Spectacular job on my son's birthday cake! Chocolate Carousel made my wedding cake 13 years ago, so when it came time to celebrate my son's birthday, there was no question where I was going. They earned my trust years ago, and they exceeded my expectations once again. From my very first phone call, Rylee was an absolute pleasure to work with. She made the entire process effortless, patiently answered all of my questions, and put my mind at ease every step of the way. I came in with an AI-generated image of the cake I envisioned. We all know AI images don't always translate perfectly into a real cake, but Chocolate Carousel brought that vision to life better than I could have imagined. The attention to detail was incredible, and the finished cake looked amazingly close to the original design. The cake wasn't just beautiful--it was absolutely delicious! We chose chocolate and vanilla cake with cannoli cream, and it was one of the freshest cakes we've ever had. Every single slice disappeared before the party was over! Thank you to Rylee and the talented team at Chocolate Carousel for creating such a stunning and delicious centerpiece for my son's 36th birthday. You helped make his celebration unforgettable, and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend you to anyone looking for a truly special custom cake. read more

See all

They may do a great job on custom cakes, but I would not go in and just order a cake or a cupcake. I paid 4.25 for a very stale cupcake with sickeningly sweet icing. The staff was also less than welcoming. read more

We used Chocolate Carousel for our wedding cake and added brownie bites, and they were incredible! The cake was absolutely stunning and tasted even better. Our guests haven't stopped raving about the cake quality and how delicious everything was. read more

I recently ordered a cake from this bake shop for my daughter's bridal shower, and I just wanted to share how impressed I was with the entire experience. The cake was absolutely beautiful--crafted with such attention to detail that it almost felt too pretty to cut into. The design perfectly matched what I had envisioned, and it truly stood out as the centerpiece of the celebration. Beyond its appearance, the taste was just as incredible. Every bite was fresh, moist, and full of flavor without being overly sweet. It was clear that high-quality ingredients and real care went into making it. My guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious it was, and several asked where it came from, even the venue asked. Thank you to Elizabeth Sheridan for putting so much effort and creativity into your work. It made the occasion even more special, and I will definitely be coming back (and recommending you to others)! read more

I ordered a cake from here and loved it. I actually have been driving by for years and had no idea it was there. They also have good cake pops. They also have whole bake shop with chocolates and other things. The cake was one of the best in the area. Would come back! read more

Came here to pick up a Fourth of July birthday cake and they DID NOT DISAPPOINT! The shop itself has that nostalgic east coast bakery feel with all sorts of cookies and candies on display. The gal helping us was kind and welcoming. The extra large cake was tasty and looked just like the American flag-- strawberries, while cream and all. Will def be back next year for a replica! read more

See all

There was hardly any cake and what was there was very stale. They were so dry it was very disappointing. They were hollowed out and filled with sickening sweet icing. We tried to eat just the cake part but it wasn't even worth it. We bought 4. Paid $17 dollars and threw them all away. This was our favorite bakery during Covid. Something has changed. We will not be back read more

Chocolate Carousel - Hollowed out cupcakes. All buttercream icing. - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

We went on March 4th to get some some cake pops for some kid's friends and a couple of stuffed cupcakes for ourselves. The carrot cake SC was great, however the chocolate peanut butter SC was stale. So disappointing. We were afraid to ask our friends if the cake pops were stale as well. Hopefully not. So maybe this place is better know for made to order cakes and the items in the showcase are hit or miss for freshness? read more

I recently tried their biscotti! So good! They did not taste like they were baked on an old, not quite clean pan where multiple flavors could be discerned. Instead, each different flavor was unique and clearly distinguishable! read more

Ordered a cake for pick up on a specific day in the afternoon. Was informed that day that the cake wouldn't be complete until the next morning... rendering the cake almost useless to me. Don't say you can fulfill orders that you can't and give customers more of a heads up if you're going to be late. read more

Five stars every time! From custom birthday cakes, to their homemade chocolates, we are always pleased with our desserts! They go above and beyond for theme parties! read more

See all

This is exactly what I asked for and more. It was absolutely delicious and the attention to detail is so on point. I couldn't be happier on how my twins birthday cake came out. Highly highly recommend The Chocolate Carousel! read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

