Was in the mood for some pie and this place was nearby. So many choices, but we went with the 4 inch Key Lime pie, I-40, and the Peanut Butter cream. They were all good and depends on your mood when it comes to choosing a favorite. The Key Lime wasn't too tart, which was perfect and I enjoyed the graham cracker crust, the I-40 was the perfect blend of pecan and coconut, but could've done without the chocolate, however, I'm not mad at it. And the peanut butter cream was definitely creamy and not too rich. Overall a great experience!! Kinda pricy for $6 each given their small size, but I'd like to go back to try the other flavors. read more

See all

Give ppl the pies they paid for...grub hub is not my deal...why do I have to answer to them..I ordered from u

The pies tasted good . The service was friendly and the atmosphere was pleasant. I may try it again if in the area.

This was our first time visiting, and we were impressed! The crust is so tasty and light, the filling is amazing, and the overall flavor is sooooo good!!! I can't wait to try more flavors! read more

We picked up a couple pies from here to take home. We were going to get an apple pie, but unfortunately they were out as it was the afternoon. We ended up getting a pecan pie and a chocolate cream pie. It turned out to be around $60 for two pies which seemed sort of expensive to me. We had the pies later that day for dinner and they were both pretty good, but the chocolate cream was my favorite. read more

Babyyyyy! This is it right here. I don't know what made me stop by and check them out, but I'm glad I did. As soon I walked in, I could smell all the baked goodness that was happening. The case of pies looked so good, so I couldn't just pick one! I got the Chewy Chocolate Chip and Granny's Apple in the 4inch size. I then took both to my friends house and we literally argued about who got which one lol. We settled on half and half split. Y'all we were both quiet and just enjoying each bite. I'm a huge fan of desserts and a hard critique. These pies were AMAZING! Even though the granny apple was a personal size it still had fresh cut apples in each bite. The chocolate chip wasn't too cookie like , but a perfect mixed cookie pie. I also found their pricing to be fair and appropriate. I can't wait to go back and try some more flavors! read more

See all

We ALWAYS order our holiday pies from Buttermilk Sky. Usually we order the Key Lime and Pecan pies. Oh my! They are good!!

I can only say it's the best! I have to watch how much I buy because I would eat the whole pie. Can't recommend this place enough.

Very friendly staff...the pecan pie is truly one the greatest I've ever had...wife loved the coconut cream pie.

Wow these pies are amazing! They have different flavors like chocolate chip, peanut butter cup, coconut , apple crumble looked amazing ! Key lime , pecan and so many more. You can get small individual ones 4 for $16 or a big one that feeds 5 to 7 for $23 The staff is friendly , pie knowledgeable, I really want to go back for the chocolate pie looked amazing! read more

Buttermilk Sky - Key lime pie - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

So, let me start by saying I love Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop. I use to be a cake person until I started eating their pie and cookies awhile ago. I specifically love the Mansfield location because the customer service here is amazing. Every time I visit this location I feel welcomed and the employees here are so accommodating. As for the pies and cookies...I swear I think they taste different from other locations I've been too. Different in a good way. The cookies are always fresh and the pies taste like love. I have all of their pies except the key lime and coconut cream. Every pie that I have taste here are delicious and never stale and because of that I'll continue to visit this location. read more

I have not met a pie from this place that I have not loved! I learned something today, bc I was wishing I had a table to sit at while I ate my delicious Cloud 9 (before it melted!). They don't tax their desserts, therefore they can't have tables inside or outside! Good to know... I recently feel in love with their "cloud 9". This is a dreamy combination of any flavor mini pie, crumbled up and mixed vanilla ice cream. It was AMAZING! I picked the coconut cream pie (my fav) to have mixed with ice cream. It was very refreshing and of course super sweet! I will be dreaming about this until I come back for more! While I was there, I grabbed some chocolate thumb print cookies to try. They were freshly baked and soft. Not as good as their pie, but I wouldn't be opposed to getting more! The lemon ice box pie is their must try pie of the month. It's so refreshing, slightly tart, definitely sweet, and very good! If I have time before it's gone, this would make a good cloud 9 combo! It's always a pleasure coming to Buttermilk Sky! read more

See all

This location recently opened so I decided to stop by....since I pass by it twice a day! They had samples of the apple pie which was realllllly good. I didn't taste my sample until after I walked out of the store but I wished I would have bought the apple pie after tasting it. I bought the chocolate dream for myself which was really good but it was really sweet. It was a mousse chocolate filling with an Oreo crust and topped with whipped cream. It was so sweet that I ate half and saved the rest for later. My son had the peanut butter and I think it was the same.....a mousse filling with a crust. He said it was good but described it as an ice cream pie. The place was decorated with baking accessories like aprons rolling pins and pie stands.....that are also for sell. They have the same concept as Nothing Bundt Cakes. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Chocolate peanut butter dream - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

Buttermilk pie was so-so. Was a bit heavy. Piecrust more like a soft cookie. Store was clean. Staff not very knowledgeable.

