Absolutely amazing experience! The pizza was incredible--perfectly crispy crust, fresh toppings, and packed with flavor in every bite. You can really tell they use high-quality ingredients and put care into every pie. On top of that, the service was outstanding. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel genuinely welcomed from the moment we walked in. Everything came out quickly, and they went above and beyond to make sure we had a great time. read more

Delicious pizza. They definitely have the best pizza in allllll of lewiston auburn area. The guy working there was the best also. Very friendly. My new favorite spot for pizza read more

Owner is great! Works alone and was extremely accommodating for a request of 20 pizzas for a hockey team. Pizza was A+, all 60 people raved about it. Go to Cibo! read more

FINALLY!!!! We moved to Auburn a little over a year ago and have been trying to check this spot out since. Pizza is usually something we make at home, especially since moving up here. It's all Domino's, papa John's and house of pizzas with that weird dry frozen dough. So takeout pizza is completely random and last min for us. But I've learned that you have to plan ahead for this place, open til sell out, plus operated and owned by one dude, who may or may not be a close relative to Superman. We had my mom up for the weekend and were able to grab a couple pies from here for her birthday. My pickle obsessed 11yr old wanted their specialty pickle pizza, we compromised for a half pickle roni half cheese. The birthday girl (my mom) chose the mushroom Florentine, which was to die for! The garlic cream sauce tasted roasted and sweet, there was enough to keep the pizza moist but not soggy. The mushrooms were accompanied by sweet onion and spinach and the classics NY style crust was thin but still chewy. 1,000,000% worth the wait read more

Cibo - Mushroom Florentine - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

See all

We walked in and the food smelled beautiful. This pizza place is cute! and kind of scrappy! It is in the basement of a library and I think only one guy was working, taking orders and cooking pizzas? But we didn't have to wait long. We got a 16 inch pizza with garlic cream sauce, spinach, feta and kalamata olives. Something had a zing - I thought it was the olives, my sisters thought it was a the sauce. It was very good. Really enjoyed it. There was a bank of parking spots right to it. Everything was easy. Would go back! read more

Cibo - Cibo sign - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

See all

This was very good pizza. Nice thin crust and perfectly cooked. We will definitely be going back again. Also the service was great!

I'm a truck driver that been to all 48 states so I experienced a lot of different pizzas shops. I seen the reviews on this pizza shop called Cibo so I gave it a try one of the best decisions I made all week delicious thin crust pizza. read more

Cibo - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

See all

I have been searching literally for years for a decent pizza where I now live in CA- but Cibo's took me right back to my favorite childhood NY style pizza. Run- don't walk- to this single proprietor pizza spot located in auburn ME library- separate entrance. Even my other half- who is vegan- was raving about her vegan pizza. Neither of us is easy to please in the food department, but this place takes a grand prize - at a reasonable price. You can taste the pride in this pizza. read more

Cibo - Roasted Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

Hands down, my favorite pizza experience I've had in the Lewiston/Auburn area! Located right below the Auburn public library, it makes for a great lunch spot after story time with your littles or a morning of perusing books. Although the space is quite small and simple, the pizza (the reason for your visit) is the star. The options on the menu are fun and original and since it's a pizza joint, it's pretty fun that it's all they offer-- that's when you know it's good! The owner is super friendly and made our visit even better, from helping us decide on our pizza order to answering our questions! Keep in mind, if looking to order takeout, the owner mentioned that they are usually very busy during a dinner rush (and sell out most nights) so if you're interested in ordering, it's best to do online rather than by calling. I'm not sure how ordering in the restaurant works at those busy times but I do know we had no issues during lunch. The pizzas also came out quickly which was a huge bonus considering we had our two small children with us. Not to keep this review going however it is important to mention that pizza crust is probably my favorite part of the pizza and the crust here is phenomenal! I love how the owner really took time to hone in his recipes and is keeping the restaurant aspect of the business low-key so that he can maintain the quality of a delicious tasting pie! Its a great pizza-parlor in the L/A area and I'm here for it! read more

