In all fairness I remembered the garlic bread from when I was a kid traveling to Marquette for the Fourth of July. It was our first dinner spot on the trip (plus a few repeats) since then. The service is always great, food is always hot, and the kitchen/restaurant is always clean. The dishes are made differently from other restaurants with an influence from southern Italy where the owners Grandmother was from. The baked pasta is a mix of savory, well seasoned, and yummy pasta and a hot dish. Perfect for after a ski trip or rainy day. I am also a fan of the antipasto salad. It has a great crunch, tastes fresh, and is cold (feeling like they prepare it and bring it out right away). Honestly, I ate too much because it was so good . This last trip, Heaven, was our waitress. She was friendly, personable, and had an excellent memory for our experience. All of our food came out hot and together. The restaurant was packed full of people. Highly recommend for anyone staying, stopping, or existing in town. read more

Casa Calabria - Garlic - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

See all

I was extremely disappointed. My food was expensive, cold, flavorless, and definitely not fresh. The chicken parm was a heated up frozen patty. The marinara sauce was watery. There was a $6.50 charge to add chicken to my fettuccine? Outrageous. Especially, when my grilled chicken strips were served cold. 60 dollars down the drain. I wouldn't recommend Casa Calabria to anyone. read more

See all

Food was excellent. I would have given them 5 stars but service was very slow tonight. It's not normally that slow... to give them a little leeway, they did have a group of 40 come in right after us. Regardless, is definitely go again. I didn't get a picture of the bread nuts so yummy! read more

See all

Wife and I stopped in tonight. Used to be a local favorite. Wow things have changed. 10.00 for a salad. Fine comes with a garlic bread. 13.00 for a small lasagna. Fine comes with a garlic bread. Oh wait. Nope one bread for both. Salad was so bland. Lasagna was okay, not what it used to be. I would have said something, however some things are not worth it. Will not be back and not going to recommend to business colleagues. read more

Casa Calabria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

See all

There is a large parking lot on the side of the building. We walked in around 5 on a Friday and it was immediate seating. Our waitress was friendly and very knowledgeable on the menu, and honest with her favorites along with details why. The lighting is very relaxing and the seating is well spread out. It give the classic Italian restaurant vibes. The restaurant filled up quickly after we ordered. The garlic bread was exactly what I hoped for. Very buttery on the outside, well seasoned, and a very light dense bread beneath the toasted outside. The soup was well seasoned, a pinch on the salty side, but not much body to the soup. The sautéed mushrooms had a lot of flavor and paired well with my meal. The Sicilian steak was not much different than a traditional filet. I did ask for rare cooked, and it was more medium- medium well. *not pictured- spinach artichoke dip. It was delicious because it was not runny, seemed very fresh and was served with bread. read more

See all

Came for an early dinner one afternoon when it was not busy at all. We were immediately seated and service was very quick, friendly, and helpful. Atmosphere is very typical of an American-Italian restaurant. However, if you are looking for good Italian food- this is not the place. While all dishes were hot, fresh, and adequate portioned- everything was flavorless. There was nothing authentic about this Italian restaurant. The garlic bread was decent. Pizza puffs were also not bad. Bruschetta was average for an American bruschetta... Pasta Milano had so much potential and sounded so good but was totally bland. Also ordered the chicken parm and didn't even bother to take a picture. It was just sad. Overcooked pasta with a breaded chicken patty on top. It was almost school cafeteria level. Overall, we were very disappointed. read more

See all

Excellent food - most with small or large portions. The garlic bread was the best I ever had and I wish I had eaten more of it (I was too full from my stuffed shells) Service was as expected - same throughout the Marquette area (from Chicago, so not at that pace). The inside was beautiful and well laid out. All the staff was really nice and cared about our experience. Highly recommend! read more

So after my last review, the husband and I have had three LOVELY, FANTASTIC meals. It seams as the owners, and all the staff have REALLY gotten back to their original wonderful standards. So please enjoy this restaurant and I can't wait for my next visit!!! read more

Food was overpriced. Expected much more flavor and better presentation. Ordered lasagna with meat sauce and side salad. Garlic bread had no garlic taste. Minimal meat in sauce and sauce not tasty. Way too much cheese. Salad was lame. Iceberg with a few chunks of tomato. Can't they add a few other veggies or toppings? Balsamic dressing was good. Service was good. I won't be back. read more

