We've been here a few times now and we're never disappointed. This weekends lunch was especially great. The waitstaff was so helpful and friendly, and the electronic menus are actually kind of fun I did notice the prices were a bit higher than my last visit, but the portions were generous--we happily brought home plenty of leftovers. Overall, a very enjoyable experience and we'll definitely be back! read more

The pizza was extremely underwhelming, idk if it's the brooklyn in me but i've had better dollar slices. The meatball was ice cold as soon as it arrived to the table and the "ricotta" on it tasted like cream cheese. The water tastes like refrigerator. Don't dine here! read more

Perhaps one of worse dining experiences ever! Clearly a/c was broke while they blamed it on sun coming through windows. Service beyond slow.... And prices outrageous. read more

Very fun and busy place. Food was very delicious and fresh. The service was fast and friendly. The place is super busy and packed. They don't have a lot of seating for couples of 2, much more of a group setting. read more

See all

Dined here again for a friend's birthday, but for dinner this time. Was not as pleased this time around though. The reservation was at 6:30, though we were promptly seated upon our early arrival around 6:15. 4/6 people were early, but we were still waiting on the remaining 2. At 6:40 both the waiter and what I presume to be the manager come to the table to tell us they have an 8:30 reservation at the table we were at. 10 minutes into our expected reservation seemed a little soon to already be getting rushed, especially with nearly 2 hours until the next table. We put in our orders at this time as we waited for the others to arrive. Food took a bit to come, but it was busy so not a problem. We did have to put in a reminder about drinks as well after 15+ minutes after ordering another round. The waiter then tried taking the menus before the other arrived and when we mentioned they were almost there he asked if they planned on eating...well yeah. We were again reminded of their 8:30 reservation at our table. Once the others arrived they were barely seated before being pressed for their orders. They did turn their meals around very quickly at least. The waiter took a bit to come back for dessert orders despite their constant reminder of having another upcoming reservation, but we managed to get our orders in with only a minor disgruntled look from the waiter. A few minutes before 8:30 we were promptly shooed from our table after having our meals packed up and paying the bill, with the final notice of their other upcoming reservation. We took our conversation outside where we chatted for a bit before the manager came out and offered us room by the bar. Nice gesture, but maybe try that while kicking us out of our table, not 20 minutes after. On the bright side the food was still good. Though I still needed more spice in my spicy rigatoni. read more

Chatterbox - Pasta Al Cugine - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

What a great place!! The ambiance is beautiful, the staff is amazing and the food is top notch!! Took the girls there for lunch on Christmas break and it did not disappoint. Every dish at our table was great. Our server (Mario) was excellent. So happy we chose here. read more

Chatterbox - Chicken cutlet with escarole And beans - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Found a roach in one of the first dishes ordered. Disgusted and walked out. There is no excuse for not having the highest sanitation.

The owner/staff are racist. I overheard the manager disgustingly tell the waitress "let me guess, she's black" when the waitress was talking about a tip from a table from a WHITE patron. The food was mediocre and the bartender was not friendly. If you are black/latinx please do not support this business and take your money where it is deserved. read more

Great food and service! Friendly wait staff. Nothing like getting your own iPad menu. lol. My first but fun. Great apps!

Three of went to lunch here the service was great and our waiter was very friendly and cheerful. We decided to have 3 appetizers and share and then order more if needed. Our waiter said he thought it would be plenty. We started with the Buona Serra Pizza, Mozzarella, vodka sauce, pesto and marinara topped with dollops of ricotta. It was delicious, the combination sauces had a party on your taste buds. Then we had the Bacon wrapped Shrimp, 5 Jumbo shrimp wrapped in bacon and topped with a roasted garlic, amaretto sauce, we asked for 6 shrimp and it was not a problem. The shrimp were definitely jumbo and the sauce was very tasty. Two of us thought the shrimp were a little tough but one of our party thought they were perfect. We then ordered Nonna's meatballs, 4 Homemade meatballs smothered in ricotta and topped in Nonna's homemade tomato sauce with a sprinkle of parmigiano-reggiano cheese. They were delicious perfect texture and flavor. The amount of food was plenty we even took 2 meatballs home. No one felt like a cocktail so we all had tea and were brought a separate pot of tea each. A very enjoyable place for lunch. We were to busy talking and eating and didn't take pictures but everything was plated beautifully just like the pictures on the menu. I've been there before and will be going back. read more

Extremely well served. Waiters are considerate and on deck. Service 100. Good food and fun vibes. Parking lot in front of res! read more

Chatterbox - They got brunch - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

