While the food presentation was great I can't say the same about how my Chicken Parmesan tasted. It was as if the chef forgot to add a pinch of salt. I tried the lamb shank too and I can easily say, I've had better. As for the drink, I had the naughty neighbor IPA which was really good The service on the other hand was acceptable and the staff were very attentive and polite. Overall, the restaurant gives a high class vibe and you can see that in how the guests are dressed too. read more

See all

It is a small place but mighty in service and food selection This is the first time I have had no complaints here. This place had a good ambiance for a date night read more

See all

We had an excellent meal today: four people, starters were fresh and delicious, particularly the leek and potato soup was exceptional. Mains we chose were short ribs, mushroom risotto, absolutely delicious: two of us couldn't finish the portions they were so generous. Ambiance was perfect, waitstaff attentive and gracious. Such a memorable meal, we will definitely be back! Highly recommend! read more

Food and drinks were great! Service was wonderful and the outdoor patio seating was nice for a perfect evening! Would definitely visit again. read more

I would give this place 3.5 stars. It was busy when we came in but there were still a few free tables so we got seated right away with no reservations (Saturday dinner). We ordered the risotto balls for appetizer and they also brought a bread basked with an olive oil and balsamic vinegar plate that had been pre-poured. I wish they had olive oil and balsamic vinegar bottles for every table. My husband enjoyed the risotto balls as they were quite dense. I had the seafood pasta and the flavor was good once I squeezed my quarter lemon into it. The squid in it was a bit chewy which I had seen as a comment in another review so I didn't finish it. If I come back, I will order something else. The service was friendly, professional and prompt. No complaints there. The Reese cheesecake was delicious. read more

See all

The ambiance was cozy and calm. The food looked great but taste was just okay - Nothing I'll be returning for. The owner.. weird. Lacked boundaries with personal space. Made uninvited conversation and comments about physical characteristics of people at our table. He is definitely "off". read more

Casa Americo - Lamb w/ mashed potatoes - Italian Near Me - Milton, Ontario

See all

Food was great, desert even better. We sat outside and had a wonderful experience. Look forward to coming back.

The food was good, however the service was awful. The fact that other customers had to notify the owner/server that we were clearly being ignored says a lot. We were ignored from the time we entered to when it came down to getting the bill. Maybe the owner needs to get some lessons from chik fil A on what customers service really looks like read more

FOLLOW US @roastdreviews on INSTAGRAM FOR MORE! RESTAURANT: Casa Americo WHAT I ORDERED: spinach risotto Atmosphere: the dim lighting and small, open-concept space is a little crowded at times, but is still comfortable. Taste: when I feel like Italian, this restaurant is my go to. Their risotto (no matter what kind) is rich, creamy, and delicious. It is perfectly cooked, and if you do it right, can last for 2 meals. Service: This restaurant is family-run, and they treat you like a part of their family. I go there fairly often, and they've gone to the trouble of learning my name and my order (always the spinach risotto) Bang for buck: I believe it costs about $18 for the risotto, and considering how filling and tasty it is, the $18 is completely worth it. Extra perks: vegetarian, gluten-free options available. OVERALL ROAST RATING: 4.4/5 #risotto #spinachrisotto #miltoneats #italian #miltonitalian #vegetarianoptions #glutenfreeoptions #italiancuisine #food #familyrun #milton #finedining #mainstreetmilton #patio #mainstreet read more

Casa Americo - Italian Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Tip:- I had taken to go from here a few days back and mind you the food and customer service both here are horrible. read more

This restaurant has a great menu. An assortment and variety of dishes. It also has an amazing ambiance. Bring your family and friends. You will not be disappointed. From the appetizers, to the main dish and desserts. The only problem you will have is, deciding what to eat. It's a must to visit this establishment. The servers and owner will Greet you with a smile and treat you like family. read more

When we walked in, the fact that there was only 1 other table was a warning sign but we decided to try it anyways... The waiter was incredibly pushy, trying to up-sell us on everything and clearly unsatisfied when we opted out of appetizers. For drinks I ordered a cosmo which was super watery. My dinner was okay, I had the fungi risotto, but my boyfriend ordered the gnocchi with prosciutto and it was not good. The gnocchi was tasteless (literally like eating balls of soggy dough) and the sauce tasted like tomato sauce straight out of a can. Then they slapped 2 pieces of the saltiest prosciutto I've ever tasted right on top. On top of that, our food took forever to come out and is honestly way overpriced! They advertise themselves as fine dining Italian... it's not even close. I would not recommend. read more

disgusting, not fresh, chef boyardi kinda food dont waste your money nor time!!! The owner is an idiot, he is arrogant and has no social skills at all!!! would give it a zero star if I could!!! read more

The ambiance, the food quality and the service are good, but the price they charge for the food quantity they serve is too high. read more

Casa Americo - Inside - Italian Near Me - Milton, Ontario

See all

The best Italian food I have had in years. Both of our children enjoyed their meal. I will definitely return! read more

Love their food. The seafood pasta and jambalaya are amazing. Really nice dinner spot.

