The cowbell brisket is fantastic. I also tried the chicken sandwich +1 wing combo. The chicken breast is huge af. No complaints. The wing that came with my meal was bland. I had to sauce it up with the brush fire bbq sauce. The original sauce paired well with my cowbell brisket. Service was excellent as it was my first time there, the staff member was knowledgeable about the menu. It definitely guided my meal decision. Quite spacious inside with booths, tables and island high top bar seating in the center. read more

See all

I will start by saying the staff is absolutely amazing here and the establishment is spotless. However, this time around my ribs were very dry with little meat, and a lot of fat and gristle. However, my sides were fantastic! Enjoyed their selection of barbecue sauces. Sorry guys, maybe next time will be better. read more

City Barbeque - Barbecue ribs, mac & cheese, potato salad with Texas toast - Sandwiches Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

See all

We visited this location for the first time on Tuesday. Jason was so patient with my indecisiveness and set the tone for a great visit with his positivity. *I hope that's his name, that's what was on my receipt* The brisket was so tender and flavorful that I almost decided to order more to take home to the other kids. We didn't order much this stop because we weren't super hungry and were running errands so I can't say much about the food. The Mac and cheese was good, creamy and not mushy. The corn pudding was also good, sweet and no undercooked parts. The place was very clean and the service was quick! read more

We've had very hit-or-miss experiences with City BBQ over the past several years and hadn't ordered in quite a while. We were hoping the new New Albany location might provide a better, more consistent experience than we've had at Gahanna, so we decided to give City another try with a takeout order. Unfortunately, it was more of the same. There were some definite positives. The Cobb salad with chicken was very good, and the peach cobbler was excellent - although the whipped cream was missing. Unfortunately, my husband's Not a Sloppy Joe had a couple of small pieces of bone in the meat, which was unpleasant and concerning from a quality-control standpoint. The flavor of the sandwich was excellent but the bones kind of ruined it for him. The fries were just okay, the cookies were dry and broken, and our sides were completely missing. The missing sides were especially frustrating because this has happened to us multiple times before. Because of that, my husband specifically asked at pickup if everything was in the bag. He was assured it was because the items were on the receipt and had been checked off. We got home - no sides. We tried calling to get it resolved, but after sitting on hold for nearly 15 minutes, we gave up. I understand that mistakes happen, but when you're spending a significant amount on a takeout meal, you should be able to trust that the food is prepared properly and that everything you paid for is actually in the bag. When the same problem happens repeatedly - even after specifically asking that the order be checked - it stops feeling like an occasional mistake and starts looking like a quality-control issue. We really hoped the new location would be a better experience, but unfortunately New Albany seems to be just as hit-or-miss as Gahanna has been for us. At this point, we likely won't order takeout from City again. The problem isn't one forgotten side or one disappointing meal; it's the repeated inconsistency that has caused us to lose confidence in the restaurant. read more

We ordered a "party pack" (2 lbs meats, 2 quart sides). It was all ready on time, packed conveniently and delicious. I was concerned that the smoked turkey might be dry, but it was not. read more

City Barbeque is one of my favorite places to get takeout. While most of the time the food is of high quality they missed on my last visit. I'm a little irritated because I spent a significant amount of money on my order. My sides were delicious other than I was missing my fries. I live to far to take things back or to g9 back to get what was missing. My baked beans, cole slaw, peach cooler, banana pudding and cookies were all spot on. However, my ribs and bone-in chicken wings were both dry. They were so dry I could only eat one bone. Others in my family ate one or two bones, but that was the extent of it. I tried to call the establishment, but after being on hold, I gave up. I just wish quality control would be such that a business would refuse to send out an order that is not up to standard. Again this is only the second time that I have been this disappointed therefore I will continue to support City Barbecue. They generally are consistent in their quality. read more

Was lazy tonight, so we stopped by City BBQ. So good! Staff was friendly and provided great service as usual. Grabbed some chicken, some sauce and water, then chilled on their patio. The only thing I dislike is the contactless curbside pickup is directly adjacent to the patio so -- You get to eat a side of unwanted exhaust fumes. read more

See all

I have always enjoyed City BBQ and I still do. But after my last visit, I was literally blown away by how unbelievably expensive this has become. Basic meal for two with one side each, with one fountain drink, and one water was over $35......and they left room for tip as well. Although food was great, not sure how affordable this "causal dining" option will be moving forward. This has moved into the "special dining" category. Unfortunately, more and more restaurants are moving into this category. read more