What a good dining experience from start to finish. We were happy to hear they were open for lunch on Monday. I called to inquiry if we could order from the dinner menu and was told yes. They offer a lunch menu but but we were interested in entrees. The restaurant has a pretty design with a big bar and lots of tables with comfortable backed chairs. The tables are spaced apart well and there is a lot of light inside. They have huge windows that let in a lot of light. The staff was friendly and our waiter Joseph was pleasant following up with us throughout the meal. We started with cocktails. A Bloody Mary for my husband and a S'mores martini for me. Both were good and served in nice large appropriate styled stemware. Love a martini in a traditional Martini glass which they use. Shared the Burrata appetizers with sliced tomatoes, a couple small pieces of prosciutto, roasted mixed color peppers over one piece of crostini and a balsamic glaze. It was good but didn't deliver as well as the drinks and both of our entrees. Let me tell you the breaded cutlets for the Chicken Parm ala Vodka were fried to perfection. Tasty, moist with two huge cutlets including a side of pasta. It was so good that going forward all Chicken Parm dishes will be held up to this standard. I was able to choose penne as my pasta side although spaghetti, rigatoni was also available. The side of pasta was a meal in itself. I took home half my meal and all the pasta which made for another delightful dinner the following day. My husband opted for the chicken marsala served with a mushroom risotto. Again, two huge cutlets with a very good marsala sauce. He said it was wonderful. They had more than several heaters outside on the sidewalk but no tables. It is February! They have a parking lot which they share with other store fronts adjacent to the restaurant as well as metered parking directly across the street and also on the main road. We were too full for dessert. Would love to return for another time with a friend who would very much enjoy their menu and ambience. read more

See all

While I feel the ambience was pleasant and the staff very attentive, the food was fair at best. We had the fried calamari, it was chewy. Also, this is not like any other restaurant where you get a good portion. The portion was measly. 3 of us ordered the stuffed sole, it was a good size piece of sole over broccoli rabe and some mashed potatoes. It was good but there was no wow factor. Basically, it was nothing special. I wouldn't go back. read more

Disappointed by the food. Disappointed by the service. I will no longer return. Feels like I threw my money is a trash can.

Another fabulous dinner here! Had to have those bacon wrapped shrimp in that divine sauce. Excellent! Memorable! We tried the eggplant stack as a new appetizer, and for entrées we got the veal Parm on the bone, and the chicken marsala. The eggplant was wonderful, and I usually am not a big fan of eggplant. It was soft and delicious in a great marinara sauce. The veal Parm was unbelievable! It was really tender and absolutely delicious. A showstopper! The chicken marsala was really well done with lots of mushrooms in a glossy wine sauce with great flavor. Our waitress was friendly, drinks were fabulous, and it was the perfect dinner. read more

See all

At first, I was considering giving this place two stars because the food was actually decent but leaving the restaurant took away a star. I went here with my boyfriend and my friend just to have a little dinner to hang out and talk. They put us in the middle of the restaurant and it got packed very fast. I assume the reason why this place is called. The chatterbox is that it's so loud inside you can't even hear who is talking or you can hear is chatter. I had to yell in order to talk to my friend right across the table because I couldn't hear her and she couldn't hear me. My boyfriend was sitting right next to me and he even had a hard time hearing us because it was so loud. They blasted the music even louder towards the end of the night, which made it even worse for hearing us during a conversation. I actually had to yell and hurt my throat in order to talk to my friend. The food was actually decent, but we did have an issue with ordering a Italian cheesecake. It's did not taste like a traditional Italian cheesecake and it was very stale and dry. We had to send it back. Our waiter also really was not very attentive and when we had asked him for his opinion on what food items to get he just said a random item and acted like he didn't really care. When I was leaving the restaurant because we were in the center of the area there were so many people behind us their chairs all pulled out. I could barely fit in order to get through to the exit. I don't know how the servers do it, but it's very cramped. So I honestly do not recommend this place if you want an intimate get together or even to just go out to eat cause it's very cramped. It's extremely loud and honestly not worth the hype. read more

Went in because I see all their posts on IG. The place is nice! The music was great! It was a Sunday afternoon. We were started with some really delicious warm bread and butter. Then we had mussels in white wine sauce. Delicious. The my husband went with the eggplant parm, with the Vodka sauce. I had the veal Ossobuco. The portions were big. Too big for me. Most people want more of that, me no. It was too big, too heavy. If I go back, I'd order lighter stuff. Service was good. Our server was constantly checking in on us! read more

See all

Great place for brunch me and my friends came after our Sunday hike as well as for birthday brunch.

