We just love the pizza there and the fish tacos!! They are very friendly. Price is right

Decided to try somewhere new and wasn't disappointed. Got the meat lovers and wings, pizza was flavorful all the way through the crust read more

Castaways - Meat Lovers Pizza - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

What a great local find!! We used google and yelp to find this place, and we weren't disappointed. It is nice to find a clean, local place. Service was good considering they just got slammed and was down a person. The swiss burger was great! Made just right and tasted amazing! read more

See all

My husband just returned back to our rental 20 min away and it seems we got someone else's order. He was 1 of 2 people waiting so not sure why it is wrong. He had 2 ham & cheese subs (we were to have 2 Godfathers). Not sure if Buddy is the name of the person or the sub but it was written on both containers. The person even said my husband's name as they were bringing the bag to him so he didn't look inside. He wasn't going to make another round trip plus the line was busy when he called a few times. I decided to eat mine. The ham is thick cut deli ham with tough spots that I don't find that flavorful. Hopefully "Buddy" enjoyed the Italian subs. read more

Castaways - Ham & cheese sub with mayo - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

Castaways pizza and grill in Conneaut Ohio ..... I got this disgusting sandwich with more mayonnaise than is in the actual bottle I wanted all to see so I'm not making it up when I asked for new sandwich they said I had recently complained because it took 2 hrs and change to get my hot food now cold so if you want horrible service disgusting food this is the place for you and to the girl I spoke to Terese I believe FU you are not a assed for that company I never complained in my life as you all know I don't post but everyone should know and see what this place is truly about read more

Castaways - Food in garage where it belongs - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

See all

Amazing lunch! I had the Orchard Chicken salad with the Grape Vinaigrette. The mix of flavors were amazing. Great food and service!

The food is DELICIOUS and the crew are all so friendly. The owners, Krissy & Jen, are WONDERFUL people and care about the community. I HIGHLY recommend Castaways!!!! read more

I've given this restaurant several chances, but half the time the food is RAW. I'm not talking ordering a medium steak and it comes out medium rare, i'm talking about ordering a pizza or stromboli and the dough is NOT COOKED. The owner and managers simply don't care and the hourly employees aren't trained. read more

We had the breaded jalapeno cheese with marinara dipping sauce. The apps are definitely homemade and the marinara was amazing and we drank what was left! We also had a huge stromboli and the eggplant parm platter, which comes with garlic bread sticks and a side. The eggplant was absolutely amazing, affordable, and I'm going to get four meals out of that giant dish. They have local beers and it was an all around great, fun, and delicious place to hang out at! Highly recommend!! read more

See all

My son and I were passing through Conneaut, Ohio looking for a place to stope and watch the solar ecclipse when we stumbled upon Castaways Pizza & Grill. What a pleasant suprise it turned out to be! The food was fantastic, and the service was incredibly friendly. My son, who works in a pizza business in Chicago where pizza is king, was particularly impressed. The pizza at Castaways was a real hit with both of us. The flavors were fresh and delicious, the balance of ingredients was prefect, and the crust was just right. Overall, our experience at Castaways was exceptional. If you are in the area, WE hightly recommend stopping by for a pizza. You will not be disappointed! read more

I'm gonna be honest we waited a long time for food. But it was with the wait! We came in on a Tuesday evening at about 640. The girl who greeted us was talking to someone else and said that she was supposed to be out of there hours ago. She was supposed to be out at four but she stayed to help because they were so busy. Her name was Jennifer and she ended up waiting on us as we sat at the bar for a little while and went ahead and ordered our dinner. When a table opened up we moved over to it and she continued to be our server. She did a great job make sure our drinks were full and she kept us up on our order status. With everything I saw this girl doing and staying so much later than she was scheduled for Jennifer deserves a raise! She is probably one of their most valued employees and I hope they pay her well! Anyway the food, I had the Godfather sub and it was delicious! My choice of fries were the sweet potato fries and they were very good except the butter that was brought out with them tasted like it belonged on popcorn instead of sweet potato fries! My husband had the captains catch platter -I think it was what it was called- And he loved it! Especially the shrimp poppers and the fried perch. Those were his two favorites. His came with fries too but he barely ate any because the other food was so good! Overall even though it took forever to get our food I'm giving them four stars because it was definitely worth the wait! Highly recommend! Would eat here again! read more

