We tried Buona Sera for dinner after our daughters rowed in the Saratoga Invitational. Sunday evening; called for a reservation, but not necessary. Got seated right away in the "Lake Room" and got served right away. The Lake Room has a nice view over Saratoga Lake, and the ambiance was good for family dinner, except for a couple of loud tables that made it hard to hear everyone. I had a bourbon Manhattan that was perfect - not so dry that it tasted like a glass of bourbon and not so much vermouth as to make it too sweet - and really smoothed off the afternoon - then a glass of St Francis Cabernet to go with dinner. Appetizers were pan-fried mozzarella and the Shrimp Limoncello. The mozzarella was "Made with Our Fresh Homemade Mozzarella, and Breadcrumbs, Served over Marinara." Light, slight breading and fried just enough with a perfectly sweet complementary red sauce. The Shrimp Limoncello was "Three U-10 Shrimp Sauteed with Roasted Garlic, Roasted Heirloom Tomatoes and Limoncello, Served with Grilled Bread." Shrimp were cooked just right, not overcooked, as happens many times with shrimp, and the tomatoes and bread were complementary and tasty, but the limoncello was a little too much lemon, not enough cello. (a little more tart than we liked) 2 entrees were the pan seared salmon over risotto with a request to undercook the salmon somewhat, which they honored, and it made the salmon very moist and tasty. The Roasted Garlic and Basil risotto was excellent - rice not overcooked, perfect with a deep warm roasted garlic flavor. My Eggplant Parmesan was prepared the old fashioned way with thinly sliced eggplant properly drained and sweet with an ultra thin breading fried just right with a delicious marinara sauce and plenty of mozzarella, served over house-made spaghetti cooked al dente. Ample enough to have half for lunch the next day. Oh, and I had a side order of broccoli rabe - slightly bitter, as it should be, with ample garlic flavor cooked perfectly. Excellent. The fourth entree was Shrimp Aglio E Olio - "Sauteed shrimp, broccoli rabe, roasted tomatoes, in a garlic and olive oil sauce. Served over spaghetti." Once again, large fresh (not meaning not previously frozen, just clearly not old) meaty shrimp cooked perfectly - still moist with some crunch with a wonderful pungent garlic sauce over that perfectly al dente spaghetti. My daughter loved it. Also enough for lunch the next day. Desserts were homemade tiramisu and lemon ricotta cake with raspberry sauce and whipped cream. Tiramisu was classic and delicious. Lemon cake was a little dry but tangy and tasty, especially with the full-flavored raspberry sauce. We only get to Saratoga in the spring and fall for the rowing races, but this will be our go-to place for post-regatta dinner any time we're around. Very very good. Not cheap, but one doesn't mind when it's well worth the price. read more

Only reason for two stars is because of Ryleigh our waitress!!! She was absolutely amazing. The rest of the night was a disaster. Ordered two apps and one came out and the other was out 10 minutes later (comped). Next was dinner. My wife chicken parm was ice cold so we send it back and instead of remaking they threw it in the oven and baked it more. (See pic of this burnt mess). How does the kitchen not realize this should not go out??? HOW!!! (Comped) My sister got the eggplant parm, all I can say is stay away from this dish. I talked it and it was the worst! (Comped). I don't know how this place is staying open and I feel bad for the amazing staff. The manager also came over and it was obvious he didn't really care we had issues, another reason I feel sorry for the amazing staff. We also had a good experience at the bar before we sat with Cassidy. This was our second and last time going to this place!!! read more

