I must love it since I keep coming back. Normally I get a cannoli and sit by the window. There's…read morealways other pleasant customers inside as well happy to see children. It's quiet, on the smaller side.

I love that West Allis has so many cute spots for a classy meal or quick bite, and very much…read morefamily-owned businesses. Aggie's is a fun, hip bakery and cake shop that been around for a really long time. I was excited to finally try a "cake shop" although I didn't get cake on this trip, I would try another time! There's a great seating area, a nice display of all the baked good made fresh that morning, and an opportunity to grab a cup of coffee too. I had asked the person working behind the display what their most popular baked goods were and I was met with silence and then a "everything is good." I was slightly peeved by my interaction here and didn't let it fully deter my review of the baked goods themselves. I had the apple dumpling after seeing decent reviews about it on Yelp. The pastry wasn't at all flaky or buttery but rather hard and biscuit-like. Maybe I went in with the wrong expectation of what an apple dumpling was but it wasn't what I had wanted exactly. It leaned more sweet and glaze heavy than it did cinnamon spice. Overall, would recommend checking out Aggie's for their longstanding history in the Milwaukee area. It just wasn't for me!

Holy Moly, their cookies are fantastic! Picked up 3 of them on the way into town: Triple Choco…read moreChip, S'mores, and M&M. Where to start, or better yet, where to start eating???? The cookies are large so snacking on them is a dangerous road to go down, but oh, so worth it! I left then on a plate on my counter and as the day went on the cookies started to disappear. Luckily I had family to help me, but these are great cookies! No pictures of the whole cookies because they were started on before I could grab my camera. They will be gone by bedtime, I'm sure. These have flavor, unlike some others that are just plain dough with little flavor except for the chips or m&ms. Every bite is great!

This review is difficult and I want to come across with kindness. It's a WOW location, service is…read moredelightful. The bakery is so charming and cute. Everything looked amazing. I ordered two pastries that were breakfast style, and sadly when I left and went to eat them 5 min later realized they microwaved them. You can buy the MOST amazing pastry made with love and perfection and put it in the microwave and it's garbage. I am shocked a bakery would EVER do this. I took a nibble of each of the two and threw them away. Other pastries (cookie) were great. Seriously! What baker allows a microwave!?!? Stop doing this. Get an air fryer or just serve room temp and they would be great instead of in the garbage pail right outside your bakery. You've got a great place here ruined by 20 seconds of harm.

Today was my first time trying this place. I got there less than two hours after opening, and they…read morewere already almost sold out. There was one customer ahead of me, who seemed more concerned with making conversation with me and asking me what I would be ordering, rather than making his own decision. After it was finally my turn, I asked the employee if a specific product contained custard or pastry cream, and the answer somehow included telling me the history of the owner attending pastry school, a list of their locations and hours, and a tour of everything they carry. I was just looking to get in and out, and apparently this is not the place for that. I am used to big city bakeries, and I would say this is a small town bakery. I'm sure it's fine if you have time to kill, but I wasn't looking for that. I decided on a dark chocolate croissant. It was $6. The small part that had chocolate in it was WONDERFUL, but it was just about a dollar coin size of chocolate in a large croissant, so it was almost entirely just a plain croissant. For $6. I wanted to like this place, especially since there don't seem to be other bakeries in the area, but I likely will not be back.

First time at this location. Staff was not very friendly. It's your basic croissant variations. Not…read morea lot of filling in the ham and cheese or the fruit.

Last week, I got myself a Peach Cobbler sandwich cookie and it was one of the most delicious things…read moreI have ever eaten. It is a July special and I guarantee I will be back there before the end of the month to get AT LEAST one more. Maybe two. Or twelve.

Love this place! Every bakery good is phenomenal and always is so fresh. Cute little place in…read moreWauwatosa and all the employees I've interacted with are so friendly.

I have ordered my birthday cake from here for the past 4 years. My current favorite flavor is the…read morewhite raspberry SO GOOD. I like how they have options for how thick you want the icing. And I get a free small one on my birthday yay.

Ask for samples always :) they always have new flavors that I haven't tried because I usually on go…read morehere once a year for my bday. This years new flavor I got to try was strawberries and cream. I don't like frosting in general but will lick the plate for this cream cheese frosting!!

Absolutely fantastic!! I had one of the mini cherry pies. The crust was flaky and baked…read moreperfectly. The filling was just the right amount of tart and sweet. It was also the perfect consistency. I planned to only eat 1/2 of it and save the rest for tomorrow, well, I couldn't stop eating it! Jenny is so friendly and obviously loves what she does!

From the owner: Website: all-in-favor-say-pie.square.site…read more All in Favor, Say Pie is a locally owned and operated business located in Waukesha, WI. At All in Favor, Say Pie! I make custom order, fresh baked pies. Pies are not immediately available for pickup from my home. Please go to my website and place your order. I learned how to make pie crust from my Great Grandma Romundson. Throughout the years I have perfected my crust to a buttery flavored, flaky style crust. Often I hear that the crust is the best part of my pie. If you have a special occasion coming up and need a dessert that will make everyone want seconds, please call or send us a message today. Whether it is a birthday celebration, Baby shower, Bridal Shower, Mother's Day, Father's Day, Pi Day, or any holiday for that matter, pies make a great dessert to share with others. Place your order today for your next celebration! We look forward to serving you.

I try to get my bread there Sundays a few times a month! This past Sunday the Baker's Choice…read moresourdough was spinach artichoke and I have to say it was the best bread I have ever eaten !! I always get a loaf of reg sourdough of their Baker's Choice and I freeze 1/2 and it lasts me awhile but this will be gone . Highly recommend buying their bread, their savory scones are delicious as well and they are super friendly !! Go there!!

Crafted with care. This not a premade corporate monstrosity. Real food with real good coffeeread more

For being around 10:30 AM on a Monday morning they had good stream of customers patronizing…read more Friendly employees Chicken salad sandwich was a good size Cup of chili came with a roll Seating is available

Great donuts and beautiful cookies. Took the granddaughters and the staff was so friendly. Gave the…read morekids a little toy. Will be going back.