Was passing through on our way to Long Island. Food and prices was probably 4 stars. Service was 2 stars. Asked if they had Dr. Pepper, she said no.. I asked what about Mr. Pibb, she didn't know. led me to believe she was new so wanted to cut them some slack. My son ordered a sprite, she comes by and says they are out of sprite, son says just water then. Sprite still charged on the bill. Son had chocolate chip pancakes which get delivered with no silverware or syrup offered. I don't argue the 2 dollar sprite charge and still tipped 6 bucks feeling generous. Give the filled out receipt to the old lady up front with it clearly filled out 54.75 + 6.00 = 60.75, old lady says what is this i can't make it out is that a sixty dollar tip? I say no it's six bucks she asks me to make my 6.00 look clearer. Again food was good, daughter had a BLT, said it was good, Wife had a grilled cheese, said it was good, but the cheese could've been melted more. The fries were real good. I had a chili cheese dog which was good, Son's pancakes were good. read more

Ordered a georgia hot, scrambled eggs, and a side of grits. They didn't send any grits at all. The georgia hot was burnt, dry, and stiff. They slapped two pieces of gross processed cheese on the eggs for no reason. Threw all of this BS away. read more

Cody's Diner - Georgia hot, scrambled eggs - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Ordered on UberEats from hotel nearby twice during my stay. It was PERFECT. It was made and delivered within 20 minutes. Food portions are large and price is on point. Highly recommend. read more

Cody's Diner - Chef Salad - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Cody's is about as old school as you can get. Open 24 hours, standard diner menu, relatively inexpensive - you can easily drop 25 at a diner this days, probably 1/2 that a Cody's. The food is exactly what is should be. Fine dining? Hell no! But it absolutely delivers what it sets out to do. Ya gotta respect that. read more

Got food delivered from UberEats. Ordered meat ravioli, was given cheese ravioli. It's not hard to actually do the right dish, no? The pasta tasted...alright, but it certainly wasn't worth what I paid for. read more

Disappointed food had hair all over it!! And they refuse to refund me Hair in everything I ordered Check you food !! read more

See all

The old lady that works up front is the most rudest and careless woman, I have every seen. She talks crab about the customers right there in front of their faces. Like hellooo lady we can hear you. It's a new server there, I didn't get her name. She's short with pretty locs, she looks Indian. During my visit there I over heard the old lady calling her girl! multiple times. Which made me upset and uncomfortable as a customer. The new server is sweet and kind. She goes above and beyond to make her customers happy, however I has to witness the old lady scolding her the whole time I was there. I will never be back. read more

food was hot but the waiter was hotter!! fries were crispy, prices were cheap, and the inside is so cute read more

See all

Great food, 24/7, plus a great ev charger never too busy and always able to charge. If your in new haven't you need to go read more

Cody's Diner - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

There is an old lady there. Completely unprofessional. As soon as I walked in, she was rude. Not friendly in any sort of way. Every question was an inconvenience for her. read more

A very pleasant experience. Have passed by here a hundred times (no exaggeration) but have been hesitant to stop in based on prior reviews. Glad we did. The service was very good. The food was excellent, too. Mom got pancakes and 2 over easy eggs. Eggs were cooked perfectly and pancakes were hot and fluffy. I got an egg salad platter which consisted of choice of bread, lettuce, tomato and a very freshly made egg salad. It came with steak fries which were well cooked but needed to be salted fresh out of fryer. They have Orange Crush on fountain! read more

See all

The food,service and dinner is wonderful please try them. Look the service is dope them woman are so fast it's like their on roller blades. Then you get the food and it's fire my God has blessed someone hands in this restaurant. Like I said at the beginning please if you visit from out of town please make this a stop! read more

Ordered Cody's Big Breakfast through GRUBHUB and found several hairs in my food. Definitely won't be ordering from this restaurant again.

