Okay, first of all, let me start by saying this review is long overdue, and I apologize because…read moreIsland Crave has been one of my favorite spots for YEARS. My cousin put me on, and ever since then, it has been one of my go-to places for authentic Jamaican food in Harlem. When I say authentic, I mean authentic--the type that tastes like your auntie, uncle, or grandma is in the back cooking just for you.
The portions are always generous, the food is always flavorful, and the owners and staff are some of the nicest people. Every time you walk in, it feels like you're being welcomed home.
Back in July (forgive me y'all, life was lifing and I just recently moved back to NY), my cousin and I went because I was having a whole craving--oxtails were calling my name, and Island Crave delivered like they always do.
I ordered oxtails, rice and peas, cabbage, and of course plantains, because what is a meal without them? I got a cream soda (duh, automatic), and we also got festival, because I don't care where I go--if festival is on the menu, I'm getting festival. The oxtails were so tender, falling off the bone the way they're supposed to. The gravy? PERFECT. Not too much, not too little--just enough to coat the rice the way God intended.
Rice and peas? Chef's kiss.
Cabbage? Always hitting.
Plantains? Sweet and soft, no complaints.
Everything was absolutely delicious. If you're Caribbean, you already know--you want that taste of home, that flavor that hits your spirit. Island Crave gives you exactly that.
I've also had their porridge--plantain porridge and cornmeal porridge--both are so comforting and perfect when you need something filling in the morning, especially after a night out. And the ackee and saltfish? Listen... I am an ackee and saltfish girl to my core, and theirs is so good. A whole island breakfast moment. You taste all the flavors and seasonings in every bite.
I highly, HIGHLY recommend Island Crave. It's one of my true go-to spots in Harlem, and honestly, even if you're not in the neighborhood, it's worth the trip. The food is always fresh, always flavorful, always consistent.
If you do check them out, please come back and let me know what you think--because I'm a fan through and through.