Yep, and the ambiance is usually jumping but this is based on the food alone. Came with one of my buddies not expecting too much from the grub. Lets go: The Carbonara is close to heaven and almost a perfect blend of fresh ingredients not drenched in cheap sauce. Chef nails this as it's probably as good as any Carbonara I've had. Never been to Italy so I'll reserve the word perfect until then. Blanca pizza is a carbs rich treat worth every minute on the treadmill. The di parma is the star. I dont remember the last time I ordered lasagna but tasted my buddies and it was good. I sat at the bar, service was great. Only criticism is the seats are way too close and people are closer than I am used to. 5 stars for all the reasons above! read more

A must try. Trendy place with great food. Lively fun atmosphere with music playing - some may find it too loud but we liked it. Service was a bit slow, but understandable considering the place was jampacked on a Friday night the food, well, the food was absolutely fabulous. From the appetizers down to dessert nothing disappointed. Must have appetizers: octopus, shrimp ceviche, pizza. Entrées: all the veal is bone in large portions. Veal martini, fried veal scarpariello, veal parm. Lobster ravioli, and the chicken scarp to die for. Zeppoli's, tiramisu, and Tres leches for dessert. Absolutely amazing. read more

Chatterbox - Bone in veal Parm - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Last night I ordered a $40 sole dish of which I ate nothing. There were 2 ginormous pieces of sole that were breaded and fried oozing oil in my dish. The waiter asked me what was wrong because he saw I wasn't eating. I explained that this is different than what the menu said and was extremely oily. His responses was that's a shame. In the end he gave my table of 6 a free tartufo. That didn't help me. I left hungry. read more

Great food Joe Pesci pizza is next level yummy Oso Buco was fantastic Everything on the menu was delicious Great service read more

See all

The toasted bread was served with very delicious olive oil. The food was excellent. Waiter Vinny was attentive. read more

See all

Let me start off by saying, I am not one to write a review unless I had either a great experience or a truly terrible one. Went to Chatterbox as a group of 13 to celebrate my grandfather's 75th birthday on a 6:30 reservation. The entire experience was rushed. First, they bring out the appetizers... no sooner than everyone had their first helping, the waitstaff started frantically taking the appetizer plates away with food still left on them. The wait staff was hovering and waiting for my wife to finish the charcuterie she was actively eating off her plate. They stood there until she hurriedly ate them. We did attempt to stop them but the place was so loud that we went unheard. Here come the entrees: As the waiter was handing out dinners, he spilled a ton of salmony, oil filled juice onto the lap of a family member, completely destroying his jeans. There wasn't much of an apology and definitely not a comp on the bill. They got one person's order wrong so she had to wait 15 minutes for her pasta to arrive. Once again, no sooner than the rest of us ate our entrees the waitstaff came to collect in quite a hurry. The person who received her dish late couldn't even finish it - they brought her a to go tin. To top it off, the food was sub par. I've been here before and didn't have a complaint about the food. Even if the food was great, you couldn't enjoy it because of the rush. Lastly, they did their birthday schtick while my 75 year old grandfather wasn't even at the table. He was mid walking to the bathroom. He had to scurry all the way back to do the cake thing. On that note, they served cake first and took the coffee order after the cake was already eaten. Who does cake without coffee?! Furthermore, the waitstaff was aggressively asking us to hand them our silverware just after the cake was eaten. Bottom line is, for the price you pay to dine here, you should be able to enjoy your food rather than eating in a whirlwind. It seems as though they just wanted us out of there to start their night scene. The waitstaff should pay more attention to the customers rather than rushing to clear the table. If this is how Chatterbox handles large parties then I would recommend going elsewhere. I gave Chatterbox 3 stars because the atmosphere is nice, music is good and the food was better on other occasions. I hope this review is acknowledged by the owner for the betterment of this restaurant. read more

Decent place to drink and chill - I can't speak for the food because I only hung out at the bar. Service was pretty quick, and vibes weren't bad. I appreciated that there was parking directly next to, and in front of this place (I think metered parking until 7 pm). read more

Poor experience all around. Previously cooked/reheated food, not fresh, no flavor, bad services.

