As a side note- I've been ordering from cold Stone for like 5 years or more and I've never felt compelled to leave a bad review, or even say a bad word about it. I think everyone agrees all the toppings they mix in with the ice cream is the best part. That being said, last night I went on Uber Eats and I ordered from the cold stone on Hempstead tpke in levittown and I've never seen such a scarce portion of toppings in my lifetime. And I ordered 2 triple pints so it was $70 worth of ice cream (mainly for the toppings) I paid for and I chose 6 toppings for each triple pint, because that's how I roll,. But I got like 3 sprinkles , some Oreo crumbs, and a couple of tiny marshmallows. This type of treatment of your customers is borderline abusive. 3535 Hempstead tpke cold stone you need to do better. Even if you are rationing or something be frugal with the toppings on the small , single and double scoop orders, not the big dogs who pick up weight , like 2 triple pints on a Wednesday night re up. I will Be ordering from the Hicksville location next time, or maybe even hit up my old connect B*skin R****ns.... read more

Cold Stone Creamery - 6 toppings - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

My favorite ice cream shop! I've been going to Cold Stone since I was younger and it has always been the best. This location was good, service was good as usual. It was clean and everyone was helpful. Even though I usually know what I want, it is appreciated to get new suggestions. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Our Strawberry Blonde - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

Employees are very young and do not care about this business! 7/10 times your order will be wrong if you order pick up or delivery. If you call to have it corrected you will be cursed out by the kids! So mean! The ice cream is good but your best bet is walking into the store and watching the kids mix up your batter. Needs so much improvement, sadly! read more

Went into the establishment tonight and there was at least 8 employees behind the counter. I was waiting on line and the employee blew past my wife and I to take the customers behind us. We thought he made a simple mistake and the other customers didn't stop him. We figured no big deal we will just wait. Another employee finally came up and asked if he can help us and then proceeded to finish up the order of the other customers. We finally asked if someone could actually do our order. We finally placed our order but they were out of the toppings we wanted. OK now we go to ring up and the employee asks if we would like a reciept. We say yes and the employee them proceeds to tell us sorry we can't print it up tonight. No further explanation. Last part of this disaster was while another employee was dealing with another customer(I assume it was a friend of hers) started cursing at her using excessive vulgarity. It was a complete and utter disaster visiting this location. We will not be going back. read more

Ice cream is still very good pricey though. For the price of the ice cream should have seating available in or out or both. They had one table with one chair. Came in when it was empty employees didn't say hi and was just chatting in the corner. Had to eventually ask them a question to get help. Once again for the price step up the atmosphere. read more

The ice cream are definitely delicious! The prices are moderate and I am always looking for bargains. So I'm not a regular here even though I always scream for ice cream! The staff are helpful, but serious and not friendlier than I would expect. The place is adequate and clean. read more

Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream is one of the very best Ice Creams you'll ever eat in your life. It's so rich and creamy. The Chocolate Cake Batter is outstanding. read more

I don't know how they do it. How they manage to stay in business. The long twisted hair was a freebee with the costly high prices. I didn't ask for it. I gave it back. I told the guy just give me vanilla. He didn't. I sure hope the replacement cup is hair free. read more

See all

Wow...2 days in a row they messed up two orders. First time I had cold stone, I had vanilla, strawberry, and yellow cake... The strawberries were completely frozen. Second time I ordered, it was a family order, we paid extra for a waffle bowl which costs extra, they did not include it, and I even gave a tip. I contacted support to report a complaint, one day passed, no one gets back to me. Next day I order, I order a vanilla, strawberry, and yellow cake. I paid extra, instead they gave a vanilla with sprinkles. Safe to say they have lost a customer. I will no longer go here, three strikes, that's all you get. Two stars because it is delicious, if only they got some orders right, five stars would've been possible. To think they are so busy...I wonder if I am just unlucky. read more

