Cancel

Open app

Search

Chisholm Lake Store

3.9 (14 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Chisholm Lake Store Photos

Business Info

CHISHOLM LAKE STORE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Chisholm Lake Store

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Dining room

Let's just get the best thing out there first. The ribeye steak was delicious (even though it was overcooked). Flavor was excellent. That was the highlight of the evening. Of the three steaks our party ordered (at medium rare, medium and medium well), every one of them were cooked to well done. WELL DONE!! . No pink whatsoever in any of them, not even the one ordered medium RARE. For a place that "specializes" in steaks, you would expect them to know how to properly prepare a steak to order. Per another comment, apparently one of the cooks said (when someone complained about their steaks being overcooked), said "that's just the way they cook them, medium well is no pink." Huh???? Moving on ... The "salad bar" was a bowl of lettuce, some cherry tomatoes, chunks of cucumber, shredded cheese, dehydrated bacon bits, croutons and your choice of two dressings (ranch and thousand island). The most basic of salad items, pretty bare bones. If you don't like either of those two dressings - too bad. If they (the dressings) had been homemade and delicious, it would've really helped, but they definitely were not. Oh, and your salad bowl is a small styrofoam bowl. Salad "bar" was lackluster. Rolls were Kings Hawaiian rolls (or a generic version of those). They're okay. Homemade yeast rolls would've been more appropriate, at this price point. Baked potato was a good size and cooked thoroughly. Sour cream available in a little package on salad bar. Butter? No butter. Liquid Parkay was on the table. . Liquid vegetable oil!!! . At these prices, real butter should definitely have been available. A bit pricey, considering you're not served on "real" dishes and you get store bought bread and 2 salad dressings. About the ambiance ... well, if you like "super overcrowded, jam packed together like sardines, sitting at a long school cafeteria type table with other people" type dining, you'll love it. If loud and chaotic is your thing, you'll enjoy it. If you don't mind being jostled and bumped by people trying to get past (because of the aforementioned overcrowding), you'll be fine. Apparently, this loud, chaotic scene is considered (by the owners and obviously by some regulars) to be "part of the charm" of the place. Just not our thing. While we enjoyed our food (pretty much), all we could think of was "let's hurry and finish and get out of this madhouse!" But apparently, lots of people don't mind all that, because they were extremely busy and are obviously this busy pretty much every weekend. Doing such a brisk business, you'd think they would consider adding on to the small space. It really would help the customer experience. They're only open two days a week (Friday and Saturday evenings), so there's no option of going during a "less busy time." All the staff we encountered were very friendly and helpful. That was nice. We may go back someday, for the steak, but would try to get there a little earlier or later than we did today, and hope it would not be so jam packed. P.S. one more thing - you walk in the door and are automatically in line to go to the counter and order there, then go try to find somewhere to sit (a real trick, when there are people standing everywhere and ALL of the empty tables have "Reserved" signs on them). They should absolutely not take reservations when they've got people standing all around looking for a place to sit down. Should be first come, first serve. Just my view, as a guest standing there looking at empty tables and unable to sit down.

a menu for the restaurant

See all

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

The food and service was amazing, especially the fillet! The ambiance is very relaxed and cozy.

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Bubba H.

Bubba H.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jan G.
0
48
18

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lee W.
0
30
1

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 1

5 years ago

I had the ribeye steak and it was delicious!! A little pricey at $30 a steak but it was good. Located at the end of a long curvy road!!

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 1

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Chisholm Lake Store

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

McAdoo's - The Rib-eye Dinner

McAdoo's

4.3(32 reviews)
17.1 mi
•$$

Local Bar with Massive Rib-eyes…read more Mcadoo's is an experience, and one you should explore if you are in the Blytheville area. I have, over the years, wanted to go and check the place out, but a combination of not being able to find it and not having enough time has always kept me from a visit. During my last visit to Blytheville, a business colleague and I decided to check this infamous establishment out and have a business dinner, beers, and rib-eyes. Mcadoo's is located in central Blytheville, across from the fire station, and it is in a simple metal shack, which can make it hard to find. There are no signs on the building, just the name written on the entrance door. Inside, you find a fully functioning bar with pool tables and plenty of tables to sit at. Mcadoo's has an old-school vibe as the inside is lit up by old-school red lights. Like bars of old, you can smoke inside; keep this in mind if you are a non-smoker or have allergies to smoke. Mcadoo's has a fully stocked bar, but it's mostly known for its rib-eye steaks. Our server came to our table and informed us that they had no apps and that our only options were rib-eye with salad, baked potato, and toast, or rib-eye with toast, as nothing else was available on the menu. The rib-eyes took about twenty minutes to arrive, and they were massive and cooked to perfection. The salad and the baked potato were fresh and okay, but the focus was on the steak. The steaks were juicy and tender, and they were also very affordable. The allure of Mcadoo's is the experience, the full bar and the affordable rib-eyes. It is also a favourite place for locals to hang out. Overall, a good experience and a great rib-eye dinner.

