Using Yelp on a road trip, we found this little cute place with good food. Really, it is a meat and three type place with extra offerings. It is cute and relaxing inside. There were several tables of people, but it wasn't load. It was very relaxing and nice. Our waitress seemed well versed on the menu choices and provided good descriptions. We ordered the Burtons Burger and the Pulled Pork platter with corn and green beans. All was very good. The pulled pork came with delicious gravy. We then ordered two pieces of pie... the famous white pie and then the coconut creme pie. We were disappointed in the pies. Three coconut cream pie didn't have enough coconut taste and the crust was thin on the bottom. On the other hand the White Pie was totally over flavored and tasted like an artificially flavored boxed cake. Overall, we had a really nice experience. read more

Stopped here on my way from Edwardsville to Murray for cheap comfort food and I was astonished at the quality of food for the price. My boyfriend and I split fried mushrooms (MUST TRY- SIMPLY AMAZING), a lunch plate of catfish bites with two side orders of mashed potatoes with white gravy and some cornbread and we both LOVED every bite. I make this trip often and will definitely be taking a pit stop here again. Next time I'm snagging some coconut meringue pie read more

BURTONS IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!! Best food, best service, and nice and comfortable setting to have dinner. Never leave without first trying the pie!!!!!!!! read more

This is an outstanding restaurant. I live in Dallas and always eat at Burton's multiple times when I visit beautiful Southern IL.

Burton's is a nice little hometown restaurant, serving simple, yet good food. Nothing fancy, and if you are a vegan like the person that wrote the bad review, you may want to pass (or try thinking outside the box and have a big grilled chicken salad minus the chicken for goodness sakes). My grilled chicken salad last night was perfect (and plentiful enough that I could have skipped the chicken and still had plenty to eat). The staff was great, the food more than adequate (my husband's pork roast dinner was wonderful), and their pies are amazing ... Try the White pie; besides being unique (it's a local thing) it is really, really good. Ignore the Vegan; she (or he) wouldn't have been happy dining anywhere in this quaint little southern area of the world ... Face it folks, Southerners aren't generally known for their tofu. Editing this, because I looked at the "vegetarian"'s other reviews and found a great review of a chili burger that he loved in NM ... Last time I checked, vegans didn't eat burgers, chili or otherwise. Hmmm, gotta wonder about his review of Burton's. In fact, he doesn't seem to like much of anything that isn't in New Mexico. read more

On a short trip to Benton on our Harley. Drove by Burtons on our way home and saw the sign. Home of the famous white pie so we decided to stop. Good food. Fried chicken & chicken tenders were good.Great service. Pie was awesome. Will recommend to others. read more

Yes, good food, friendly, clean. PIE, PIE, PIE. I'm picking up 2 apple pies tonight to take home.

Excellent restaurant. All food cooked to order the old fashion way. Pies baked fresh daily... Varieties like chocolate cream, raisin, and their famous white pie. Fried Chicken on Thursdays and Sundays are really good. read more

Burton's Cafe - Famous for their white pie.. Delicious - American Near Me - Whittington, Illinois

Good atmosphere casual or dress it up. Comfortable. Staff very attentive. Menue great can make a small plate frm most menue items. Help with wine choices and able to taste prior to order. Desert choices are many will make fresh coffee upon request. Lamb chops cooked tender special appetizers of portabella mushrooms was fantastic from the menue pasta stuffed with pear and ricotta excellent. A new fav place to dine and so close to home who knew now you do try it out read more

Popular small town restaurant. Home of the "White Pie" - try a piece. Very good, very inexpensive food. Decor: small town restaurant. Friendly and relaxed. No background music - hooray! Open for lunch and dinner. We would go there again. read more

I'm sure it was something different back then but we eat here some when I was a kid and I seemed to enjoy it and as my family members. Had a nostalgic thought and though I'd post a review. Last time I ate here was a good 6 or more years and I though it was just an average place, nothing too good and nothing toooo bad. And when I was little that well was in the mid 90s when we would have been frequent to this location. read more

Heard great things about this place but was sadly disappointed when I ordered country fried steak and it was not homemade, the potatoes were instant and the gravy came out of a can or packet. read more

If you are looking for a great home cooked meal this is the place to go. The food was so good... We would recommend this to anyone.

I remember eating at Burton's when I was in college and always loved it. I wasn't quite as impressed as an adult coming back 20 years later. The price of the adult meals were very reasonable- $7.99 for an entree and 2 sides. Not bad at all. On the other hand, the kids meals were kinda expensive for what they actually got. My kids got 2 chicken strips and a side for $6. Now one would assume that for that price it would include a drink. No where on the menu nor did the waitress say otherwise. When I got the bill, I found they charged an additional $2 for each kids drink. So a kids meal actually ended up costing $8 per kid. I feel like that's kinda expensive when you can go to Applebee's or Chili's and get a kids meal that includes everything for $5. If I would have realized that each kids meal was going to be $8, it would have been cheaper to order them an adult meal to split and 2 drinks and it would have saved me $4. Additionally, the day had just began and they were already out of several things they said they had. read more

We are sometimes hesitant to stop by local restaurants. This nice little place is totally awesome. The entree was perfectly done! Both my husband and I so enjoyed our meals. And the white pie. A big YUM! read more