I came here yesterday with some friends and we all had such a great time! As soon as you enter the restaurant, it's classy yet has a homey feeling. All of the staff were very attentive and charming (especially the owner... I'll be back just for his lovely compliments). I ordered a latte, both of my friends ordered cappuccino's, complete with your choice of topping of cinnamon, chocolate, both or as is. As soon as my friend took her sip she claimed this was the best cappuccino she had ever had. Which was unexpected yet delightful. The latte was good, it wasn't the best but it was tasty. Our meal began with complimentary bread and oil, a tradition that has sadly ceased to exist in modern all-alike chain food restaurants. Sad. We then ordered three appetizers to split: 1. Spiedini Di Agnello: These lamb skewers are placed upon a pillow of fresh, mesculin greens with fresh parmesan cheese. The skewers were flavorful but sadly they were cold so I did not enjoy them as much as I would have if they were warm. The mesculin greens were great, there was a light oil and balsamic dressing that went perfectly with the meal. 2. Risotto Balls: These were AWESOME! They are deep fried risotto and cheese balls topped with a tomato sauce. Now, I don't like red pasta sauces but this sauce was amazing, it was such a lovely and fresh compliment to the fried risotto. 3. Antipasto plate: this was a treat, it came with kalamata olives (pitted, phew), fresh parmesan cheese, tomato slices and bocconcini cheese (for anyone who does not know what bocconcini cheese is: it is a very fresh mozzarella cheese and incredibly milky at times) Tip: eat the tomato with the bocconcini, yum! As well as pesto soaked zucchini and eggplant. This was lovely, light and fresh. Everything really complimented each other on the plate. For dessert the three of us shared a piece of tiramisu.. oh my lord. This was heaven on a plate. We are really glad they ran out of carrot cake (our first choice) because we would have missed our chance with this creamy, moist, delicate dessert. All in all. we had a great time at Casa Americo. I would love to come back and explore their menu a bit more, maybe a dinner? This was a wonderful experience and I loved every bite and minute. read more

Casa Americo - The inside - Italian Near Me - Milton, Ontario

See all

Came here for a surprise bridal shower recently (it's the bride's favourite restaurant). The antipasto plate was good, and the bruschetta was loaded with goat cheese, onions, tomatoes and balsamic reduction. My main was a nice thick cod fillet and dessert was of course creme brûlée. There was a wait for dinner, but all mains were brought out at once. One of our waiters was hilarious throughout the night, and they were attentive without being invasive. Nice location on Milton Main Street too; nice patio out front. So, I'd call it pseudo-Italian, although that's the case with most Italian restaurants :) read more

See all

Came her to celebrate our daughters 22nd birthday with some family on a Wednesday night, was so pleased with our choice! The menu had a great selection of items, something for everyone! The service was fast and friendly and the ambiance was lovely. The food itself was much better than I expected (28 years in hospitality and kitchens has jaded me a little!). The appetizers were excellent, we ordered a number of different ones for the table, the calamari was a crowd pleaser as were the crab cakes, and my youngest is still talking about the Caesar salad two weeks later! Entree's were excellent and everyone cleaned there plates, and portions were more than adequate! Didn't have a chance to try desserts as we had a birthday cake at home to get to, but if dinner was any indication they will be good too! A great spot for a little celebration dinner and would be a great date night dinner spot too! We will definitely be going back! read more

Food was okay, definitely not close to the Italian dining experience you expect for these prices. Service for us was not that great. The waiter seemed to keep missing our table but visited the two ladies sitting right next to us several times. Ambiance was okay. Would be better if tables weren't so close to each other. Felt very cramped in there. read more

Good value. The quality/quantity of food is worth the cost. The overall quality and tastiness of the dishes at Casa Americo is good. Their butternut squash soup in particular is superb. The service is as much as you would expect with a small family owned Italian restaurant. The owner is a very friendly person and I know he's always looking for new ways to improve customer satisfaction. This is a great place to have work lunches or meet your friend for a hearty Italian lunch. Never tried the dinner at Casa so cannot comment on that. read more

Expensive. Not real italian food. More american/italian. Small place. The food is just ok.