I work primarily nights and it was so hard to find a good place to grab a bite to eat at odd hours that didn't put a hole in my piggy bank up until I tried this place this morning. The steak bomb breakfast sandwich on a hardroll is to die for. The pick up window was fast efficient and clean! Def will be back. read more

Cody's Diner - Codys Steak Bomb Sandwich hard roll - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

My ex wife goes here. It angers me and my dog Mason. The staff is incredible and the food is great. I'm going to glue my hand to my face. Try the disco fries. The girl at the window is always so nice! Thank you always. What an amazing atmosphere. read more

I haven't been here in a while. This diner is open 24 hours. My cousin & me went an event in Strand theater. It ended late. I don't usually eat late nights anymore but I was really hungry. They expanded the inside which means they doing good. I think it's b/c Yale is so close by. It was packed w/ college kids. It looked good! Waitress was attentive & friendly. They had the ac on full blast I was freezing. I ordered a cheeseburger deluxe. My cousin ordered a vegetable omelette w/ disco fries. Unfortunately,my cousin doesn't like to share food. Booooo! Hot chocolate was delicious & the waitress added whipped cream which was a plus. I was a little upset they changed they steak fries into curly fries. Steak fries are my fave cut. Food was ok. I'm used to it tasting better. I guess I was bummed about the steak fries. I also was in between ordering a cheeseburger deluxe or breakfast. I wished I ordered the breakfast. They make some really good pancakes.I love their cheesecake. It's really good. I ordered 1 to go. read more

Took an online order and when I drove there they were closed. Kind of a bummer. Money will be held up and food delayed. Get on your sh*t, guys. read more

Cody's Diner - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

I've been coming here for several years... Food is consistent, clean, fresh, and served with a smile... Try out the pastrami New York style! read more

Cody's Diner - Pastrami - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

The food here is great! I highly recommend the crispy chicken wrap--it's absolutely delicious. The diner's interior has a unique, nostalgic charm that makes you feel like you're stepping back into your grandma's time. read more

Your typical everyday diner offering most if not all foods one would expect at a diner, the service is typically very fast paced, with the vibe of the restaurant giving a slight old school appeal. All in all I'd recommend coming here for a bite at night, though one issue I do have with this restaurant is that it has like 8+ different ghost kitchens, meaning it shares many different names on food delivery apps even though it's the same quality food from Codys Diner. These ghost restaurants names include the following, Cami's breakfast Cafe, Eggys Omelets, Hot ones Wings & Sandwiches, Grilled Cheese Mania, Patty Meltery, High Burgers, Pancake paradise, and Famous French Toast. Literally every single one of these "restaurants" just have normal menu items from Codys Diner, being the exact same food. I find it pretty frustrating having to scroll past all these when they all come from the same location when browsing for food. read more

Got here. Sat anywhere. Got up to go bigger table. Waitress was awesome. lol. Good job. Menu was good, got Cody's Big Breakfast (I use slang/aka CBB). My food was cooked to recognition. One might, say...? It even deserves prays??? Yummerz in my tummerz. So umm... who is Cody tho, I'm jk-ing. He did a good job here. Nice Cody. The pancakes... holy... the pancakes... I ated them right all the way up to the stomach :) ambience diner ambience was swell. TVs and such, read more

Cody's Diner - Pepper . Pepcorn - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Went in to eat and 3:20 PM and was told to come back because they had just mopped the floors. Told them I'd come back but will never go back. read more

Last night a few of us employees ordered breakfast sandwiches from Cody's Diner. I must say we all enjoyed our sandwiches & we all agreed we will be ordering from them again. read more

Ok, Ordered delivery and paid all them crazy fees. Order arrives on a scooter in a reasonable time... ordered meatloaf with mashed veggies and a salad... received pot roast and no veggies.meat was all mixed in the potatoes.. So I call and explain it all to a few people...The cook says he made a mistake....The crazy person on the phone says,,,,Come down here and exchange it for the meatloaf...I explained I was at work and can't, after paying 475 tip 4 for delivery and 299 something fees. She said ,,Don't no what to tell you and hangs up....lmao read more

Cody's Diner - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

WE Love Cody's. Incredibly excellent food for a small diner. Highly recommend "Best Prime Rib Sandwich" hot. The Chili Cheddar Burger, cheese fries so delicious and we are regular customers. Service is so kind and fast. Will keep coming back. read more

