Cincy Sammy's deserves more hype! Where else can you get dessert, customized, and half the price of many desserts elsewhere! Pros: the GF cookie selection! Last time I was here, there was only one choice, but there was so many this time! First time ever having a GF red velvet cookie. Wish it had more flavor, but I am grateful for a GF cookie! Cons: Surprised there wasn't a non-dairy ice cream option! I'd stop here more often if there were. Also wish the sauce toppings were displayed differently. Cincy Sammy's is fun and affordable, give them a try! read more

Cincy Sammys - GF red velvet cookie, cherry amaretto ice cream, blackberry sauce - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

Stopped on the way home from dinner and grabbed dessert from this gem! This dog themed family friendly location was a perfect way to end the night. The melty gooeyness of the homemade cookie blended w the vanilla was beyond tasty! It may have been winter out but it warmed my heart. read more

Cincy Sammys - Chocolate chip skillet cookie w/vanilla ice cream and hot caramel. - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

The ice cream is amazing! The cookie and cream had large chunks of chocolate in it and the fudge really paired well. The cookies were solid. The service is awesome. Within minutes of ordering, a worker called and offered me options to replace what they were out of (throwing an extra cookie in as well without my knowledge). This was great, affordable, and definitely worth trying out. read more

Cincy Sammys - Sundae Chocolate Chip Cookie and Vanilla Ice Cream with peanut butter and rainbow sprinkles - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

See all

Fresh-baked cookies in unique rotating flavors, delicious hard-scooped ice cream, huge portions, and the friendliest owners and service. It really can't get much better than that! Check out their social media for the cookie flavors of the week. In addition, they have cookie pie, milkshakes, and occasional other treats like brownies and cinnamon rolls (insanely great)! Plenty of space inside to eat, or you can enjoy your treats outside on the patio tables after ordering from their walk-up window. read more

See all

It's a good thing I don't live here, because I would be eating these sammies constantly. I love everything about Cincy Sammies. The place is cute, the staff are nice, the ice cream is amazing, and the cookies are even better. I had a sundae with buckeye ice cream and a PB graham cracker chocolate chip cookie. Heaven. Its gonna be a mandatory stop the next time I visit family in OH. My only little nitpick is that the sundae was served on a wax paper-lined paper boat. I actually LOVE that they're using compostable dishes, but it was just hard to eat off the paper that kept sticking to it. An actual compostable bowl would be better. Or even just not bothering with the paper. read more

See all

Their cookies and ice cream are delicious. I've been here a couple times now and I'm obsessed with Gotcha Day!

The ice cream sandwich was amazing. The cookie was an all double chocolate chip cookie it was soft and chewy and their ice cream is very creamy. The service was quick and friendly. The ambiance was warm and friendly. read more

This is a cute, quaint little place to get your dessert soul happy. They provided chocolate chip and Oreo cookies. I had to purchase the double chocolate. They also sale ice cream. The cookies were moist and delicious. The icings were creamy and smooth. It's a great spot for the family, friends, or a simple date. Sundays are chill. read more

Cincy Sammys - Chocolate chip and Oreo cookies - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

Drove past and just happened to recognize the tiny baby sign and turned around immediately. There was a Yelp event here that I couldn't attend about a year ago. Glad I accidentally drove by, I'm rarely on this side of town. My husband got a chocolate chip cookie Sammy with vanilla ice cream and I got the pb&j cookie. This cookie literally stopped me in my tracks, it was mouthwatering good. The reason for the 4 stars is because the cookies are fresh and homemade. The ice cream was just ok but good enough to make my husband's sammy on point. My kids would love it here but we may just keep this to ourselves. read more

See all

Sweet deliciousness! This place is wonderful. The staff and owners are really kind and patient. The cookies are delicious, and the fact that you can choose between 2-3 options for gluten free that do not cost extra??? Amazing! The first sandwich I had was pumpkin spice cookies with half cinnamon and half coffee ice creams. That's correct, they let me split the flavors of ice cream! It was so so tasty! The location is great, the decor is cute, and the treats are delicious! This place is a definite must try! P.S. Don't forget to bring some quarters for the claw machine. The proceeds are given to a charity. I think the charity changes monthly, but I could be wrong about the timing. The kids had a blast! read more

Cincy Sammys - Sammies! - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

See all

So my goal in life is to find the best tasting cookies. I think I have found the winner. Cincy Sammys has the BEST tasting cookies I have ever had and I have had many from Crumbl, Panera bread, Whole Foods, Insomnia, Mrs. Field's etc you name it. I brought some to share with my kids & husband and they all thought they were the best tasting cookies. My husband said these cookies have just the right balance of sweetness, softness and flavors. I agree 100%! Love how they make them in small batches and their prices aren't outrageous. Also, their ice cream was yummy as well. Will be back even though it is a bit of a drive for me! read more

Cincy Sammys - Assortments of cookies. ALL were delicious! - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

See all

Wow - I attended the Mason Schools Second Grade social with my awesome boy last night and I had a GF confetti cookie from Cincy Sammie's. It was amazing! A little too big for me but I loved it so much that I finished it. I can't wait to come visit with the whole family! read more

Cute establishment and unique in the fact we have no place (or that I'm aware of) like it in Cincinnati, Cincy Sammys is a wonderful option for ice cream sandwiches if you certainly like cookies and ice cream! They have gluten free optional cookies, but unfortunately no dairy free ice cream option for those of us with a dairy allergy/sensitivity. That's the only thing I think would be great if they offered. Otherwise, the cookie and ice cream options are a delicious variety, and the customer service is friendly and accommodating. It's hard to spot initially because they do not have an overhead sign, but their sign is on their glass window on front. Just keep your eyes peeled! You don't want to pass them up! read more

