Cancel

Open app

Search

CiCi's Cakery

4.9 (92 reviews)

CiCi's Cakery Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - CiCi's Cakery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

CiCi's Cakery did not disappoint. Everyone loved it, especially my daughter (it was her birthday) taste was spot on and cake was moist. My daughter said it was even better the next day (for reference no one in my house likes leftovers including sweets). Thank you again!!!

Barb G.

The best cupcakes in town! They are the most beautiful and also super delicious! Theresa was kind enough to fulfill my order within a short notice. My daughter and her classmates enjoyed the exquisite cupcakes on her 18th birthday in college on 4/28/2024.

Cake for my son's baptism. The flavor I chose was chocolate cake with salted caramel.
Candy B.

I found Cici's Cakery after desperately searching through Instagram for someone to make a cake for my son's baptism. The baker that I previously contacted just stopped communicating with me and left me hanging two weeks before the baptism date. Theresa was great to work with; she was professional and was extremely prompt in answering my emails. She was truly an answered prayer to this desperate momma! Please do not hesitate in having her create whatever cake you have in mind because she will execute it with perfection. Her cake was not only beautiful but sinfully delicious! I loved it and I was excited to share her info with my guests because they loved it too! I can't wait to try her other flavors! Thank you so so much Theresa!

Chocolate cake with cookies and cream filling
Mary S.

I bought a cake from Theresa to surprise my fiancé after closing on our first home. Working with Theresa was such a piece of cake I showed her an idea of what I wanted and my budget and she whipped up this amazing cake. It was so moist and delicious! Thank you for making my move extra special!!

Vanilla Beam Cupcake with Coconut Buttercream Icing
Kimberly P.

Everywhere we go I search for a good cupcake place. While CiCi's doesn't offer a storefront, if your looking for a quality cupcake in Bergen County, give this place a try. Her buttercream icing is so smooth and creamy. I was very impressed!! Great job Theresa!!

CiCi's Cakery

CiCi Cakery did a Barbie doll themed cake for my daughter's birthday. She actually created the cake around the Barbie doll itself. The cake was stunning! It was so delicious as well. Cici created cupcakes to match the cake in addition. Everyone at the birthday party was floored by the cake! Best cake ever ever!!!

Baby Shower Cake
Bianca B.

Ordered a second cake from Theresa for my daughter's first birthday and it was a hit! The cake turned out beautifully and was delicious. We ordered the funfetti with buttercream. We also ordered the red velvet cupcakes. Everyone loved them. Thanks again for making the process easy and delicious!

Earl Grey Tea cake!!  AMAZING!!!!
Tate M.

CiCi's Cakery is AMAZING!! This review is a long time coming and I CAN NOT believe I haven't written a review yet!! As I get ready for my Daughters 2nd birthday i Leo thinking of her cake last year and how it is ALL anyone could talk about (and not to brag but my daughters pretty cute.. yet the cake and her cupcAkes really stole the show!). The flavor is AMAZING!! My husband (who isn't even that big on sweets) was literally hiding cupcakes from the other party goers so that we would have leftovers for the next day!! Lol. Not o let were they delicious but they were beautiful!!! CiCi's Cakery was a pleasure to work with and was so accommodating when I contacted her last minute about cakes for my daughters birthday!! Now that my mouth is watering writing this... I'm definitely going to try to order 1-2 dozen cupcAkes while we celebrate her next birthday in quarantine! Lol

6" fondant/buttercream cake
Ping F.

So I'm the type of person who likes to plan ahead, especially if I know I'll be too busy later on. I contacted Theresa 2 months in advance (there's no such thing as too early) inquiring about baking a custom marvel/iron man cake. She quoted me several prices and options and was very quick in responding to my questions. I told her I would confirm the pick up date a month from the actual party since I was still in the planning process. Two months later she reached out to me to reconfirm everything. The waiter who brought out the cake was very impressed, as was everyone else at the table, especially the birthday boy. Ordered the blue velvet with Oreo buttercream. The fondant was thin and easy to cut into. The cake was moist yet springy. Not sweet at all which was a good balance since sometimes the cake itself is too sweet. I tasted a dash of salt that balanced out the buttercream. The buttercream also wasn't as sweet as I expected which was a plus! Surprisingly the fondant was edible! Most of the time I have to discard it since it's too hard. I'll keep CiCi's Cakery in mind for future cake orders.

Kristina N.

Contacted the owner after I searched yelp for custom cakes and saw their Instagram account. Communication was easy. I ordered a 9" green tea cake with black sesame buttercream frosting with floral design. No trouble for pick up and owner was friendly. Would order again for a special occasion! The cake was moist and everyone enjoyed it. I also ordered a similar style green tea cake with buttercream from a DIFFERENT vendor last year and it was much dryer so people did not enjoy it.

Hazelnut naked cake
Claire C.

We were extremely pleased with Theresa cake, her savoir faire is beautiful. The hazelnut cake was absolutely delicious and the decoration was absolutely outstanding. I had previously sent a picture of the cake I wanted to recreate and Theresa was wonderful and created it beautifully. She was also very responsive and answer all questions I had. I could not have asked for better!

Theresa was such a pleasure to work with. I told her my vision for the design and her cake exceeded my expectations. The guests were raving about how moist and flavorful the cake was. Oreo buttercream yum!! We also ordered cupcakes. They were so pretty that I almost didn't want to eat them. You have to try her black sesame buttercream. I can just eat it by itself!

Ariana K.

Theresa is an absolute genius when it comes to cake design!! She was very responsive, thoughtful, and creative when bringing our Christmas in July themed grinch cake to life. Would 1000% recommend!