Out of towner, but always on the hunt for great eats where the locals go. Two different friends recommended Casa, and later I saw a wall sign in an NMU building. So that had to be the universe sending me straight to some good Marquette eats. Thank you, universe! Casa didn't disappoint. It was a Saturday night, and NMU's football and hockey teams both hosted big rivals. We did have to wait about thirty minutes for our table. Add in the pandemic related shortages of staff (be nice to your servers!), and that meant another twenty minutes of waiting after we'd been seated. It happens. Fortunately Casa's got a great bar where we rode out our first wait over glasses of Lambrusco and college football on the big screens. We'd already studied the menu by the time we reached our table. Ordered tenderloin tips as well as the ribeye, both medium rare (because why else?!). Steaks were cooked perfectly and seasoned with a mouth watering Italian blend that I'm sure they won't reveal. Only thing was, my ribeye wasn't as marbled or "melt in your mouth" like most ribeyes I've ever had. The cut was tougher than a marbled ribeye, more like a sirloin. But our server insisted it was ribeye, and it still tasted great. I did enjoy it. We also added some pasta sides, and these were tasty. But the star of the show is Casa's GARLIC BREAD. This stuff'll downright bring a tear to your eye. Order the regular and add a side of marinara sauce for dipping. (We did try the mozzarella covered variety, but we loved the regular more--don't mess with the original!) We gobbled up the pieces that came with our entrees and ordered MORE. Mmm. Split another bottle of Lambrusco and called it a meal. We left stuffed and satisfied. I'd go back! :-D read more

Casa Calabria - Sipping a red while waiting for a table! - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

The ambiance was nice, the service was good. The food was subpar. We ordered shrimp as a side. 6 shrimp for 12.99. They were covered in Montreal Steak seasoning. This was ordered for a child so I feel the server should have suggested that it probably wasn't a good choice. The red sauce tasted like a school cafeteria lunch menu. I ordered the large Antipasta salad. It contained chopped lettuce, a green olive, a black olive, one slice of pepperoni, a quarter of a slice of salami and 2 chunks of tomato. 15.99. It was the worst excuse for an Antipasta salad I've ever ordered. I think the Alfredo sauce was straight out of a can from Dollar General. This is an upscale restaurant and they don't make their own sauce??? The bill came to 225.00 for 2 children and 4 adults. We were very disappointed to say the least. read more

Charming atmosphere, efficient wait staff, delicious garlic bread! Dinner was a generous portion, and was excellent. We would definitely recommend. read more

Great service, excellent food. We went here for my daughter's birthday from out of town. Everybody in the restaurant seemed to be having a good time and we did too. excellent option for very good Italian food. For the life of me, I cannot understand the negative reviews. read more

Great food good atmosphere lasagna was very, very good and lots of cheese with it brother that came with the bill was a little salty, but it had a lot of butter and it was good read more

Stuffed shells with a side of mushrooms - cost me 40.00. The sauce was good. There were only five slices of mushroom on my dish. The side was 4.50. The dish was in a bowl and like soup. Terrible place I will never go back read more

I had the char grilled pork and stuffed shells with Alfredo. To die for Wife had the lasagna. Wonderful. Excellent Get the Grand Traverse resiling local wine Great good great service read more

The service was so so, the attention to detail was non existent, had to get up from the table to get someone to wait on our table of 7, the salads were good except the Caesar made with iceberg lettuce, The minestrone was good, the garlic bread was very good. The meatball sandwich was not good. The lasagna, which most of us had was probably the worst I've ever had. Basically a glob of melted mozzarella with meat sauce served in a bowl. Extremely salty and unlike any lasagna I've had. I would go back but only order spaghetti but not the one baked in a bowl. read more

Very disappointed! We've been coming here for years and it was always our favorite stop whenever we were in town. Not anymore after our dinner there two nights ago. I ordered a filet medium well and it was so well done I took it home and gave it to our dog. My husband's steak was better but still lacked flavor and his lasagna was a waste of money. Nearly all cheese with little sauce and again, no flavor. Even the garlic bread was disappointing! These were our usual orders and the quality has greatly decreased and we don't plan to return as a result. Not sure what changed but it's definitely different now, and not in a good way. read more

The food was just so-so....we ordered an antipasto salad which was a joke, barely anything in it. The meatball sub was huge. We skipped eating the bread from it( way too much bread) and just ate the meatballs, which were delicious. The service was slow, it was very busy that night. When we asked for a sharper knife, our server looked at us like we were serial killers and said she'd have to check with the manager! The place itself was nice, like a typical Italian restaurant. read more

LOVE this place. Great pizza, FANTASTIC pasta, great bread, service, LOVE it all. Delivery or dine in. It's the best!!