Cibo - Dill Pickle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

See all

There are barely any words except the best pizza in the area. The location also, rocks love that it is small businesses that support each other. Cibo always promotes other small eatery's and I love it!! read more

Best pizza around, Hands down This is the only place we go for pizza now. They will even make a 1/2 baked, not cut pizza, so you can finish baking it @ home! The crust is perfect, the sauce is great & the presentation of the pizza looks like it was made for a food magazine Do yourself a favor & check this spot out, you will return again & again because it's that goooood! read more

First time in Maine looking for a good pizza place. Found Cibo New York style. Dill pickle pizza was amazing. Will definitely come back if we end up back here in Lewiston, ME. read more

This is the best pizza I've had in a long time. The crust us light & crunchy. We had the pepperoni pie and sausage & fennel. So good! The man working was very friendly. We sat inside and enjoyed our pizza. It's located at the bottom of a beautiful library. read more

See all

Great pizza place with a few tables if you want to eat in. The garlic bread and marina was great! read more

Cibo - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

Located in a narrow space beneath the library is super cool! Old book deposit door remains just inside the entryway. I arrived about 6:30, which is only 30 minutes before they close and the friendly guy behind the counter happily took my order. Seems odd to me they would close at 19:00, but hey this is Auburn, Maine. I ordered the sausage and fennel and walked it back to my hotel. The crust is a perfect New York style, crispy on the bottom; but, flexible, tasty and not at all tough or too chewy as most places are churning out. You can tell they have put effort into this dough recipe. There was a good ratio of sausage, sauce and cheese. The sausage was finely ground and I would prefer to have had some bigger chunks. I wasn't certain if they would add some fresh fennel, or fennel seeds. Honestly, I'm not detecting much in the way of fennel taste, sight or aroma. Regardless, I'd stop back in a heartbeat next time I'm in Auburn! read more

Cibo - Halfway through the sausage and fennel - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

Nothing fancy, just FANTASTIC pizza! Made with a lot of care. Crust was nice and crisp, right thickness. Sauce was rich and complex. This is world-class pizza! Must stop if you go through Auburn. read more

We moved here from Brooklyn back in 2019, and among the things we miss the most up here in Maine is exceptional pizza. We have worked our way through a handful of joints in L/A and it's been hit or miss. Tonight we decided to give Cibo a shot, and so glad we did--and wondering what took us so long. We got a cheese (in my opinion, this is the gold standard by which every pizza joint should be measured), and constructed our own with roni, caramelized onion and fennel (ooh mama!), and roasted mushrooms (earthy and rich). They are legit in claiming that they're cranking out NY-style pies--thinner crust, overall larger pie size (16"), and the tangy cheese and tomato sauce alchemy. Extra bonus points from me for offering vegan and vege options, including house made roni (tried it--yum!), and chik un (will try next time!). We will definitely return to Cibo and see what else they got. Excited to support this local business and talented pizza maker! read more

Woooooooo this fire ass vegan pizza in Auburn, Maine?!? We got the plant based buffalo chicken and supreme pizzas. And we were all extremely impressed!!! The crust is delightful, the size of the pizza was incredible and the toppings were delicious. I'm a big sauce person and I really enjoyed the red sauce AND especially the drizzled red bell pepper sauce! Everything about it was fantastic, would highly recommend. read more

Cibo - two pizzas in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

I took my wife and two young kids here before a hockey game this past weekend. The pizza was awesome (better than any of my Portland area favorites) and the owner was a really great guy. Will be back for sure next time we're in Lewiston/Auburn. I wish he'd open one in my town. read more

We saw this place had a ton of 5 star reviews (Yelp, google, fb) so we had to try it out! Probably the best pizza we've had in the Lewiston /Auburn area. They have great options for vegans and meat eaters alike. Pickle pizza is a must try!! This is def our go to pizza place from now on. read more