The pies are so good and the service is awesome! I will definitely be back!! You won't be disappointed!

We were at Ninja Kitchen next door and decided to stop by right before they closed. We got 2 personal pies, mine was peanut butter with Oreo crust. The cashier was nice and knowledgeable about the pies. We were in and out in about 3 minutes. We took pies home pies. The pie was the best pie I ever had. I'd definitely go back. read more

Woke up and my soulmate said I want PIE for breakfast. Quick Maps search led us here and we bought six mini pies of varied types. The seasonal blueberry bomb pie was legit and the apple set me off. We will see about the others later. Service was amazing and the young lady with very well done and classy nails took the time to explain everything to my old ass. Sorry, I forgot your name, but the delicious apple pie made my brain reset and I'm drawing a blank now. Thanks, my lady is happy and that means I'm happy! read more

Quaint shop. Friendly folks. Everything looked super yummy. We tried a few of their small pies. Hopefully it'll be yummy.

I've made three visits to this location so far and every time have experienced nothing but smiling, courteous employees and a variety of delicious, fresh pies. There is usually a seasonal pie and staple pies, such as chocolate chip, buttermilk, and cream pies. We usually purchase the mini pies, which are $4.25. The location is very clean and nice on the inside. This pie shop is a great addition to the Mansfield area and I look forward to coming here every week from now on. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

I have to admit, the only reason I came here was because it was pi day. Me and Nana drove over here to try the pies. The outside of the store was very clean, the storefront was very cute. It was decorated like a true Southerner would decorate their kitchen. I decided to get to get the I 40. And Nana got the banana cream pie. We got the 4-inch pies oh, and I also got a lemon cookie for my sister. Total out the door was less than $10. There was a large assortment of 4-inch pies & full 9-inch pies in the store. Pies were all decorated very nicely, and they look just like they do on the company website. The I-40, is it take on pecan pie. It's got gooey sweet stuff that a pecan pie does. It also has chocolate chips and coconut. This is one damn good pies! I think the crust was a shortbread, but it really didn't taste like a shortbread to me. Nana's banana cream pie was a little cold almost semi-frozen. The crust had caramel on top of it, then some banana, banana pudding, and topped with whipped cream and a Nilla Wafer. I thought my pie was pretty damn good. And then I tried Nana's pie... Oh my God! I could feel the diabetes creeping into my endocrine. It was very sweet, it was decadent, it was smooth and creamy. It was something that you would share. If you eat the entire 4 inch Pie by yourself, I suggest you go straight to the dentist office. Or maybe to your primary care physician to have your sugar checked. Now the customer service was another story. The girl working at the front counter was basically what do you want? And we were still looking around and she told me what the total was. I figured it was my time to go. There was no one else in the store while we were looking around, I don't know what her hurry was. There are currently four or five locations of Buttermilk sky in the Metroplex. Hopefully the other stores have better customer service! I would have given this location a five if it wasn't for the chick at the front counter who was in a hurry. read more

See all

My family has ordered the pies over the last couple of years for special occasions. Nothing is better. The pies are always delicious and savory. Sweet, rich. Always amazing read more

New dessert addition to Mansfield! They have four flavors for their mini pies-- buttermilk, key lime, pecan, and I40. Buttermilk was completely sold out. I ended up getting one key lime, one pecan, and two I40s. The I40 has pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut. The mini pies are $4.25 each, but if you get four pies, it's $16. The store had samples out of the pecan pie out. Pretty delicious. I will have to come back so that I get the buttermilk pie to try. If you sign up for their emails, you get a free mini pie for your birthday! Winning! How can one go wrong with a pie shop? I will be a returning customer! read more

Buttermilk Sky - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

See all

They have delicious pecan pie. It is sinfully good. I won a whole pecan pie, and I didn't want to part with one slice. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Pecan pie - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