The ambiance is nice and it looks like they would be legit. However I am convinced that they took a piece of frozen tv dinner breaded chicken and set it atop subpar spaghetti marinara. Chicken parm and spaghetti both lacked flavor and the chicken Parmesan was not crisp at all. I think they let it thaw to long after removing it from the tv dinner package and then didn't cook it long enough... Breading was soggy and the whole piece was like a rectangle chicken nugget. So disappointed because to make matters worse the garlic bread tasted great so I doubled down on that and hope I didn't cause arterial damage. read more

Stopped here after local recommendations. Ordered a 4 ounce filet steak for $28. When it came it was served alone on a bread plate! I asked the server why no potato or vegetable? She said the entrees come with soup or salad and you already have your salad. I was aghast to be served a piece of meat on a small plate...I put it on my salad plate to look like a meal and wound up ordering mushrooms as a side! My husband ordered a pizza pasta bake that was small and lots of cheese, he said it was nothing special. Minus the wine, $60 for a small pasta dish, and a 4 oz. steak with (extra) mushrooms I added, for I think $8, (that does not come with the steak), and salad, no vegetable or potato, was way overpriced. No amount of garlic bread can cover up the portion sizes. I suggested she let the mgr./owner know. I doubt he would care considering some of the reviews I have recently read. If Marquette thinks this is the #1 Italian restaurant...you've been duped! read more

Casa Calabria - Small bread plate that steak was served on vs. Salad plate. - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

See all

Olive Garden's more expensive, slow serviced, sister. I have been coming here occasionally for years for a few guilty pleasures on their menu (heavily buttered chunk of garlic bread), but just now realizing at how laughable this place actually is. For the prices this place charges you would at least expect to have good service and good food. Unfortunately, the service is clouded by the slow bar and kitchen, and the food speaks for itself. Don't normal pasta dishes simmer in the pan with the sauce? Just not my type of place. They are clearly cutting corners and by the reviews on here they don't seem to care. It's also always jam packed inside like sardines, still don't know why, but I guess everything tastes better when it's drowning in butter and cheese. If you're craving cheese and marinara, just grab a pizza roll from Lake Superior Pizza Subs--now THAT hits the spot. read more

See all

While the service was good, the food was awful. Spouse got the lasagna, it was served in a bowl, swimming in sauce with not much actual lasagna. Our daughter orederd the stuffed shells and it was the same as the lasagna. I had to send my simple, spaghetti and meatballs back. While the sauce was hot, the pasta was barely warm and rubbery. My replacement was much the same. Thought about sending it back again, but didn't bother. read more

Food was great, atmosphere was subdued, and the service was excellent. The filet was cooked to perfection. The spaghetti with meat sauce was delicious. I'll be back. read more

We were a party of 4 including two kids, staying at the landmark inn while on vacation in the UP. Found this doing a yelp search, we were very impressed! We ordered lasagna (large portion), pepperoni topped pasta bake, spaghetti/meatballs, and kids pasta plain. The lasagna was huge, enough for the heartiest appetite. Pasta Bake also plenty for one. The garlic bread is amazing and goes well with the leftover meat sauce. Service was top notch, often checking in on us and helpful with the menu. Also $8 for a carafe of house wine--can't beat that! The star of the dinner may have been the Mackinac island fudge brownie cheesecake. You must have this treat. So good. We were very glad to top our day off with a wonderful meal here. If ever in town or at NMU, highly recommend this establishment. read more

We ordered a large house special pizza and an order of bread. The pizza was terrible! Canned mushrooms, the sauce was sub par. The world famous bread use to be dynamite, and so buttery that it would glisten! The bread we received was so dry and had barely any butter on it. It used to be a treat to go to The Casa for dinner, and unfortunately their food has gone down hill. On a good note, their waitress staff was pleasant. read more

I loved the lasagna I had here, the bread is amazing. Our service was great too. I like the Italian ambiance

Amazing food and amazing staff!!! would recommend! very nice place to have dinner if your looking for something a little different. wonderful place! read more