First the good the space is lovely. It's overlooking the water. There's plenty of room for large parties, family gatherings so we had a large party of 12. The ambience is nice. Everyone is really friendly. There's a cute little bar area for waiting. The food was spectacular. We had muscles and clams that's appetizers and they were absolutely the best that I've ever had so well done bravo. Now they're not so great we were sat right under. I guess an air conditioner unit so my brother-in-law had condensation dripping on him the entire meal and then my father-in-law ordered the same item that I ordered which was the seafood medley and he didn't get any shrimp or any scallop. I received three shrimp and one scallop in my dish, which was fine. Definitely would've liked an extra scallop. Lastly, granted it was Saturday night evening, so I understand that the restaurant was extremely busy, but it took forever for us to get a meal and we had a reservation at 5:30 and we left at 8:30pm. Thank goodness we ordered appetizers because we had three little kids with us that were melting down as we were waiting for our food. Thank goodness, the appetizers came out in a timely manner, but our entrée took forever like over an hour. Overall, I really liked this place but definitely need a lot of time to eat here since it seems like it takes a while for them to prepare the meals, but they were very well cooked. read more

Buona Sera - Veal chop - Italian Near Me - Malta, New York

See all

I reiterate this is my favorite local restaurant. I am not going to let one off night cloud the fact that we have had many fine meals here. I have hosted as many as 10-12 at a time and everyone loved it. The people who work here are top notch, the chef is fantastic (but he needs to make sure when he's off they go light on the salt). Best eggplant in the area. Good old fashioneds, btw. read more

If excellent food, great service and a lakeside ambiance fit your idea of what a restaurant should be, then Buona Sera is the place!

Very average food on a pretty spot but a little bit far from the water to really call it lakefront, even though there's not that much between the building and the water. But the service was terrible, and the food was only ok. Too bad because it is pretty spot, but it feels like it's basically a touristy spot vs fine dining. I would not go back or recommend. read more

I've unfortunately got sick two times that I've ate here. I think it is due to the amount of oil and or butter in dishes as I have a sensitive stomach to that. Wish there was more salad options on the menu & a few more dishes that don't involve pasta. read more

First class service. The food was tremendous. Highest recommend. Every thing was absolutely perfect.

Always a good choice, food is always good, restaurant is quiet and authentic . The food is presented well, not sloppy. Service has always been excellent and very relaxed. read more

Absolutely wonderful! Good was amazing and our waiter was so wonderful and accommodating! Highly recommend!

My friend and I went to see a performance at The Little Theatre (SPAC). Afterward, I suggested that we have an early dinner at Buona Sera, an Italian restaurant overlooking the south shore of Saratoga Lake that neither of us had been to. We were seated at a table by the window which afforded us an unobstructed view of the lake. Perfect. Our waiter, Doug, said this was his first shift. He did a fine job managing our table and the others around us. The disappointment lies in the management's lack of customer care and the food. Both of us ordered the Carpaccio which was a nicely plated combination of arugula, prosciutto, fried goat cheese balls (interesting!), shaved Parmesan, and toasted pine nuts. Impressive. My friend ordered one of their specials - Shrimp and Scallop Fra Diablo served over linguini. She was happy with her selection. My Veal Marsala arrived while I was still eating my Carpaccio starter. A real no-no. The gal who brought our entrees left it on the table where it sat for the 10+ minutes it took for me to finish my appetizer and became barely warm. Reader, take note. I requested that the spaghetti served with my veal be set on the side of the meat instead of under it. I asked them to add a bit of garlic and oil to the pasta. I did not want the veal and what tasted like jar sauce (no Marsala flavor was evident to me or my husband who ate my leftover meal) to be on top of the spaghetti. Doug sheepishly returned to our table after taking our order and told me that the chef/owner said there would be a $10 up charge to accommodate my request. Excuse me? I told him to tell the chef/owner not to bother. It wasn't the amount of the charge, it was the idea that there would be an up charge at all. I order Veal Marsala this way all the time and never did any restauranteur add a ridiculous fee for such a simple request. Plus the veal was tough and flavorless, and the two spears of asparagus were missing their tips. This entree was uninspiring. My friend ordered chicken to go for her husband. It arrived on a plate, not packed up ready to take home. We ordered desserts to go and the person who brought them to us dropped one - which had to be replaced. The cannolis were among the best I've ever enjoyed, with crisp shells and a delicious filling. Kudos to the pastry chef! The best part of our experience was the view. With a plethora of Italian restaurants in Saratoga Springs and the surrounding area, my friend and I agreed we won't be returning to Buona Sera. read more

