Celli's cookies are tasty! These small-batch and organic yummies is a great find in W-burg, and offers the following flavors: Cappuccino, Chocolate Sugar Cookie, Classic Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Coconut, Dark Chocolate Walnut, Italian Wedding, Lemon Glazed, Milk Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt, Semisweet Chocolate and Pecan, Snickerdoodle, White Chocolate Cranberry Sea Salt, and White, Dark, and Semisweet Chocolate. We ordered the Classic Chocolate Chip, the Dark Chocolate Walnut, the Milk Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt, the Semisweet Chocolate and Pecan, and the White Chocolate Cranberry Sea Salt - they were all so tasty! Slightly soft and a little chewy, I can see how if they were warmed up in the oven for a few would make this super gooey and decadent. My favorite was the Dark Chocolate Walnut and the Semisweet Chocolate and Pecan - can't get enough of them nuts! The store is small, and there is literally just a round table with various selections of the cookies; in and out you go! Note that these are very limited and when they're sold out, they're sold out! I recommend in getting there super early to get the best selection! The staff is friendly, and there's plenty of parking in the (tight) plaza lot. +Dark Chocolate Walnut cookies +Semisweet Chocolate and Pecan cookies +limited availability & selection of cookies +parking in small plaza lot read more

I love delicious chocolate chips and this are on the top. Heavy but soft and chocolate chucks are mouth watering. Thank you. read more

Celli's Chocolate Chips - Two fresh chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Cookies are my favorite dessert, but also the one I hold to the highest standard. Having a cookie here raised my standards for all future cookies. The portion size is perfect: satisfying without being too much. The ratio of cookie edge to cookie center is flawless, as is the ratio of add-in to cookie dough. Chewiness and freshness are at their peak. Walking in to the business smells like they just pulled out a tray of your favorite cookies. You're warmly greeted and faced with a simple menu of choices. It feels like walking into the kitchen of an old family friend. It's not just service- it's hospitality. For the quality and quantity, the low price is unbelievable. I like to think I'm good at baking cookies, but $2 for a fresh, homemade cookie that I couldn't replicate with hours of effort is a steal. At less than $20 for a dozen cookies, I'll definitely be here next time I need to bring a dessert somewhere and want to fool people into thinking I'm an amazing baker. I came here on a strong recommendation and was still surprised by how much I loved it! The whole place is a hidden gem. The Earl is my favorite so far, but I've also heard rave reviews of the Hudson and the Lemon drop. We'll be back to keep eating our way through the menu. read more

Celli's Chocolate Chips - The Earl : dark, semisweet, and white chocolate chips - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

What a nice experience for my 1st time there and amazing cookies! Wonderful and personable customer service along with the best cookies I've ever had.. Thank you so much and we will be back. read more

Celli's is the cookie place that Williamsburg has been needing. I went to visit when they opened up in their new location. When you walk in it's not like a regular bakery where the items are behind a glass. The cookies are nicely wrapped and the decor is beautiful. Be prepared to spend at least $12 on a pack of 4 cookies. They post daily what flavors they will be carrying for the day. read more

Celli's Chocolate Chips - Semi Sweet chocolate and pecan - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

I mean let me be the first but not the last to tell you these cookies are sooooo insanely good! I couldn't get enough! Totally worth the price! read more

First this is a family owned business and they are one of the sweetest families ever. The cookies are baked fresh and so so good. You have many choices to choose from. The whole family can enjoy!! Check them out if you haven't! read more

I love love love this woman owned company. So during these very different times and not seeing as many friends and family or being able to celebrate events I was able to gift the people I love with these Cooke's ... Why these cookies and not another company. It's the sweetest gift you can literally to anyone there packaging and presentation is beautiful let's get down to talking about the Cooke's......have eaten chocolate chip cookies all over the New York but continue to come back to Cellis chocolate chips cookies as I am never disappointed I oreder from Bloomingdale's as there do not have a store here yet. Love me a good cookie. read more

Celli's Chocolate Chips - Tea and cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Very delicious and fresh. Just what I was looking for to satisfy my chocolate chip addiction.

Tina offers excellent customer service. The cookies were delicious. I look forward to returning to try more flavors.

