Best pizza in the Carefree Highway area from Lake Pleasant to Scottsdale Road/Tom Darling!! Went Friday night, not much of a crowd. Great pizza 18" Pepperoni, sausage and mushroom. Light, flaky crust, delicate sauce, great ingredients!!! Seriously, best in the area (and I LOVE pizza). Garden salad was fresh and had a good mix of ingredients. Happy Hour Domestic Drafts $5 until 6pm (other specials too, but that is what we had). Top notch!!! Support this place!! read more

Somehow the pizza didn't taste the same as other visits: Less cheese Cheese that was there was different. Sauce was still bitter Overcooked also Pizza and wings combo gone. 4.2 review. read more

SUPER Delicious pizza! The best in the north valley. I wish we hadn't waited so long to try it. The waitress was so friendly and kind and helped us with descriptions and decisions. Ended up with the bbq chicken pizza. It was fabulous. Perfectly cooked, the crust is amazing!! The decor is adorable western theme and everything was very clean and tidy. Super casual place. In addition to food and service I judge a place by how clean their restrooms are. They passed all my expectations! read more

Cowboy Pizza - Bbq chicken pizza, it's AMAZING - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

We were staying in a VRBO in the boulders and ordered pizza from here instead of our usual place. The pizza was great! There seems to be a fair amount of Neapolitan style pizza places around there, and this was definitely more traditional, which is what we were looking for. Huge pizzas and huge slices. Everything was delicious and it was ready on time for pick up. read more

Cowboy Pizza is the real deal! I was a bit apprehensive about just how good a pizza joint in Cave Creek could be, but I was so wrong. This was the best pizza I've had so far in Arizona. I ordered the Tuesday special--an XL two-topping pizza for $20. I ordered the pizza with half pepperoni and half sausage. It was crazy good! The crust was airy and delicious and you could tell they use top-notch ingredients. Plus, you definitely cannot beat the price! I'm looking forward to returning during my next visit to Cave Creek. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

Pizza is the best Italian style made with real Italian ingredients it only comes in an 18" size I do wish they would make a smaller size servers if you want ambiance order takeout I will go back read more

Great pizza but plllllllease put the baked potato pizza back on the menu. It was such a great pizza and so disappointing to hear of the choice to take it off. read more

I was very excited to try this place as other Yelpers rave about their delicious crust and I was drawn to their dough fermenting process. Unfortunately I was a little disappointed by the flavor and taste. We ended up ordering Bo's meatball pizza but wasn't anything special. It tasted just like a sausage pizza with less flavor to it. I would have to sadly say that it was pretty tasteless, not to mention the crust was dry and didn't appeal my palette. They serve alcohol but they don't make any cocktails, you choose the type of alcohol and soda. My BF ordered whiskey and soda, all you can taste was the soda. They forgot about our salad so we had to ask for it. Napkins wrapped around the utensils had stains on them, pretty disturbed by it. All in all, would not recommend this place nor go back again. Not the best experience but the girl that helped us out was very friendly. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Bo's meatball pizza: $29 (nothing special about it) - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

Sad to say this but I don't think I'll ever come back up to this establishment again. I used to drive 25-30 just for the pizza here, but they got rid of the best specialty slices and kept some very basic and plain ones. The Cowboy cheesesteak was bland with nothing that made it pop. The hot Hawaiian is no better than anywhere else you could get it. The black truffle mushroom and the loaded baked potato were the best slices I've ever had in this city and I used to recommend all my clients and everyone to this place especially all the people I would pickup from the airport as one of my jobs is a driver. I'm sorry to say I won't be anymore and I hope they bring back the better options and and not make someone wait almost 30m for 2 slices. read more

We ordered take out. It was easy to order online. The pizza was very good. And a good value. The pizza was very large.

Stick to the pizza. It was pretty good... The side dishes were not. The store front is nice... the girl talking the order was not. Enjoy. read more

We have tried a lot of pizza but this is hands down the best the Scottsdale/Cavecreek/Phoenix area! Gluten free specifically is the best around this area so far. Not great as leftovers but perfection when fresh. My favorite is the Truffle mushroom with white sauce pizza. I usually prefer more traditional but that is crave worthy. The atmosphere isn't great, get it to go! read more

The potato pizza was amazing and the service was great. We came in late with a large group and everyone was super friendly and welcoming. We will definitely go back! read more

Margarita pizza is the best slice before going to the rodeo at Buffalo Chip! Love this place and the atmosphere

Pizza had no flavor and the chicken was over cooked and no cheese. Very odd. Sorry this was a four strike.

This is really the best value and taste you can get north of the 101 in Scottsdale/Cave creek. The competition is limited, but these guys do a good job. read more

5 stars even though last time we were here they slightly messed up and didn't hold the bacon on our potato pizza. We couldn't eat it, but the service was amazing and the place is always very clean. The cheesy bread is to die for and the cheese pizza is excellent. We have gone here 5 or 6 times and actually drive 30 minutes just for the pizza (and great service!) read more

Love this pizza spot. Have had several delicious pizzas as take out for the bike shop I work in. Flavorful toppings with a crisp light crust on each pie we have ordered from here. The toppings are fresh and prepared to order each time. Just like it should be. The Thai pizza is my favorite, but wear a bib because the peanut oil is gonna drench your front side if you're not careful. I will always come back for the great food and service at this fine local establishment. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Box of happiness. - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

We got two italian grinders to go that were dry, flavorless and were immediately deposited in a dumpster so we wouldn't have to see them to avoid getting mad. The homemade chilie powder covered potato chips were childlike and don't belong with italian food. read more

Looking for a taste explosion? The mushroom and black truffle pizza at Cowboy Pizza is quite possibly the best pizza my wife and I have ever had. Service was amazing, young lady asked if we had been there before. We hadn't, she went on to explain the menu. Choose the recommended pizza and WOW !!! Try it and you too will be blown away. Pizza is not just pizza with this pie. Ambience-it's a pizza place and it is that. Will be returning read more

We picked up takeout. Delicious pizza - the crust was perfect! Helpful staff, too! We'll definitely be back - Yee Haw to Cowboy Pizza!