So it's cold, cloudy and probably raining, you're probably in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. You really need some hot, hearty, rib sticking food and you feel like Italian. This is the place. My daughter suggested this one after talking to some people around campus. He hit this place for dinner on Friday night and it was packed. Surprisingly, we were greeted and got a table for 5 right away. I checked out Yelp just to see what people were suggesting. We got drinks right away and ordered a garlic bread appetizer. We figured it would be pieces we could share amongst the group. Nope. I big honking piece of bread. The waiter knew we were looking at sharing it. He neither mentioned it being one big piece or offer to bring it cut up. We hacked away at it with the butter knife he gave us. It was really difficult as the yelp reviews are correct. This thing is bread floating in a butter bath. I went with a large chicken parmigiana and my daughter had fettuccine alfredo with shrimp. My wife ordered lasagna. Mine was delicious and my daughter enjoyed hers, but my wife wasn't so pleased. Unfortunately the reviews here are true too. She couldn't eat it and swapped me plates. It's like a little crock pot of cheesy grease. If you stir it around enough you will find some pieces of noodle. Now I wasn't gonna let a crock of mozzarella grease beat me so, I fought my way through to the end. I finished it and it was really good. I say that because I LOVE CHEESE. I have to admit some bites I choked on because the cheese was so thick. Now I know it sounds like I'm complaining, but I'm not really. The food was really good. The staff was polite and the prices are decent. I read the reviews and ordered what I did anyway. I can't blame anyone else for that. I'll be back up here at NMU again. I will crave Italian again. I will come back here again. And yes..... I'll probably order lasagna and garlic bread. Again. read more

Great food and great service. I have never had a disappointing dish here, all the menu items are great from the pizza to the gnocchi to the steak. read more

This place is to be avoided at all cost Terrible service ,waited 1 hr for a pizza It arrived terribly over spiced Wife and I took 1 bite and declared it inedible Upon informing the staff they were rude They smirked when they offered us the opportunity to wait another hr for a replacement. ....this is a bad restaurant Beware they have a low health dept rating It's listed on yelp below 50 out of 100 Poor management and employees are treated like toilet paper. Never ever again will I eat at this unsafe and poorly run establishment. read more

I have enjoyed Casa Italian since I was a child. Whenever we're in town we try to at least get some of their decadent garlic bread and some pasta. When we had to plan a woodsy wedding during the pandemic, the Casa graciously set us up with our own room (the bar side of the restaurant) and fed our little group in lieu of a reception. Everyone was happy with their meals and the price was far more reasonable than what we would have paid back home (near Detroit). I also want to add that Casa is where our extended family had dinner together the night my dad passed away. As a family-owned restaurant, they were kind and sensitive as we sought some comfort food and shared memories in our shock. Thank you, Casa, for always taking care of our family and feeding us well in good times and bad. We will be back! read more

Great experience as usual! The place was packed so it took about 15 mins to be seated and a bit to order but not surprising for the amount of people in the place. The food was amazing. I got the pasta milano. It was perfect. The waitress was amazing. Great place as always! read more

Casa Calabria - Pizza Puffs - Amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

See all

The best Alfredo I've ever had. The bruschetta was very different then I've had in the past but was uniquely delish.

I'd like to give a big thanks to Hanna she was so nice, she made everything better, our drinks, our food, and made us have the best dinner ever,I want to give a hundred stars thanks so much Hanna p.s have a great day! read more

Not only is the food good, but the bartender (Sofia) makes one of the BEST Old Fashions I've ever had. Highly recommend!

The food is amazing and fairly priced! Service was great! Stopped in on our honeymoon because it was recommended by a local, do not regret stopping. read more

Casa Calabria - Pizza Near Me - Marquette, Michigan

We came in on Wed evening early. Waitress was nice but a bit overly confident. I ordered steak tips med rare with a side salad with the supposed famous Italian dressing, I also opted for a side of sauted mushrooms. The steak was OVERDONE, the mushrooms were like rubber and COST $17 REALLY????? The salad was not a side but an antipasta. I don't eat processed meats or cheese. It was extremely OVERDRESSED. Very oily. Will never return or recommend. read more

We had a reservation for 7pm...they didn't have our reservation (we had the confirmation email) we waited almost 45 minutes and had to go up twice before being seated. It was another 20 minutes before our poor waitress came over and asked if someone had take care of us...after she took our order, she came back about 10 minutes later and said they had no fettuccine (3 of our party ordered it). After picking another pasta, we FINALLY get our food...the re ordered pasta was STONE cold...we had to get our waitress' attention and she took it back to the kitchen...the rest of us had basically finished our meal before the replacements arrived! Our waitress was amazing but the manager did not show his face ONCE to even apologize for the wait, the food or anything!! Totally disappointed!!! read more