We were on an elevator with a couple who were talking about a speakeasy and followed them there. Past some bathrooms, through a door that could've passed as the mop/cleaning supplies closet, and you open a sketchy door into one of the best bars I've ever been to. No windows, dark lighting, cozy, true speakeasy feel. Not only that, but the service was impeccable and the drinks are probably the best cocktails I've had to date. Vineyard mule--wine, brandy, ginger beer, mint--sweet, but not too sugary, mint was super fresh, served in a mule glass with grapes to add to the "vineyard" piece, my favorite drink of the night Blackberry northside--vodka, blackberry, mint, and lime--the perfectly refreshing summer drink Simon says--tequila, champagne, lemon, chocolate--started out with a lemon taste and finished with a deep dark chocolate flavor, felt like a warm and cozy drink with a summer flare Reasonably priced, amazing combinations by the mixologist putting together the menu, can't say enough good things about the service, and I don't think you can go wrong picking a drink. It's a place where I want to be a "regular". read more

See all

This place is definitely hard to miss if you don't know about it! Such a cute little gem inside of the Fountain Square Theatre! The minute you walk in you can't help but take on the low-key, cozy, speakeasy vibes. The black and gold theme of the space really captivates you. Though small, there is plenty of spaces inside to sit. We quickly found a couch to sit at and ordered our drinks. The drinks are to die for!! We ordered a mule off of the menu and it was super delicious!!! Will definitely be back if I ever want a low-key night to enjoy a drink! read more

Commodore - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The best cocktail bar in all of Indianapolis. I started coming here when only those who knew someone knew about that place. Now it's pretty well know to be the best. The interior has a relaxed but upbeat mood to it and the bartenders are second to none at their craft. I doubt you'll find a better drink anywhere in Indiana! If you don't see what you like on the menu, just let them know what you're into and they will give you the best they have! read more

Commodore - Scotch Paper Plane! - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Who knew this hidden gem was in the heart of Fountain Square? Definitely not me! A friend suggested we go and I was pleasantly surprised upon entering. I loved that there were couches and even a table or two in a private corner. I enjoyed watching the drinks be made with fresh ingredients and I'm looking forward to bringing more friends to this unique bar. read more

Commodore - The entrance - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The first rule about speakeasies is that we don't talk about speakeasies. But... If we DID talk about speakeasies, we would definitely be talking about this one. What an absolute vibe! I am simply in love with Commodore. The atmosphere is perfect and the drinks are expertly crafted. I absolutely adore the out of the way nature of this spot and the variety of seating available. From comfy couches to hip high-boys, there's something for everybody. The menu cocktails offer a great variety for every palate, but you can most definitely request your fave as well. The bartenders here have the goods. If you're looking for boozy vibes with a slightly upscale feeling and great tunes, this may be the spot for you. Just keep it between us, got it? read more

A friend of mine told me about this unique, hidden bar one night so we decided to double date and take our husbands to dinner and drinks afterward. It was like a fun challenge trying to find the "secret door," but when we finally did and entered this incredibly unique place. We were greeted with cool air and a clean smell (most bars do not smell this good!). We saw a set of open couches so we immediately had a chance to sit down and engage our friends. The cozy couches and intimate atmosphere was perfect. The drinks were unique and fun and the tater tots were perfectly crisp and a great snack for our time there. Only a couple of things that could be improved: The music volume ranged from "I'm trying not to scream at my friend who is sitting three feet away" to "I am screaming at my friend who is sitting three feet away." It was loud. And probably the only reason we left when we did. They also had a tarot card reader at one of the tables. Kind of threw me off a little. Other than the noise level, this place was perfect for our date night and we will definitely be back! read more

Cool speakeasy tucked behind the maialina restaurant. The door is unlabeled so it's hard to find, follow the music and chatter to the back! It has such a nice cocktail vibe and the bartenders will make you the coolest drinks. I got the hot toddy which was perfect for a cold winter night. One of my favorite aspects was that my receipt were delivered in a book. Very neat place! read more

