Great atmosphere, great staff, food was delicious(build your own burger night). We went for a…read moreBuffalo Sabres game and the staff ensured we had a great seat and we couldn't have had a better time, except for maybe a Buffalo win.

I stopped in at Rosco's last Sunday to catch my team's game and grab lunch. Their website claims…read morethey show every NFL game, and this was true. I found a table near a tv where my game was showing and asked if I could sit there. The server offered any table in that area, then offered to change any of the tvs in that area to my game. (This doesn't happen at BWWs.or Primantis.) My server, Wes I think, was friendly and attentive. He kept my drink full, but didn't hover or interrupt me watching my game. I ordered the candied bacon BLT with the fresh cut fries. The sandwich was delicious, a perfect BLT. (Although I got it with regular mayo, and the spicy mayo on the side.) The fries were hot and crispy, but a tiny bit too salty. However, they were perfect with ketchup. I also ordered a piece of pumpkin pie with whipped cream. It was pretty good, but I'm pretty sure it was from Sam's Club. This was my first visit, but I will definitely back again during the football season to try their Mac and cheese and burgers.

intro: i heard about this place from a friend who gave rave reviews. the way he boasted about…read moretheir cheesesteak being the best he has ever had in erie, pa, led me to go check it out for myself. i am a born and raised erieite, however i lived in philadelphia for 15+ years and have enjoyed some of the best philly cheesesteak's ever. rising action: i had to go see for myself if it actually lived up to the hype. i finally got around to asses this philly cheesesteak phenomenon that had hit erie, pa. i went and ordered my cheesesteak set at the bar and proceeded to evaluate it for myself. that first bite was like a time machine that threw me back to those 15+ years when i lived in philadelphia. i stood up and asked, who made this. i then said, this had to be made by a philadelphian!! the chef came out of the kitchen and i gave him a standing ovation!! the cheesesteak received 10's across the board from me. conclusion: the cheesesteak was made with the right steak (cooked to perfection), the right cheese (melted into the steak, not sitting on top), the peppers and onions (blended throughout the steak, not sitting on top), and last but not least, the perfect bun (soft and wrapped around the steak absorbing all the flavors, not just holding the ingredients but embracing them)!! f.y.i., the bun is just as important as the steak and is shipped in right from philadelphia!! recommendation: all who rated any cheesesteak better than philly on the rocks need to go taste theirs. i guarantee you after that, they will hold the #1 spot in this category!! i demand they be moved there now!!

If you want, an authentic Philly cheesesteak and other stuff from that part of Pennsylvania go…read morehere. whatever bread they use was fantastic. I don't know if they had a problem with her phone system, but I tried calling to place an order and could not get through so we drove down and it took almost an hour to get our food. If they could speed that process up, that would be great. It was worth the wait.

Visited this place on my way to Niagara Falls stopped in Erie for the night. Had the shrimp tacos…read moreand a beer both were delicious and reasonably priced. The waitress was pleasant and tended the bar great. They have an excellent selection of beers to go. Definitely recommend stopping if in the area.

9/15/2025 Ate List:…read moreTurkey Rachel - 5.7 Public House over the years has changed a lot. Near it's opening and when I lived locally. This spot was bumping. Food was amazing and would be THE spot in the area to go. Lunch, Dinner, it wouldn't matter - there would be a wait. With every visit over the last decade or so, my experience continues to decline as the food and service has suffered with time. What once was a staple meal has become a poor iteration of what once was. Bread is obnoxiously thick. The flavors on the ingredients feel off. It's disappointing. Still feel like there's a chance this spot recovers in time but with their expansions - this location has suffered.

This review would have been a 5/5 if large wet wipes or cloth napkins would have been available…read moreduring dinner for all the sticky fingers. The paper towel roll was cumbersome. First, it is not our first time at Underdog. We found it several years ago at its old location. We were between hangry, famished, and slightly dehydrated when arrived. Seaglass hunting works up an appetite. The smoked deviled eggs were delicious. The huge fried provolone were outstanding. As someone who drinks unsweetened ice tea daily, it was terrible. My (picky eater) dinner date had concerns about the BBQ sauce selection. No worries BBQ sauce came to the table in a caddy to pick your own sauce. She had selected the pulled pork mac & cheese. I had the ribs with cornbread, cornbread (no baked beans for me), and coleslaw. The coleslaw would have been better with oil & vinegar. The meat just fell off the bones. We remembered the cornbread as being good ... warm with honey butter OH MY! We brought some back to the hotel. The live performance from Shari Dixon was nice addition to dinner. These Piitsburghers will be back!

