Ok, first thing to say, their ice cream is PRICEY! 3 average sized scoops in a homemade waffle cone…read morewill run you $11.15 plus tax. But their ice cream is made without artificial colors or crappy ingredients that you can't pronounce. Their standard base ingredients are whole milk, cream, cane sugar, egg yolks, nonfat dry milk, tapioca starch and salt. Now, take a look at the ingredients in your standard (cheaper) ice cream shop brands and you'll see the difference. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted with smiles and hellos and the said to let them know if we had any questions or wanted to try any flavors. They had regular dairy ice cream as well as dairy free options and were very knowledgeable about allergies, which comes in handy going anywhere with my mom (gluten free, dairy free, soy free). I got three scoops in a waffle cone (go big or go home) and my mom got two in a dish. My dad wouldn't spend the money to buy an ice cream for himself... The first time I've ever seen him be cheap! Haha My flavors of choice were coffee break, backyard s'mores and brownie batter. I tried the Irish cream, but it had a strong vanilla flavor with just a hint of Irish cream, so not my jam. My mom had brownie batter and lemon drop. We both really enjoyed our ice cream choices. I will definitely go back, but it will be a little bit because of the cost. The space is bright, clean and welcoming. There is indoor seating as well as seating out on the plaza sidewalk in front of the shop.

Pictured: Shirley Temple ice cream…read more BuffaliciousBites gives Millie's Homemade Ice Cream 5 stars!

The ice cream and service is consistently great at this location. During my most recent visit,…read morethere were a lot of people but the staff was dishing out the ice cream quickly. I ordered the Buffalo Pot Hole ice cream in a dish and oh my gosh, it was delicious! I look forward to coming back soon.

Frosty's has been a staple in our family's summers since we moved into the area. My son who just…read moreturned 3 has already been to 4 opening days. (That math is crazy) We saw they were opening a couple days due to warm weather and had to get over there to get some ice cream and say hello. It was PACKED! Probably would be less packed now that the weather is cold and snowy again but we waited in line and got our treats. I ended up going with a root beer float this time. We also had an assortment of cones and dishes of soft serve with plenty of sprinkles. We can't wait until they open up fully for the season and will be here quite often.

When considering ice cream, the only smart idea is to go to Nick Charlaps. They have multiple…read morelocations and service is excellent at all. But most importantly, you really can never go wrong with Nick Charlap's ice cream.

The past few years I'vs been here the shakes were very good. I went last Friday afternoon. I…read moretasted mine & it was basically milk with very little ice cream. There was a spitful of peanut butter fudge at the bottom of the cup & it wasn't a thick consistency at all. My Mom said her shake was basically milk and air. I should've had them made over again but had already drove away. Make sure your employees know how to make a proper milkshake.

Nick Charlaps has the best ice cream ever!!! So many variations to choose from!!! I highly…read morerecommend the vanilla

Stopped in yesterday for a half gallon of ice cream and chose chocolate peanut butter. Wow! Hugh…read morechunks of peanut butter in the smoothest chocolate ice cream. Best I have ever had! Can't go wrong with any of the homemade ice cream here. Will definitely be back again and again!

I brought my kids to Rosie's on the west side on a random Tuesday night; figuring, how busy could…read moreit possibly be on a Tuesday?! Well, the line was literally out the door at 7 PM! But honestly? The moment you walk in, none of that matters. The smell is pure bliss! You're immediately hit with the aroma of fresh cones baking, and you're surrounded by ice cream made right there. It's a small space, packed with a lot of people, but the line moved surprisingly well. The servers are extraordinarily patient and kind, which is even more impressive considering it was a hot July Tuesday. They do have a limit on samples, and I actually think that's a great thing... it keeps the line moving and makes people more deliberate about what they want to try. Once we sat down, we had some of the most delicious ice cream I've ever tasted in my life. We even took some pints home, and it was just as delicious there as it was in the shop. Completely recommend! We'll be back.

I've been wanting to try Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream ever since I kept seeing it all over the…read moreinternet. Then two different people recommended it to me on the same day, so I knew it was a sign and I'm so glad I went! I love that they offer multiple rotating seasonal flavors along with affordable gluten-free options. The staff was friendly and helpful, the portions were fair for the price, and the shop was very clean. They also have a cute outdoor seating area that makes it a great spot to enjoy your ice cream. And don't forget to bring your pups, they're dog-friendly too!

Best sponge candy, orange chocolate and coconut clusters in the entire U.S. You won't find…read morechocolate like it. Amazing service, people and overall experience. Watch them make candy while enjoying an orange chocolate ice cream cone or an amazing cup of coffee.

One of the best places to come for ice cream, coffee and of course chocolate!! The staff is also…read moreamazing!

I was craving a late-night snack and was pleasantly surprised by White Rabbit. I've driven by it so…read moremany times without stopping, but I'm so glad I finally did! The restaurant has a charming Alice in Wonderland theme that creates a fun and unique atmosphere. Their dessert selection was absolutely delicious, making it a great spot to sit down and satisfy your sweet tooth. Our waiter was fantastic--friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable about the menu, which made the experience even better. If you're looking for a cozy place to enjoy some amazing desserts, I definitely recommend giving White Rabbit a try!

Do not come unless you are prepared to spend. Party of three, one enjoyed their cheesecake, one…read moretheir crepe, but the third found their cake to be dry and flavorless, even with half a canister of strawberry coulis decorating the plate (very watery consistency). Price doesn't match overall quality, unfortunately.

This is a hidden gem! I've liv d in this neighborhood for 10 years and am known kicking myself for…read morenot giving this place a try sooner. The most extensive ice cream menu that I have ever seen while not being overly expensive. Every choice here is a winner. The friendliest staff you'll ever meet too! Service with a smile and a kind word. It's window service with picnic tables for when you can't wait to dive in. Very welcoming vibe here! This is a must try! What are you waiting for?

Stopped by and incredibly happy that I did. The service is excellent. Ambiance, well, your sitting…read moreoutside at a picnic table but it's summertime! Enjoy the heat. We had what was basically a "Turtle" in ice cream form. Unbelievably delicious!!! If you want something icy, cold, to beat the heat, this is the place! Would definitely recommend this place to anyone and everyone! It's really that simple!