Commodore - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Went back with a few friends, and this time we were able to grab some comfy chairs in a corner instead of at the bar. The bartender was just ok, not very friendly, but we enjoyed our time, and my drink was pretty good. This time there was a DJ, who was playing a good selection of music, and it created more of a club vibe, yet still chill. read more

Commodore - a cocktail in a glass on a table - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Super cute date night spot! Had the j.a.m drink. It was delicious! I had to get 2. I can't wait to go back and try another drink. Love this speak easy. If you're looking for a good spot with good music. YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED. If you're ever looking for a spot to have cute speak easy vibes... THIS is your spot. read more

See all

Loved the atmosphere, it was a good setting for conversation. Drinks were delicious, loved the espresso martini.

Ambiance, the drinks, the overall vibe! Definitely a bar you need to visit if you're in the Fountain Square area especially if you're like me and love a good espresso martini. read more

We stumbled upon this place when we were looking for a new bar to try. Someone recommended it to us and I'm glad we were able to find it. It took us a moment but I'm glad we did. The drinks were super good in my opinion. The bartenders will bring you a menu to where you sit and then you order at the bar when you are ready. We went on a jazz night and it did get really loud since it is a small establishment. But we definitely will be back with some friends! read more

Commodore - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We love this place. One of the best and most inventive cocktail bars in Indy. Went to an angels envy event there today and it was so cool. The bartenders here are very cool and they dream up some wild and amazing drinks. We usually go at 5pm so there is no crowd. Will be always revisiting. read more

Commodore - Angels envy tasting - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a sweet little spot tucked into the historic Fountain Square neighborhood! Perfectly bustling and subdued at the same time, hits all the high notes of a proper speakeasy with an exceptional selection of booze and cute corners to drink it in. Tyler can really hold it down behind the bar, turning out old classics, but helping me find new favorites too! read more

Discovered this place over the weekend, after having heard about it several time over the past months. Tried 2 gin-based cocktails (G&T and Turning Saturn), both delicious and beautifully presented in unique glasses. Prices were upscale ($10-14/ea), but it was a fun treat for myself and a unique experience. Interior was dark and cozy with lots of seating. Would be a fun place to go with friends. I will be back! read more

If you want a fun, speakeasy-style experience then you must visit Commodore. It's tucked away inside the Fountain Square Theater behind an unmarked door. The vibes inside are dark and cozy. It's a small spot, so if you have a large group this might not be the best spot. They have good amount of cocktail options and a small selection of beer and wine. The Vine and Pina has become my favorite drink in the city! The bartenders are very welcoming and knowledgeable and can suggest something to fit your taste. read more

Commodore - Vine and Pina - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A LITERAL hidden gem in the Fountain Square theater! Located on the first floor down a winding hallway, behind an unmarked door, you'll find yourself back in the roaring 20's speakeasy! Velvet chairs, rich colors, and amazing cocktails! The staff is happy to help select the perfect cocktail for you. They even offer a small menu of snacks. Thoughtful touches everywhere to the small, tucked away seating areas, to receiving your bill in old books! Whether you're starting your night or ending with a nightcap, this is the place to be! read more

Commodore - Blittersweet Memories cocktail - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The fact the door is not marked is part of the appeal. The search is worth it, like finding buried treasure. I couldn't believe this place was open for two years before I made it a point to experience it. The atmosphere is on point, the drinks crafted with passion, and the bartenders love what they do. It gets busy fast on the weekends but you can see why when you try it! read more

Commodore - The glorious back bar! - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is the best and most hidden speakeasy in Indy. The drinks taste amazing and the presentation is spot on. I also love the metal straws. They give you a cute surprise with check too :) find your way here, half the fun of it is finding it. The low lit vibes are perfect for a chill night and drinks. read more

