I don't know where to begin... The food! Is phenomenal The service is outstanding The vibes are just perfect old style Italian! Thank you!! read more

Our party of four enjoyed a "Fabulous Works" and a vegetarian thin crust pie. Delicious crust, perfectly baked with generous toppings. Excellent old school pizzas. Standard Crust is actually quite thick, and chewy...thin crust is a bit thicker than expected and far thicker than a typical New York crust. All very tasty. Good selection of reasonably priced beers on tap. Fast, friendly service, family run. Casual, well lit with generous seating. We would definitely recommend, and look forward to returning. read more

Pizzafarro's - Thin crust, vegetarian combo - Italian Near Me - Carefree, Arizona

See all

Loved their thin crust and the topping were the best. I would recommend everyone to give it a try.

I love Pizzafarro's! They have the best pizza. So many of my friends and family come from all over the valley for their pizza!

Great service. Family ran and very welcoming. I enjoyed the spaghetti and meatballs. Italian sausage is good. Pizza was also good. Comfortable dining experience. Highly recommend. read more

We're from NJ and CT. Been here in AZ for 30 years. Pizzafarros is the best in the Phoenix, Scottsdale area. ! And we KNOW GOOD PIZZA !

Always been one of my husband and I's favorite spots. Anytime we are back in Cave Creek we get a pizza from here & it's aways amazing. They really have a passion for what they do and it shows. We love the atmosphere too! read more

This has always been my very favorite Pizza place in Cave Creek and has a long reputation in Scottsdale. I highly recommend it and super Italian authentic. read more

It used to be good but it has gone downhill and very expensive. I ordered the lasagna and it was not very tasty.

Best pizza we've had since moving here last summer. It was busy and the waitresses were hustling to accommodate everyone and so friendly.

How is the second best pizza in north Scottsdale on Yelp? No way. First. That's maybe a "flatbread pizza", not an actual pizza. Second. You need to order 2x whatever you were thinking. Maybe it's intended to be a personal pizza. Bad value and grocery store quality. read more

Good pizza. Nice service. Nice ambience. Very family friendly. Food was good! I would recommend!

Slovenly servers matched the restaurant decor. Cardboard salty pizza. Great location for a restaurant!

Very good pizza. We had tried this a year ago and it must've been under different owners and we decided to give it another try before making a review and glad we did because they really impressed with their veggie pizza. Super fresh high-quality great pizza. read more

I don't leave reviews however, pizza was over cooked, no taste and service was non-existent. Server never returned to table (not once) except when we asked for the check. I'm from Los Angeles and a fan of Ray's pizza here... I could have cooked a frozen pizza at home and been more satisfied. read more

I was told at hotel to eat here. Have to say it didn't disappoint. Food and service were amazing. I will definitely come back when I'm in the area. read more

First time here. Cute little place but a little dated and dull. We tried the wings and garlic bread first which were very good. The pizza was a little too dense and thick for my taste. Reminded me of a French bread pizza. The sauce, sausage and pepperoni were all good but I'd like to try the thin crust next time. Service was a bit slow. A lot of gabbing going on with, what I believe were regulars. Overall a decent place but there are better pizza joints around with better hours, better crust and service. read more

The best pizza in the Valley! Even if you're not in Cave Creek / Carefree area it's so worth the drive to bite into a slice of heaven. The owner has been in the back making pizzas for 50 years so he knows a thing or two about pizza. He makes his sausage in house and man is it delicious! read more

Pizzafarro's - Sausage, jalapeño, and mushroom thin crust pizza - Italian Near Me - Carefree, Arizona

This place is our Sunday go to for pizza take away. We always go for the thin crust style pizza. Never disappoints.

Pizza is fresh and made to order. Coleslaw is homemade and superb! Local pizza place, hidden away from the crowds. Order one to go. Worth the wait! read more

In my 57 years - the vast majority of which I've really enjoyed eating lots of pizza - - this is *the very best* * Thin, tasty crust that is both crispy and soft * Generous amount of flavorful sauce * Tasty (vs. tasteless) cheese * Just-right amount of toppings * A je nais se quoi that sends it over the top! read more

Pizzafarro's - Artichoke, mushrooms, crispy and yeasty thin crust. I mean SERIOUSLY!? - Italian Near Me - Carefree, Arizona

We live in Cave Creek and came from New York. By far the best pizza in the area. Thin crust and fresh ingredients.

Cute space. Amazing service from a British gal. Ordered eggplant parm. Good, but not great. Pizzas looked amazing. Will be back.

Great pizza, we have had dine in and take out. I preferred take out because we spent less time waiting, but I'm impatient. Atmosphere felt very small town, lots of regulars in on a Friday night. Service was good- our drinks were always kept full! We got hand tossed margarita pizza twice it was so delish! Big tomatoes, basil, and garlic! We tried the bbq wings too and they could have been crispier, but let's be honest we came for the pizza! I love supporting a small business that makes such great food!! read more

Pizzafarro's - a man eating a slice of pizza - Italian Near Me - Carefree, Arizona

Best pizza in the state! Staff and owners friendly and welcoming! Excellent service and customer oriented! Friendly and welcoming atmosphere! Restaurant is always clean and inviting! read more