See all

We spent day at Races... being from out of town. Asked for recommendation for Italian cuisine. Drove 15 minutes only but after dining here would have drove an hour for the veal. We started with meatballs ..marininera sauce was delicious. The veal parmesan was perfect with a huge helping. Service was great ...will be back next trip for races. read more

Riley was great waitress.. attentive and friendly! Food was excellent! View of lake always good read more

Everything here is top notch! The kitchen crew works well together to make the meals and service an excellent experience. Service is amazing and always present. The food is incredible at any time, love that they have specials even during the week not just on weekends! We make a plan to eat here at least once a month, more if we have guests visiting. Crossing fingers that management considers a Feast of Seven Fishes for the holidays!! read more

Best kept secret in Saratoga. Food was wonderful. Service fun.and spit on. We went in February and do say it was cold sitting near the back windows. Sure its beautiful with a great view in spring/summer. read more

Best Italian food I had in a long time. Authentic recipes. Great service. Nice views

Food is wonderful, especially the pasta (and I'm not a pasta guy). Service was pretty good considering it being summer during track season when it is jam packed. Only downside was the loud table sitting nearby speaking at maximum volume without consideration for anyone else, otherwise a 9.5/10 visit here in July. Buona Sera has become one of our favorites especially outside of track season. read more

Jackie the hostess greeted me at the door with her usual charisma . I sat at a table where the beautiful Pertrina took my order for Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken. The service was prompt and the busboy was very attentive with water refills. My only disappointment was that the pasta was slightly undercooked and for $30, I wish there was more chicken in the dish. read more

The food that was made correctly was yummy, but there were massive things incorrect at all times, entrees, desserts. If they could sort out their problems it does seem like they got some yummy food. Too bad. read more

NEVER AGAIN!! They ruined what was to be a nice evening. Only 6 for dinner. 5 dinners all brought out separately of which took 10+ min....THE LAST ONE NEVER CAME!! Now everyone's meal was cold. We tried to be polite but it was a real let down for all of us. read more

Great food, great service, great view & reasonable prices. What else do you need? My wife and I stopped by on a recent trip up to Saratoga. Started off with the Meatballs - absolutely delicious. Next up were the best Braised Short Ribs I've ever had. The Chiffon with Strawberries & Cream was the perfect ending to a great night. Wine selection was excellent. If you're planning on being in the area don't miss out on this gem. read more

Second time here and slightly disappointed this time around. Seafood special was very salty. Eggplant parmigiana pasta also too salty. Soup was awesome and service was good. read more

Wanted to love because scallops were delicious but 2 for $22 is out of control ! Love the feel of this place (the establishment itself)

Was seated right away and the staff went above and beyond. Food was amazing and the dessert was top notch. Would highly recommend and will be returning read more

Buona Sera - Italian Near Me - Malta, New York

See all

Went there last night. We love Italian food. We all had straight up Martini's to start. There were very good! Mixed perfectly! We ordered the Bread appetizer. It had a large loaf of warm Italian bread with roasted Garlic and spiced up butter! Main dishes were Veal Marsala. Veal cooked perfectly! Shrimp Luigi was delicious and sausage and penne pasta. All dishes were absolutely scrumptious! To finish off the meal we had eggnog cheesecake, Delicious! Service was great and they give military discounts I definitely will be back. There's a couple of seafood dishes I like to try. Thank You, Buona Sera read more

Everything was beautiful . The staff were so nice, friendly and fun. My birthday was amazing. The food was Excellent! Large portions, perfectly cooked, And reasonably priced. The desert ( cake) was yummy. Oh, the bread was delish. lol. We will be back. Thank you. Maxine Ahmed read more

Our waiter was fantastic and the food was just as great! Went there with my family. The waiter had a great sense of humor and was very attentive. He made us feel so welcome! The food was VERY good! The broccoli and tomatoes in this dish were such a pop of flavor that added to the savory flavor of the pasta and shrimp. Pieces of garlic throughout the dish that were cooked in the sauce and were an extra burst of flavor. I would recommend this new place to everyone. I am a foodie and love great service and this place did both fantastically! read more

Buona Sera - Shrimp Aglio e Olio - Italian Near Me - Malta, New York

The food was amazing and the view was beautiful! Our server was great. We definitely will go there again!