Commodore - Cocktails, left (Christmas in a hammock), right (White Russian), and middle is sweetest drink they have - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Best craft cocktail lounge in indy. There is some decent competition but this place is a true gem. It certainly is hidden and has a true speakeasy feel. In the main floor of the same building as mailina and imbibe in fountain square, one has to walk to a short hallway and without any signage open a standard door into a completely different world. There are hints of 20s speakeasy inside mixed with contemporary finishes and music. The bartenders are super knowledgeable and experienced, and the cocktail selection is fantastic. The cocktails are a work of art. Nuanced in flavor, appearance, consistency. Though not on the menu, I am a sucker for a grappa gimlet. Shared kitchen with imbibe for late night grubbage. A must visit! read more

Visited on a Friday night. First, it's small. Like, probably the size of your living room small. The bartender was very knowledgeable, spent time on what I usually drink, and had a great recommendation. The issue I had with the rating was the music. Random hard rock pumped in way too loud for any conversation. Totally killed any vibe the place is going for. Change that, and it would be way better. read more

The Commodore is the newest attempt at a speakeasy style bar in Indianapolis. Although it isn't quite as clandestine as the prohibition era speakeasies, the bar does a good job of masking their location. Even if you know which building it is in, they don't have any signage pointing to their entrance and no sliding panel to knock on to give a password. Fortunately, you don't need a password to get in here, but it does take some patience to find and helps to have good word of mouth from someone. As a matter of fact, the bartender doesn't want anyone to set this up on Yelp because he's afraid it will become just like any other bar. He wanted to maintain the secret place which is why I haven't given any specifics about how to find the entrance. They have a huge instagram following, so I don't see what problem Yelp is going to add. If you are in the area, stop for dinner at one of the local restaurants and ask for assistance finding it. Inside the bar is rather dark but with mid century furniture grouped in the open space before the bar. The bar (mainly cocktails) is along the back wall and when we first visited, my wife and I were told to just grab a seat at one of the tables. It was 5 pm on a Thursday evening, so the place was rather empty. Lots of room at that time for social distancing. The bartender came over with actual cocktail lists that made it easier to determine what we wanted to order. I prefer gin drinks, so I ordered the "Corpse of New Orleans" which is served in a small Peychauds bitters bottle with a metal straw. My wife isn't much of a cocktail drinker, so she described what she liked and the bartender made her a "Clarified Milk Punch" which she really enjoyed since she likes the flavor of margaritas most places, this was closest to what they had available. There isn't food available, but since Maialina is on the same floor of the building, we came back the night before Halloween with two other couples, dined Italian, and then headed over to the Commodore entrance for cocktails. The bar was decorated for Halloween and was very dark inside with only some purple lights (possibly black lights). We grabbed some lounge seating just large enough for the six of us. But no menus were offered, just Ouija boards with the cocktails etched in with small red letters. Nearly impossible for us to read in the low lighting. If that's all they offer you, just ask for a real menu to make it easier on yourself to figure out what the house specialties are. The place was much more crowded the second night since it was a Friday and a little later in the evening. They had the music turned up a bit too loud for conversation which I don't get. There is no room for a dance floor, so why so loud? We got them to turn it down enough so that we could enjoy our visit with each other as well as the ambiance. I wonder if this place that opened during the pandemic and chooses to hide deep inside a building with no signage to let customers know where to find them, AND discourages social media will make it. It's a cool place for folks who like cocktails, but if you are just a "dive bar" kinda patron, you probably won't like the limited offerings and high priced drinks. I doubt they carry bud light, but I didn't ask. I will say that everyone in our group who ordered a cocktail enjoyed what they had. Our friend who only drinks straight rye was pleased with their selection. Unless this place gets a following of "regulars", I think the lack of attention will make it fall victim to poor cash flow like so many other places. The novelty of the place is in finding it. Once you are here, it seems just like any other bar with tasty cocktails. I don't know if that is enough to continue bring folks in. Review #3841 read more