I have used them in the passed excellent !!!! Will use them again and again... delicious cakes and will make anything you want they copied an invitation for me .... read more

Got our wedding cake here on a recommendation, and the anniversary package. Each year they recreate a small version of our wedding cake so we can celebrate with fresh cake instead of the frozen tradition version. I ALWAYS end up picking up more than just our cake, and order here whenever I need something special. Just know to order a week or more out, especially close to holidays as they do get incredibly busy, and for very good reason read more

Boy oh boy I made a big mistake stopping into the Chocolate Carousel and you lousy Yelpers with all of your kind words only made it worse. See here's the deal, My sense of direction is awful. So whenever I'm at work and need to go to the post office I enter the Chocolate Carousel in my gps because it's in the same plaza as the post office. If you ever try entering a USPS in a gps you will surely be more confused, at least I am. So I dropped my package at the post office. I sat in my car a minute and looked up to see CC staring at me. I swear I heard "Steve, come inside". But before I jumped to anything I said let me see what my always faithful Yelpers have to say ab this joint. Hmmmm, now after reading a bit I'm intrigued. I'll go in and take a little looksy, if nothing sparks my interest I'll leave never to return. Well I walked in and to my immediate left was a case full of cupcakes. They weren't huge nor were they tiny. They were a good size. I peaked around a bit more, some cookies and pastries and cakes. Typical bakery stuff. Now let me get back to those cupcakes. A worker came over and offered assistance. I asked which cupcake she recommends. She said the cannoli, but I already had my eye on the tri-color. I asked ab the tri-color. She said if you like the Tri-color cookies it's the same and even has apricot jam inside. SOLD! Apricot Jam and topped with chocolate ganache. Yeah I'll take one for the road. $5 was a bit steep but if it is good there no price too high. So I get it in my car, took a bite and woofed the whole thing in embarrassment. I failed to take pics or truly enjoy and savor the moment. I was disgusted with myself and often consider taking a spin back to the "post office". read more

My fiancé and I were supposed to get married at Clark's Landing on April 17th. Unfortunately, due to COVID, we were unable to have our big celebration. However, I ordered a carrot cake (our favorite from our tasting) from Chocolate Carousel along with 2 buttercream donuts. We were able to pick it up curbside. Everything was amazing! It made the day still feel special while we cut our cake over a zoom call with family. Also, at our cake tasting, everything was so delicious. We were able to pick different flavors for each tier which made us incredibly happy because there's no way we could pick just one. We cannot wait until next year when we get our big cake on our rescheduled wedding day! read more

See all

Used to be good - now not so much last few cakes were stale altho custom ordered and way too much icing. Tried to get a 2 tier birthday cake was quoted almost 500.00 keeping in mind it was basic and a birthday not a wedding realize prices have gone up however felt it was totally way over priced and received honestly 3 other places ranging from 180-250 so thinking I was correct in my thinking. Makes me sad as we did used to like this place years ago things have changed A Lot - including where we currently get our cakes. read more

Chocolate Carousel made our wedding cake. It was white cake with strawberry and cannoli filling. The best wedding cake we have ever tried. Everyone loved the cake, some of our guest were going to the other tables to take the cannoli cake slices. They also offered to make our anniversary cake, it came out perfect. read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

Our first anniversary cake! A replica of our wedding cake: white cake with cannoli cream. Just as delicious as our wedding night read more

See all

Absolutely fantastic bakery -- was the preferred bakery for my wedding venue and price included a cake. I was leary since wedding cakes are notorious for being dry. Boy was I wrong!!! Hubby and I live out of state so we were not able to do a tasting or pick up a tasting box. Elizabeth (?) walled us through amazing combos over the phone. We ultimately ended up with a 3 tier cake with two different flavors: carrot cake with cream cheese filling and choc/vanilla cake with cannoli filling. Everyone raved about the cake. We CANNOT wait until our 1 yr wedding anniversary to go back for our complimentary anni cake. The cake was flavorful, moist, and super delicious. They also have tons of great seasonal flavors read more

Chocolate Carousel - a wedding cake with a silhouette of a man lifting a barbell - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

How do you even describe something so amazing a taste unique unlike no other? The service was quick and the staff was friendly, They answered any question I had, being about allergies, substitutions, and cross contamination so I wouldn't get sick, the lighting and atmosphere weren't bad either. read more