EVERYTHING A COOKIE SHOULD BE!! Wow - these cookies are phenomenal! Chewy, thick enough to sink your teeth into but not overwhelming, sweet but not cloying, a generous amount of good size mix-ins (if the flavor calls for it) - these were COOKIE PERFECTION!! I read about Celli's somewhere online so I stopped in to sample the goods and I am so glad I did. Now I can pop over to pick up just a couple cookies instead of making a homemade batch and eating them all.... but as good of a cookie baker as I am, these are even better. I loved the different flavors - choc chip and butterscotch, triple chocolate chip (dark, milk, and light), lemon drop - all of them were amazing. The staff was so kind and patient as well, and the shop was adorable. I sincerely hope they don't suffer from lack of foot traffic in their location - spread the word about these cookies because we need this shop in the 'burg! They sell cookies individually or by the dozen or half dozen, and I believe they had coffee drinks as well (all I could focus on were cookies - it smelled amazing walking in!). These would make great corporate gifts or wedding favors - I will definitely be keeping them in mind for gift baskets in the future! read more

TO DIE FOR!!!!!! THE BEST, MOST SCRUMPTIOUS Item I have ever put in my mouth. Forget any other cookie you've ever had anywhere, anytime and for any reason. So fresh and perfectly created I cannot ABIDE eating any other cookie EVER. End of story! read more

These are some of the best cookies I've ever had. Whenever I have an excuse to get a friend a gift, I come to Celli's to get some cookies. (And the Celli family is always kind to be around-- they're happy to recommend something when I have trouble deciding!) read more

My boss gave me one of these cookies for covering his shift and I swear it changed my life. This is hands down the best chocolate chip cookie I have ever eaten. Honestly I haven't even finished it; I stopped midway to write this review. 11/10 will be going there myself soon. edit to add that the cookie I had was the Hudson read more

Simply put, best cookies Ive ever had. Stopped in yesterday and Ms. Celli herself was there as was her wonderful daughter. They were so warm and friendly that even if the cookies weren't so amazing I'd still go back just to buy from them. I got the chocolate chip, caramel sea salt and almond. They were incredible. Well worth the $ and I cannot wait to go back. This product is special. You wont find another like it. If its possible to be addicted to cookies, I am now. read more

Their cookies are delicious and the atmosphere in the shop is so great! Any time I come in, I'm greeted warmly and have great conversations with whoever is working. One time I stopped by right as they sold out and they chased me to my car to give me the two last cookies they had in the back- FOR FREE!! They are wonderful read more

I am always on the hunt for the best chocolate chip cookies. And in Williamsburg I found them here. Delicious!! Lots of chocolate chips and organic ingredients. Highly recommend! read more

Went in to pick up a dozen traditional chocolate chip cookies for my husband's birthday and a couple for my daughter's teacher. They didn't have many left from the lunch rush so they took my order and called me when they were ready. They are fantastic! I can't wait to try some of the other varieties. read more

Their cookies are fantastic! Bring them into the office quite regularly and everyone raves about them. Owners/staff are very friendly and welcoming as well! read more

I won a dozen of their new "The Dood" cookies as a result of winning the naming contest. I feel so lucky that I got to take a sneak peek into the space that they are making...let me tell you, it's absolutely warm, welcoming, and worth the wait. The cookies are delicious, the perfect texture, and hearty in size. I also was able to try the granola which didn't last long at all in our house it was so good! I love supporting small businesses in my community and can't wait until I can make a stop in for cookies soon. It is family-owned by such a sweet family. I felt immediately welcomed in and loved everything from the bright walls to the rustic furniture and amazing small-batch cookies. I'm excited for them to be officially open soon, my jeans are not ;) read more

OMG I just tasted the most delicious cookie I've ever had. It was a chocolate chip cookie with Caramel chips. Y'all hear me when I say Celli's Chocolate Chips on John Tyler Road are THE BEST. I just had one fresh from the oven. It's like magic morsels that melt in your mouth . Sweet Bliss. They are Yumtastic! Even the presentation was great. It was wrapped with a pretty black and gold bow. Personalized card that said thanks was a wonderful touch. I will definitely be back. read more

Celli's Chocolate Chips - Bakeries Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My husband called to place an order and it was ready very quickly! Very friendly staff and delicious cookies - we will be back for more!

