Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Closed 4:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of LKB M.
    33
    64
    66

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 415 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Iniga Pizzeria Napoletana - Mais

    Iniga Pizzeria Napoletana

    (88 reviews)

    $$

    I really like the pizza I know how to tell a good pizza since my husband is actually from Napoli…read moreand is a chef. I wish in my margherita they would add more basil, tomato and not burnt. Mine was cooked perfect since I told them to add more basil garlic and more sauce The drinks are great. The ambiance is very modern I wish they would had played Italian music to make it authentic. There are so many waiters all very young and they need to be more mindful to come to our table to make sure we are ok we wanted to order more food but our server was ghosting us. We saw many servers eating in the back many pizzas were burnt

    It was a cold night in DeKalb, Illinois. However, it was nice and comfortably warm in Iniga's…read morePizzeria. We decided to drop in since it had just opened, and we wanted to see what they had to offer. If you look at the name "pizzeria napoletana" you may get the idea that this isn't Pizza Hut. It isn't. This is (according to my wife who has been to Naples in Italy) pizza the Napoletanese way. Thin crusts, interesting toppings, and different than mainstream American pizza. When we arrived we were promptly greeted at the door as we walked in, and given a choice of bar or dining room seating. We selected the dining room. Both areas were warm and comfortable, with the usual things in the bar (big screen TV) and dining room (art on the walls, nice tables and chairs, nice booths). We started with the Bagna Cauda, which was delicious. It seemed to be a little light on the garlic compared to my friend's version of the dish, but it was still good. It was served with bread, fennel, pepper and zucchini for dipping. It could have fed 4. For pizzas, my wife ordered their Margherita Verace, and I ordered their Puttanesca pizza. The Puttanesca had green olives, brown olives and white anchovies. The crust was very thin - so thin that I ended up cutting this with my knife and using my fork. I couldn't even fold it - the crust is very soft. I tried my wife's Margherita Verace, and it was similar in crust. It had lots of good stuff on it, and tasted good. Drinks were reasonably sized. I had a glass of wine which was fresh, and my wife after trying to order (and pronounce) Raganrok found that they were out of the sweet mead, so she went with a Negroni instead, which she said was quite good. The bathrooms were clean, but chilly in temperature. I hit the hot air hand dryer as I walked out in an effort to warm up the space. Clean, all fixtures worked, and well kept. The question boils down to this: Are you willing to experience pizza the way it was originally made - or not. If you are willing, you should try this place out. If you aren't willing - well, that's on YOU to change. You're missing a lot.

    Zana's Wood Fire Pizza - Athena (sun dried tomato garlic pesto, roasted mushrooms, smoked prosciutto, mozzarella cheese)

    Zana's Wood Fire Pizza

    (35 reviews)

    I enjoy Sicelian pizza, my wife iffy about it, but we both strongly suggest more ingredients on it…read more A single piece of sausage on a slice, and other scant ingredients didn't cut it. Bread tasty, drink offerings good with beers, wines, cocktails and soft drinks. Server super good and helpful. Inside felt bare and dark- with poor lighting. We want you to make it- step it up please! Others I've about Zana's have similar comments.

    My wife and I decided to give this place a shot after hearing people talk about how great this…read moreplace is! We went for dinner on the Sunday after Thanksgiving and it was relatively empty (as expected after the holiday weekend). Even with it being empty, we were still greeted with a smile and were seated right away. Our server was very nice, too! We ordered the chicken wings to start and wow, it was pretty spicy! Nowhere in the menu did it say it was spicy but my wife and I still liked it a lot. Packed a good punch but it wasn't unbearable. It was nice and crispy as well and they were fairly big. You also get 6 in an order. I ordered the Athena and it was very tasty! The crust was really thin and the dough was cooked just right. Not so soft but also not very firm! Every bite had a great amount of topping so you weren't just biting into one topping or not at all. As for the cheese pizza, it was decent. Not a ton of flavor happening and was honestly surprised their house red sauce was pretty mild in flavor. My wife might try the Bianca next time but isn't sure how she would feel about the ricotta cheese. Overall, it was a great experience! The place was well lit and very clean. The staff was very attentive and friendly. The food was still very delicious despite the cheese pizza being just ok. We'll definitely come back again!

    Dough Brothers Pizzeria

    Dough Brothers Pizzeria

    (45 reviews)

    $

    We don't order pizza often but when we do, it's always from Dough Bros…read more And we're always been pleased.... Until last night. Very disappointed!!! I don't believe my order was complex but, I like my pizza the way I like it. I'm particular about it... I like extra sauce, easy cheese & well done. We ordered a 12" pick 5 While it had the toppings requested, I ALWAYS ask for extra sauce & it barely had any at all. Like literally NONE. Almost as if I said easy or no sauce- which my receipt shows I did not. It was extremely dry & flavorless as I also always request slightly well done. One piece for us both (in fact it was 2 bites for me) removed the toppings to see a couple specs of red & in the trash it went. Not sure what's going on in the unit at the end of the strip, but it was a madhouse & made parking a bit of a challenge... I probably would've opted for delivery had I known that. However!!! I WILL say the checkout/pick up process once made it in, was smooth, fast & the staff was friendly. You'll see by my reviews, I'm NOT a repeat constant bad reviewer. I personally always check out reviews before trying somewhere & when I see negative ones... I'll click on that person & when I see NOTHING but bad reviews- I take those reviews with a grain of salt because the person obviously is never happy & has nothing good to say about anything... I give praise when it's deserved but I also have to give a thumbs down also once in a while when it's deserved as well. Better luck next time I hope....‍

    Not great. Fundraiser, so they were busy. However, 40min wait b/c of a fundraiser. Great. Nice…read morecommunity involvement, but be staffed and prepared and don't let quality suffer. We've been before and we're happy. But this trip stunk! Regular crust overcooked and brown/burnt on top. Thick crust overcooked with very inconsistent sauce. 1/4 of beer nuggets were overcooked chunks. $65 was a little much on sub-,sub-par pizza.

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...