I was going to dine in but decided to do take out as I found this place is a little more kid friendly than I was expecting. I got a pint of reasonably priced beer while I waited on my order. So I ordered a 9" pepperoni and mushroom pizza and some breaded deep fried mushrooms to go. My order came out within 15 minutes. The pizza was pretty good. The crust was thin and crispy. The sauce was pretty decent. There were a fair amount of toppings although they weren't spread out very evenly. The price was about right ($12) but the breaded mushrooms were a little steep ($8) for the few smallish pieces I got. The staff was friendly and they do have a reasonably priced pizza buffet that would definitely entice hungry families on a budget. Chet and Matt's is a 4 star kind of place. read more

See all

Stopped by for dinner with friends. We wanted to try a local pizza place avoiding chain restaurants and something children would eat. Place appeared busy attracting tourists in the area. There also appeared to be a salad bar that we did not get a chance to try. We ordered two orders of breadsticks with cheese for the table, cheese pizza, meat lovers pizza, redskin potato pizza along with fried cauliflower. I wished the waitress would have offered some advice when we ordered that much food. The breadsticks with cheese were essentially a ticker cheese pizza and we were completely full when the actual cheese pizza arrived. The red skin pizza was good as it was something new I don't typically see around. The best part of the whole meal was the fried cauliflower which I wish we had a bigger portion as we were trying to split with the table. I'm not sure if I would come back here. The food was fine but nothing to rave over other than the fried cauliflower that I feel we didn't get enough of. read more

See all

We were traveling and decided to check out the lunch buffet. The pizzas were great. There were four to pick from, salad, breadsticks, and dessert pizza. Our server Alexis was attentive. It was quiet and not crowded at lunchtime. I would go back. read more

This was recommended to us by a local and I'm so glad we listened. We went twice as the pizza was so fresh and flavorful. Cheese, pepperoni and bbq chicken pizza. All were a hit. Ingredients were fresh and the pizza was hot and oozing with flavor. Would highly recommend. And they deliver! read more

A very nice local sports themed pizza establishment. This was our first visit here while in town for a long weekend at Cedar Point. Usually we eat our meals in the park, or at Hotel Breakers, but tonight we wanted to try something different. This is a fun place! Sports memorabilia on all the walls, and a full size goal post and scoreboard outside. We ordered some appetizers: jalapeño poppers and chicken wings. For our pizza we ordered a large Veggie Heaven pizza. All the food was very good. The pizza had a generous amount of toppings. Service was friendly and our food was ready quickly. Our large pizza, appetizers, and beers cost less than $50. Not bad for a meal for four. read more

See all

We enjoy Chet & Matt's Pizza. They have a fresh, tasty salad and pizza buffet in the evenings. The servers are great, we enjoy visiting with Alexis. Recommended! read more

We ordered from this pizza place while staying at Kalahari, and overall it was a great experience! They delivered everything right to the lobby, which was super convenient. We tried the 7-inch roasted redskin potato pizza, the 7-inch cheese with mushroom and pepperoni, and a 6-piece garlic Parmesan wing order. The redskin potato pizza was definitely our favorite -- so much flavor and something really unique. The wings were also amazing, especially the garlic parm sauce... absolutely delicious! The cheese, mushroom, and pepperoni pizza wasn't our favorite, but everything else more than made up for it. This place really shines with its specialty pizzas and wings. We'd definitely order from them again! read more

I read a bunch of recommendations to order from here if you're staying at Great Wolf Lodge. Best decision ever!! Sooooooo delicious!!!! When ordering online for delivery it specifically states that you need to meet them in the lobby. They were right on time and very friendly. read more

Chet & Matt's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

The pizza was really good! Even the gluten free! The delivery driver was accommodating and helpful in communicating since we were at Kalahari. read more

Please give Chet and Matt's pizza a try. It is by far the tastiest, freshest, and most satisfying treat in Sandusky! we have sampled the others and they are in the minor leagues in comparison. Our favorite is the 16 inch thin crust Pirate's Special. read more

Well first time there last time there basically, their pizza was far from normal, wouldn't even put out cheese, every time you picked up a piece thinking it was cheese it was far from it, even if it was cheese still probably wouldn't eat it because the cheese and sauce tasted artificial, their service was slow it took 10 minutes to pay the check we had to ask for, the Waiter check us out and had to use a colleges money for the change, we will not be coming back. read more

Great pizza. Poor website. Can not order on line. Put your address in and then what .. nothing.