Pandan cake with coconut buttercream

See all

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Thanks for your review, Anthony! Glad everyone liked the cake. :)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Wow! Thanks for the compliment! So glad you liked the cake!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Sw w.
3
70
30

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Thanks for your feedback! Glad you liked the cake! :)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Theresa C.

Theresa C.

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - CiCi's Cakery

Hi cede- can i consult with you for possible cake options?

Hello! Please email me at ciciscakerynj@gmail.com for all inquiries. Thank you!

Hi,CICI,Could you tell me how much is it? I like the purple cake,my favorite color and flavor(macha) Thank.

Pricing depends on the number of servings, and overall design. Please email me at ciciscakerybkny@gmail.com to inquire about specific pricing. Thanks!

Hi just curious if you are taking orders I saw at the bottom where you would be closed for the rest of 2018?

Hi- I am currently on maternity leave. Hope to start taking orders by January 2019, if not sooner!

Are there ready made cakes in the store?

I do not have a store front. And I do not have already made cakes available as I like to bake everything fresh for each customer.

View All 5 Questions

You might also consider

Black Magic Bakehouse

Black Magic Bakehouse

4.5(73 reviews)
1.4 km

I downed an ENTIRE cream-filled doughnut…read more Came to know of this place through a Yelp friend and, enchanted by the name, I started following them on social and always kept in mind to go visit when I could. I don't live close by to it, so it takes some planning. They're known for their sourdough donuts so I had to have one, even though I'm lactose intolerant. Ordered the orange-pistachio cream doughnut on Ohhh my yumness -- it was SO good. Not really sweet/ definitely not overly sweet, which is so elegant. Not everyone gets the sugar balance on point but I'm a huge fan of their flavor balance. Could really taste the orange OR pistachio, maybe a hint of the pistachio, but no complaints at all. Every bite was really very enjoyable What WERE super duper sweet though were the staff :). Also no complaints there :) The coffee was also really good, too! You know how sometimes a bakery can be really good at some items but their beverages leave much to be desired? Not the case here. Space is cute and small but not small? There is a small dining room in the back. The decor is also "just right" whimsical.

We showed up before opening with half a dozen people already waiting. All of the choices were good…read more Here's my ranking. 6.) Chocolate babka 5.) Biscotti 4.) Apple fritter 3.) Salted maple pecan Cinnie 2.) Cinnamon vanilla crueller 1.) Chocolate almond croissant I'm going to skip the sourdough loaf next time. There are about a dozen seats inside. We were lucky to grab a table.

Photos
Black Magic Bakehouse - Menu 3/24

Menu 3/24

Black Magic Bakehouse - Exterior

Exterior

Black Magic Bakehouse

See all

Baking Grace

Baking Grace

4.6(173 reviews)
4.9 km
•$$

My son ordered the chocolate silk cake for me for my birthday (Christmas Day) and it was amazing…read more The flavor, the texture the richness - all top notch! Only issue was that when he ordered it online, he requested it to say happy birthday but when he got home he checked it and it didn't have anything written on it. :( I guess he didn't think to ask/check. We will definitely be back!

Baking Grace is definitely one of the bakeries on top of my list whenever I need a cake, especially…read morefor birthdays. Their cakes are incredibly delicious, light, airy, moist, and full of flavor without being overly sweet. I've ordered both the Chocolate Silk and Cannoli cakes, and they've been a hit every single time. You can really tell they use high quality ingredients, and the balance of flavors is spot on. The staff is another big reason I keep coming back. Every time I've ordered a cake, they've been friendly, helpful, and incredibly accommodating, which makes the whole process easy and stress-free. While I've only ordered their cakes so far, they offer so many other items that I'm excited to try in due time. On top of everything, their prices are very reasonable for the quality you're getting. Highly recommend Baking Grace to anyone looking for a consistently amazing cake and great customer service.

Photos
Baking Grace - 2 tier custom cake, flowers added by customer.  Original picture is next... had to pull off the flowers and add my own.

2 tier custom cake, flowers added by customer. Original picture is next... had to pull off the flowers and add my own.

Baking Grace
Baking Grace - 7" carrot cake. Feeds 8-10 ppl

See all

7" carrot cake. Feeds 8-10 ppl

Sook Pastry - blueberry scone is very good

Sook Pastry

4.3(1k reviews)
1.4 km
•$$

I've been hearing about Sook for quite some time and finally had the chance to check it out. Sook…read moreis located on one of the side streets off East Ridgewood Avenue (walking distance). They also have a chocolate shop next door. When I walked inside of the bakery, I felt transported to a pastry shop in France. I visited on a Sunday afternoon and it was super busy. Service was quick and efficient. I ordered a latte and a scone. The scone was very delicious and fresh. My boyfriend ordered a frozen hot chocolate and a chocolate éclair. I tried a bit of the éclair and we both agreed that it was the star of the show. I normally am not a big éclair person but this one was so chocolatey and rich. It was filled with this creamy, fresh chocolate filling. I strongly dislike the store bought cream filling that they are usually piped with. We sat at one of the little tables on the sidewalk outside since the weather was nice. I will be back if I am in the area and in the mood for a sweet treat!

This place knows chocolate! Their hot chocolate is rich and flavorful…read more It was a line to the door on a Monday holiday afternoon. Small place with a couple of tables. We snagged one as people were getting up. I got a napoleon and another dessert that was chocolate mouse with Carmel and a biscuit cookie on the bottom. It was soo good. Really fluffy but also creamy and rich. Highly recommend this place if you love chocolate! I spent near $30 for a small hot chocolate, a cookie, pastry and mini cake. So it is expensive! But worth it once in a while. And they have a bathroom in the back!

Photos
Sook Pastry - Dining area

Dining area

Sook Pastry - The clover (10inch) so decadent!

The clover (10inch) so decadent!

Sook Pastry - Outside view

See all

Outside view

CiCi's Cakery - bakeries - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...