful . The portions will make your eyes buck it's so much . Let's not forget the service , our server MEGAN made our first a freakin blast . Very family friendly , and is a MUST TRY !!!! read more

Suggest you arrive early for breakfast or you will be line out the door at the converted old house turned eatery. They have delicious PIE options and if I can get pie for breakfast the day is going to start off perfect. Rhubarb pie is seasonal and on this visit in August, this delicious treat with a golden buttery crust and not overly sweet filing of rhubarb (no strawberry in it ) to my breakfast table. The savory item for me was a big serving side item of German Potatoes with the right amount of onion and crisp and softness. Drinks are a tad pricey at $3.00, otherwise food cost is good, food is good and good service. Overall good for being slam packed, definitely a must stop when passing by. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Rhubarb pie for breakfast!!! - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

The food was some of the best I've had. Our waitress was so kind and very professional. I loved the interior of the restaurant.

I found this little gem while Visiting Evansville. The service was good and the bread pudding French toast was delicious! *chefs kiss* Prices were good too. read more

See all

Cozy enough for a house converted to a resto--don't go for the ambiance. Wait staff was hit or miss (got white instead of wheat bread and never brought a drink) but floor manager was nice. The turkey club sandwich is the best I've ever had. Fresh sliced real turkey (not deli spam), perfectly cooked thick bacon, and bread toasted just right. read more

Driving by it for years.. finally ventured in and was pleasantly surprised! Food was really good, And service prompt and friendly!

Ambiance of the restaurant was comfortable. The server was amazing and had a very pleasant attitude. Food was seasoned and tastes amazing. I would recommend to others. read more

See all

Wonderful home cooking style place. Great charm good service and hearty portions for a fair price.

Real hole in the wall spot which has its benefits and cons. We sat in a booth and ended up ordering our food Togo. Which to be fair it's hard to judge a true experience after ordering Togo but alas. The flavor was there for the signature entrees. Outside of their comfort zone I felt it could falter. The pot roast I got was pretty dry and we had received triple orders of cabbage but were missing other sides. There were also a lot of gnats at our booth... However I'll be back because the pancakes at the table next to us looked amazing. Maybe we will try breakfast next time. read more

What a Local Gem. everything tasted like mammaw made it. wait was a little long, but im sure it was an honest mistake. very very yummy. reataraunt is chill and lowkey. a casual, good ole fashioned home cookin for this poor college kid. will be coming back! read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - ava with meatloaf dinner! - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

bitch this place is the BOMB. DIGGITY. meatloaf and mash potatoes good lord!! they also give u strawberry butter with yo carbs and DAMN!!! i am stunned!!! read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - this is my friend payton, she also gave 5 stars - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Food was excellent and home cooked, they had great service with plenty of choice on the menu!

Food was fine but service was awfully slow. The ambiance was like a barn, hardly worth for a fine dinner in a nice restaurant. I ate three times in four months and I see no improvement. read more

Good food. Went here prior to a wedding and enjoyed the service as much as the food we got. I'd recommend the German style fries. It was a tasty lunch, although I don't remember there being very many things on the menu that were up my alley. I'll ding them for their Mac and cheese. Do not recommend. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - a plate of food on a table - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Food was average, had small town vibes. Nothing special, but I would eat there again.

Fantastic fresh and fulfilling portions of American and Southern-style "home cooking" with enthusiastic and knowledgeable servers who meet your every culinary need. We were well-served and entertained by our server, Caitlin, and have never been disappointed here. read more

See all

Good food. Ok service. A little tired but charming-ish. I give it a solid 3 out of 5.

As far as ambiance goes this is a mom and pop kinda place . The food is ABSOLUTELY delicious and wonderful . The portions will make your eyes buck it's so much . Let's not forget the service , our server MEGAN made our first a freakin blast . Very family friendly , and is a MUST TRY !!!! read more

Everything about Cross Eyed Cricket made me want to come back, Missy was friendly and greeted us immediately and offered drinks and then offered some great suggestions when we asked for help. The strawberry butter and biscuits immediately got us excited. Then came the best chicken fried chicken ever, the fried cabbage was outstanding and went so well with my pork chop that is basted in the greatest bourbon sauce and German potatoes were perfect. You don't eat food that good and not steal from one another and the Mexican chicken was amazing, all the sides were delicious and then the best bread pudding in years to finish. Prices were very reasonable, everyone there enjoyed being there and it is hard to find that in restaurant staff these days. I can't wait to return and have the breakfast. read more

Very good food. We have been in Evansville for a short time and we have visited the location off of Lloyds Expressway several times. My favorite was the fried cabbage, but the entire meal was excellent. We have ordered the patty melt, fried chicken, and other items. Everything was on point. Service was good, located in what appears an old house nothing fancy but clean. read more

Had lunch here with my mom. First time I have been to this restaurant in a long time. I ordered a patty melt with fries. My mom got a hamburger with chips. The patty melt was perfectly cooked and the amount of grilled onions made the sandwich. Fries were pretty good, I like a little more crisp. My mom enjoyed her burger. Some of the best sweet tea I have had in Evansville. read more

Easy to drive past parking a little tricky but once inside got an old school mom and pops style diner feel. Good portions of food with great taste. Service was good and always busy with local old timers. Seating is limited during busy times. read more

Went here with my two year old. He liked the chocolate milk and tried everything. I ate two meals since he wasn't hungry. Service was friendly but rushed. Every table was filled. I feel like the was grandma food served by Grandma's. Seemed perfect for Evansville. We'll eat here again. read more

Ehhhhj food was average at best and wayyyy overpriced. Our waitress was fantastic. Wouldn't recommend.

This was our first time eating here. It was ok, nothing to write home about. The biscuits and gravy were good for a restaurant(homemade is way better). The pan roasted Brussel sprouts were hard and I could not eat them. Kind of expensive for the portion sizes you get. On the upside the restaurant was clean, the staff was very friendly, and very helpful. It is a very charming little restaurant. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Pan Roasted Brussel Sprouts - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

The food has hit or miss but the vibes are immaculate. I would say their waffles lack flavor or sweetness to them.

This was the second time my wife and I have ate here. First time was last year with our daughter and grandson in tow. We remembered it being good, so we decided to stop for breakfast while passing through Evansville. We are so glad we did. Everything was spot on. If we lived close, we would be frequent patrons. I'm getting hungry remembering the food as I write this review. Just. Eat. Here. You will not be disappointed! read more

The omelette was massive, falling off the plate! So good. Great atmosphere and great service. A small town vibe in Evansville. Breakfast served all day. read more

Cross Eyed Cricket - Ham, bacon, spinich and onion omelette. Awesome. - Comfort Food Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Simple diner food, made well at a good price and served with great service. We go there often.