I want to preface by saying that I got the food to go. But the actual bbq was very very mid. coming…read morefrom someone that grew up in the south and spent the majority of my life there. Just very bland. The sides were absolutely amazing and the desert. The banana pudding delicious. The critique to the banana pudding is I wish there was more banana slices.

We had the beef dip. Mine was on gluten free bun. It was tender and tasted good but it all was…read morepretty cold except for the au jus. The waitress was friendly and provided us with fresh HOT fries. That helped a lot. It is pretty dark in there but convenient. We would eat there again.

We drove from Niagara Falls NY to see the Parade of Sails in Erie, and booked the hotel just 57.4…read morefeet away. After enjoying the Parade of Sail, we returned to the hotel, BUT stopped in for a bite. I cannot remember any time I eaten Broccoli Alfredo, and that was while on several aircraft carriers, steaming there and here, in San Francisco's famed North Beach, and many other international eateries, including Italia! Seriously, I was shocked of the very creamy and tasty cheese sauce, and I've eaten this in NapoIi, Italia, and even there it wasn't as tasty! I was very impressed, and very much enjoying it! Thanks much for the tasty memories, and GO Navy always!!! PS: If you have your mil ID with you, you can ask for, and get a military/vet discount too!

Was there with a party of 11 on Saturday night. Food was fantastic. Drinks were good as well. I…read moregot my bill and it was higher than i expected, but i didn't question it. Wanted to leave a cash tip as i normally do. Didn't realize until after i had left my cash tip that my bill might have included automatic gratuity as we had a large party. The next morning i was thinking, oh no, i tipped double. Not until i checked my bank account did i realize that they had backed off the automatic gratuity. Much appreciated honesty in service. Not easy to find in todays world. Thank you!

!!!WINGS WINGS WINGS!! I don't know much about their other…read morefood, but these were perhaps some of the best wings I have ever had. And what a selection of sauces and styles. The pizza balls were also tasty! Great beer selection, as well. And they have pitchers! Very good. Definitely returning.

I highly recommend it! I went here with friends and WILL be going back…read more The food was FANTASTIC, the portions were quite large and the prices were very reasonable for the amount of food received. Our server, Jenna, was super nice and attentive.

I don't know where to begin but they robbed me for sum fried pickles orderd them and when my sister…read moreJulie came to Pick them up they told her they had nothing like the bartender took em orderd delivery again Nov 17 th today the same thing after the manager telling me he couldn't replace my pickles orderd again because he said he would discount them and orderd the same order which was the cheddar bacon burger told them burn it repeatedly burn it and it come out like the picture walked back because they said they would deliver but after the 45 minute wait I decided to walk to bigbar when I got there the bartender I asked him for a drink for my troubles he said no so I bought him a beer but after leaveing there I received 3 phone calls from different orders from different peoples they need to get it to together and stop worrying about homeless people coming to ask for food

In response to Milen D's recent review of Firestones(which I witnessed)…read more I honestly can't decide what's more embarrassing: your experience at the restaurant or the fact that you thought this review was worth posting. You apparently walked in expecting the entire establishment to revolve around your very specific demands, got disappointed, called someone a "clown," accused them of lying, and then produced this barely decipherable masterpiece of nonsense. The staff didn't fail you--you failed to understand where you were, what they offered, and apparently how restaurants work. And judging by the grammar and coherence of this review, I'm not sure you were in any condition to be evaluating anyone else's performance. Being unhappy with a meal is one thing. Throwing a tantrum because a restaurant didn't conform to whatever bizarre expectations you had in your head is another. Do everyone a favor next time: stay home, lower your expectations, and let the adults enjoy their dinner without having to witness another episode of The World's Most Confused Customer. The restaurant got one bad review. You got permanently immortalized as the person who wrote it. I'd say one of those is considerably harder to recover from.

I was in Erie for a conference and wanted to go to a local restaurant that had great reviews…read more I enjoyed the staff and seeing the Pirates game on the TV. The menu wasn't deep but I like that because you go with what you're good making and avoid decision paralysis. I had a pepperoni pizza and a draft sour beer. Both were good and I'd probably get them again. Definitely a good place to get some eats and a beer.