Three sisters read the Yelp reviews and received wonderful hospitality and great food here. We…read morerecommend the steak salad and the bologna sandwich. Each was delicious. Miss Barbara is a most delightful hostess and owner. Looking for local color? This is the place. The entrance does not face the road so you will have to look for the building that looks like a body shop, but the spacious interior has a big bar and plenty of seating with several pool tables. Clearly this is a neighborhood hangout.

Photos
McAdoo's - The Bar

The Bar

McAdoo's - The Entrance

The Entrance

McAdoo's - The Bar

See all

The Bar

Home Plate Bar & Grill - Ribeye & Fried Okra

Home Plate Bar & Grill

4.0(15 reviews)
27.0 mi

Worst restaurant experience I've had in a long time…read more I don't know how you manage to ruin a frozen burger patty and frozen chicken tenders, but Home Plate found a way. The burger was so bad I couldn't get past two bites, and I managed exactly two fries before giving up. They also got my order -- a simple one -- wrong. When the waitress asked how everything was, I told her honestly: awful. Her response was to remind me I'd still be paying for it, then hit me with "better luck next time." Hey, Home Plate. There won't be a next time!

We were visiting from out of town on a Sunday afternoon and ended up here to eat…read more The interior of the place is cute and cozy with a diner vibe. This is a seat yourself kind of place. The bar menu looked interesting but we didn't order any adult beverages this time. The service was friendly and since most of the tables were full, I think the speed at which our food came out was acceptable. However, my food wasn't hot but my husband's food was piping hot. I took a star off because their 2 pc catfish meal is really only one filet cut in half. So if you're hungry, or if you're expecting full filets, you may want to consider the 4 pc meal. The prices are very reasonable. I didn't get any names of those who waited on us but the older gentlemen exchanged a few dad jokes with my husband which was fun. The restaurant and the women's restroom were clean. I would recommend this place and will certainly check them out again the next time we're in the area.

Photos
Home Plate Bar & Grill - The food was excellent and the waitress were friendly and truck drivers get a 10% discount

The food was excellent and the waitress were friendly and truck drivers get a 10% discount

Home Plate Bar & Grill - Philly cheese steak cut from real beef steak

Philly cheese steak cut from real beef steak

Home Plate Bar & Grill

See all

Mae's Grill - fried chicken breast, cornbread, collard greens, and black eyed peas ($13.50)

Mae's Grill

4.0(9 reviews)
17.4 mi

A friend and I recently ate lunch here together. It's a great soul food restaurant, located in the…read moretype of neighborhood that I'm only comfortable frequenting during the daylight hours. On this day of the week (Wednesday), the restaurant featured their fried chicken. A local resident had strongly and repeatedly recommended Mae's food. My friend and I both ordered the fried chicken. I'm sure glad that I did! It was perfectly breaded, seasoned, and cooked. We were given our choice of cut, and we both chose chicken breasts. It was nicely-sized and fresh. I would definitely recommend it, and I would order it again. For side items, the collard greens, sweet potatoes, and blackeye(d) peas were all delicious and properly prepared. I ate every last bit, especially since the portion sizes were a bit too small. I would suppose that tiny portions dramatically reduce food waste. The square of cornbread was quite welcomed. I had also heard that Mae's cooks up some delicious pork chops (on Thursdays) and meatloaf (some Fridays). I look forward to trying those as well. The building doesn't have central air conditioning, but rather a series of window units. During the height of summer, it can get uncomfortably hot inside the restaurant, so they do a lot of take out business. If you want to eat inside, be sure to pick a cool/cloudy day. Also, the parking situation is a bit chaotic, with no designated spaces marked out. It's kind of a free-for-all. The safest bet is to backup into an open spot, just for better visibility when you leave. I made the mistake of parking head-in. It took me forever to back out. The street that runs in front of the restaurant is full of fast and careless drivers. Be sure to take some cash with you, because this place doesn't accept any credit or debit cards.

Went here for lunch with a part time co worker. Chicken is delicious. Service is friendly. The…read moresides could be bigger. Ambiance is ok. Location is not close to any other restaurants

Photos
Mae's Grill - Partial view of interior dining area

Partial view of interior dining area

Mae's Grill - Fried chicken breast, sweet potatoes, cornbread, collard greens, and blackeye(d) peas

Fried chicken breast, sweet potatoes, cornbread, collard greens, and blackeye(d) peas

Mae's Grill - Mae's Grill!!

See all

Mae's Grill!!

Chisholm Lake Store - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...