My friend and I came here before the year was over. It was a bit busy when I gotten there . She ordered a egg roll to stary off with. I deicded to order a decaffeinated coffee because inside the restaurant it was very cold inside. Not sure if they do have heat sitting near the window or not but I sure wish there was heat. I started off with having chicken Pollo soup which was alright I wish it said what inside the soup . I was happy that it was taco Tuesday so half off tacos. My favorite was the general tso chicken taco. I decided to also get the chicken Pollo the taco was a bit soggy. I also gotten the Rib Eye but it didnt taste like it , it tasted more like steak. The service was a bit slow , other then that everything tasted really good. read more

See all

The ambiance, saves you a trip to Mexico. The folklore is here in every wall and corner. Very nice, attention is professional and I am Having a wonderful dirty martini along with a Mexican-Latin chicken soup that is famous. The best of this restaurant is that they have karaoke on Friday night. It was a complete terrific night, come with your good vibes and connect with theirs! read more

See all

Very tasty tacos and margaritas! We went for their 1/2 price street tacos & 1/2 price margaritas special. Both the tacos and margaritas were great! read more

Cancun Inn - Tacos & margaritas - Mexican Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

The food was pretty good, but the portion size was fairly small for the price we paid. The service was exceptionally slow tonight as it seems there was an event going on. It took about 30 minutes to order and quite some time before we got our food. The guacamole served with the quesadilla was a bit chunky. The burrata taco was good but soggy from all the ingredients. The taco salad was very good. There was live entertainment tonight: Rachel Leeya and Anthony Lorino. They were incredible! read more

See all

I used to go here when Israel owned for 35 + years. his chicken tortilla soup has 30+ herbs and spices. the enchilada sauce on enchiladas is great and his shrimp camarones dishes. all foods great. Fun to eat in or outside. Colorful taco chips served. However, for the new owners, please run your tap water thru a PUR filter as the bleach smell from tap water is nasty. We usually get tap water and a Dos Equis but this tap water has a strong bleach smell. It doesn't take much to buy a pur filteration pitchers then Add bagged Ice from pure water. read more

Had the best meal and service here! Beautiful restaurant, sat on back patio and it's gorgeous. Great place for a small get together. Inside they had live music that made for the best ambiance. The waitstaff was friendly, quick and so caring. The drinks were AMAZING! Best Margaritas I've had in OC. The food was delicious and had great portions. Highly recommend coming here for your next night out. read more

Nice restaurant. Fijita very delicious, many taco choices. Offer free chips while waiting meal. Nice services. read more

Cancun Inn - Fijita Pork House salad Taco Chips for free - Mexican Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

We went to Cancun to have dinner. It was my birthday. When we arrived we were greeted with our usual cocktails made by Ryan. He makes the best cocktails. Someone must have tipped off the staff because everyone wished me Happy birthday. At our table there were a gathering of balloons. It was karaoke night so Martin sang to me. Dinner was excellent as usual. The service is always on point, thanks to Will They made me a plate of strawberries dipped in chocolate with whipped cream for desert. Excellent! Everyone at Cancun Inn always makes us feel special, but tonight they went above board and made me feel like a million dollars on my birthday. Thank you Ryan, Will and all of the staff at Cancun Inn. read more

The staff of friendly and accommodating the food is excellent. I've been coming here for several years and they did change hands last year. I think but it's just the same if not better. I really recommend this restaurant if you like Mexican food. read more

I really wanted to like this place but unfortunately everything I had was not good. The guacamole was premade and no flavor. Super cold and distasteful. The birria taco where dry, the zarzuela was not good and the shrimp rubbery. The plantain where not cooked all the way and the aioli sauce was not good. The mango wings where un flavorful. I can go on and on and on. Not one thing was good. Unfortunately we won't be returning. read more

Wow what an experience! And I mean that--this was not a dinner it was an experience! We met the owner, Israel, very quickly and he was such a character. Very friendly, funny, and if you ask him to do some magic tricks or tell you stories about his life working in Vegas, you'll get quite the treat (and be sure to have some free time to enjoy it). The food was excellent. Homemade chips and salsa to start were on point. Pro tip: ask for spicier salsa to try their other two. The medium salsa was soooo good. We got several meals between us and they were all really good. I got the salmon special with pineapple habanero salsa. The fajitas were also good, as were the fish tacos. Would highly recommend. Can't wait to come back! read more

Always a good time, thanks to Israel and stuff! Great service by will. Great food and drinks! Never make it to dessert. Go! Mike and Carmen read more

Cancun Inn - a man sitting in a theater - Mexican Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

Horrible service and food. Went on 10/12. Waited about half hour to get any kind of service. About 45 minutes in i had to get up and get my own water. Ordered a quesadilla and it was not good. The beans looked like mud. Never again. read more

This place is definitely a hidden gem! They are street tacos are absolutely amazing! The service is beyond friendly, and they make your dining experience a lot of fun! There is both indoor and outdoor seating. The margaritas are absolutely fantastic! I highly recommend this place read more