Castaways - Front of restaurant from street - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

In town from California. This place was recommended to us. The whole family came down and we were amazed by the food, service, and amazing prices!! The staff was great!! Make sure you ask for Jen!! She made this place even more amazing it felt like she was family!! read more

I was in town on business tonight, and ate at this fantastic little restaurant tonight. We all had wings . The wings were delicious. The staff were very friendly and kind. read more

What is the biggest, best, cheapest pizza? Stop in! This was the first pizza I ate after moving to Conneaut I got a sheet pizza and I haven't been able to eat pizza anywhere else. read more

Great specials, good pizzas and my favorite is their taco salad! Nice family atmosphere

I love them!! I love the African American lady with the black heart under her eye. She is by far my favorite server to get and makes my experience so much better. If anyone sees this and has the power I swear she needs a raise or something. She's amazing and works so hard at what she does. The food is also amazing!! read more

I LOVE CASTAWAYS!!!! Great food, and great service 5 star. Patty Picard Meeker read more

Castaways - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

My first ever Lake Perch dinner, and right on the edge of lake of Lake Erie! I have heard about the famous lake perch for a couple years and finally accidentally found this nice little place. It was 11am but the fish an beer hit the spot! read more

See all

Pizza and Perch. Absolutely AMAZING in every way. This awesome little restaurant, blocks from Lake Erie, is definitely a new favorite place. Certainly worth the 40 minute drive from our camp at Pymatuning. The restaurant itself is small and fairly inconspicuous, next to a bait shop that will clean your Lake Erie Perch for a buck a pound. Why bother fishing when this place is around!? Staff is awesome and friendly, the food is amaze-balls, and it way cheaper than the other Erie resort areas. We ordered a bunch for a family-style dinner. The shrimp-jalapeño poppers were incredible. As were the pickle "fries," which resembled Texas toothpicks. The Perch was amazingly good (and to the reviewer who complained about a fish bone... Get over it). Crispy, hand sized filets were cheaper than the Cod we normally get at Pittsburgh area spots. The pizza...... The PIZZA!!! Ridiculously good!! The homemade sauce is to die for, and we even asked for a to-go cup for the leftover sauce. Seriously, it is THAT good. Sweeter than most, but the spices make up for it. We are already planning another trip to this place. Cheap + awesome food + next to Lake Erie is an amazing combination! read more

Castaways - Menu - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

See all

Love this place! The owners give a LOT back to the Conneaut Community! Pizza is excellent as are their wings! 55 cents on Thursdays!! Try it! You won't be disappointed! read more

Castaway Conneaut Ohio The cast away is a small corner restaurant in Conneaut Ohio about 5 blocks from the harbor, and like practically every restaurant on Conneaut, they specialize in pizza, wings and fried food. However, I have had their steak salad, which can be pretty decent, but they are not very consistent with their items, and it can be a hit or miss. The fish sandwich is deep fried almost to the point of being jerky and lacks any flavor, their wings are soggy and drenched in some sort of bottled sauce, and the pizza, well I wouldn't order it again. On a plus, they just recently painted and refreshed the interior which it desperately needed. So they have made some strives to do better. Now they just need to revamp the menu so to stand out from every other restaurant. To sum it up, its OK food at OK prices. read more

Castaways - the front of a restaurant - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

Definitely an underrated place to eat. I really enjoyed the food I had. The servers are nice. I do like other places better but for a place open all year around this is a great place. read more

I have been here before so I knew to expect awesome food but tonight was amazing. I work with special needs adults and I had 4 clients with me tonight and we had Samantha and she was beyond excellent with my guys and the rest of the place (as she was the only server) she was on top of her game tonight, very professional with my guys and we will definitely be back. read more

The Lake Eire Perch was awesome. Lightly breaded and seasoned. Friendly service also.