In the mood for pizza around lunch and stopped in here. Just the super friendly owner/chef working and just pizza on the menu. We had a really delicious Greek pizza! Fresh, good quality ingredients, just excellent crust, piping hot right out of the oven. Seriously excellent pizza here!! read more

Pickle Pizza! Need I say more! Dreams do come true! Awesome. Very friendly owner too. read more

Cibo - Pickle pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, Maine

Absolutely amazing pizza! And offering a vegan option is great. Will definitely be ordering many more in the future.

This is the best NY style pizza in the central Maine area! Every one we have ordered has been amazing. My Dad grew up in Brooklyn and I pick up and deliver pizza to him from Cibo's., he lives an hour away. Just order "unsliced, half-baked". Pre heat your oven and pizza stone or tray to 500 degrees and pop the pizza in to finish it off. Just watch it so you know your timing. His oven takes 5-6 minutes, and it's perfect, every time. Ordering is done online, you can order for right away, or schedule for when you want it. I order in the morning, when they aren't open yet, select the time my husband will be picking it up after work, and I get a confirmation email when they open & when it's ready. So easy! My husband just walks in and picks it up! Check business hours online. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

This is my wife's and I's absolute favorite pizza place in all of Maine. The customer service is always top notch and we honestly haven't been able to find better pizza. My wife has a dairy allergy and they are always so kind and accommodating to her allergy. Their dairy free options are amazingly delicious and they have actual dairy free and vegan options on their menu not just a dairy cheese substitute option. They also offer yummy cheesy bread that is dairy free and we haven't been able to find that anywhere else. We honestly stopped searching for a different place because for us, this is the best place there is. No need to keep looking! read more

Great pizza. Would definitely have again. Order was for an Italian sub pizza. It wasn't made right ( got ham and nothing else lol) as I think the order was confused but it was delicious none the less. Crust great, sauce and cheese combo great. Will order again but will flip the lid before leaving lol. read more

Great home baked breads, brioche, and sub rolls, nice selection of sandwiches including a great roasted veggie with a selection of house made condiments. A variety of daily soup specials are available, all homemade, as are the meatballs. Have a breakfast burrito- they're awesome! read more

The best pizza, lots of vegan/vegetarian options!!

Wooooah mama!! So I love pickles. Dill pickles. But on a pizza? The Pickle!? So right on it is beyond worthy. The crust also nails it. The whole cibo experience is worth the stop. Can't stop eating it. Halfway gone in minutes. Do yourself a favor and put this on your pizzas of Maine -- check that, New England -- tour. Hat is off to Cibo! read more

Wow, just wow!. Looks like these guys actually know how to make and bake pizza. Maine is really not a place for pizza because no one, until now knew how to make a pizza. They mostly used conveyor belt ovens which are really for pita bread and other things. Those ovens aren't meant for pizza. Pizza is not suppose to be cooked in a pan either!. 90% of "pizza" in Maine is a joke. Ok now that I'm done bitchin' and moanin' I have to say Cibo is different. These guys are either from out of state or have been taught correctly how to make real pizza. After trying Cibo, every other pizza shop in Maine is just a joke!. Keep doing what you're doing!. read more

A friend of mine had posted a picture of "The Gatsby" a few months ago and I had to have it. It was even better than I could have imagined. I have never left here disappointed, every item I have gotten has been delicious and freshly made to order and the bread - YUM! The gentleman running this place is also very personable and pleasant. I need to come here more! read more

Delicious vegan pizza and super friendly service. They also offer plant based options for their other dishes like quesadillas and cheesy bread. One of my favorite spots! read more

Everything is homemade and fresh! Even the buns and rolls are made in house and are AMAZING! From The Gatsby to the Meatball Sub everything is delicious! Vegetarian and vegan options too! read more