Today I was craving some cold stone make my own icecream. This was the closest location to where I was. It was very clean and organized staff was super friendly and attentive. I felt so welcome as I walked in. Ruby is phenomenal and very pleasant. She's truly amazing with outstanding customer service. She deserves a bonus. It's very pleasing to know it's still young people out here that's so manner and helpful. Thank you Ruby. read more

See all

Before I kickback relax and have a couple of Steveweisers! Im going to get something swweeeet from cold stone! Strawberry Cake Batter I say! Chocolate Cake Batter cotton candy sweet cream all the flavors will stun ya into a frenzy and thats the bottom line cause Cold Stone said so! read more

See all

I mean it's Cold Stone. The best ice cream on earth...bottom line Not sure what all the negativity is about. I had no issues...In fact I was over served.. read more

This dumb byotch with the piercings I think her name is Corianna or Corinne she literally be skipping people on line, like it's not rocket science we're all in 1 straight line and this airhead be skipping people; not even like I was looking down I was patiently waiting to be helped smh. So effin rude. The whole store is just a mess. I feel bad for most of these kids (except Corinne) because they do look stressed and the owner or manager he's the most useless person ever he's always otp doing nothing but staring at his staff struggling, that's probably why this store is a mess. Lynbrook is much better. read more

The service at this store is the worst. 5 people behind a counter with 3 customers in a store, 2 of whom were being assisted before me while I waited to get help. Then another customer came in and skipped me and went directly to one of the other associates and immediately was being helped. By then I had lost all patience because I had to wait and witness 5 different ppl behind a counter walking back and forth and only one of them was helping the couple before me until the lady walked over and asked for help. I honestly hope it wasn't a racial thing but I was the only African American in the store at the time. This particular establishment has got to do better with training their staff and letting them know they are in the service industry. A customer comes in, you help them, end of story. read more

i've always loved cold stone up until this experience. My order was originally made incorrectly and after driving 30 minutes to my house, I came back just to simply have it replaced. I came in and even apologized to him for the inconvenience and asked him to remake my order. When i walked in he hid in the back and attempted to avoid taking my order, when he finally came out I had to flag him down while the other workers were just standing around and he continued to make snarky comments about me coming back just for toppings. When leaving I was even laughed at. Very unprofessional!!! read more

Great service. Awesome help and attitude by staff members on a holiday. Especially when they to hand pack a quart of ice cream for you. Got the chocolate cake batter, which is awesomely yummy, but might be a little too sweet as a shake. Not planning on adventuring for the tastebuds either. Glad they carried out their spirit on having a good day for themselves. Give them time to help you, especially when they get rush hour line into the store. Just breathe. read more

My boyfriend and I were craving a cold treat the other day and decided to take a drive down to Cold Stone. First, the layout of the store is quite confusing with the new COVID procedures. I understand having sections blocked off to keep customers 6+ feet apart, but there were no instructions as so how the "line" (if you want to call it that...) was supposed to flow. Service was also quite weak. There was only one other customer in the store and 6 employees behind the counter. It took several minutes for us to even be acknowledged. I am appreciative that there are many sorbet options for us dairy free folks! The mango/strawberry combo (with added coconut) was a nice tropical treat. Prices are sky-high though. You're probably better off just buying a pint from the grocery store and adding in your own toppings. Skip Cold Stone (or at least this location) in the near future. read more