Amazing! Made reservations for a group of 23 about 5 days in advance. Response to my email was quick and efficient as was making the reservation. Our party arrived on time and seated immediately. We were in a semi private room of three tables of eight. They offered a pizza buffet for both kids and adults, at a very affordable price. This is a great idea to move along large groups and takes off a lot of pressure for the waitresses. :) You could also order off the menu, of course. The pizza was delicious as well as the salad bar. My husband also ordered hot barbecue wings which were delicious. If you have a group and are in town for any sort of sports event... This place definitely knows how to do it. The only thing I would recommend is some sort of signage above the pizzas on the buffet because it was a guessing game as to what you were choosing bc all the pizzas looked the same. Would definitely return and recommend! read more

Chet & Matt's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

There were several people working in the dining area but there was hardly any service - one cup of drink & you fend for yourself only one of our four people had a refill after they asked for it. The food was average tasting- generous size cheese bread - the size of the jumbo wings was good - the flavor was average. Sports memorabilia decor is fitting for the area and the restaurant plenty of seating. read more

SUNDAY BRUNCH BUFFET IS A NO GO ! We have been to Chet & Matt's quite a few times and really enjoy their specialty line of pizzas :-) However, I would urge you to stay away from their Sunday brunch buffet. Pricing is $14.99pp and does not include a drink. The breakfast portion was just so so, the salad bar portion had a nice selection, but the pizza portion was awful! There were only two or three pizzas available at a time and they sat there until they were dry and not chosen for quite some time. We asked if fresh pizzas could brought out and were told there is only room on the buffet for a few pizzas at a time. This is understandable, however the pizzas being provided should remain fresh, with a nice selection. Will never go the buffet route again. Our bill was almost $40.00 for two people for the buffet and two sodas. Waste of our hard earned $. read more

Delivery requested to hotel. They called me and were at wrong hotel. They called again and asked for room number. I gave the correct address and room number when I placed my order. They delivered food to hotel (sandwich, pizza & salad) to hotel without any plates or silverware. Delivery driver was very unprofessional and unpleasant. read more

We're total tourists to this area but we were hungry for pizza and saw this place had solid reviews. We were greeted on entry and given a place to sit at the bar and look over the menu. The waitress was friendly and asked where we were from and such, was able to recommend which size pizza to order to split, and got us ice water while we waited for our pizza to cook. It took about 20 minutes. We got it to-go to take back to our hotel room. There were a good number of specialty pizzas to choose from and we liked the flavor of ours. The crispiness of the crust made it extra good. I thought the paintings inside the restaurant were really cool. Someone worked hard to make it unique and special, not like all the pizza chains. read more

See all

Brought a huge crew. One check is required for groups of 15+. Friendly staff and quick service. Pizza was delicious!

The people were nice. The pizza was alright, but that's the best i can say. There werent enough people in there during lunch time on a saturday to keep fresh pizzas coming. I had high expectations but it was mid at best. read more

We called ahead for a large group. They stated the could accommodate us IF we all got the buffet. We arrived and they said they had a "drink station" set up for us, as they had a server call off. "Go ahead and drink whatever, we just figured we'd make it easier on everyone." ...seemed very nice. It was downhill from there. The "buffet" was one or 2 pizzas at a time (which was not enough for the rest of the customers eating the buffet, let alone our group.) As soon as they brought pizza out, it was gone. (Remember, we called as soon as they opened to give them a heads up.) THEN, they insisted we pay in 1 transaction. 40 people--$800!!!!!! They charged everyone for drinks, even though most drank water...and they set up the "drink station," making it seem like a courtesy...and a random up charge, making it over $19/person. I'm not sure anyone left "full," more just tired of attacking the buffet like rats to get a slice of pizza. read more

Food was very good! Wings were awesome!!! Waitress was nice. And it's kid friendly too, took our 3 kids !