After reading the great reviews we decided to give this place a try... While the owner and staff were very friendly, I can say I was very disappointed in my meal. I ordered the fajitas, and they came out cold, chicken tasted old and in some weird gravy like sauce?? Usually when served fajitas in a restaurant, they come out sizzling on a hot plate with all the fixings. All that came with it was beans and rice and a small dollop of sour cream. The beans were bland and the rice was flavorless. My daughter got beef tacos and they weren't very good either. My husband ordered enchiladas and they just weren't amazing. Chips were good, warm and fresh. Salsa was meh. I left feeling disappointed and not satisfied and still hungry. There are much better places to eat so we probably won't be coming back anytime soon, unfortunately. read more

I've never got up and left a restaurant before ordering, until we came here last week. I'd been here once before a couple years ago and it was decent. So we came back and within a few mins, we left. The chips were stale and the salsa was wayyyyy too sweet and vinegary. Was afraid ordering anything else would be a complete waste of money. Won't return here. read more

My wife and I had an absolutely wonderful experience on Friday night at the Cancun Inn! While the restaurant has a pristine reputation among locals, the food and atmosphere certainly lived up to the hype. We started with a staple in all of our Mexican meals, a perfectly executed guacamole and freshly fried chips. For our mains, I was enticed by the Carne Asada & Camarones Ajillo main course, which was EXCEPTIONAL (particularly the delectable garlic sauce that highlighted the dish), and my wife was wowed by her flakey, mango-accented founder taco. Just deliciously-elevated Mexican fare. The best part? Meeting the charming owner Israel, who served us complimentary post-dinner cocktails (which were comprised of tequila, amaretto and peach schnapps) that paired wonderfully with our insanely-tasty churros. Israel was a gentleman who immediately felt like a friend we've known for years, and we can't thank him (and his kind, efficient staff) for the 5 star experience. We are so thrilled to have found our new go-to Mexican restaurant! Can't recommend the Cancun Inn enough ... enjoy! read more

Really enjoyed the food. My meat was perfect. Attentive staff. To us this is a hidden gem !

Food was good. Waiter gave me the creeps. Looked miserable. Ambiance was nice. I will give this place another shot and see how it goes.

This place left me slightly disappointed. I did enjoy many things but there were surprisingly many more food related aspects that could be drastically improved. I understand that each patron may experience each restaurant slightly differently and that my experience doesn't necessarily sum up this establishment as a whole. But, I still feel like it's worth summarizing my experience. Positives Great customer service!! Guacamole is tasty Ambience is super warm, inviting, and aesthetically pleasing. Negatives Salsa tastes like canned tomatoes with added sugar The fish tacos are dully seasoned. (And super expensive. It was 22$) Bean sauce tastes like canned beans Pico de Gallo isn't even close to fresh Margarita tastes like water and vodka Maybe I've experienced too many great Mexican food places, but I feel like this restaurant's food can be drastically improved. I would encourage anyone to give it a try for themselves. read more

Cancun Inn - Mexican Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

We ordered food from them through GrubHub. Food was delivered and we ordered plantains two orders. I only gave you four plantains and they charge too much money. They should've gave more food. Also, we ordered steak fajitas and they completely forgot to fulfill the order they didn't even give us utensils, napkins, anything. The chicken dish that we ordered that was OK but they give you small portions that bill for delivery was about $120. It was ridiculous so we call the restaurant they had a waiter personally drive to my house I gave us the steak fajitas utensils I gave us two orders of flan as a courtesyand apologized more of a tourist attraction place I would not order again, was not pleased with the food quality or the portions for the price read more

What a wonderful place to enjoy a Mexican meal. Staff and owners are the best. Food is delicious. Get the garlic soup out of this world. I also got the Chalupas. So yummy. Margaritas are delicious and made perfectly. Garlic Shrimp was really good. All I can say is I can't complain about anything. Can't wait to see them again. read more

Cancun Inn - Steak fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Sugar Loaf, New York

See all

This was a horrific experience. We were served after people thst came n after us. Chios good salsa tasted like ketchup. Everyone had cloth napkins but us . I had to ask for them No vegan options. They made me veggie burritos that tasted terrible. I believe they were cross contaminated with meat as I was sick afterward. My partners food tasted poorly also. Needless to say. We will not be going back. We waited over an hour to neat foe this horrible experience asked for thr check before we were done as we knew it woukd take a long time the waiters were nice however. read more

I called in a small order for take out and spoke with a very kind employee over the phone, when I went to pick it up they welcomed me in and got me my order. When I got home they had included a nice little surprise in my order that I had asked about over the phone but decided to just get sides instead. I thought it was a really nice touch. The food was great and I would happily go back after my small interaction I had with them. They treat you like family. read more

Had a wonderful time at this place! I spoke to a kind awesome gentleman named Will and the food was absolutely stellar! Street tacos are an absolute must. Best service I've had in the 845 and make sure you try chimichangas WILLY STYLE. read more