Food was good, but service was extremely slow and unpleasant. Lots of kind employees, but the only waitress working tonight was terribly rude to all customers and her co-workers. I've always enjoyed this restaurant, even when it isn't the fastest stop, but tonight was an overwhelmingly negative experience. Hope that next time a different server will be in. read more

Every time we are in Conneaut we make sure to stop by for the Oriental pizza and home made desserts. Recently remodeled and definitely worth a try! read more

Castaways - Oriental pizza - New American Near Me - Conneaut, Ohio

Ordered my pizza and was told 30 to 35 minutes for pick up showed up 45 minutes later and my pizza was not made was told I had to wait for them to make one. Last time I was there I ordered well done chicken wings and when I got home they were under cooked and I had to return them. Would rather go to Pizza Hut now. They can't keep up. read more

Very nice people and great food, really enjoyed the wings and fries. Will definitely come back if I visit the lake again.

We stopped here for an early lunch on a weekday. Sat outside on the patio which is a nice option to have. Our server was excellent and suggested several options. I had the perch sandwich and I don't remember what my wife had. The perch sandwich was excellent and was also a good value. The perch was breaded nicely and was just perfect in texture and freshness. I also should mention that the bun was very good. The only thing I would have changed is the amount of perch, maybe 3 small pieces instead of 2. read more

Bones in the fish. Not just a few. Supposedly Lake Erie perch. Certainly wasn't cleaned correctly Didn't pay. But have no appetite for my birthday now. read more

I don't know about the folks that panned this place but we LOVED it. Started with the "veggie basket" a nice variety of deep fried green beans, carrots, cauliflower and others served with ranch. Delicious! I had the shrimp basket (21 shrimp) fries and house made Cole slaw which was delicious. Husband had a incredible pizza with cheese, meatball, Italian sausage, onions, mushrooms, black olives and banana peppers. The crust was tender on the inside and crisp on the outside. LOTS of toppings and the sauce was delicious Out the door $40 and we had food to take home. Service was fast and the wait staff was great. We will be back for sure. Lots of parking, great for couples, families and you can catch your favorite sports team on the television. Hands down two thumbs UP! read more

Super friendly staff, great service and delicious fish fry. What's not to love? We'll be back quite often.

This was our first time at castaway as we are from erie. We were not disappointed, the Oriental pizza was well worth the drive. The homemade crust was perfect, the toppings were a party in my mouth. Pleasantly unique, never had a pizza like it. A little sweet and a little spicy. We will definitely be coming back to get another. Our waitress was very nice and attentive, she refilled our MOUNTAIN DEW at our table several times without our asking. My husband asked if he could watch the Masters on TV and she gave him the remote incase he needed to turn it up. The bathroom was clean and well stocked. I only gave 4stars because the bathroom is very small and not handicap accessible. But don't let that dissuade you from ordering this wonderful pizza from private owners and enjoying it in the comfort of your own home. read more

One of my favorite places to go for pizza if not the best! I like their plain pepperono pizzas the best.

Saturday, August 13 2016, my family went to Castaways and we were very very disappointed. Not only did our waitress not treat us very well, there were fish bones in every bite of both my parents fish. The fish tasted as if it was fried in three week old grease. Of course, we weren't rude but expressed our concern to the waitress at the cash register, and her reply was "sorry." We didn't even eat our meals, and there was nothing done about our terrible food and service. My family and I will never go back. Terrible place to eat. read more

Great food. I recommend trying the Stromboli, but they have quite a variety on the menu.

Hit or miss. Orders for family and myself run the gambit of the whole menu. Perch can be flaky or greasy. Great wings. My personal "Go To" is the calzone, especially for takeout. I've had it on par with some of the best, if they could just nail down the consistency. The latest calzone I ordered was horrible. Not only was the crust tough, but they made it in the shape of a stromboli. It also lacked the usual abundance of fillings. When I picked up the order the staff opened the box and I commented about the mistake and was told that the ricotta, pepperoni, sausage,black olives and mushrooms were there, just a mixup with the shape. When I got home we noticed a big disappointment in the flavor. I gave them a jingle to let the restaurant know about our concerns, the waitress was friendly and told me it was her fault and she was new at the job. She kindly asked if there was anything she could do. When this eatery is ps on the ball, IMO the food is hard to beat. Too good to let one or two bad orders overshadow the times food is great. I recommend giving this place a try. Just wish the kitchen would hit the target with consistency. read more