First time dining at Old Oaks Steakhouse. We regularly visit high-end steakhouses--Mastro's,…read moreFleming's, Morton's, Ruth's Chris, BOA, The Grill on the Alley, Hall's in Charleston, Peter Luger, and independents around the country--so I'm writing this as constructive feedback because I really want an independent steakhouse like this to succeed in Thousand Oaks.
First impression: the room needs some work. The lighting was too bright for a steakhouse and should be brought down to create a more intimate atmosphere. I also think the cream/brown table linens were a miss. Crisp white linen and better lighting would immediately elevate the room.
Service was excellent. Our server was knowledgeable, friendly, attentive, and fun. Five stars for him.
Bartender also gets five stars. We had a blueberry martini and a Woodford Old Fashioned, and both were on point.
For appetizers, the lobster deviled eggs were a miss for us. Too many eggs, too much vinegar, and we really couldn't taste the lobster or identify much of the filling.
The crab cakes, however, were very good. We order crab cakes at almost every steakhouse we visit, and our benchmark is The Grill on the Alley. Old Oaks is definitely up there on the crab itself--meaty and well done. I'd just add more sauce and some type of garnish, avocado, greens, grilled lemon, etc., to finish the plate.
The wine list pricing lost a sale. Caymus is one of my favorites, but at roughly $340 a bottle I passed. Same issue with the Groth around $240. I understand a steakhouse needs proper wine margins, but those prices felt too aggressive. At about $100 less on the Caymus, we probably would have ordered the bottle. Instead, we had a glass of the Napa house Cabernet, which was very good.
We're also Caesar salad fanatics. The Caesar was very good and I'd order it again. If an independent restaurant wants to separate itself, I'd love to see a tableside Caesar similar to BOA. Pick the best ideas from the best steakhouses and make them your own.
The steak program has an impressive selection of dry-aged beef. We shared the porterhouse, and this is an area where we have a pretty high benchmark. One of the best porterhouses we've ever had is Peter Luger in New York. In my opinion, the New York location is better than Las Vegas, although Vegas was a very close second. That is the type of buttery, deeply flavored, perfectly seasoned porterhouse experience I'm comparing against.
Old Oaks' porterhouse didn't quite get there for me. It lacked some of the seasoning and buttery softness I personally look for, but I also came away realizing that I'm probably just not a big dry-aged steak person. That part is personal preference and not necessarily the restaurant's fault. I really liked seeing both an 8 oz and 12 oz filet on the menu, and I'd come back to try the 12 oz filet. I would actually like to see a few more wet-aged steak options alongside the dry-aged selections.
We planned on the loaded baked potato until we saw the fries at another table. The fries were great. But this is where things slipped: we asked for ranch and ketchup, and the ranch tasted like bottled Hidden Valley. At this level, a steakhouse should be making its sauces in-house. We switched to the blue cheese, which was very good and tasted house-made.
I'd also strongly recommend adding an excellent creamed corn. Hall's Chophouse in Charleston has one that is practically worth the trip by itself. A signature side like that gives people something to talk about and come back for.
Dessert needs the biggest overhaul. A truly great butter cake can bring people in just for cocktails and dessert. What we received reminded us more of olive-oil muffins cut in half than a decadent steakhouse dessert. We joked with our server that it felt more like something I should have had for breakfast with bacon and eggs. The ice cream itself was great, but even after asking for a ridiculous amount of whipped cream, the portion was small and didn't have that rich, over-the-top steakhouse feel.
Our bill was around $430 including a 22% tip. We were prepared to spend more, but the food didn't consistently have the richness and decadence that makes you want to keep ordering at a high-end steakhouse.
My wife says four stars. I'm closer to three. I'm somewhere in between because I can see the potential and I do want to go back.
The fixes aren't huge: lower and rework the lighting, white tablecloths, expand the wet-aged steak options, consider sizzling steak plates, tighten up a few appetizers and sides, make every sauce in-house, add a killer creamed corn, and completely rethink dessert.
Great service, great bartender, very good crab cakes and Caesar, and a lot of potential. With a few relatively small changes, this could become a steakhouse we regularly visit in Thousand Oaks.