The new crispy baked potato was awesome. I wish I could say the same for the rest of the food. My wife and I had the leg/ thigh chicken. Dry and barely warm. Obviously, it was from lunch. The corn pudding was cold as well. This was the first and the last time we go to this store! The store in Gahanna is much better! read more

Very delicious salad with pulled pork. Had tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese and assorted greens and a hearty portion of pulled pork. I also had a order of hush puppies. Hubby ordered the same but had brisket instead, for a additional $3. Very yummy lunch and a covered patio. read more

See all

Great BBQ at a reasonable price and always spot on service. The half smoked chicken is always delicious, along with the brisket and pork. The sandwiches are also very good. The sides are amazing. Dining area is always clean and welcoming. The also have a small outside patio area. A must stop for good Ohio BBQ. Don't forget to get the pickles with your order. read more

Longtime customer first time in New Albany. CB has always been great and I'm happy they came out of Covid the same. Had my usual; leg/thigh, one side, and an Arnie Palmer. Everything was great, bright environment, and smiling staff. Thank you for your consistency! read more

City Barbeque - Sandwiches Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

See all

Have had brisket several times and was great. Past couple has had a lot (a lot) of gristle.

We went in for a last minute catering and Carrol and Donna were amazing!!!!! They made sure to get what we needed!!!! Asked all the right questions!! Took the time and it showed !!! We had enough food and everyone enjoyed it!!!!! Shout out to Carrol and Donna. Nate and Amanda! read more

Very nice new location with a much more modern atmosphere. We were the only ones there but ate in the very nice patio. Great digital menu by the way. You order and wait for your food as before. They also have you your metal silverware and however much sauce you want. If you want any more sauce any variety just ask. If you want a drink refill you ask them for a new cup. Service was extreme helpfully, the food was excellent and hot. We got the pick 2 meats. One with ribs, chicken (pictured) and two sides the other with ribs and pulled pork with 3 sides. Great smoky flavor, the fries were off the drier, the hush puppies were amazing. It's good to be out again and enjoy a nice meal on a hot day. Love the new location. Will definitely return. read more

City Barbeque - Two meats, ribs, chicken and hush puppies. The fries came later as they're making them fresh. - Sandwiches Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

I have picked up food here several times for parties and gatherings. They do a great job of assembling everything you could possibly need... And the food is excellent. Always a hit! read more

I always leave City BBQ thinking it was just okay but wasn't offensive and this new location isn't much different. I recently tried something different as I've ordered the same thing for many many years and I regretted it. I tried the pulled chicken sandwich and was really let down by this. Firstly it was really wet and not from any kind of sauce. Like maybe it was pulled early in the day and sitting in broth or something to keep it warm, I'm not sure. I also didn't love the flavor and it didn't mesh well with BBQ sauce. I'll definitely be sticking to my pulled pork going forward, or the turkey which I've also tried and enjoyed. I also always forget I don't like their green beans so this is my note to myself - don't order the green beans, you don't like them. The fries and the mac and cheese are the best sides in my opinion. Their lemonade is a real winner but I miss when they used to have warm BBQ sauce at the condiment bar as well as pickles. I'm sure I'll keep having standard meals here but I've never been blown away. read more

See all

Dry, dry, dry! We ordered the party pack and wings. Pulled pork was good but brisket was dry. Mac and cheese was dried out and bland. The wings were pitiful...they were tiny and dry as a bone. Wasted $80... read more

Really nice City bbq. The employees were friendly and offered extra bbq sauce. The ribs are done right and the fries came out hot. That's probably the most important thing I think is hot fresh fries. read more

See all

The brisket was great. Just enough smoke and it wasn't dry like so many are. What really surprised us though were the fried pickles. They were lightly battered and delicious. Also, the baked beans were great. Really enjoyed our dinner. read more

I've had the roasted chicken, the ribs and just recently the Nashville hot chicken sandwich. I have to say the Nashville hot chicken sandwich was the best. Normally comes with mayo, slaw and pickles, provolone cheese is extra. Great spicy breading! Will definitely be getting this every time I go. Just keep in mind that the sandwich did not come with a side, it cost like $3.50 just to add a side of fries. You can get delivery from here if you order through GrubHub. The sweet tea is hit and miss unfortunately. I've come before and it was very sweet, this time it really wasn't sweet and had and ash taste. Maybe it was old? Other than that most everything else is pretty consistent. read more

