Great food, but NOT a BYO joint. I recommend any of the messes, but am fond of Grandpas. If you want BYO, the Wellesley location still is....a 'single' mess will get you 2 1/2 meals out of it and is $8-$12. Parking can be tight, don't park in the CVS lot, try behind the bank directly behind Comellas or on the street, if you can find it. read more

Comella's is home to the best italian food you'll ever eat. Bring a date! It's incredably inexpensive! I go there whenever i can. Every item on the menu is delicious! (And it has a VERY long menu.) read more

I work down the street, and I eat here all the time. Actually I do take-out most of the time because the place is rather small. However, it's a good place to eat a quick meal if you want to go to the West Newton Cinema a few doors down. Anyway, i always order the small eggplant parmesan with "mess" which is a mixture of pastas that they have extra of that day. It's always delicious because their marinara sauce is so incredible. For $10. it's enough for two large meals. read more

Yup, even their messes are good! And the one in Belmont has pizza! Always delicious. Good meatballs too. I love their sauce. And this is coming from an Italian who is VERY picky about sauce! read more

This is a wonderful place to go! The menu is gigantic, and the prices are fairly reasonable, especially considering the great portions you are served. The food is ready to go or on the table within 10 minutes of ordering, and it was unbelievably good. The only downside is that parking is somewhat limited (on street if you can find it, or in another store's lot illegally.) The service is pleasant, the restaurant is clean, and the atmosphere is pleasantly casual. read more

Comella's is awesome. The small dining space is clean and comfortable, but I prefer to take out. There's a guy at the small wine shop across the street who asks me if I'm "in sales" every time I go in (I'm not)...kind of odd (offensive?), but still a good 1-2 punch: mess from Comella's + a cheap bottle of wine from the guy across the street = perfectly relaxed and slightly drunken evening at home. Also, I think they have a magic stove (microwave?) because seemingly nothing takes more than 3 minutes to emerge from the kitchen. read more

Tonight I had the most unbelievable experience at this restaurant. 20 minutes after receiving my dinner and glass of wine, my party was told that "the girls" had to leave because it was closing time. "Would we, as customers, please finish and leave"! We were threatened by the owner who said, "I am calling the police" because, "you refuse to leave"! We were harrassed and finally left! Others on the sidewalk had just experienced the same treatment! We all agreed that we would spread the word and this would be the end of Comellas for us! read more

Comella's has some of the best Italian dishes in the city and the prices are very reasonable. We have never been disappointed with their level of quality and service. The Pizza is fabulous, The Calzones are addicting, the Stuffed Shells are "fatteningly" delicious and the Lasagna is among the best in the city. Oh, and an honorable mention to the Chicken Parmesan! read more

Loved the Italian mess with sausage, meatballs, onions, peppers and mushrooms! My daughter and I should have split a single order though as I was more than full just eating half. Great casual place that served homemade food in fast food time. I'd go back if I'm ever in this part of the country again. My only criticism would be the quality of the fresh tomatoes in April. But then again, I'm comparing it to our produce back in California and that's probably not fair. read more

I've had more Italian food than anyone I know, and this is the best Italian take-out I have ever had. Their customizable "mess" is their signature dish but you can get it almost any way you like. They have multiple locations in the Boston Suburbs. This location is tiny and on a busy road in the West Newton Village of Newton. OverallFood is really good. Highly recommended. read more

Not a fan of this place and it's unfortunate because I work next door. It's a great concept, homemade pastas and messes but the food just isn't good. I've had a variety of things and there's always something not great about it. One time I got gnocchi with oil and garlic and it was so drenched in oil and encased in garlic I had to go back. The salads are often sad looking. The chicken is pounded SO thin there's barely any meat left. I used to go here often for convenience but can't stomach it anymore. read more

I wish that there were a Comella's in NYC- this place is out of control AMAZING! Every time I am in Boston I make sure to go here because it is such a treat. The red sauce is nothing short of magnificent, and it is highly addictive. Some of my favorite dishes are the eggplant parmigiana, chicken parmigiana, meatball and pasta platter, and the garlic knots. You should go out of your way to check this place out! read more

Disappointed in Shrimp Scampi I ordered yesterday. Not nearly as good as in the past read more

Food was great, though cashier was giving me looks and rolled his eyes at me. The pasta was pretty good, and the restaurant is small. Hopefully the cashier had an off day as he was very rude. read more

My fiance and I love Comella's! It's the tastiest and cheapest homemade Italian food in town. I highly recommend the messes, lasagna, stuffed shells, and ravioli. I'm a particularly big fan of the squash ravioli, but I recommend getting it to go with no sauce, or getting the sauce on the side--too much sauce will overpower the squash taste. I'm vegetarian, and they have so many good options! My fiance is a meat-eater, and he often orders something involving chicken, meatballs, and/or sausage, and he's always satisfied. For dessert, get a tiramisu to go, bring it home, and add a tablespoon of rum to the bottom. Amazing. Why I gave it four stars instead of five: 1. It gets a little crowded at times, especially right after a movie lets out at the West Newton Cinema, which is practically next door. There aren't many tables, and there's no waiting area, whether you're waiting for a table or take-out. 2. Some of the menu items are underwhelming. Skip the garlic bread. Skip the caprese (fresh mozzarella) salad/sandwich. The alfredo sauce is very salty, the pesto sauce is very oily, and the oil/buter/garlic sauce is not well blended. The parmesan cheese they put on top is also pretty salty. Also worth knowing: You order at the counter and seat yourself, but the staff will bring your food to you when it's ready, if you're eating there. read more