I have ordered cakes here and they have been fine but customer service is terrible. And we did return to order a cake for a party a week away but were told a week is not enough time - we should have done a month in advance even though website says 1 week. And no apology- just made it seem like we should have known better in a rather rude way. I won't return read more

Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. We loved our tasting samples and had great fun. We give our highest recommendation to the Chocolate Carousel. read more

Chocolate Carousel - Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. Thank you! - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

I purchased a box of chocolates for a gift. Save your money go buy Whitman! Presentation was awful, candy thrown in a box all different ways , no paper in box , no gift wrap , no ribbon just a small box with tasteless old candy thrown in it ! I had heard they were good but my disappointment tells me never again. Most embarrassing gift ever gave ! They need to stick to cake forget going there for tasteless old chocolates ! read more

Just had a surprise 50th for my SO and Chocolate Carousel made 2 cakes for me, one for him & one for our friend who shares the same bday. They both came out great! All I did was tell them my "theme" & they knocked it out of the park! I didn't even see them until it was time to serve & was blown away. And the taste?? Everyone...and I mean everyone...thought they were delicious! Could not recommend them enough! read more

Chocolate Carousel - White cake with chocolate mousse - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

See all

Best cupcakes and ice cream cupcakes are delicious too. Really nothing you get is yummy. Worth the drive

On a trip to see my young nieces I wanted to bring them something special. What kids (especially little girls) don't like fancy cookies? The girls loved their cookies. Of course the initial reason I was scoping out bakeries was for a customized birthday cake for my hubs upcoming birthday. After visiting several local bakeries I decided on the Chocolate Carousel. I did some research on Yelp & CC was held in pretty tall regard. Not to mention the convenient location. It was evident why as soon as I walked in the door. Firstly, the place smells fantastic! In looking around, there were beautiful decorated cookies, cakes & candies in the varied display areas. The whole set up is very visually appealing. They also have a few tables inside to sit & chow down. After speaking with the young lady at the counter I ordered my custom cake. There were a ton of choices & I decided on a layer cake, 1 layer chocolate & 1 yellow. It was filled with banana & strawberries in a vanilla pudding mix. They were able to transpose an edible clip art picture, which I emailed them, onto the cake for a fee if $15. When I picked up the cake it was exactly what I wanted; they did a great job! My husband LOVED his cake! I was concerned the buttercream frosting would make it too sweet but I had no reason to be. It was delicious with just the right amount of sweetness. I highly recommend this bakery. They had more reasonable prices for their cakes & the up charges than some of the other bakeries I visited. The only reason this not a 5 Star review is service seems a bit slow. The phone was ringing pretty consistently both times I stopped in & the girl at the counter was doing double duty. Of course now that I've tasted their goods, I absolutely get it. read more

See all

We got our wedding cake from Chocolate Carousel, referred by Windows on the Water at Frogbridge, and boy we did NOT regret it! Our custom cake was visually stunning with fresh flowers to match our centerpieces, delicious, light and airy, and we received many many compliments! We can't wait to eat some on our anniversary next year. From start (contactless tasting session) to finish (wedding night), they were a pleasure to work with! read more

Chocolate Carousel - a wedding cake with flowers on top - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

We were very disappointed with our wedding cake. It was not executed to our selection. Butter cream was replaced for white chocolate icing, yellow cake was substituted for white cake, and our filling was supposed to be strawberries with chocolate mousse, instead a scant amount of strawberry was present with no chocolate mousse. Lisa the owner declined to speak with us but instead sent an email stating the cake was created as ordered. We also sent a photo to show Lisa the errors. She refused to acknowledge her bakery's errors and was not apologetic or offered any reimbursement. She is unprofessional and I WOULD NOT recommend this bakery for your wedding cake. read more

We couldn't be happier with how gorgeous our wedding cake was. It was even more beautiful than we ever imagined and it tasted great. Thank you so much and we hope to work together again in the future! Kyle & Noel read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

See all

Horrible Customer Service. Asked my fiance to pick up a wedding cake sample box I had ordered to do a tasting & staff never greeted him, talked among themselves about their personal lives for over 5 minutes while he stood there and when a woman walked in tried to serve her before him! I can't believe how terrible some people are at their jobs! My fiance is over 6 foot black man, no one can say they didn't see him waiting to be served. Absolutely uncalled for. No excuses for this kind of behavior. Obviously they won't be getting our business & I hope people consider another bakery also. read more