I wanted to like this place, I really did. I was invited there for dinner by my in-laws. They reserved a table for 9 about a month ago. When we arrived, the place was packed and we were shown to a table that would have been crowded with 8 people at it. A large table was empty at the front but we were told that was 'reserved'. I guess those people reserved MORE than a month ago? We wedged ourselves into the smaller table and ordered food. ...2 hours later, the mains arrived. By that time, the wine was long drunk, and our appetizers were a distant memory, as they had arrived promptly. The servers ran around trying to be pleasant but they seemed overwhelmed by the number of people in the place. We were told that a lot of the diners had theatre tickets to a nearby event. The food was fine, fresh and hot, but by the time it finally arrived, no one cared anymore. When we asked for the bill, the owner himself came out to deliver it. Finally- an apology for all the waiting and perhaps some free dessert...? Nope, just a story about a group of people who had lunch there today and how great a time they had. Oh-kay... I went upstairs to use the ladies room, which was lovely, newly renovated. I could tell because they didn't have any toilet paper holders, or any toilet paper for that matter (thank goodness for paper towels). When I attempted to wash my hands, the sink didn't work (no one had turned on the water to it). So, all the female diners had dirty hands?!? I'll maybe try again, at a quieter time, but I really felt that the situation could have been handled better. We had hoped to have a pleasant holiday get-together with family, and what we got was a cramped, hungry, tedious evening. it's a pity. read more

I was highly impressed by the service and food at Casa Americo, a cute restaurant nestled in the tiny downtown of Milton. The restaurant had a live piano player the evening I ate there, which added a different vibe to the restaurant...and it was very nice and relaxing. I ordered Gnocchi al Pomodoro con Proscuito. The gnocchi, a food I am typically very particular about, was quite delicious and cooked just right. I also enjoyed a glass of Barolo Fontana Fredda, which was introduced by their nice, but not overwhelming, wine list. I would definitely recommend eating here if you are in the area. The meals were not too overpriced, either. read more

My dad is absolutely crazy about Italian food, so the family took him here for Father's Day. Happily, Casa Americo did not disappoint. My brother ordered one of the specials, a steak, that came out on a sizzling cast iron skillet and sent the other patrons into a jealous tizzy. My penne alla vodka was not so dramatic, but its flavour was bold, bacony and addictive. I ate the entire massive bowl with no regrets (until, of course, the dessert menu came out). The owner is very friendly, funny and active on the restaurant floor, and he visited our table to present my father (and brother!) with a free tiramisu in honour of the holiday. Most of the desserts are not Italian classics - Casa Americo serves a small selection of Cheesecake Factory slices - but that's my only real quibble. read more

I had reservation made for 12 at another establishment. Called them five times over a month to confirm. Day prior they told me I had no reservation. Casa Americo and it's lovely owner accommodated us at the last min. Food was spectacular, ambiance was great. We had the private room upstairs. At the last min they got us in and saved the day. Would recommend this restaurant to anyone and will definitely be back. Oh, sea bass was incredible!!! read more

A fantastic hidden italian restaurant in on main street Milton. This small restaurant has a very casual and relaxing atmosphere and the perfect place for a date night or intimate get together with friends. The staff were extremely friendly and my night was full of laughter the old school staff. The ladies were served first as per tradition and men last, its nice to see the classic style of serving once in a while especially when its unexpected. The appetizers we got were delicious. We got the bruchetta with mozzarella and goat cheese with romaine tomatoes and a balsamic reduction. Our second appetizer was their calamari and it was the best calamari I've had so far! Light and fresh with flavor, the calamari was soft and tender and just melted in your mouthed. For this dish alone I would come back again. My main was the classic chicken Parmesan with gnocchi pasta and vegetables. It was a very large portion so not for the light eaters. The sauce was fresh but I found it bit more acidic for my taste. Otherwise the meal was delicious! I'm glad I found a new italian hot spot restaurant and I'm looking forward to my next visit! read more

We were in Milton on a Sunday night of a long weekend and Casa Americo was one of the few places that were open. So, we were thankful we could find a place to go an eat. The restaurant is certainly nice enough, the gentleman who served us was very charming and the portions were large. Unfortunately we were not blown away by the food. When they served us bread with the meal one of the pieces was stale. The bruschetta which the waiter made sure to convince us to get was so so with almost too much cheese - you could not fully taste all of the tomatoes. I had the Wiener schnitzel which was ok. It was a bit thick and too fried. They served one of us the wrong schnitzel with sauce we did not order and then went and charged us extra for this. Another person ordered an oven baked penne. The dish was a good size but it did not have much flavour and we did not bother to bring the leftovers home which is pretty unusual for my family. The linguine alla Greca was the nicest of the dishes we ordered. So, we were glad it was open and the people were nice. Unfortunately the food wasn't close to the type of Italian food we normally eat. read more

Third time eating here and was second Rate. Halibut special over cooked and tasteless for 28.00 Mentioned to waiter and zero consideration Cappuccino was watered down and foam? Non existent Won't be back Thumbs way down read more