Pizza slices of many different pies is pretty much the way of it here as the best way to get a piece of the pie here is to come for the buffet! So I've been here twice one time my friend and I just ordered our own pie and I must say it was definitely decent but nothing amazing as I just wasn't really into the crust as it just didn't leave a I gotta come back here vibe to it just like the rest of the pie. So my friend and I ordered a pepperoni sausage pie with some banana peppers on it was decent and definitely good for the time being but nothing out of the ordinary to be like that was amazing so I'm sure that's why it took me soo long to come back here again. This time around I just felt like having a few different slices of pizza and remembering that they had a pizza buffet here I was like let's give them one more chance and today was it. The buffet had the basics and a few other combinations like a mac&cheese one and your standard Hawaiian pie as well as a salad bar and an assortment of chicken wings all for the taking. Here again I just felt like the pies were average the variety was nice but the pizza was just ok to me as were the wings. If you are going to visit here check their website first as they have a few different coupons for a few different things so it will definitely save you a few bucks! Overall it's all about the buffet here as you get a variety that way and it's just what you'd expect it to be if I were to come back here it would only be for this as it wasn't too pricey and if I want a slice of a few different ones then a buffet is the way to go! read more

See all

What happened to this pizza?! Clearly have changed the recipe and it's gone from one of the best pies around to no better than a $1 slice pie. The ride home I could tell the pizza didn't have the normal smell and then the taste was truly bad. read more

Chet & Matt's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

I have celiac disease and Chet & Matt's was AMAZING! To start, their staff was so friendly and helpful when I called to order. We ordered a large gluten free pizza, a small gluten free pizza, and a cinnamon stick pizza and I was in heaven. I have not had cinnamon sticks in probably 15 years and these are amazing. The pizza was delicious too. I highly recommend Chet & Matt's Pizza, if you do not, you're missing out. Thank you Matt & Chet's Pizza for doing such a great job! read more

See all

Service was Great and on Point! Great Atmosphere! Food was really good and Hot!! Would definitely eat here again!!

While staying at Great Wolf Lodge, we did a search to see what pizza place in the area had the best reviews. Chet and Matt's looked like a good choice, and we were pretty pleased. We had to meet the driver in front of the hotel, and he was professional and polite, even calling to let us know when he was about to pull into the hotel. The large cheese pizza we ordered was good and I also liked the apple dessert pizza. However, none of liked the cheese dipping sauce for the bread sticks, so those went to waste. It was extremely bland. Also worth noting, this pizza is extremely acid reflux inducing. Even my teen son, who has never had acid reflux before, got it so badly that he almost got sick. read more

Good buffet. Kept fresh pizza rolling out. Good service. Nice atmosphere with lots of local sports memorabilia. read more

Ordered pizza, for take out, said ready in 15, when showed up 20 min said the order failed to print out. Asked if I could wait another 15. Came back in 15 and waited another 5 min. Asked if there was anything they would do and they took $5 off. No thank you nothing! Very disappointed in the service here! Won't be coming back read more

Called my order in and it was ready in exactly 20 minutes. We picked up the pizza in the drive through. Very efficient service and very friendly. Pizza was piping hot! Brought it back to our hotel just a few minutes away. Pizza stay hot! The pizza was fantastic! Great ingredients! Nice chewy crust!! A must have when in the area!! read more

I've been eating their pizza for at least 40 years. My number one favorite...up until the last year or so. How have they changed their pizza? What did they do? It's a little greasier; they cook it too long, and it's on the verge of being burnt; they always had the best onion pizza. You could see the white cheese, and tons of sweet onion. NOT ANYMORE! What...did you change everything? The ovens? The cheese? The onions? "If it ain't broke don't fix it"!!!!! I'm upset! read more

Hands down best pizza in Sandusky. Every year I come into town for ColossalCon we specifically get Chet & Matt's pizza delivered to the Kalahari. The delivery is flawless and the pizza is seriously delicious. Definitely try it out if you're looking for pizza! read more

