Stopped by on Sunday for a late breakfast, had the steak quesadilla with scrambled eggs. Very good…read more Service was fast and friendly.

We have driven past here a few times, I follow them on facebook (which is a good idea) and today we…read morefinally stopped in. The place is quite big, if you see a full parking lot, don't worry, between the large bar, restaurant area and patio, you will find a place to sit. We went for Taco Tuesday. All of the food is great! The quesadilla had a lot of cheese and chicken, his taco's were as full as you could get them. Just because it says Taco Tuesday does not mean they only serve tacos. They have a great selection of Mexican food on Tuesdays. It was hard for me to choose, but I finally decided on a quesadilla for $9.50 and added rice and beans for $1 each. My husband chose the taco place for $10. Sour cream is an extra $1, salsa $.75. Bailey our server was great, she was spot on. Every employee greeted you with a smile and a hello. It is a nice atmosphere here, very friendly. Upon leaving, there were a couple at the bar that said goodbye and to have a nice night and chatted with us for a little bit. I am thinking they are regulars, It is so nice to have people do that and you never saw them before. Anyway, while we were there someone ordered spaghetti and meatballs, that is something I want to get from there. I almost asked if I could get a picture. 3 good size meatballs. We will definitely be back. Side note, we always go out early to avoid crowds and wait times. We were there around 4:30ish.

Wow I'm from Chicago & we know pizza! This place is close to me & ordered a Buffalo Chicken style…read morepizza mildly hot. So tasty I couldn't stop eating it. The chicken was great & pizza crispy & thin wow Nonna's you get it. The wait staff very nice & accommodating parking free & large lot , even have a free standing bar in separate area. Saw a ton of families there *****

I don't understand the hype. I've tried this place a few times and I continue to be disappointed…read more My husband ordered a salad with his entree and the lettuce came out black/brown and wilted. He sent it right back. The waitress never apologized. She never bussed our table throughout the dinner- we actually just started stacking our plates on an empty booth behind us to make room. The pizza sauce is too sweet, and I'm not a fan of the cracker crumb crust. Prices are pretty high ($3.50 for a soda???). And there's quite a smell when you walk in that I can't figure out what it is.

Holy delicious. One of the best meals I've had in all of my days. If you find yourself coming…read moreacross the depot on a Tuesday, you must stop and try the chicken pot pie. Only available in the winter time.

Really good fish fry! Drinks are strong at a reasonable price. Definitely small town vibes. Service…read morewas great & they had live music.

Always great pizza. Love them. Best in Caledonia I think. Great delivery too. Also fabulous ice…read morecream concoctions!

Ordered through UberEats and made the silly assumption that a Roast Beef Dinner at a restaurant…read morethat has "Steakhouse" in the name would be cuts of a roast. Nope, it was the same beef that goes in a sandwich, curly thin slices only in gravy sauce, served with mashed potatoes that had no flavor and would drip off the fork. I couldn't believe that anyone would even consider calling that a Roast Beef Dinner.

I have gone to both Nonna's locations before & the pizza here falls in line with what they were…read moreproducing at either. Yes I am aware the old Caledonia one & Sturtevant have different owners. This new location is closer to the Sturtevant location in selection. Very good selection & wow the prices are very reasonable.....VERY!!! Not te that the reviews from before June 2026 are from the "old" carry out only Caledonia Nonna's Pizzeria. Came here for a Friday lunch with friends. Wait staff was very friendly to us considering it was a meet up with two couples both with 5-6 month old daughters. You ca get a filling meal plus take 1/3 home for $15 per person. I got the Calzone, you can't get them at many places that even sell pizzas. Nostalgia from when I was young. It was great size, filling, 3 toppings for $15. No up charge for getting 2 meats. Very good. Took 1/3 of it home for dinner later, was still delicious. My wife got the Buffalo Chicken Salad & it was a massive salad. Lots of chicken. Even after finishing just a little (our daughter kept getting fussy or jealous so we had to split our time holding her), when putting into the to-go container it filled to the brim of that. Our friends got the small pizza & a pasta with meatballs. Each had great portion sizes. Heck the small pizza seems expensive but when you think about how it can be a personal pizza & you just take 1/3 of it home, it is a great deal. Great place!!! Waitress was very nice to us & accommodating. Place is big inside. Ironically when the old DeRango's was here, we came here for carry out 4x but never once even peaked inside the restaurant portion. Interior was larger than I expected. Only possible negative was that it took at least 5-8 minutes from when we walked in for any person to walk from outside of the kitchen to the restaurant to notice there were people waiting to be seated. They only had one waitress since it was only lunch & she did a great job of managing all 6-8 tables of guests, but the hostess must do double duties between carry out & hostess. Maybe just add some sort of bell or noise that detects when someone enters & exits.

My spouse and I shared the antipasto salad and a medium sausage, mushroom, etc pizza--both were…read moreexcellent. North Racine needed a quality Italian restaurant; this is it -- highly recommend Sam & Will's. They also have a decent selection of affordable wine and beers; along with a FULL BAR.

We live on the far west side of Racine in Mt. Pleasant so this is our most frequent go to for Pizza…read moreand lasagna. Their chicken is very good too. Yes, we like Wells Bros. too but carry out from there is cold by the time we get home. For warm satisfying family pizza gatherings, it is close and excellent.

A quick pick up spot for pizza and in my opinion one of the best pizza in Racine! You won't be…read moredisappointed by the pizza and service here. It's carry out only but the waiting lobby is clean and bright.

So sad to see that they have retired and permanently closed this location. I wish I had given them…read morea 5 star review sooner. I live in Racine, and I have enjoyed their pizza since we moved here in 2019. Like many Southeastern Wisconsiners,I am an Illinois transplant, the land where the best pizza was born, so it's often hard to find comparable or even acceptable pizza elsewhere. Needless to say, I am very sad that DeRango's Pizza Palace will no longer be a contender for Friday night pizza night :'( I wish them well in their retirement years!

The BEST Lasagna is RACINE! Yes, I tried all the locations around Racine and I still can't find…read moreanything better than this! There pizza is good, but the Lasagna is the best with Garlic Bread + Bread and butter! Always keep coming back, great job at filling it up and keeping the taste the same goodness!

Worst sub I ever had. I told him a little mayonnaise and a little French dressing and what I got…read morewas a mayonnaise in French dressing sandwich one of the worst sub sandwich I have ever had and I remember back in the day Jerry had the best and the older ladies after him, but this place won't make it for another two years I guarantee that

Absolutely fantastic New owners are Rocking it!…read moreKeep up the great work! Everything is great and they have more options!