This restaurant is absolutely the best Mexican food I have ever had. Along with the fantastic food and ambience, this family owned restaurant offers the best hospitality. Should you dine here on your visit to sugar loaf or the surrounding area, consider yourself very lucky! They are well known for their famous sangria and margaritas. The chips and salsa are also excellent. read more

This is a fabulous Mexican restaurant tucked in the beautiful village of Sugar Loaf, NY. The food is wonderful and they make you feel like family. read more

Beware. New owners. We waited 45 minutes for our food that never came. People were complaining they were waiting 20 minutes for their check, their orders were wrong, ect. I wish I could say the salsa and chips were good but I would be lying. read more

The food was delicious and the service was excellent, but the kitchen needs to get its act together. Four of the five of us had practically finished our food before the fifth entree arrived. We took it to go, because who wants to eat alone? The other problem was that there were little bugs flying around us while we ate. Both of these issues are easy fixes. read more

LOVE LOVE LOVEEEEEE I felt at home. So much care into their way of taking orders and caring for the customer. Israel was like a father to me that night. He ordered us chips and salads with house salads on the house and recommended some specials which were to-die-for. Israel also said goodbye to my boyfriend and I with kind words, a handshake and a hug. He is the absolute best!!!! read more

Had been so excited to try this place. The guacamole was inedible and that was the end of the road for me. Half the drinks were good, half were not. Very friendly and attentive service, however, we were out numbered by the staff who literally sat right next to us to eat and carry on conversations. Made us feel very uncomfortable. I was expecting so much more being that this is literally the only restaurant in town. read more

The prior reviews were spot on! HAVE to get the guacamole! Salsa was excelente! Isreal was such a delightful and charming host- he took our order and checked in frequently. Make sure you know what the specials are... We ordered before asking and I missed the fish tacos and the grilled salmon. Well, we'll be back!! Family run and the quality is phenomenal! read more

Seriously, my friend and I came here after a concert at Sugarloaf PAC, the owner introduced himself and told us how great the place was and all the magazines they were mentioned in. He's really sweet, but I didn't need a marketing pitch as we were already there! I have to say though, he was right. Cancun Inn has some of the best Mexican I've ever had, and what a gem to find it in Sugarloaf, NY! I got the enchiladas and a taco, very good! Washed it down with a nice Strawberry/Mango margarita. read more

On the way back to Long Island from a long Upstate trip, I never thought I would stumble across a great Mexican restaurant experience, but that's exactly what happened last night at Cancun Inn in Chester, New York, near Goshen. First of all, the family owners greet every customer like they have been coming here for years. Elba and Israel truly know how to treat their patrons. They filled our table with things to nosh on, as if the chips and salsa weren't already among the best I've sampled with just the right amount of flavor. Entrees, drinks, their rice, beans and vegetables...I must say there wasn't a negative word about anything we put in our mouths. Sit inside or out and enjoy some great food and (perhaps more impressive) some of the most attentive service you will encounter anywhere. El Restaurante Cancun Inn esta MUY BIEN!! read more

This restaurant has new owners and the food is absolutely fabulous. After going there once and being blown away, we have since been back twice, and have made reservations for a party of 12 next weekend. The specialty tacos are homemade and seriously unbelievable - from the mushroom taco, cauliflower taco, short rib taco, chorizo taco, chicken, pulled pork, we tried them all and one was better than the next. I could not recommend this restaurant enough. read more

Best Mexican food around. Family owned restaurant , super friendly and passionate about their business. Had the best guacamole and warm chips, Shrimp Cancun appetizer, Carne asada and chicken chimichangas for entree! Will be back! read more

What a fabulous place! Apparently under new ownership and they have done a great job updating the place and the menu. We had a great meal and drinks. The special Salmon was cooked to perfection. Not over cooked and the sauce was great. We have added it to our must go to places! read more

I recently ordered take out from the Cancun Inn in Sugar Loaf. IT WAS AWFUL!!!!!!! I ordered 3 Chile Rellenos and they were tasteless, luke warm and in some kind of watery red sauce. The previous owners gave you rice, refried beans and a salad with your order. I received none of that-for $23 I received 3 horrible rellenos in a tin take out pan with a plastic cover on top and a bag of chips!!! The decor is creepy too-it might even upset small children. This place should be avoided in my opinion. It was a waste of money. read more

New owners picking up right where the old owners left off....superb service. Good luck to new owners!

Not only does this place make amazing food, BUT THE STAFF is what really makes it. I'm pretty sure he is the owner, but the minute you walk in they treat you like family. From hand shakes when you walk in, to constantly walking around the restaurant engaging with his customers and checking in on us, to the warm hug he gives you on the way out. Now on to the food! I got a platter special - which they had a nice selection - which lets you sample a bit of everything. My plate came with a cheese enchilada, beef taco, and cheese stuffed pepper. My partner got the chicken fajita and it smelled wonderful and tasted even better. The salsa that comes with the chips - I need that recipe! Also, I find that guacamole can always be hit or miss - this place was a hit! If you're not getting food, stop by for a drink at least. Just get in through that door and feel the energy and love! read more