Nice kids working there, but the food isn't good. I got the Chicken Broccoli Alfredo with ziti, and it was flavorless. The broccoli was in huge chunks, undercooked, and had no flavor. The sauce was watery and not spread throughout the takeout dish, just slopped on top. Garlic bread was pretty soggy. I don't recommend this place if you're craving Italian. read more

Comella's is not a BYOB. Because it was on this site, and the reviews were favorable, we tried it last night. So I've ordered our meals, and ask if they would open the wine that we brought. The guy who took my order referred me to the woman who was handling the phone orders. When I asked her about opening the wine she told me that they are not a BYOB, and haven't been for at least four years. Didn't any of the reviewers think this might be an important point on a site dedicated to BYOB restaurants? read more

This restaurant came recommend from friends... boy they were right! We got take-out and ordered 1/2 bucket of Grandpa's Mess (a tray full of pasta with cheese, meatballs and spicey sausage-- Delish!) I will be frequenting this place for take out for sure! Only wish I had discovered it sooner! read more

Horrific customer service. Had a terrible incident at the West Newton store where a young worker berated me, my 9 year old son and his friend...COMPLETELY INAPPROPRIATE! I made several attempts to bring this to the attention of the owner, to no avail. Matt Comella got in touch with me weeks after the incident and after two requests, and then blatantly ignored my request for a call back. Perhaps he just doesn't care. The one woman I did speak to from another store was pleasant and apologetic, but it's really not up to her. Maybe Gene would be more interested, but there's no way to reach these people. So... if you want the young help in their teens/20s to berate you not once, but twice, then go to Comella's. If you want great pizza in West Newton I suggest waiting for Sweet Tomatoes to open again. Don't waste your time or money on this dump. Paying customers deserve MUCH better!!! read more

Love it. Our easy date-night choice - pick up movie tickets, hit Comella's for a chicken parm on homemade fusilli with a couple glasses of Chianti, then mosey over to the theater. The best part - they are so cool with our two kids when we have Saturday dinner there. It's a cozy joint, the antithesis of that family-style Italian stripmall chain, and it works perfectly for us. It feels like a city place - I love the intimate scale. They always provide a high chair and are super cool when my 4-y.o. starts getting twitchy. A gem. read more

This place is the definition of 'hole in the wall' but the food is awesome! I had some sort of 'mess' which was a mix of different kinds of pastas with sauce and then whatever you wanted on top (eggplant, meatballs, sausage, chicken, shrimp, etc). I was really surprised by the quality of the food... it's just like Mom used to make! One point off for the horrible parking situation and the fact that they don't have a bathroom (that's a real minus for me!). I will definitely be stopping by again if I'm in the area and looking for a quick and inexpensive meal. read more

What a tasty veal parm sandwich for just 7 little dollars! And there was so many options! We weren't sure about this "bucket" thing. Do I want lasagna in a bucket? Perhaps I'll have to go back and find out! read more

For good, cheap, friendly, fast Italian, trek out to Newton for some great stuff. Comella's is a Newton institution, and they have just opened up a Deli a few doors down...but Comella's itself cannot be beat. Their mess plates are a huge serving of pasta, meats, sauces, and cheese. If you are hungry, get one plate for yourself, but if not its best to share. Highly reccomended! Very chill, very fun, great relaxing date spot. read more

Can you say comfort food? The Mess is delicous. My personal favorite is the Eggplant and Chicken Parm Mess, it is excellent. Generous portions at a reasonable price. read more

If you are hungry, eat here! Quick yet friendly service here. You'll get your food in less than 15 minutes. I usually get the chicken parm with pasta which is huge and fantastically good! I usually cannot finish it, but most of it and not enough to take home. Their garlic bread is really good too. Home made I suppose. The mess looks really good, if you like a lot of cheese and other Italian ingredients! Overall, no complaints! read more

Who's hungry? If you are and you are craving Italian food and you happen to be in the vicinity of Newton, stop by Comella's and order the "mess". You will be hungry no more...and your wallet will not suffer for it. read more

