I recently completed a tour booked with Charming Holidays, 4 days / 3 nights in Beijing, and a total of 6 days / 5 nights in Nanjing, Wuxi, Suzhou, Hangzhou, and Shanghai.
My overall impression is that you get what you pay for. In general, the tour group gets you from city to city, attractions to meals to hotels, fairly quickly and efficiently. For the price, the hotels are usually fantastic (4-star and up) and the meals are good. There's one tour guide per city and they usually do a decent job of explaining some of the city's history and culture.
A few gripes and things to note:
1. Language. When we booked the tour, we were told that the tour guides would be able to speak English, Cantonese and Mandarin as necessary for the tour group. This was not our experience. I went on this tour with my family, and we speak primarily Cantonese and English. While our guide in Beijing (Alan) did a great job of translating between all three languages as necessary, the tour guides for the second leg of our journey (Nanjing to Shanghai) spoke primarily in Mandarin. Even when we requested a few basic translations to either Cantonese or English, we were told that there wouldn't be enough time on the tour to translate (reason: "too much history") for our benefit. Result: for the last 5 days of the tour we understood little to none of what was being said. Personally, I spent much of this time playing Plants vs Zombies. It's apparently our fault that we aren't fluent in Mandarin.
2. Rudeness. While I was busy killing time with PvZ, my wife was fuming. This was understandable, since she came with the expectation of learning about her heritage. Not only this, but several tour guides repeatedly insulted her personally upon her request to have the tour translated, that because she is American, no amount of translation into Cantonese or English would make her understand. This was especially prevalent in Nanjing, Wuxi, and Suzhou. While Asian travelers are known for their rudeness and impulsiveness, it appears that these traits still manifest in their home country.
3. The guilt/obligation-ridden shopping, eating and... living. We understand that these tours are exceptionally affordable due to sponsorship by the Chinese government and also by individual businesses. We also understand that the motivation to sponsor these tours is to introduce and "show off" the country's attractions to Western/foreign tourists. A large part of why these tours exist is because the tour groups are taken to and expected to patronize these businesses. However we did not appreciate being blatantly told that we should buy their goods just because they paid for our meal or hotel. We did purchase some goods, not because we felt guilt or obligation, but because we felt they were worth buying! (Weird, right?)
The odd part is that we suspected there were some repercussions for not buying as many goods at a particular business. For instance the meal after may not be as good, the heat on the bus may not be on for your 3 hour ride to another city, etc.
I digress. Other things to note:
- be prepared to wake up at 6am
or earlier most days. The hotels are generally great as noted above, and hotel breakfast buffets are pretty standard (and delicious) across the hotels we stayed in.
- everything is remarkably on time. The bus driver was always early or on time to pick us up.
- lack of transparency. It was difficult to know what was happening when, where we were going, etc. As a result there were several times I didn't know we were going on a 2.5-hour bus ride during which my bladder almost exploded. Had I known that we wouldn't be seeing a bathroom for a few hours I may not have chosen to drink several additional glasses of water, etc.
You will not know anything about anything unless you explicitly ask.
- upon arriving in Beijing, we could not find our tour guide and had to call the company to figure out who to contact and how.
- the restrooms in China (at restaurants, attractions, public restrooms) are 100% disgusting. Hot/warm water, paper towels and even toilet paper are not a given. Bring your own.
- bring respiration masks for Beijing especially if the pollution is bad. A large portion of the population smokes throughout the cities we visited in China.
- the tour chaperone for the Nanjing-Shanghai leg (Vivian) was pleasant but didn't do much. For each city, we had a separate tour guide that did all the talking. She basically shuttled us from city to city.
- my favorite parts of the tour were when we were dropped off in a city center for a few hours to explore, eat and shop on our own. Even though it was more of a challenge for us due to the language barrier, it was nice to not feel pressured into buying anything from a particular business.
Overall, TL;DR: it's a fantastic deal if you can deal with all the shenanigans. If the purpose is to attract Western and foreign tourists to China, I'd say the tour failed on all counts. read more