The birthday cake I ordered from here was delicious and looked beautiful! We couldn't believe how decently priced it was looks, taste, and size-wise! The staff is very friendly and they take time to answer all of your questions. The bakery is also very pretty and clean. All of their treats look amazing to the eye. I will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

See all

I first discovered Chocolate Carousel through my wedding venue and I ordered a cake from them for my rehearsal dinner as well. After tasting that first cake, my life has changed forever. I now look for any excuse to order a cake from Chocolate Carousel. My rehearsal dinner cake was definitely the most beautiful, decorated like a tree trunk which fit so perfectly with my rustic theme. Not only did it look amazing but it tasted even better (lemon cake with vanilla custard). I have never seen so many people eat cake at an event before. All of my friends are now obsessed with this bakery as well. My wedding cake was decorated for my beach theme and contained almond cake with raspberry mousse filling (also insanely delicious). Since those events I have ordered additional cakes for my friend's engagement party cake and another friend's 30th birthday (for those events I literally bought the cakes in Wall and transported them to NYC!) I cannot wait for the next event to get another cake for. This bakery is simply the best!! read more

See all

I was so incredibly happy with my wedding cake... 2 years later, and people still talk about it! I explained my theme... Bright, bold citrus colors... And they made the most beautiful cake (see photo). We chose a vanilla cake with vanilla mousse and blueberry filling. It was to die for. We had a lot of fun at the tasting- playing around with all the different flavor combinations. All around A+ read more

Chocolate Carousel - 2 years later, and I'm still obsessed with my wedding cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

Can I give 10 stars? We got our wedding cake from this bakery and not only did they create our vision, they exceeded my expectations ten times over. Additionally, their wedding cake was THE BEST. All of our guests said it was the BEST wedding cake they have ever had and that is the ultimate compliment. I am sooo happy we chose this bakery. Do not hesitate to order thru them. I additionally ordered a small cake for our rehearsal dinner and gave them a color palette. They made it beautifully and the color palette was so beautiful. It was a surprise anniversary cake to be presented at my rehearsal dinner for my Matron of honor, whose wedding anni was the same day as our dinner. They literally matched the cake colors to her wedding bouquet colors like they read my mind!! People are still talking about how good the cake was!!! It was PERFECTION! Our wedding was 9-19 at the Mill :) thank you! - the Casteels read more

Chocolate Carousel - The custom anniversary cake we ordered. Matched their wedding bouquet colors SO PERFECTLY! Thank you! A wonderful surprise for the couple! - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

This is the best place for all of your Bakery needs ! I needed a perfect cake for my son and his new wife. I went in and explained what I needed and they bent over backwards to make it happen ! I have been a customer here since the day they opened read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

I ordered a birthday cake for my mother-in-law from Chocolate Carousel and we couldn't have been happier. They executed an adorable "beachy" design, complete with chocolate seashells, and dropped the cake off for us, all for $50 for a 10in cake. AND it was absolutely delicious. We went with the vanilla cake and chocolate mouse, it was SO GOOD. We will definitely order from them again. read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a beach themed wedding cake and it was beyond beautiful and delicious!!! The staff was very helpful. Couldn't be happier!

I ordered 2 dozen of their assorted filled cupcakes for my son's hockey team who were playing down the road from the shop. I ordered online from Maryland, sight unseen, on a Sunday morning an hour before I needed them. I called first to see if they could possibly fill my order and they said they had the cupcakes available. My son and his teammates said the cupcakes were the best they've ever had. read more

Chocolate Carousel made our wedding cake and did our cake pop favors and everything was fantastic. My now husband and I had no idea what we wanted for our cake but the staff was so helpful in making our cake and offered great suggestions. They helped us include everything we wanted and made such a beautiful design. Our tasting was so fun and easy and the staff was super knowledgeable and helpful. We also had them for the bridal shower and rehearsal dinner and again never disappointed. All three cakes were perfectly designed and not a single piece was left. We could not be more thankful! read more

Chocolate Carousel - Bakeries Near Me - Wall, New Jersey