Chet & Matt's Pizza - Ultimate Cheese Please - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

Spent the day at Cedar Point Amusement Park and this place was highly recommended by my in laws for an afterwards dinner. So glad we went here! They do have a buffet table but it was closed by the time we got here. We literally just missed it. But it's ok- we ended up ordering from the menu and everything was delicious! Now, I'm from NYC and I know what good pizza is - and they definitely had some good tasting pizza! I had a little bit of two worlds- the gluten free cheese pizza world -due to my kids, and the regular bbq chicken pizza world haha I love that they have gluten free options - the gluten free pizza was just as good as my regular bbq pizza. Also had jalopeno poppers for an appetizer, also really good! They were the kind with the cream cheese inside- yum! The inside of this place was really big, plenty of seating and we didn't have to wait or anything. Also, our waitress was aces. Kept coming over to check on us and making sure we were all set. Had a large group of people too. All in all- nice place!! Everyone left with full bellies. Oh! And don't forget about the insanely affordable prices! Doesn't leave a dent in the wallet. read more

See all

The key to enjoying Chet & Matt's is knowing what you're getting. You don't come here expecting hand-tossed bubbly Neapolitan pizzas or extra-thick Detroit or Chicago-style deep dish. Fitting a small town, the place specializes in a standard crust with generous layers of cheese and a flavorful pizza sauce. I had never had a pizza buffet before but was delightfully surprised. The kitchen was great at pumping out a steady supply of pizzas of all varieties which let you try a BUNCH of different flavors. I wasn't expecting a pizza place in a small town to put out imaginative pizzas like Mac n cheese or cherry pie but they surprising worked and, in retrospect, were very fitting for the Midwest palate. The workhorse of this place is the pizza sauce which is perfectly-balanced between tangy, sweet, and savory with only a mild herbiness which is what makes it so flexible. I unashamedly added ladlefuls to my plate and dipped all my pizzas in this crack sauce :D The crust is thick enough to support the toppings but neither crispy or doughy, it just gets the job done. Overall I enjoyed my meal at Chet & Matt's. The high-school sports theme gives the place a lot of character and the $9 buffet option really can't be beat considering the quality creative pies they fill it with. I can see why this place is a local favorite and would definitely give it a try for your next pizza fix. read more

This is a nice family oriented sports bar. It was difficult for us to make it in during the pizza buffet's limited hours but we finally made it and it was pretty good. There wasn't a ton of pizza out but they did replace them as fast as people were eating them. Nice little salad bar also. They had a dessert pizza that was of the cinnamon variety and a Tupperware container of rice crispy treats. It is a clean well run restaurant. read more

Buffet is so busin Everything is chill I love sports Great pizza Good nice service I must try again 10/9 read more

Chet & Matt's Pizza - Rice crispy - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Our soccer team was in town for a tournament and we contacted Chet and Matt's Pizza to arrange for our team dinner after the last game. We spoke with Chet and everyone was pleasant and made the dinner a great experience for everyone! They were ready for our group on time and had pizzas ready for us. Definitely recommend, and it's always good to support good local businesses like this one! read more

Fabulous food. We do delivery when staying at Kalahari or Great Wolf Lodge. It is a requirement of staying at Waterpark for us to get Chet &Matt's. Pizza is cut in strips and just is fantastic. Chicken Fingers and fries are good too. We tried the Spaghetti Meatball pizza and will try it again. Thank you for delivering to Sands in back of Kalahari! read more

We ordered the pepperoni and bacon pizza and it was wonderful! The perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Can't wait to come back!

Didn't take pictures but ordered three different pizza and all were great. Fresh, good pizza, will definitely be back.

We were at Great Wolf Lodge, and on our way home, we stopped for lunch. The children wanted pizza. We stopped here. The cheese bread and pizza were excellent. One of our pizzas was gluten-free, and it was one of the best we have had. Courtney was our server, and she was great. Refilled our drinks automatically. If we're ever in the area again we will be eating here. read more