If you Love Pie, then you should definitely check out this establishment. They are tucked away here in Mansfield on Broad Street in same parking lot as Bank of America. They have whole large pies' individual pies and an assortment box of bite size in one box. The prices are 4 individual pies for $16. Just purchasing 1 pie is $4.25. Or if you want a whole pie they are $23.00. The pies have not disappointed yet and I've been several times. My family loves the I40 (Pecan, Chocolate chip and toasted coconut). The chocolate pie, buttermilk pie and key lime pie are our other favorites. Today we are trying the Apple Pie! Hope it's good! There are many locations popping up.... But Mansfield is my favorite!! Staff are super friendly and welcoming! read more

See all

Delicious pies. Options for two sizes (4" and 9"). We grabbed a pack of 4 small pies ($16): pecan, "I-40" (pecan + chocolate chips), apple, and key-lime. Pecan and Key-lime pies were our favorites. The Pecan-chocolate chip was a bit too sweet for our liking. Will be back. They rotate flavors and there was a bunch of other stuff we wanted to try :) read more

Overall the pies were tasty and it's nice having a local place to get a dessert that isn't ice cream. The actual shop is fairly small and there is no seating, but the decor is very cute and southern. You just pick your pies and take them to go. Also the customer services wasn't the most helpful. No one took the time to talk to us, explain the flavors, or talk to us in general. I ended up switching flavors at the last minute because I thought they only had the flavors in the case. I happened to see a sign and asked questions so I was able to get other pies I didn't see displayed. As a side note it's weird that everything in stock was not displayed in the case. We planned on eating in the car due to lack of seating and there wasn't silverware in the bag, I guess we were supposed to ask for it. Good pies, not the best experience. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Southern pie, chocolate pie, I40, and chocolate chip cookie pie - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Tried four different 4" pies and was looking forward to eating them as I was craving it. I guess pies are not my thing or something because i was underwhelmed. read more

I'm so excited for a pie shop in Mansfield. We shared a chocolate cream and it was pretty tasty. I like that they have various sizes and some good flavors. I would like to see more flavors and somewhere to sit and enjoy them would be great. I hope to come back and try more flavors soon! read more

See all

I would not return to this pie store. I was given a free pie certificate for Christmas. Upon arrival at the store I was informed the gift card would not be honored because they had a change in ownership. I truly believe it would have been honored if I was not a black person. So skeptical, so judgemental. Not good. I felt so bad, I even called before I drove to store that is miles from where I live. read more

Purchased a buttermilk pie one time .. the pie crust is horrible barely look like it was cooked

I love Buttermilk Sky Pie! The staff is so sweet and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. And the pies!! Oh the pies! They taste like home! So fresh and delicious! Tastes like they were baked with love. My favorites are the apple pie and pecan pie! If ever you're in Mansfield you've got to stop in. read more

I've had pies from here twice. I regret to say they are the worst pies I've ever had. Most recent was a coconut cream pie. The "whipped cream" must have had marshmallows in it. The crust as about 1/2" think and the filling was about the same - maybe " The rest of the pie consisted if the marshmallow type topping. I was so disappointed and cannot say I would ever buy another pie from them. The staff are friendly but I would nit spent my money on another if this over priced pies. Actually even if they were cheaper I would not buy sitter one. read more

I'm not a big Pie person but my Husband loves them. The cute little pies are perfect for him cause he doesn't have a big sweet tooth so it's great. They are reasonably priced and the flavors are always amazing! read more

Best pies in the DFW. I'd recommend everyone to try them, especially if you have a sweet tooth!

We bought a chocolate cream, a buttermilk, and a coconut cream! I wasn't planning on eating the entire personal size... but, it's gone! Thank you for making delicious pies!!! read more

The peanut butter pie is AMAZING!!! We tried several different pies and they were all good but the peanut butter pie beat them all. Service was quick and friendly! read more

We tried the Coconut Cream, Nanny's Pecan, and the Southern Custard mini pies, and to say it exceeded our expectations! The crust is just sweet enough and crumbles in your mouth. The fillings compliment the crusts well to create the perfect pie. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

Talk about great service. I called and said I was running late and the lady said if we are here past 7 we will open and give you pies. I came late and they were there so I got to purchase pies. They even gave me a sample. Man, talk about service I was truly impressed. I purchased 4 small pies and went on my way. Such a good experience read more

Wow... super excited and impressed with this pie shop. We bought the butter cream, key lime and chocolate pie with ice cream. Yumminess to the extreme with great service and a beautiful store. Can't wait to try the coconut pie coming up this next week. Try them all they are good. read more

Buttermilk Sky - Love pies... yay - Bakeries Near Me - Mansfield, Texas

I went and picked up a chocolate pie, two cloud nines, an i40 and a pecan pie. Shared them with my family and they all loved them! They are small but great portion sizes and they were delicious! read more