Ok, lets start with the positive. The young lady at the front counter who took my call & takes your money is and was on this occasion, very nice and polite. I am a local resident and order from here quite often. When I order, it is always a rather large order as I am feeding a family of 4. Unfortunately, after this experience, that has come to a crashing end. I ordered 3 large Pizzas with a variety of toppings so the cost wasn't cheap. But that's always expected and as someone who enjoys quality food, I am always willing to spend more to ensure that we get what we want. I always tip well as I understand that the servers work very hard for their living. I know I'm not alone when I say, "you get what you pay for". So, I arrived and 2 of the 3 pizzas were done so I agreed to pay while waiting for the last one to be completed. First mistake. I also left a tip, even for a to-go order, as is customary where I'm from. Second mistake. After reviewing the pepperoni order it was clear that the pizza was mishandled like it was dropped. It was oddly warped, cheese was sliding off in places and it was slightly overcooked. When paying nearly $80 for pizza, this is of course is unacceptable. I mentioned my concerns a couple of times to the nice front counter and she nervously shook it off as if she was hoping I was just to just let it go. She was so nervous that it was evident that it must be an issue to ever bring it to management. The ending would prove this to be so. After receiving the final pie, I again asked what accommodation would be made for the mistake on the pepperoni. She sheepishly went to the owner/manager/head cook who came to front counter in a rather aggressive manner. In a rather defensive and rude manner he asked me what the issue is. When I showed him the pizza he literally turned his head, threw up his hands and stared glaringly at me and said "what would you like me to do, make another one?" I more than calmly and politely explained that I have hungry children waiting so that wasn't an option. I simply want to be compensated as I'm not getting exactly what I ordered and not getting what I paid for. He literally turned his back, shook his head, and then told his counter employee to give me $2 off. I can assure you by his tone and demeanor it was meant to tell me to go "%$#& off". I grew up in the city and I'm well aware of the intention behind the gesture. Nothing I said even remotely deserved that. I was nothing but polite and kind, yet that's how I get treated after spending that kind of money? I know ran into ego & arrogance so my response was simple so I could get home to my hungry children. "Keep it & I won't be back". We never finished the pizzas and as promised, won't be back. I should have learned my lesson when I ordered the veal during one previous visit. Its pre-breaded, frozen cutlets & unless it's soaked in sauce, it's always dry. They're overpriced and the quality is dipping rapidly. It is unfortunate and I can honestly say that I gave them more than one opportunity to make it right. Third and final mistake. So, my recommendation, just avoid them altogether. There are better options available. I order read more

WOW What a great tasting pizza! The sauce was perfect and the sausage was so flavorful, haven't had that taste in a very very long time!! Thin crust was cooked perfectly and of perfect consistency for a neopolitan style NY pizza! Service was good. Medium Antipasto salad was more than enough for 2 and a 3rd could have enjoyed it also! Wish it wasn't so far away as I would be a regular at least once a week! read more

Horrible customer service. Messed up my pizza by not adding jalapeños before they cooked it, then just threw them on uncooked right before they handed it to me. I politely asked about the uncooked Jalapeños. And she offered no help and handed me the bill. They weren't even busy. read more

Delicious Pizza! The Team is amazing!! We love Pizzafarro's!!! Best Pizza in town... Thank you read more

It's been years since I've gotten your pizza... and it's as fantastic as I remember! Delicious! Thank you read more

Try this place! We drive 45 minutes from Vistancia to Cave Creek just for this pizza! Thin crust with homemade sausage is the best! Get a pound or two of raw sausage to go for ur pizzas at home. U will love it! Also makes a great bolegnese. Inside is dated but clean and staff is super friendly. Enjoy! read more

We went for dinner Saturday night around 6 pm. We had no idea that this place has been in business for 50 yrs. It was not crowded, we were seated right away. We ordered a bottle of Chianti for 27.00, we ordered a antipasto salad and a large thin crust pizza with sausage and mushroom. Everything was delicious. Our server Mel was very friendly and attentive. We will be back . read more

See all

I'm giving it a three only because when I was there yesterday they let a man him to pick up his order without his mask. We were at one of the two small tables they had out right outside the door where the moron no mask person stood . Covid is real.. three in my family have. The food was great but I won't go back until they abide by the mask mandate for everyone that walks into the establishment read more

Server was nice, food not that great and timeliness absolutely horrible. So disappointed in how long it took to get food. Hire more cooks or you will lose business. read more

We have tried both the thicker original crust and think crust and we prefer the thinner crust. It was very good and fresh tasting. It can be on the oily side which is maybe the only downside unless you like that. The crust seemed to have a garlicky flavor to it. We definitely order pizza for takeout if we are ever in the mood but they also have nice dining room that we have dined in at as well. Pizzas are priced to where we got a large and a small pizza and it was about $50 pre-tip. read more

Great long standing place. Been getting their top quality pizza and salads there for over 30 years. Owner still makes them too. It's well worth the extra drive to go there and have a meal. You will be impressed with the food quality and the good service too. read more

We LOVE this neighborhood pizza place! Palmer, Dom, Sherri are all amazing! They make us feel like we're visiting family:-) Pizza is incredible! Best my husband & I have ever had and we're from the East Coast with NY pizza. Highly recommend!! read more

I really wanted to like this pizza! Some food blogger who writes for Desert Ridge said it was soo good! I'm from the east coast and understand what good pizza should and should not be. Despite the young girl who waited on me being extremely nice, the pizza was pretty tasteless and an absolute grease fest! I had the thin crust. So the hunt will continue for good pizza in the Cave Creek/ Carefree area! read more

Pizzafarro's - Half plain, half pepperoni thin crust. Soo greasy it made my stomach uneasy after eating it. - Italian Near Me - Carefree, Arizona

Their food is very good but if you decide your going into to the restaurant to eat in you better plan on a very long wait. We have gone there to eat in twice in the last month and they had only one server for the entire eat in crowd. You will wait over a hour from the time you order til you see your meals. That being said your best option if you live in the Carefree/Cave Creek area is take out since they seem to put what limited resources they have into that side of the business. read more

Great thin crust pizza. Some of the best in the area. Also get the meatballs. Comes with red sauce which is first rate. We have done takeout a number of times and the food is consistently delicious. read more