Very impressed with a great Italian joint in Milton. The ButterNut Squash Soup was delicious and the Fungi Risotto (don't recall the correct Italian name) did not disappoint. Great texture and taste! Good ambiance with soft light and music for a romantic evening. Had a lovely chat with the owners and HIGHLY recommend exploring this beautiful spot! read more

This is my type of place! It's a small Italian restaurant with moderately-priced, good quality comfort food. I waited to write this review until the next morning because we had a couple bottles of a very nice red. I enjoyed the Osso-Bucco while my wife orders the mushroom risotto. They were both absolutely delicious with a few extra props to the risotto for being the best that I've ever had. The service is pleasant but watch out for the opener and closer. One of the servers is oozing with charisma and old-world charm and will have you ordering the nicest wines, followed by an after-dinner cocktail before you can say Sambuca. Enjoy! Addendum: Been there a few more times and had a pretty consistent experience. However, went there for our 19th anniversary dinner and were pretty disappointed with the service. Upcharged us on the mashed potatoes and mushrooms (????) with our beef tenderloin. The mushrooms were terrible. Got a bit of attitude from our server and it kind of soured our night. Just putting it out there... read more

I dont indian should make italian food unless they have the heart of making good food ! The fries is definitely from McCain and chicken fingers is also from a bag ! My halibut taste like mud and my salad was rotten and my cucumber were wet . Her gnnocci was from a frozen bag and the veal taste like rubber . Big disappointment ! Pls change how you serve the food !!!!! And definitely will not come back ever !!!!!!!!!!! read more

Amazing service and food was really good! Had the jambalaya - totally recommend! Delicious to the last bite! I'll be back and would highly recommend :) read more

Was at Casa Americo for dinner on Saturday with the family. There were only two other tables seated when we walked in, but by the time we ordered the place was full. Good sign i guess. The staff was great, service was quick, plates were extremely hot, and food tasted good. This was our first time at this restaurant and we were impressed. I ordered the prosciutto-wrapped halibut special which was cooked to perfection. Two of us ordered the seafood pasta which looked and tasted good. Sauce was good (little heavy on the veggies, but that is personal preference). We started with the crab cakes and the diavolo calamari, both thumbs up. The owner/manager thanked us, and also mentioned to us how busy they have been and how they have been on a wait lately. Good for them. Great experience from start to finish. We will be back. read more

Consistently good Italian food, in a casual setting. This is one of my standard go-tos when I can't decide what in the area to have. read more

My family have been coming here since 2014. I've always loved their butternut squash soup. Most of the items on the menu are excellent. Good venue for business meetings. read more

Happened upon this place, very happy we did. The small restaurant handled our walk-in party of 10. The menu was great, I really enjoyed the grilled calamari it's one of my favorite dishes and hard to find a place with it on the menu. Their's was different from anything I've had, but in a good way. The sauce that comes is fantastic. Order extra bread don't waste it. read more

If I could give zero stars, I would. My friend and I visited Casa Americo for lunch last Friday with our two babies (4 months and 9 months). The patio was full but indoors was empty apart from one other table in a far corner so we requested and were seated indoors (restaurant does have highchairs). We ordered drinks / food and as my 4-month old got restless, I started to nurse her at our table. Shortly thereafter, our server (and possibly the owner, though I'm not sure of this) motioned with his hand over his chest and mouthed what I understood to be "do you want some privacy?"; I declined politely. He then came over and said "I would prefer if you didn't do that here"; "that" being breastfeeding my child. I was completely shocked and indicated it was my legal right to breastfeed in public. He then said that he thought it would be polite to the other customers if I did that elsewhere, and further suggested that I should breastfeed in a room upstairs. I told him that it would be more polite to my daughter to feed her when she's hungry wherever I am. My friend and I then started gathering our things and said we were leaving after which he said "you already ordered your food". Another server (possibly another one of the owners) then came over and said we could stay but we indicated that we were not interested in staying. Worst and saddest restaurant experience for me!!! If this has happened to you, I'm so sorry. read more

We were very excited to come to Casa Americo for dinner and I hate to say it, but we were not too happy with it. We got the Risotto balls as an app. My husband loved them but I thought they were wayyyy too salty. We both got the "prime rib" and it 100% was not prime rib. It was steak. We didn't complain about that because it still tasted good. However, I ordered mine med rare and got it well. I told the server and he asked me to cut the other piece to make sure... Not very professional, I'm showing you one piece is over cooked, that's enough. They took it back and brought another one which was perfect. I did have 2 people check to make sure it was OK which was nice. Overall, to spend almost $100 without alcohol and get a mediocre app and "prime rib", we weren't too impressed. read more

"It is a great place for really good Italian food and Italian type service. We were pleased and had a good dining experience. A must visit place!" read more