See all

Cute little spot to hang out and have a tasty treat! Right across from the library, it makes a great little date with a kiddo - books and then over for a treat! Also, awesome place for a pre-dinner treat if there's a long wait at some of the popular restaurants just up the street! Or just a spot to tackle that cookie, buttercream, ice cream craving! read more

See all

I walked in and I was greeted with a big smile. The kids working were named Lorelei and Adam and they took great care of us, asking about our day and gave us recommendations as a first timer. We got sit at fun seating next to a weird looking piece of seaweed with a cowboy hat named patrick. My only complaint is that the claw machine took all my money. Even though it's for a great cause, I am now broke. I would come here again. read more

See all

The cookies are amazing and the ice cream is high quality. Recommend scraping some ice cream off for the end as the middle cookie will have squeezed out all the ice cream. Basic chocolate chip with vanilla is sooooo good. How fun to have a store dedicated to chip wheelies! Oh! And skip the chips and sprinkles, you don't need them read more

Whenever my family and I travel to Cincinnati, we always go here because of the delicious desserts and allergy friendly options. For ice cream sandwiches they have a bunch of cookies that are gluten-free. They also have all different kinds of desserts. But when we went, one of the workers even offered to go into the back and scoop the ice cream so that there was no cross-contamination. Overall, this is a 10 out of 10 place. I, 100% recommend. read more

The cookies and ice cream are SO good! The shop is cute. I can't wait to go back to try more!

Stopped into Cincy Sammy's for the first time on a chilly, rainy January Saturday afternoon. We had a chocolate chip cookie ($2.75) and a cinnamon roll ($5.00). Apparently they usually make the cinnamon rolls as advance orders, but they made them today for anyone to buy just because they felt like it. The cinnamon roll was exceptionally good. The chocolate chip cookie was very good and better than (and less expensive than) a Crumbl cookie. I look forward to visiting here again. read more

The cookies were yummy! The ice cream was okay. Very surprised no cones available for the ice cream but that's the plug of this place---only comes on a cookie, or with another dessert. Cute place to sit outside. read more

This was a fun after dinner stop but we probably should have just thrown caution to the wind and had a Sammy for dinner! The cookies are delicious as a stand-alone and the ice cream is equally amazing. I got the ice cream with cookies in it. Even the small Sammy was a lot of treat- I was too full to finish. Cute little set-up in the store with some games and cute art. It was busy when we were there but they had plenty of everything and we were served quickly and cheerfully. Get your cookie sandwich warmed! That's something special. read more

Yes yes and yes. I'll take it all! This new cookie spot in downtown Mason is fantastic. Seems locally owned and just opened summer 2022. The cookies are fresh, doughy, soft and absolutely delicious. The big stuffed cookie rotates and is a mandatory purchase. I didn't try the sandwiches yet but will definitely be back. Don't waste your time with the new Crumbl opening in Deerfield, just come here instead. Locally owned and higher quality. read more

Cincy Sammys - Classic chocolate chip stuffed with double chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

They have many varieties including gluten free. 4 kinds of GF cookies and about 8 different flavors of ice cream. Was really surprised by how delicious the cookie and the ice cream were! Love, love it! read more

Cookies and ice cream, what's not to like? It was delicious. Very friendly service - the staff was helpful in explaining the options as well. Very clean and cute inside! It was fun for a date night with my husband and we will be back with our kids who are jealous we went without them read more

Cincy Sammys - The Clark - Desserts Near Me - Mason, Ohio

I love their cookies and will definitely go back! The place is cute and it's a perfect little shop in the heart of Mason. The customer service is amazing, and I love supporting a small business! read more

Sooo decadent and delicious! And reasonably priced! The cookies were all fantastic. Owner was super nice and it's a great space! Highly recommend! read more

Very well nice decor and theme. Friendly staff. Arrived right after closing but they were more than happy to let my kids get a treat. Very appreciative of that. read more

Entire family loved it. This is a family owned business and love that only sell fresh. If you go here and your favorite cookie is sold out, don't leave or complain online. Please just pick a different cookie and support this family. All of their options are delicious. Can't wait to come back and bring a few tennis balls. read more

The sweets are delicious!! The service is amazing. Prices are low. Highly recommend!!

When there is a new cincy dessert place we have to check it out. Cookie sundae was great! Staff was smiling and patient. Check this place out! read more

Downtown Mason was in desperate need of a fabulous dessert place - and this place absolutely fills a need! The interior feels like the epitome of summer (a nice break from the upcoming Ohio winter ;) ). I came here with my boyfriend recently and we split an ice cream cookie sandwich and it was delicious! It very much reminds me of Insomnia Cookies, but they are tastier and local. Word of advice - these cookies are pretty big (especially the center filled cookies). It honestly can substitute a meal or be good to split with someone. Be sure to come down and support this new, local business! read more

The best ice cream sandwiches I've ever had. The key is the fresh cookies that sets Cincy Sammys apart!

I love CincySammys! I ordered cinnamon rolls and bengals cookies ahead of time. The cinnamon rolls and cookies were delicious. The cookies were a big hit at our watch party. My favorite part was seeing the whole family on Saturday morning during pickup. I will definitely be back. Please support this business!! read more

Excellent ice cream, excellent cookies - Great service and loved their personal touch with their pet pics! Hubby and I each got one ice cream and cookie sandwich but it is a LOT! Will definitely go again - I didn't see smaller cookie ice cream sandwiches on the menu - I could have missed - but I would definitely suggest smaller size cookies for kids and adults - who can't finish an entire cookie ice cream sandwich- first time in my life I left a cookie uneaten - soooo very rich, sooooo good. We would love to see this place make it! We support small local businesses- Can't say enough about the good quality and taste of their ingredients- Love LOVE their dog pics - I would like to see a frozen yogurt option if that is feasible - read more