See all

A tiny cocktail bar hidden in the Fountain Square Theater building is a fun place to wander in while visiting Fountain Square. We stuck with the standards, gin and tonic and an old fashioned before dining next door. Hubs was impressed with their crystal clear ice cube in his old fashioned. The staff is super friendly and we couldn't resist the popcorn popping that smelled so good. There is a limited menu of snack type food but we didn't sample. Give it a try! You'll be pleased you did! read more

The outstanding service, the ambience, creative cocktails the relaxed just can't say enough about this place is a great place to try

I love a good speakeasy! My friends and I stopped into Commodore after a concert in fountain square. A couple of my friends had been before so they showed us where to enter. In typical speakeasy fashion, the door isn't marked so it might be tough to find if you didn't know what you were looking for- but that's half the fun! It was pretty busy on a Saturday night but my friends say it's quiet and relatively empty on weeknights. We all enjoyed our cocktails minus the espresso martini which I wouldn't order again. read more

Great crowd and vibes! The only thing that was not our speed was the music (the genre was predominately electronic with a few pop songs in between). If you're looking for a low key place for friends to hang and get a good drink, then this is the spot for you. If you're looking for mainly food, there aren't many options. read more

Commodore - J.A.M Cocktail - Speakeasies Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Really enjoyed drinking old fashions and lemon drop martinis with my wife for her birthday. Had a great time!

Super cool place if you can find it! Drinks are great and creative very high end cocktails. Place has a great vibe but can get very busy so if you want to pick another day other than say Friday night, you'll probably have a more chill time, but regardless great place to stake out and get a drink if you're in fountain square. read more

Wonderfully dark atmosphere! And the drinks were strong and tasted great. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a speakeasy vibe.

Great ambiance unfortunately had an unpleasant experience with a bartender he was incredibly rude and aggressive not sure if I just caught him on a bad night or what the situation may be. Although I know I will not be going back. read more

This place is awesome. Such a cool vibe. Service was great. Friendly staff made for a great experience. Highly recommend to any local or visitor in Indy. read more

Went on a Saturday night so definitely busy and the music was loud, but the drinks were bomb. They had this vineyard mule that is super good! Also they're onion rings were really good! We all tried different drinks and they all seemed to be made with care. The flavors were all very well balanced. Excellent choice to meet up with friends. read more

First of all, why are we writing reviews about speakeasies. I am writing this one to counter the existing one. This is easily the best cocktail bar in Indianapolis IF YOU ACTUALLY LIKE COCKTAILS. If you just enjoy being tipsy, any bar can happily satisfy you. However, if you are curious about exploring new spirits and the combinations thereof, The Commodore is your spot. There's a handful of places that do a good job with their drink lists (Union 50, Spoke & Steele), but nowhere else I've tried has bartenders that can chat up classic cocktails, and riff on what you like or don't. read more

Great little bar but gets louder with music so if you want to talk, this may not be the place.

Great drinks but the music is like going to brothers. Come here if you want to enjoy a drink and listen to tik toks top hits

This joint may be small, loud, and hot like a sauna. The bartenders may show no emotion. The cocktails a phenomenal though. Can't go wrong with anything off of their menu. read more

We went here for drinks after dinner nearby on a Friday night. It has a spot-on speakeasy atmosphere and incredible cocktails; providing selections of old classics and modern riffs. The house old fashioneds are what you want and expect, and the Black Widow and Zero Fuss are terrific house recipes. Very busy, so be ready to be patient. read more

This place is MAGICAL! Sexy and Secretive! Love the whole vibe from the minute I walked into the door! The OLD FASHIONS are phenomenal!!!

The bar itself was awesome, very lowkey until you get inside it's like a party! My critique is the tarot reader, who was very average. She charged $20 for a 7 minute reading; and didn't give me any guidelines to how it worked, and told me she didn't have enough time to answer my questions and was very strict on time. She started out by asking me questions about my love and work life... I thought tarot readers just go off the energy reading, not off of the info I'm giving them. Felt more like a therapy session I didn't order than a tarot reading lol read more

Great cocktails and atmosphere! As close to a speakeasy as I have found in Indianapolis!