It has been about a year since we'd been there because we're not often in the area, so we were looking forward to their lasagna and pizza, which we have enjoyed in visits~past.
Was that a mistake! First off, I noticed as we went in the door the sticker in the window telling me that YELP reviewers have given them such wonderful reviews. Usually, when a restaurant has to tell you they've been given rave reviews, it's because they feel the need to convince you the world thinks they're great. Really great restaurants don't have to toot their own horn because they firmly rest on the laurels of their truly great cuisine. But I didn't give it much thought as I entered in anticipation of a wonderful lasagna.
The differences, once inside, were immediately apparent. In the past, the family who owned the business would ensure you were not only greeted and seated but made to feel welcome with a smile. We were lucky the waiter decided to seat us, and although the owner/hostess bopped around the room, she seemed not to have time for her customers that day. But no matter, we're here for the food, right?
The next thing I noticed was they had absolutely lovely music playing in the background, but most people would be lucky to become aware of it, because they had mounted on the wall a television tuned to an international sports news channel. This was an interesting new feature, but no one in the restaurant seemed to be interested in the international sports news, yet it blared on so loudly as to drown out the lovely music and make conversation rather difficult. It seemed quite out of place, as well, because it created an atmosphere of a sports bar, which felt out of synch with the fact that this was a small family italian ristorante, not a southern california~style sports bar. But no matter, there's always the food.
With anticipation we ordered and awaited our food. Since conversation was not DOable with the cacophany of noise between the sports news and the music, my companion took to working a puzzle book while I watched the international sports news, about which I know nothing. It's a good thing there's always good food here.
The food finally arrived, and it was dismal! My family has always enjoyed their pizzas, but this turned out to be the worst pizza we have EVER had, EVER! My lasagna was good, but not nearly the wondrous italian delight I've always enjoyed, and it was half the size it used to be.
But worst of all was the overall value. Never mind the noisy and unfriendly environment (our waiter could not bear to muster even one facial expression remotely resembling a smile), we could bear it all if the food was great and the price was right . . . but alas, it was not so.
We spent $42 for ONE pizza and ONE lasagna ~ no beverages or desserts, just ONE pizza and ONE lasagna. Even that might be tolerable if the pizza were even remotely what we anticipated based on past experience, or the lasagna was sizable enough to have a little leftover to take home. But in this economy, $42 for a LUNCH that was barely shy of AWFUL, I'd say there was no value there at all, and sadly, Cafe Corleone has seen the last of us.
Although the waiter had given our payment to the owner, she was sitting in a booth talking with someone at the time, and it wasn't until we decided it wasn't worth waiting for our change and started to walk out that she hopped to her feet and said "Thank you for coming!" as we're going out the door . . . a mere shadow of the proud, family~owned Italian restaurateurship of our past experience there.
The only conclusion we could come to as we get in our car and 'clickit" was that perhaps Cafe Corleone changed ownership or something, because there was nothing we recognized that reminds us of why we so looked forward to the experience. And since there are so few truly wonderful little restaurants in the area, it was with a small maudlin tear that we drew a line through the name Cafe Corleone in our list of favorite places to visit. read more