Bills Bake Shoppe is owned by Bill Cast. He has been baking since he was 8 years old in his…read morefather's bakery, he is now in his 70's. If you want Authentic Italian Pastries look no further. Come to Mahoningtown... It's worth the trip! Tell Bill Kenny sent you.

This is where we stop every time we drive in from Pittsburgh to visit old friends. I have long gone…read morerelatives from this area and grew up in New Castle. You won't find many bakeries left like this. I've never had anything bad from here!!! We're on way next week! love talking to whomever is working. Great service!

I bought your Oatrageous Cookies and now I go to the Fairground Market once a week just to buy…read morethese cookies! I'm addicted to them! I wish I were joking! I never thought to look on the package where they come from! Lol So now I will visit your store! Please don't ever stop making them!

Once a week or so during the summer, a farmer's market can be found in a parking lot in Beechview…read morein a parking lot near the Fallowfield trolley station. The other evening, as I dismounted the train, I came face to face with a bearded man in a blue shirt, overalls, suspenders and wide-brimmed hat that I assume was of the Mennonite faith. Before him on a table sat a bevy of baked beauties. Cookies, muffins, gobs...Shoofly pie. As I approached him, he asked "A workin' man, are ya?" "Yes sir. I just got done for the day." "Well, God Bless ya." "Thank you." "What can I do for ya?" "Well, I have 4 bucks cash on me." "Oh, we can work something out." And work something out we did, the gentleman offering me a 50 cent discount on a small Shoofly pie and a chocolate gob. Sweet Montgomery, was the pie treacly! Yet, I welcomed its wholesome, molasses-derived taste and texture that adhered to the insides of my mouth like glue. It was similiar to a pecan pie without pecans and possessed a flavor that approached chocolate or Nutella. Its crumbly crust has no preservatives and doesn't hold up well after a few days I was told, so eat it fast I did, half that evening and the other half the following afternoon with lunch. The gob was dense, moist, and contained a sugary white frosting between the bisected ball of cocoa. On the label it read "Hostetler's Bakery" in capital letters complete with a street address and telephone number. I must make the pilgrimage for olden wonder and rural warmth surely await me there.

We were not big fans of this pastry. Texture taste etc. The price was very high also $14.00 dollars…read morefor a generous helping a bit much.

(5/3/2014) Totally welcome addition to the festival circuit, what's not to love? Buttery, flaky,…read morepuff pastry wrapped around sweet or savory fillings to-go. Not sure I would call these "strudels", but way tasty, nonetheless. Surprisingly for sitting in a hot box all day, pastries were really hot! Had the Beef Wellington which was not like any real Beef Wellington, but a good savory ground meat patty and the German Sausage, fatty, black peppery (some sinew). They're like the best Hot Pockets ever!

Always our go to spot for donuts. We have enjoyed them…read moresince we were little kids. Our favorite is the Maple cream filled. But honestly, they are all delicious!!

Delicious, they are the only to eat in New Castle. The glazed twists bring me back to the 1970sread more

Love this place. The lady who owns it is super sweet! The milk tea is my favorite!…read moreIf you do not like what you I order they will make you something else

Small but excellent. Local produce, preserves, pickles, sauces and plants. Good things to eat…read moremade by local folks. Fair Trade coffee served and sold by bag. Occasional music or food demos. Come and hang out!

I only went to Cerise once when I first heard about an authentic French bakery in Youngstown, as I…read morelive in Akron. They really know their stuff! The line was out the door but there was still a good selection when my turn came. I bought a mixture of pastries and all were exceptionally good and the staff was very professional and welcoming.

Popped in today to my excitement a few new pastries and Homemade Granola. They also have a new…read morePasta. Incredible absolutely Incredible.

Dedicated GF bakery! It's tucked behind the Papa Johns pizza…read moreon the side of the plaza. A little tricky to find first time visiting. We went at the end of their day, they close at 2. Most items had been sold but they brought somethings from the back for us. They are experienced bakers and everything we bought has been fantastic! The owners couldn't have been nicer and more gracious. Bear Claw for the ride home, just like I remember before being GF Blueberry sweet cake is so moist! Can't wait to try the pizza crust as a pita per their suggestion! Cookies, just the taste you are looking for from a bakery cookie. No gritty, funny aftertaste! Don't walk, RUN to this gem! Note: they are only GF, not nut free

They bake up the best gluten-free goodies ,dinner rolls and pies. They also offer donuts and cream…read moresticks on Fridays and Saturdays.