Good food, great ambiance, staff is help and friendly, love this place. Next time try another dessert read more

Buona Sera - Dessert - Italian Near Me - Malta, New York

I have been here three times now this summer so I feel like I can give a well-rounded review. It seems like over the years the building has expanded beyond the capacity of the kitchen so don't be surprised if you see empty tables but are told there is a wait. At least during the summer they get a LOT of large parties, families of 6-10 so the kitchen and waitstaff can get slammed. Don't come here if you expect to be doted on and have your perfectly coursed meals. Having said that everything I've ordered has come out fairly quickly and PIPING HOT and the food if not Michelin quality is very solid. Everything I've ordered has been extremely fresh and seems like a lot of effort is put into every dish considering it's a pretty varied menu. If you are up to just experience a bustling local restaurant that clearly has a lot of love put into it by the owners come to Buena Sera. Also very nice flowers out front. read more

Don't judge a book by its cover ! This restaurant from outside may not look like much , but the food and service is top notch. A nice view of the lake adds to the ambiance. Definitely worth the visit! read more

We came here in our way to friends home in Malta ....so glad we did. The scallop appetizer was phenomenal, our entrees of a shrimp Luigi special and cauliflower penne was to die for. ...we ordered the house made bread with roasted garlic which into itself was also amazing ! Used this bread to soak up all the bread from our dishes..was well worth the extra carbs !!! My dirty vodka martini was on point...a must visit f your in the area ! read more

See all

Excellent food. We had the lamb chop special and spaghetti with clam sauce. Very delicious. The service was great and the host was super friendly. Will definitely go back. read more

The service was wonderful. The food was even better! I had the Bolognese and it was fantastic! My friends had the eggplant parm and roasted cauliflower penne. Both were equally as delicious. The warm bread with garlic butter is also a must. Dessert shouldn't be skipped either. read more

I believe the ambience needs a little help up by far. The food and the service makes up for it. Young people run it and they've done a great job. Highly recommended. read more

Even though it was Belmont track week, our service by Lindsey was great! The food was delicious. We tried the chicken Marsala and chicken parmesan. Our friends had the penne chicken and baked chicken but sorry no picture. We were seated up by the windows to look out at the lake. Definitely get the bread board or 2. The portions are big but save room for the carrot cake, it was outstanding. We went early for dinner and parked close to the door due to the rain. I would say if you can back your car in so you can pull out as it is a busy intersection. It was really busy when we left. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Julia has been amazing getting our reservation booked, proactively going above and beyond the usual service. Ambiance, service and food great! Wholeheartedly recommend! Julien, Tom & friends. read more

Although the location is scenic by the lake. The exterior and interior need remodeling. The temperature of the interior is unacceptable, difficult to breath in the rear lake view area enclosed glass area. I would encourage accessible windows, what happens if there is a fire, or even a side door? This isn't an exaggerated concern - the waiters literal sweat was not just visible on them but actually dripping onto our table and the surroundings!!! I've never seen that, I said to them I'm so sorry to ask but are YOU ok in this heat?? The wait times for anything was unusually long and not sensible. One couple was already waiting for service prior to us showing up and yet some of our items came first? The drinks were as if an inexperienced person made them. We sent them back... The food was subpar, the sauce for Italian food should be delightful not rancid... the food was overcooked, not flavorful and was not fresh - a stocked freezer and YouTube could have produced better results. The cost for just a short time was astronomical- well over 100$ for what was not even $20 worth in my opinion. We left... early and will likely never return. read more

Food was below average for the price. Service was bad. Ordered dessert and sat there for 20 minutes. Apparently dessert manager didn't see the order and waitress was nowhere to be found. Won't be going back there, very disappointed. read more

One of my favorite restaurants ever the staff is amazing. The food is awesome if you want a nice dinner this is the place to go.