The smartest thing that the owner of this Cold Stone Creamery did was to choose this location to open his store. This place is an absolute Gold Mine!! Any time I have stopped in for one of their concoctions, the store is never empty. Forget the weekends and summertime, you then have to deal with all the lines. Unlike Starbucks (too many to count), there is no other Cold Stone Creamery nearby. OK, I'm sure you have all been to a Cold Stone Creamery before and know how amazingly delicious everything is there. Then, there's no need to try and convince you to order one of Cold Stone's Signature Creations like the Strawberry Banana Rendezvous (strawberry ice cream, graham cracker crust, white chocolate chips, strawberries and banana) or the Peanut Butter Cup Perfection (chocolate ice cream, peanut butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup and fudge). You might as well just kick yourself afterwards for the 5 lbs. you are guaranteed to gain from this one!! It is huge!! (no, I didn't get one, the guy in front of me did - really!!) You can also have a little fun and make up your own concoction like me, the "Cherry Surprise" (sweet cream ice cream with cherry pie filling and almonds) Don't laugh, this just may be their next "Signature Creation"!! I like this location for several reason's: it's always immaculate, there are tables to sit and eat, the staff are very nice and they are always in tune when they sing that stupid little song whenever they get a tip. For the best reason of all, my daughter's babysitter works there (no explanation needed)!! This isn't advertised but you can also order a Kid Creation (smallest cup size) which includes 1 mix in for $2.25, for those of you who don't want to feel as guilty afterwards. Speaking of guilt, there are also these unbelievable "Signature Cakes" in a display case as soon as you walk in, just waiting for you to pick one out to take home. So, the diet starts tomorrow - stop by this Cold Stone Creamery, lines and all. You may even see "Cherry Surprise" on the board as their newest creation!! (You never know!!) read more

See all

Went last week for a once in awhile Cold Stone fix. I would like to start by saying their pricing dramatically increased. I'm not sure if it's due to the pandemic but I remember when a "Love It" size was 5.99 now it's 8.99. Cold Stone ice cream is consistent but the prices are very disappointing. Service isn't the best but sometimes you get some nice servers. read more

Not happy with this cake at all Red velvet was stale I will never spend another dime in this place I work too hard to waste my money on garbage read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

One of the male employees took an extremely long time to complete our order because he spent a significant amount of time talking to coworkers while making our order. He messed up 3 out of our 5 ice creams. He looked so preoccupied talking to his coworkers we weren't even sure he remembered he was helping us. Will not be returning to this location. read more

The kid w the curly mullet and glasses and earrings sucks at his job. He can't multitask and took forever for simple orders and messed up 3/5 orders. read more

The icecream was really good im not going to lie. The strawberry and dark chocolate flavor was very creamy and rich. There are a lot of flavors to choose from that you end up feeling overwhelmed by the choices you have. I got the waffle cone and the portion size of the ice cream was fairly large. But the waffle cone itself was very stale and did not taste good at all. I wish the waffle cone was better and this review would have gotten 5 stars. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - strawberry and dark chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

This place may be doing its best. But the way Uber eats works is you accept an order when you know you can have it done in time. But making drivers wait for 25 minutes so that customers have to wait for 45 is ridiculous. Don't accept it if you can't do it! read more

Third time in 2 months I received almost all ice cream very little add ins after ordering chocolate devotion. Its obvious no one enjoys working there and it shows when you ask for an ice cream that needs to be mixed. $9 for mostly chocolate ice cream and a small piece of stale brownie. Worst cold stone in NY. Not going back. read more

I love this cold stone! They have the best ice cream here. I always get cake batter with Oreos and it's so amazing!

Place is dope and all but mad money. So many other cheap options to get for desert. Flavors are pretty sick but even then, a place like Ralphs also sick flavors and they not gunna crank ur racks as hard. Cold Stone doesn't even offer 2-fers like Ralphs does. I can't express how much bread these guys will charge you. Cold stone will always be great but they need to step their game up across the board if they gunna run yo pockets dry. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

This is my favorite go to place for all the cakes . I have been ordering cakes here from a year though I moved down to different city , I pick cakes from this spot as I like it from here . I have been to this place recently and the crew working in that shift are all new ppl who had no idea . I understand the new hiring happen all time and they sure turn out to be great at job but , it would be really great and comfortable if there is atleast one experienced person who knows what's going on . I wanted to order a cake and 3 People working inside don't even have an idea of what to write down for notes . I don't blame them, it's the manager who has to assist them or some existing employee should always be there Incase of difficulty and to teach how to respond to clients. I hope this won't be the scenario going further read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

The ice cream is great!! Really do enjoy coldstone overall. The gentleman who was working when we stopped in was very nice, there was another lady working on cakes in the back - the cakes looked awesome. Why not 5 stars? There was a garbage can holding the bathroom door open (not sure why?), and the two time I went in there there was no toilet paper. read more