I love the smells of this restaurant. It reminds me of my hometown in Missouri. Unfortunately, the Barbeque is not up to what I am used to being raised in between Kansas City and St. Louis. The barbecue and sides were very delicious and tasty. However, the meat is definitely over, salted and over peppered like they are trying to compensate for something. The smoke on the food was on point the staff were friendly and patient read more

While we love city bbq it's sometimes hit or miss. Unfortunately, today was a miss. We picked up the 4-6 person family pack on our way home from a zoo trip. The brisket was on the dry side and our buns were hard/stale. The Turkey was delicious! The sides were completely on point. Green beans are the family favorite followed by Mac cheese, and banana pudding. read more

City Barbecue food quality is not what it used to be. The service and ambience is still great though.

I don't know what is happening at City BBQ, but the last few times we have been it was a big disappointment. Two weeks ago we went and I ordered their chicken tenders (first time), and French fries. It had been awhile since we ordered their fries--and what a change. They were frozen fries! They told me they had switched because it was easier for carry out-they stayed warmer?!?! Sounds like an excuse to go cheaper to me. They were bad enough for me to tell them I didn't want them. Such a shame, they were always good before. The chicken tenders, however, were great. My husband ate half my order. They were plump, juicy and pretty large. We went today for lunch and I had already decided to get the tenders again--they were awful. They were dry, small and over cooked. What happened in two weeks? Were the first ones a mistake because it was close to closing time? I won't order them again because I don't trust they will be good. From what I can see, the prices are going up and the quality is going down. They should stick to what they do--bbq, and forget the new tacos, etc. There are several other newer bbq places we have tried, and we will stick with them. read more

Newer location and a little more spacious compared to others. Tried the Sampler and loved it. Really enjoyed the chicken & the brisket! The greens are decent, however, the corn pudding is lacking yet edible. Service here is helpful and very friendly. Will certainly return! read more

Great spot for bbq, whether catering or lunch, the hush puppies are always a must. Brisket is great and everything else is pretty good too.

Everything so delicious! I adore anything bbq, especially brisket. So so good! Sides are great, employees are awesome. Nothing not to love here. read more

Stopped for a quick bite on the way to the airport and was pleasantly surprised! Staff was helpful and guided us to the best sellers. Ate the Nashville Hot Chicken sandwich and it was pure heaven. Spicy but not too hot, and the combo of the fried chicken, cold slaw, pickles, and spicy Mayo is pure heaven. French fries were also fab dipped in their tasty BBQ sauce. I can't wait for my next trip to Columbus!! read more

I love buying City BBQ on Rib Tuesdays. However, at this location the service was not what I expected. My last purchase of 6 bbq bones had to be the smallest ribs I've ever seen. My Previous purchase of ribs were not as small, but customer service was mediocre. I recall a cashier having more interest in talking to one of the cooks with her head turned toward the kitchen the whole time. Don't think I'll be back at THIS location. read more

City Barbeque - 6 tiny bbq bones - Sandwiches Near Me - New Albany, Ohio

Place is good. Not the best BBQ I've had but it is still solid. I've had Turkey , brisket , sausage , pulled pork (dry) , baked beans, green beans, banana pudding all . Cornbread was not great, just ok. Service was goodish. They also have Cheerwine which is a huge W in my book!!! read more

We recently moved to Columbus and were looking for good BBQ. Boy did we find it! This place is every bit as good as Nashville or Kansas City and the people are super friendly! This joint is a must go!! read more

Have been here twice. First time they said they never got my order. Second time I was missing several items. Food itself is average for the price, but when you add in the missing items, this place is OVERPRICED. GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! read more

All city Barbeque locations are great que.there are a bunch new que places opening up in ahia, cowtown bring them on good luck at all the business's. Brisket,ribs,pulled pork,chicken.the sides you can't beat.don't forget the city Barbeque in Newark what a great stop for lunch or dinner. read more

I love you ribs and fries so as much I love city barbecue I got you 5 stars.

The Judge Sampler was fit for two people who like to eat. Don't freak if the chicken is a bit pink, that's because it was smoked not baked. The Texas toast is almost as good as the cornbread. read more

This location has never gotten my take-out order correct. Every time I pick it up, something is missing. Today, 3 orders of fries and every sauce was left out. Tried calling and was on hold for at least 20 minutes. Not to mention that there was a very long hair in my mac and cheese. Take care y'all ;) read more