Celli's Chocolate Chips has the best cookies around and incredible customer service (truly a great family who runs it). Their cookies are fresh and made with the best top-quality ingredients. 10/10 recommend for anyone looking for a delicious, homemade cookie. read more

OBSESSED is the only word I have for them! Celli's doesn't just have good cookies, they are the BEST. We happened to try them for the first time when they were at their old location, thanks to a recommendation by a friend. Needless to say, we have been addicted ever since. Some of my family members aren't even into sweets yet they love them! What makes them so special is not just their absolutely delicious cookies but also the amazing family who owns it. You can taste all the love, passion, and affection that went into baking them even just after the first bite. My personal favorites are: Caramel Sea Salt, Dark Chocolate Walnut, Cappuccino, Lemon Glazed, White+Dark+Semi, Classic, Chocolate sugar, Wedding... so basically everything. If you haven't tried them, you are seriously missing out. read more

Celli's is a family run business who make quality cookies that taste amazing! They are always friendly and accommodating. We love their cookies and would highly recommend them to everyone!! read more

The most delicious cookies in Williamsburg! Thick, chunky, gooey, scrumptious cookies made from scratch. Family owned, local business that we're lucky to have! The Celli's are super nice folks with an awesome product! This is one local "secret" spot you don't want to miss! read more

Great cookies and I am really picky about sweets since I bake. Wonderful flavor. Super sweet ladies serving us. Family owned business. Highly recommend trying them. Call ahead of time to check out the flavors for the day. read more

I have been fortunate enough to have been able to enjoy Celli's cookies even before their storefront shop was a thing. They have an amazing product and I am so excited for their shop to open ! While they have been waiting for the official go day they have been taking online orders and working hard to share their wonderfully yummy cookies with the public. I myself can't wait to show them some love on the 15th of April!! read more

I've been buying cookies from this family-owned business since the very beginning. Amazing selection of cookies - always fresh and delicious - baked by the most talented and lovely, Gina Celli. Can't wait until their retail outlet opens soon in town. read more

Got cookies in a rush, but we're some of the best I've ever had! Chocolate chip were perfect, even still warm at pick up! Will definitely go back! read more

These are the best cookies I have ever had! This is what a cookie should taste like!! I am not a big sweet eater but these cookie's are just right as far as sweetness goes, "they are the bomb" you just have to try! You can smell the aroma as you pass by on John Tyler Hwy!!! read more

Great cookies made and owned by amazing people! I got a chance to meet them and hear about how much passion they had for their business. They dedicate much time to what they are doing and as a result the cookies deserve 5 stars. Try "The Dood" read more

Unfortunately to get the dozen discount you have to order at least 24 hrs ahead. If you drop in and want a dozen you pay the single cookie price. Too bad for out of area customers that just happen to find the shop. read more

I ordered some cookies for an event last week. When I picked them up, they were still warm from the oven. Every bite is a little party of happiness. Place an order, you won't be disappointed. read more

Yummy chocolate chip cookies! Hidden in plain sight and the exterior can lead you to believe the place isn't even open but it is! I called the store just in case and was happy to know they were inside cooking their cookies! Hopefully a big sign will be made to make the place more visible! read more

Hands down the best cookies ever ~ made of the finest organic ingredients too!! The little cafe atmosphere (they do have coffee also) is cozy and relaxing if you want to "eat-in"! Highly recommend Celli's for the best Choc Chip Cookies (along with other kinds also available each day!) read more

I have visited Celli's twice already and the cookies are delicious! The customer service is amazing and the Celli family goes above and beyond to make sure the customer is happy and satisfied! I first ordered a dozen of the traditional and after devouring them in just a few days, I was back for another order. I requested a variety box so I could try all of the different flavors and they were all amazing. I highly recommend Celli's to anyone looking for a delicious, homemade cookie! read more

Want to let someone know you are thinking of them in a memorable way......send a dozen of these scrumptious cookies. It will be a thought that is NOT forgotten. Beautifully packaged for delivery too. So much better than sending flowers! read more

I have never had a bad experience with this amazing bakery. Not only are their cookies among the best I've ever had but you can really tell they are made with love. This family works so hard to make sure every customer has a great experience and it really shows. Their online orders are super quick and still arrive hot, I promise you will not regret ordering their cookies. read more

After hearing about Celli's amazing cookies for almost two years, I was so excited to be able to visit the store today and order fresh cookies. The best cookies I have ever tasted. I had the Black + White, Traditional Chocolate Chip, Walnut, and the Hudson. They are as big as my face. Also, their coffee was amazing as well, even though I went for the cookies. Bonus surprise. The Celli family are so very kind and sweet, like talking to your best girlfriend while baking in the kitchen. I can't wait to order some and send out for gifts to my friends and family. Their official opening is Monday 4/15. I know they will be super successful transitioning from a home based business to this store front. We will be back! Often! read more