I just ordered the turkey and stuffing dinner. No joke...if I was given this on Thanksgiving I would have been ecstatic. Tender, fresh and tasty turkey, delicious stuffing. Seriously...excellent food. I order a lot and it's always good. read more

The absolutely worst cup of coffee I ever had in my life. Weird because a diner only has to do two things well - coffee and eggs (and I'm not talking poached). Somewhere the fictional Juan Valdez is crying real tears into his donkey's mane about how Cody's abuses his country's greatest export. The two New Haven cops at the counter were definitely comped. read more

Authentic diner experience, really exactly what you'd expect. Met expectations. The waitress at the counter was very nice.

Its a definite Yes for me! I'm from the south and never had a hard roll, but I am hooked! We were in town for 4 days and 3 of those mornings were spent at this place. Friendly service and good hot food! read more

I saw a lot of negative reviews for this place and was originally turned off, but it proved the perfect place to grab a late night coffee after a show at Long Wharf. Service was incredibly speedy and the servers were so kind. I only got coffee so I can't speak to the food, but whatever the family behind me was eating smelled amazing! All around just a lovely classic diner feel. Will definitely be returning next time I'm in New Haven! read more

Cody's Diner - a man taking a picture of himself in the mirror - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

There it was, in the middle of nowhere! Made a U turn and went in for lunch. A great lunch it was. Very happy.

Had a late night hunger, I didn't know it at the time but a cheeseburger club at Cody's was the cure! Perfect sweet potato fries on the side completed it. Service was spot on! I'll be back! read more

Tried to checkout Louis Lunch (was too packed there!) so we trekked to Cody's after a quick internet Diner search, had a great Burger, my Daughter had Pastrami club but the star was the Onion rings, they were soooo good.... try this Diner we are glad we did. read more

Cody's Diner - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

I ordered from door dash and chose pick up to get the BOGO deal on the chicken tenders with fries. When I got the order, it was 5 tenders per box but no fries. I show them the description which clearly says "with fries". They take my order back and say they'll add the fries. Which they do, but they took 2 fingers out from each box! This is ASS! Come on...so now I get 3 fingers and fries, or 5 fingers and no fries, yet the menu says it includes fries with 5 fingers. Shame...really??? They're both a frozen product you drop in the fryer, from which make a banging food cost...just saying... read more

this place is magical and it's clear that some of you just don't get that. they gave me a side of gravy the size of a baby. read more

Been eating here since my club kid days in the 1990s now married and living quietly around the corner. Best of all things diner Staples like eggs and hash are spot on. Prices, food quality, portion size, friendly staff: all good. read more

I wish I could give less than one star. Ordered through Grub Hub. Food is burned beyond recognition. Inedible. Just terrible. read more

Cody's Diner - This is supposed to be kielbasa. - Diners Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Food was good, open late is a plus. The pricing is accurate and fair for what you receive

I've ordered late-night blueberry pancakes delivered from here several times during the pandemic and I have to say the 3-star rating of "okay" is right about on target. Sad thing is that its 100% NOT about the food it's about the lack of attention to detail... I keep coming back despite the fact that EVERY TIME there is something missing from my order. Last time my pancakes came with no syrup... fortunately I had a bottle but if I hadn't that "detail" could have ruined my dinner. Tonight was a bit worse they left a $3 item off my order and it's clearly on the receipt. (the idea in ordering an EXTRA side of sausage was to have EXTRA sausage lol!) EVERY. SINGLE. TIME it's something. :( I LOVE your pancakes guys but going to have to try some other diners. read more

Was put up at Hotel by my company due to bad weather. My boss picked up Cody's diner for dinner and brought it to every employee's hotel room. What a great guy. My dinner was a turkey and cheese sandwich on a hard roll with great interest. Everything was delicious and I was starving so I ate it all up. The next morning he treated us all to breakfast again at Cody's I had an egg sandwich with hashbrowns and was completely satisfied. read more