If Dorsia from American Psycho were a real place, this would be it. A restaurant so pretentious, trying so hard to be more than it is, but in reality, it's just a step above Olive Garden with equally unimpressive service. I made a reservation, and when we arrived, the man at the door--who never introduced himself--greeted us. He could have been a waiter, a bartender, a manager, or even the owner. Honestly, I couldn't tell because he didn't say who he was. He just seemed very self-important. After observing his demeanor, I'm fairly certain he was either a busboy or the owner's nephew, minding the store for the night. Anyway, he told us there was no reservation under our name, but when we showed him our OpenTable confirmation, he acted like he had never seen a smartphone before, as if the concept of electronic reservations was completely foreign to him. Why take reservations on OpenTable if you're not going to honor them? The restaurant was almost empty, yet he insisted on seating us at a high-top table even though we clearly wanted a regular one. The weird part is, we sat down at 6:15, and by 7:15, we were being rushed out the door. If you were planning to push us out in an hour, why not seat us at one of the many empty tables in the dining room that stayed vacant throughout our rushed meal? As for the food, it was a solid 2 out of 10, if you like pre-made, processed, microwave food--on par with Olive Garden. If you're looking for authentic, quality Italian cuisine, this is not the place. My Nona made better Italian food, and she's been gone for 30 years. The only redeeming part of the experience was the drink. I ordered an Old Fashioned for $17, and while it was good, you shouldn't be paying Manhattan prices in Pleasantville. So, if you want to go and pretend you're experiencing a special, high-quality dining experience, this is your spot. It's a place pretending to serve great food in a great atmosphere, but that's all you're doing--pretending. The only thing they truly care about is getting you in and out as quickly as possible to free up the table for the next group of customers, who may or may not even show up. At least the busboy can show his uncle how much money he made that night. To be fair, every business wants to turn a profit, but not at the expense of making customers feel rushed and unimportant. People go out to eat for a unique experience, something they can't get at home. Your job as a restaurant is to make the customer feel welcomed and appreciated. Unfortunately, I felt neither, and the food was subpar. Enjoy the generous tip I gave you and use it to buy a clue! Maybe your regulars don't know or care about quality because this is supposed to be an "it" spot, but there are plenty of people who can tell the difference between real fine dining and just pretending. read more

Went here a few months ago and used to go every now and then for lunch up until the last time and not to mention we were the only table there all the time anyways we ordered calamari and when we got them they were all tentacles no exaggeration!!!!! How dare they!!!! never ever ever experienced that just ridiculous so didn't eat them obviously we were disgusted and were like what the heck really????? u would think they'd ask y we didn't eat them but noooo because they knew dam well it was wrong didn't take them off the check they r so hard up its pathetic... actually many people r complaining about that place quality and prices just ridiculous ... take those tentacles and shove them deep Buon appetite read more

Food amazing-delishh & fresh. Service great ,drinks even better :) went for brunch but unfortunately we got there after 3pm so we ordered from the "all day menu" read more

Had been wanting to try this new place and had been following on Instagram. Went on a Sunday around 3pm. Pretty good crowd at the bar. Only down side to that is that because of the layout, people standing around the bar inhibit you to come and go and it gets tight. Not really much of an issue and you can't fault a place for that. For table apps, we got the bacon wrapped shrimp, baked clams, nonnas meatballs, and fried calamari. The meatballs and the shrimp were excellent. The calamari was rubbery and the baked clams were a little fishy with a scampi sauce that someone dumped way too much lemon in. The mains were very good. Good sized portions for sure. My only complaint was that with the high price tag, you would expect that it would come with a side. Maybe a salad? Nothing. All forgivable due to the fact that the food is good. The reason for the 3 stars is the service. The waitress did the best she could, but it takes a very long time to get anything or even place an order. I saw the owner walking around from table to table greeting guests, but he did not stop at our table for some reason. He even stopped by the surrounding tables multiple times but never to ours. It's not a good customer service thing. He could have been having a bad day. He seemed a little mopey. Will I go back? If there was a party or event that I was invited to, yes. Otherwise- tried it and now I can move on. read more

Chatterbox - Veal parm ala vodka - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Food was good. But on pricey side for brunch. We had the chicken and waffles and Omelette and Fries. Which were each about 25 and 26 dollars each. Service was good. People were nice. The place was nice inside. read more

Phenomenal. I came in with a friend for lunch on a Friday afternoon and cannot rave enough about our experience. The space was beautiful with tons of indoor and patio seating. The service was great, very attentive. I was hopeful that the food would be good but I had no expectations that it would be THAT good. I got the pleasantville parm wedge (chicken parm with vodka sauce) and fries - it was incredible. The portion was generous (I wrapped up half of the wedge to bring home). They had good music playing, and the restroom was very clean as well. I don't live locally, but would easily return to the area just to order that meal again. read more

Chatterbox - Pleasantville Parm Wedge with fries - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

