Cancel

Open app

Search

Captains Three Fisheries

5.0 (3 reviews)

Captains Three Fisheries Photos

Business Info

More like Captains Three Fisheries

Recommended Reviews - Captains Three Fisheries

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Fish is always fresh. People always great. Price is always fair. Been buying fresh fish there for years.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Captains Three Fisheries

Keys Fisheries - World Famous Lobster Reuben

Keys Fisheries

4.0(1.5k reviews)
5.2 mi
•$$

I bypassed the Lobster Ruben, had the conch ceviche and a fried hogfish sandwich, it was one of the…read morebest seafood meals of my life. Bonus points for the bar next door, and having the tartar/cocktail sauce readily available. Their prices are incredibly low for the freshness and quality they serve up. I can't wait to return to the Florida Keys again to eat here.

We stopped here after snorkeling the sombrero reef for lunch. You order at a counter and find a…read moreseat and they call your name when it's ready. You go around the corner to the bar area to order any drinks. We found a spot outside at a picnic table by the marina to eat. The food is fresh but overpriced. The lobster roll was good but had more roll than lobster. The lobster chowder was better than the lobster bisque I had at a different restaurant but still not as good as what I make at home. I tried the famous lobster Rueben. It was toasted perfectly on rye. It was fine but I think the sauerkraut over powers the lobster when the lobster needs to be the star of the sandwich. The beating I had here was probably the coconut shrimp with mango sauce. It was perfection. Deliciously crispy and the mango chutney was perfect with it. After we finished eating we went into the seafood market to check out their fresh seafood selection and grabbed a pie of key lime pie to go which comes in a little tart tin. It was really good flavored and the crust was obviously homemade. Not your typical graham cracker crust which was a nice change.

Photos
Keys Fisheries - Inside the Market!

Inside the Market!

Keys Fisheries - Key Lime Rum Cake~ Highly Recommend!

Key Lime Rum Cake~ Highly Recommend!

Keys Fisheries - The front of the restaurant

See all

The front of the restaurant

Fish Tales Market & Eatery - Cobia fish sandwich

Fish Tales Market & Eatery

4.3(210 reviews)
1.1 mi
•$$

Oh HEY! The best restaurant food down here. Looks small from outside. The people working are flying…read morearound busy. We all got fish sandwiches and a piece of German chocolate cake. Sandwich was killer!!! Cute how they stamp it with restaurant name. Fries were hot and tasty. Grabbed some fresh fish from the case to go. Beautiful selection of fresh fish. Some of the best. Oh don't forget the damn cookie. wooooowww! That thing was like no other cookie. Nice and plump, moist and we all wished we had a few more. Only like $2.50 each which was even more amazing! Go here! You will not regret.

I recently visited Fishtails and unfortunately left quite disappointed. Given how busy the…read morerestaurant was, I had high expectations--but the experience did not match the crowd. I ordered the grouper, which is typically a highlight in the Florida Keys, but it lacked even basic seasoning and fell flat in flavor. The coleslaw was noticeably too sweet for my taste, and the potato salad included green peppers, which is an unusual choice and didn't complement the dish well. The service also left much to be desired. Our waitress was inattentive and provided very little information throughout the meal. Most concerning was that we left a significant portion of our food untouched, yet she never checked in or asked if anything was wrong--something I would expect at any restaurant, especially one as busy as this. Overall, while the atmosphere may draw a crowd, the food quality and service did not meet expectations. For comparison, I've had a far better grouper sandwich at Keys Fisheries Market & Marina, which makes this experience even more disappointing. I hope improvements can be made, as this location clearly has potential. Respond to owner, your response is your opinion, I have no reason to give bad information, if you watched your video as you stated you would have been able to see my friend and I dusguessing the food, also she never refilled our tea as frankly we didn't even drink it all. A good and attentive waitress could have mentioned that it came with coleslaw not to give two portions. It's whatever sir and if you want to get more technical, they grouper was fishy tasting and still had the dark vein line down the filet.

Photos
Fish Tales Market & Eatery - Busy

Busy

Fish Tales Market & Eatery - Half pound of peel and eat shrimp

Half pound of peel and eat shrimp

Fish Tales Market & Eatery - Memorabilia above our table

See all

Memorabilia above our table

Island Fish - Super good oyster

Island Fish

3.8(1.8k reviews)
0.3 mi
•$$

Food was fantastic i had the "petite surf and turf" and it was delicious. Island fish has a great,…read morelively environment. Isabella took great and speedy service of us as well, would definitely return and recommend to anyone around the Marathon area.

We came here for a late dinner and to hopefully catch the sunset. We timed it fairly spot on. They…read moresaid it would be about a 20-25 minute wait but it actually took less than 15 minutes. We got seated inside just as the sun was starting to set. Sadly all the guests that had finished eating right before us decided to walk over to the dock outside the restaurant which just so happened to be the exact viewing location for the sunset so we didn't get any really good photos of it bc there were so many people over there videoing it and taking photos. It was still nice scenery while we waited for our food though. I ordered ceviche to start us off as our appetizer and it was really good. My dinner was a pasta dish with shrimp and scallops. The sauce was supposed to be a white cream sauce but it was really runny. Even adding extra Parmesan cheese to it didn't help thicken it. It tasted ok. Not my best pick. I had a choice of soup or salad with it. I chose their she crab soup and I'm glad I did. It was great. Almost reminded me of homemade chicken and dumplings soup just with crab. I really liked it. I should have stopped with that and the ceviche. My husband got a grouper fish sandwich. He thought it was good but the prices were a bit high for what it was. His fish sandwich was $29. Although good, not worth $29. My pasta definitely not worth the $31. May be a bit of a tourist trap but the food was decent.

Photos
Island Fish - Women's restroom decor

Women's restroom decor

Island Fish - Blackened grouper with seasoned rice and veggies.

Blackened grouper with seasoned rice and veggies.

Island Fish - Dining room

See all

Dining room

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina - Stone Crabs

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina

3.6(996 reviews)
6.3 mi
•$$
Outdoor seating
71 years in business

Every single item was so delicious - from the mojitos, to the tater tot nachos - fresh homemade…read morecrab Rangoon - fried green bean appetizers, to the entrees that were out of this world (flatbread special and the shrimp and tomato pesto special, and while we got several desserts we were so full by the time we left we can't wait to dig into them when we finally have room again! We did try the plantain foster onsite which was GOLD Tracy was our server and was kind, attentive, had amazing recommendations, and elevated the experience that much more! Parking onsite was easy and free, plus tons of parking around the building if needing more, it was busy but we were able to be seated right away. The view was worth a million dollars throughout our meal. There was live music that was enjoyable and just the right volume. Great value for everything we were able to get! Can't say enough good things and can't wait to go back (or try our desserts to go!)

Porky's Bayside Restaurant was a fun, laid back place to hang out and watch the boats come and go…read moreat the marina. The food was great, the service was friendly, and the atmosphere was exactly what we were looking for. It definitely has a bit of a 1970s, rough around the edges, Old Florida vibe, but that's part of the charm. Nothing fancy, nothing pretentious, just a great casual spot for lunch while passing through Marathon Key. At the end of our meal, we watched the kids feeding the fish by the marina, which was a fun way to finish the visit. Great food, great service, waterfront atmosphere, and plenty of character. We'd definitely come back.

Photos
Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina - Coconut Flan

Coconut Flan

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina - Tuna Poke

Tuna Poke

Porky's Bayside Restaurant and Marina - Fried Key Lime Pie

See all

Fried Key Lime Pie

Captains Three Fisheries - seafoodmarkets - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...