See all

Me and my buddy go in and it's like I was being rushed to order ice cream...nvm they didn't give me no napkins and my ice cream container wasn't even closed the right way went right tho the bag and ruined my seats smfh read more

We have been to multiple Cold Stone locations where you can see how well the employee mixes and chop up all topping. But not this location. You can tell the employee just wanted to get customers out. I dont recommend this store. read more

Never had a good experience with this specific site. Customer service is always bad. Servers r rude. I could walk in and no greeting but the person after me that walks in gets a greeting n helped before me...they need to be retrained. Its disgusting read more

My boyfriend and I went into the shop at 10:40pm when the shop closes at midnight. When we got there, it was decently busy with people, but all people who already ordered and paid and who were just waiting. We only needed to pay for a package of 4 ice cream sandwiches, so we thought it would be quick. We stood at the cash register without being acknowledged at all for 10 minutes. Two workers were even counting cash in the machine and complaining about still having to be there working (again, over an hour before closing time). One of them finally looked at us just to ask us to let him check out the people behind us for some reason. After he let them pay, instead of helping us, he went back to doing random things and complaining. I had to send my boyfriend to get a new pack at this point because the original one had started to melt. Then, another worker asked for the next customer and completely ignored us again. At this point, over 15 minutes just standing in the shop and being ignored by everyone, my boyfriend asked "can we pay for this here?". The same worker said "yes" while being annoyed and took my card to pay. He never said thank you, and just said "you're good". I asked if the receipt printed and he rudely asked if I wanted one, to which I said yes. He huffed and ran to another machine to print it out. Overall, it was supposed to be a quick trip just to pay for prepackaged dessert, and ended up being an extremely upsetting 20 minute rude interaction. 1000% not worth it at all. read more

Hardly had any of the flavors listed on their website. The holiday flavors are already gone yet. The flavors in store weren't even good flavors and did not have many choices. Okay place, okay ice cream. read more

Ordered 4 ice creams on door dash and only got 3. Can you imagine if any other business had a 75% success rate? When I called them, the "manager" had no idea how it happened. So no one checks the bag before it goes out? It seems like this place is run by children and in which case, they should pay an adult a living wage to manage it. read more

Open till 11pm every night. Can get crowded at times, usually when a large group comes here for a treat as it seems to be a popular destination for many teenagers. They have a large selection of ice-creams, gelatos, shakes. If you want a suggestion, try Strawberry Banana Rendezvous. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Strawberry Banana Rendezvous - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

I got a gift card for them for Christmas and i keep forgetting to use it. So it was a warm day and i decided to treat myself to a shake and a smoothie since the card was for 15$. I got the Blueberry Pineapple smoothie and a French Vanilla shake. As soon as i ordered a ton of people came in and i felt bad for the one kid working. They were both really good but are now in my fridge since i couldn't finish them both obviously. I had 3$ left on the gift card so i gave it to the people behind me who were like um thanks i think they were in shock someone on long island was actually nice to them. I tipped the guy 2$ and im off. Place was very clean too. People on Yelp sure like to complain about dumb shit in their reviews. Go eat your damn ice cream and STFU. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - French vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

Amazing ice cream, service is great, can't think of anything bad about it! It is my favorite place for ice cream!

Courteous service and very varied tastes. It is recommended to take base ice cream and to add fresh flavors that are crushed and incorporated in the ice cream in an impressive and original way. read more

See all

The workers here don't pay attention and seem to just be annoyed to be helping you. (They look to be high school age, but it shouldn't matter) The place is dirty/ counter that they hand your ice cream over was covered in toppings. Expect to pay a lot of money...for a small ice cream and large ice cream it came to almost $14 (insert screaming emoji). Why the three stars? Cause I really liked the ice cream I got hah! Cake batter and Oreo ice cream mixed with freshly crushed Oreos and chopped up cookie dough. It was creamy with large chunks of soft cookie dough and crunchy Oreo bites. I enjoyed my sundae, but I won't be rushing back. Too expensive with lame-o service. read more