Food was good waiter was not. I read a lot of reviews and seems they are big on reminding you that you don't have the table long. Anyway end of dinner was interesting, we waited for coffee with dessert, it wasn't coming. When we reminded waiter he apologized for forgetting the coffee. We had not asked for the check but he had already dropped it on the table. He then took it back and delivered the coffee. Sure enough when the bill came the coffee was included along with a side dish we had not ordered or received. I pointed it out to the waiter and he apologized for the side dish and said his thumb slipped when he rang up. I then pointed out that he forgot the coffee therefore it should have been comped. He disagreed but then adjusted the bill to take off the coffee and the side dish. I was born in the night time but not last night. Nice try To those who go there, check your bill!! read more

Fabulous good. Incredible selection . Great service. The best. Couldn't be more accommodating Generous portions Oh the bread!!! From Arthur Avenue. Yummy The setting is wonderful. You can sit outside if you wish And they have their own parking !!! read more

Okay... delicious!!! I am very familiar with Pleasantville and I believe this place is relatively new. Simply said: Delicious food. We ordered a variety of things. I can't exactly recall everything but I ordered a mixed antipasto with eggplant, artichoke, stuffed mushroom and shrimp. So so so good! Everything was delicious!!! The bread that came out first was fresh and warm. Yum! Portions are reasonable for the price. My friend took home the rest of her panini for dinner. I was very happy with the serving sizes. Also, in the evening, they open the doors and turn on the heaters. Such a beautiful vibe and ambiance. Great location for any occasion. The service was not noteworthy so I cannot speak much on that. I sincerely cannot wait to come back. read more

See all

Last weekend was our first visit to Chatterbox in Pleasantville,  what an incredible experience.  Joe JR. welcomed us even during his soft opening.  Chatterbox officially opens on March 24th!  We were treated like kings and queens.  The food is superb!  We tried their Meatballs a la Nonna and they are truly like your grandmothers...we also tried Mussels Marinara and Fried Calamari which were both fantastic...they are known for their Arthur Avenue Pizza so, of course, we had to have it along with Chicken Parm...their herbs and flavors and their sauces taste like I was back in Italy (Naples, Florence, Rome, Avellino...) doesn't matter tastes just like home!  Do not leave until you have Espresso with the most delicious fried Oreo cookies over vanilla ice cream topped with cannoli cream!   Joe JR. Welcomes you like you are family and even his menu states..."where friends become family."   A must try and you won't go anywhere else!  Well at least we won't. Thank you Joe Jr.  Can't wait to come back and bring family Jane & Johnny read more

Chatterbox - Bars Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

The service was incredible. We were greeted and served right away. We were also checked in on a bunch which is 100 times better then not being able to get anyone :) The ambiance is very chill but also romantic. I loved the decor and the space. I think the bar is really nice too. Started with burrata and it was EXTREMELY fresh. I was really in heaven eating it! Highly recommend. I do feel like the entrees fell a bit short but other than that, everything else was a 5 star in my book. For my entree, I ordered the raviolis. The raviolis were a bit over cooked for my liking.. I'm also Italian so I may be a bit more critical of it but I like a softer pasta. The sauce was good but nothing to brag about IMO. Again, probably more critical only because I've had my fair share of Italian sauces. I tried my husbands pasta and didn't like the sauce. I did see some chicken parms come out and they looked phenomenal so I will deff try a meat next time especially because I am a bit more picky with pastas. The dessert was amaaaaaazing. Tried the zeppolis- filled with Nutella & cannoli cream.. yes ... amazing. And also tried the fried Oreos. Super tasty and sweet way to end the night! read more

Chatterbox is an 8/10, and this is why: *no parking * small portions * GREAT waitstaff * good cocktails * food is consistent * little pricey for what you get read more

Cold food and drinks come free with extra siliva from the dude bartender. Would not recommend

Chatterbox was a nice spot to pop into before heading over to the theater nearby. Cute interior and more spacious than you would think. I will say, we went in the winter and the insulation of the dining area was not good. We spent the whole meal freezing which is uncomfortable. For the number of staff in the place, the services was also so-so. We got sat and asked for a few minutes to look over the drink menu and didn't see our waitress again for 15 minutes. Then we had a wait boy filling out waters every 10 seconds, which can be nice if timed properly but he hovered the table--give us a few minutes to enjoy ourselves. Then he'd go missing when our glasses actually did sit empty for a long period of time. The appetizers are a must-get. The bacon wrapped shrimp is delicious and the sauce it comes in is even better. The muscles were tender and a little bit spicy and very good. The mashed potatoes are phenomenal. Skip the meatballs, nothing special about them and save room for everything else. Everyone felt pretty mediocre about their main dishes. Overall, nice for a drink and an app and convenient location but don't have super high expectations. read more