I have been back to Comella's a couple times since my positive experience there, and unfortunately, each experience since has been poor. Most recently my fiancee and I ordered two dishes for take-out. Pasta with chicken and alfredo sauce for him and chicken parm with extra marinara for me. Both were total failures. His alfredo sauce was like nothing I have ever seen--it was gloppy and stuck to the pasta in little chunks. Even after he heated it up, he couldn't get the sauce to mix with the pasta...it just stayed stuck to the linguine in little bits and tasted like a grainy but soft mixture of Parmesan cheese and butter. My chicken parm had barely any cheese on it and all the sauce for the pasta was soaked up by the very heavily breaded chicken cutlet. And they forgot to include the extra marinara I ordered. I won't be returning to this place. read more

For the best homeade fussilli you will ever eat, come to Comella's! Fast, fanstastic food, this place gives feel good italian a new name! The resturant is a little hole in the wall, with small tables and not much decour to speak of, but the huge menu with pasta galore makes up for it! Try one of the messes- a combination of every pasta (and meat) all put together in a surprisingly yummy concoction! It is located right next to the West Newton Theater, so grab a date for a pre-movie meal! read more

So my gf and I walked around the area popping in and out of places looking for a bite and we went for Comella's. We've been in Newton for about a year but hadn't been so we were probably due. First problem was that ordering ahead makes a little more sense since after I ordered I looked like a dope standing in the middle of the place. (all the tables were full). It was fast though so I got out of there pretty quick. Portions are a good size. Shrimp scampi was good, though a little light on the shrimp. Grandpa's mess was really good. The sausage was incredible. I didn't dig the lasagna. The cheese was just too rich and something about the sauce. Ill probably go back and try a few different things. read more

Still Amazing! BUT, get the stuffed shells with eggplant and mess ($6.99, you get a huge amount of the amazing eggplant, mess and flavorful stuffed shells. read more

Italian fast food basically. Alot tastes like junk you might throw together at home with left overs and some old boxed pasta... Price ok. Good in a pinch- when there is no time to throw anything together-- also platters are really reasonably priced read more

Great comfort food, great prices without the crazy wait times and attitudes of those other Italian places. If you're never tried their "Messes" then please do-so. You can add "Mess" to practially anything on the menu, so good! read more

I love Comella's for take out (not bad for eating in, but small and sort of a takeout ambiance...). It's Italian red sauce food, and it's great! I almost always get a Mess (pasta dish) to share with the family and a meatball or chicken parm sandwich. Their pizzas are great and cost $5! You can't get food this good for this price anywhere! read more

I don't get the appeal of this place. Every pizza place in NJ basically serves the exact same menu as Comella's only with better quality. The food is over sauced and over cooked like it has been prepared way in advance so it can be assembled in quantity. I should have know that any place that serves food by the "bucket" should be avoided. read more

I had lunch for the first time at Comella's, W. Newton. My cousin and I shared a large cheese pizza, sampled a meatball and a sausage. The pizza came out under cooked. The dough was partially cooked and had to go back into the oven. The pizza in comparison to others pizza shops that I frequent was mediocre (when cooked).. Perhaps I am especially picky. Being Italian, I usually make my own, both thin crust and Sicilian style. The meatball was not bad. but the sauce was heavily seasoned that it covered up the taste of the tomatoes. I didn't try the sausage so I cannot comment on it. but with that too, the sauce was very heavily seasoned. My friend who had the sausage asked for a piece of bread and they wanted to charge $ 4.00 for a bread roll. We wouldn't mind paying a $1.00 for a piece of bread but $4 is a rip off. We will not be going back, nor will I recommend it. I live in the North Shore area and learned there is one not far from me in Melrose, but I certainly will not be going there either. read more

The fettuccine Alfredo is very good. Unfortunately when I saw a table get their water it was white

I will add to this review when I have gone a few more times, but my first impression was good. Reasonably priced, great menu, and very tasty. It's the type of place where you order from behind the counter so it's quick. My 3 star rating is because my dish was lukewarm at best. read more

Well this review is of the "mess" I got the Grandpa mess with sausage and meatballs. First in terms of sheer volume of meat the mess gets 5 stars. And really that's the problem. There's too much meat and not enough pasta and cheese. The cheese is ricotta and not mozzarella which I prefer. The meatballs were first rate but I disliked the sausage's texture. Also the sauce is somewhat acidic. Because of all the sauce and lack of pasta a slice of toasted italian bread would be nice. I realize this place is very popular and stars are a subjective thing. Maybe the shells would be more to my liking. Very small place so you'll likely either do take out or wait if you want to eat here on a Friday or Saturday. Like Jillian Q. I'd give it 3.5 stars read more

Rib sticking good Italian food. Try a mess, with your favorites added to it. I like iron mike's mess - chicken, meatballs, sausage, and veggies. The mess is like a goulash of Italian pasta and could include everything from lasagna to eggplant to ziti. It changes from time to time so you never know exactly what you'll get. This location has a few tables and is kind of cozy. Good portions and also great if you need a lot of food for a party or meeting. read more

Great food! Terrible parking situation in their W. Newton location. Eggplant parm is incredible and really enjoy being able to sit and eat or order for take out. Wine selection is fair. Good, fast service. Always crowded and very few tables! Great deal for food that tastes like it's been cooking all day! Very homey. read more