Always a local fave! Welcoming spot w/ tasty pizza & sandwiches. Wings are pretty legit too! Jacob is always very customer centric & creative w/ his cooking. Made fresh, awesome cowboy artwork to give the perfect vibe. A must stop in the Creek! read more

The Deep Dish was really good. Normal pizza was average. Service was average. Id get the deep dish again for sure!

We're so happy we landed at this place! It's small but inviting and the menu has everything from apps to sandwiches to pizzas to (really yummy) salads. The pizza is giant and the dough is stretchy. I'll post pics to help. read more

See all

The absolute worst margarita pizza we have ever had. Tons of tomato sauce dumped on thick, bready crust. A few dollops of cheese. For $28 dollars. Shocking because 2 months ago we had the best take out pizza in this area and were so excited! Do not waste your money or time here. Zero stars. read more

Oh wow, Cowboy pizza! You put other pizzas to shame. So delicious from toppings and cheese to soft and chewy crust. The combination we ordered (Shroom pizza with couple additional toppings) worked out so perfectly. I can't remember the last time I had such delicious slice of pizza. Keep it up! Bring your patience though, ordering over the phone was difficult as it kept going straight to voicemail. This place is packed with lots of takeout orders. Just give it couple months for them to work out the new business hiccups. Enjoy! Highly highly recommend. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Shroom pizza with meatballs sausage and jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

Very good pizza! So fresh and hot; came to the table quickly. Highly recommend if you are in the Cave Creek area. Also they have cookies; great dessert! Will be back! read more

Steak and bleu pizza was absolutely delicious, the flavors were amazing. Lemon cookies were recommended by the cashier, thank you they were tasty. Caprese plate was a 10 out of 10. Would recommend this place to anyone looking for a western atmosphere. Definitely will come back... read more

Great food and great service. The owners are so awesome and friendly! We have also eaten at their other restaurant, Brunch, and it is delicious read more

Had a great experience with Cowboy Pizza. The crust is very good and the specialty pizzas are interesting in their combination of ingredients. I had one with beans as a replacement for the sauce. Wasn't sure about it, but ended up super tasty! read more

Second time getting pizza here. Huge pepperoni pizza for a bunch of high school seniors read more

Cowboy Pizza - Hidden jewel of a pizza place. Small venue serving up delicious pizza. Perfect crust - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

See all

Wow!! Some of the best pizza I have had!! Other than slices, they only sell one size of pizza. They offer gluten-free crust also. They have salads, sandwiches, and other choices also. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

See all

Every time I've been here it's been good. But I called and ordered to pick up requesting that they make the pizza well done. I guess it's my fault for not checking but I hate when who's cooking just ignores your request. The pizza was under cooked. There is such a huge difference between barely cooked and well done. NOT COOL. Why would I request it well done and waste my breath, money and time? How hard is it to simply follow directions. Super disappointed. read more

GREAT PIZZA!!! The pizza was so good, I should have got an extra for the next day. Walking in Cowboy Pizza the first thing you see is a line. It's pretty busy, but that's okay. The owner is running around doing everything they can to make sure everyone is taken care of. So nice to see this. The cashier was very helpful and kind. The food came out, we ordered a large Caesar salad, spinach artichoke dip with flatbread, and a supreme pizza. The large censers salad isn't really that large, but it was good. The spinach artichoke dip does not look good at all, it looks pretty gross, but I can assure you it taste pretty good. And the pizza, just try it! Very good stuff. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

First let me start off by saying, as a person of color, the town of Cave Creek, at times, has made me feel a little uncomfortable. But Cowboy pizza did NOT reflect this feeling. Friendly staff, clean dining area. The pizza slices were hot and fresh. The pizza crust is a little too thin for me, but my husband LOVED it. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

1supreme pizza, 1size only) and 1meatball sub, sandwich only, to go =$50.00 Both were good but expensive. read more

Great pizza. Great service. Great drinks. Located next to BRUNCH. Small parking lot. Nice clean restrooms. We love this place!

This is a review of a take out pepperoni pizza and bread. We were disappointed in both the cost and quality. The crust was burned on the bottom and the sauce tasteless. We ended up throwing it away. On a happy note, the staff were very friendly . read more

We went on a Thursday night and I had heard it was small, but once we were there we ordered a pizza and drinks and then went into the other side to sit at a table. I think it's a breakfast place in AM and then pizza in pm. Everyone was very friendly, our pizza arrived hot and fresh. It was very good. Highly recommend. read more

Cowboy Pizza - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cave Creek, Arizona

We got to try the el pastor pizza last night at 'taste of Cave Creek' and it was insanely amazing. Still dreaming of it! Had to give a shout out to Cowboy Pizza for the incredibly great & innovative slice . Can't wait to return to the actual restaurant. read more